Cherreads

Chapter 1353 - Chapter 1353: The Erased History

"Isn't being alive enough?"

Within the palace of the Emperor's Children in Kostantiniye, Fugen's smile vanished. The Primarch addressed his gene-son calmly.

"Better to die than live without freedom!" Julius replied with firm resolve. "Since I've accepted your power and joined your ranks, I have the right to know the truth. What kind of unspeakable secret are you hiding that you must erase it completely?"

"This is not something you're meant to know." Fugen frowned. He knew well from over a decade of interaction that Ryan's brother-in-law had a stubborn streak. On the positive side, this trait gave Julius resilience, willpower, and the determination to overcome anything. On the downside, he had a habit of obsessively drilling into things.

Just like me, always chasing perfection, Fugen thought. That's why he'd always seen Julius in a different light.

"I must know." Julius held up the history book The Third Legion—Chronicles of the Emperor's Children, written by Fugen himself. Within its pages, many portions referencing the Second and Eleventh Legions had been blacked out or labeled "unknown." Only a few passing mentions in the Randan Campaign even hinted at their existence.

And ever since reading it, Julius had been itching with curiosity.

"Julius, do you understand what you're demanding?" Fugen's voice turned dangerous. "All of us Primarchs swore blood oaths never to speak of those two brothers. Some even had their memories erased. Even Ryan—you could ask him, and he'd never say a word!"

"That's why I came to you!" Julius stepped aggressively forward, glaring. "If you expect my loyalty, then give me the truth. What happened to those two brothers?"

"Julius, you're just a mortal!" Fugen snapped. "This isn't for you to know!"

"And who decides that? You openly write about Horus—one of the most damnable traitors in history—yet these two can't even be named? What is so disgraceful that you have to erase it entirely?" Julius shouted back. "If you won't tell me, why should I follow you?"

"I said—you don't have the right!"

"Then I'll exercise my right to walk away!"

"You no longer have that choice."

"No one can force me!"

"Julius, don't make me—"

"You're the one forcing this! My lord, I need to know the truth!"

The two stood chest to chest, glaring. Fugen's hand crept toward the Phoenix Blade by his bedside. No doubt—he was on the brink of drawing it.

But Julius refused to back down. He drew his own weapon—the legendary blade Knights Die Not by the Hand. He would rather die than yield.

Their eyes locked. In Fugen's purple-blue gaze, fury burned; in Julius's sea-blue eyes, unyielding resistance flared. Even as his soul and body were crushed under the Primarch's pressure—even as blood oozed from his eyes, nose, ears, and mouth—Julius refused to yield.

The room went still.

After several minutes, Julius dropped to one knee. Blood poured from his mouth. His head hung low. Breath ragged. Crimson drops stained the imperial-gold carpet beneath his feet.

"You're just like me in my youth. Same damned temper."

After another long silence, as Julius felt his organs bleeding out, Fugen finally released the pressure. There was respect in the Primarch's eyes—but also resignation. He gestured for Julius to sit down.

"You really want to know that badly?"

"Please… I must know!" Julius gasped.

"Very well. Because you are the Emperor-appointed brother of the Empress Consort Sulia, I will tell you something," Fugen said after a pause. "But you must swear a blood oath—never to tell another soul."

"I swear." Julius took the deadliest oath he could—absolute silence.

Silence filled the room. Fugen waited until the oath was complete before speaking again, slowly.

"The Second and Eleventh Legions… their existence represents the gravest, most unforgivable disaster in Imperial history. All those with knowledge were either executed or had their memories purged. Even we Primarchs were forced to swear never to speak of it again. The only ones who know the full truth are the Emperor, Malcador, and Ryan—who inherited all of Malcador's knowledge."

"And you?" Julius wiped blood from his face—only to realize he was using the same towel Fugen had earlier used as a makeshift loincloth. His face turned green.

"I swore the same oaths. But after my fall and ascension to daemonhood, those oaths were broken. That's the only reason I can speak of this at all." Fugen's expression darkened. "But it's not something to be proud of. Sometimes, I wish I were like Dorn—who begged to have all his memories erased."

"Even Horus is openly discussed, yet these two can't be mentioned? Why is their story so much worse?" Julius demanded.

"Let me be clear, Julius—I'm telling you this only because you are Sulia's brother. Not because you forced my hand."

"I understand."

"Alright then… You saw the entry in my book about the Randan Campaign?"

"Yes," Julius nodded. "You wrote that the Randan Xenos War happened when the expeditionary fleets reached the galactic rim and encountered a terrifying xenos race whose civilization had reached a certain technological and psychic threshold. Their power was so immense that entire fleets were wiped out. Worlds were razed, Titan legions were annihilated, and the Imperium nearly fell. The Emperor himself had to break the 'Endless Labyrinth' to reverse the tide. Even so, the losses were catastrophic."

