In the original timeline, insurance investigator Sara had only gotten involved with Neal after Kate—Neal's girlfriend—was killed. At the end of White Collar's first season, Kate had