"Correct. And in the first phase of that campaign, the ones deployed to support the front… were the Second and Eleventh Legions, under the Second Primarch." Fugen nodded, his voice heavy. "At the time, the Imperium stood no chance. The enemy had superior tech, could enslave other species at will, terraform entire planets into fortress-worlds, and possessed intelligence that even some of us Primarchs envied."

"We suffered defeat after defeat. Over 80,000 Astartes were lost. Tens of millions of Imperial Army troops. The northern frontier was obliterated. Worst of all, the Randan could mimic our signals, hijack our ships, enslave our soldiers. Every battle was asymmetrical. They had full intel—we were blind. Eventually, the Emperor had to intervene personally."

"And it was in this war that the Second Primarch… changed," Fugen said bitterly. "He was a vain man. Too confident. But brilliant. He began to understand the true nature of the Warp. He… deconstructed the Emperor."

"Deconstructed?" Julius asked.

"To humans, the Emperor is a god. A savior. Humanity's last hope. But to a Primarch? To demigods like Astartes, Custodes, and Navy Lords—what is the Emperor?"

"A master? A sovereign? A father?"

"They have power—but no rights. Position—but no voice. The Second Primarch concluded that he and his Space Marines were just tools. They weren't allowed independent thought. But that wasn't sustainable. As the galaxy was conquered, new bureaucracies emerged, enforced by the military. So what made the Emperor different from a warlord? From the Randan?"

"Of course there's a difference!" Julius protested.

"Wait. Let me finish." Fugen raised a hand. "Yes, there is a difference. While warlords and the Randan prioritize extracting maximum value from mortals, the Emperor aims to raise humanity as a whole—collectively improving strength, territory, and prosperity."

"But from a peasant's perspective—what's the difference? If A robs me, and B also robs me, does it matter who's more polite? And look at my writings—hive cities, corpse-starch, cyber-slavery. Doesn't it all say the same thing?"

"Meanwhile, the Emperor limited the power of Primarchs, Custodes, and Astartes. Many of them believed they were born to rule. To lead. But under the Emperor—they were just enforcers."

"And if that's all they would ever be… then why not rebel? Why not join Chaos? Or the xenos? Or establish their own dominion? Why sacrifice their own desires for nameless masses?"

"I see," Julius whispered, pale. "It's a question with no easy answer. Everyone has selfishness in them."

"Exactly. And the worst part—he didn't just think this. He wrote it down. Spread it. Tens of thousands of Astartes began to doubt their purpose. Separatist ideas spread rapidly."

"And in hindsight, he wasn't entirely wrong. Loyalist Primarchs? Dead, missing, or frozen. Rebels? Most of them still kicking. Like me. Ryan dragged me back after ten thousand years."

"I understand now." Julius nodded grimly. The Second Primarch hadn't just questioned authority—he'd cracked the foundation of the Imperium. He had to be erased at the root.

"And the Eleventh Primarch?"

"Ugh. He was worse." Fugen laughed bitterly. "When we found him, he wasn't just working with the Randan—he was leading them. Voluntarily. He'd undergone full genetic modifications—half human, half xenos. He didn't just accept the Randan as allies—he treated them as his true parents. He used his Primarch powers to infect his entire Legion's gene-seed. Most of the Eleventh turned into hybrid monsters—stronger than normal Astartes, radiating psychic energy."

"He proved the Second Primarch's point. If you switch sides, you get everything—power, respect, purpose. All other Legions, even loyalists, began to waver. The Emperor was livid. He ordered total extermination. Every trace was purged. The task was handed to Jonsen and Russ—the most loyal of us all."

"To defeat an enemy within… is harder than defeating one without." Julius sighed.

"His famous quote was: 'Elsewhere may not be paradise. But I just wanted to escape hell.' He dreamed of a multi-species empire—human, Ork, Eldar—all united under the Randan, excluding Chaos. Even Horus couldn't stomach that idea. So both loyalists and traitors refuse to speak his name. Too disgraceful."

"Yeah… that's shameful." Julius exhaled. His questions were finally answered.

"Now that you know everything, go prepare for battle. We march the day after tomorrow." Fugen dismissed him.

Julius bowed and left.

Alone, the Primarch sat in silence. He pulled a painting from his bedside—a portrait of the halfling Habi. This noble halfling had given his life in Fugen's duel with Mortarion, freeing Fugen from the shadow of the Second Primarch.

"Some things are worth dying for. Some things are worth protecting."

"Thank you, Habi."

[Note: This chapter is purely the author's personal speculation and fanfiction. It does not represent any official canon. All similarities are coincidental. Discussion is welcome, but personal attacks will result in deletion and bans.]

More Chapters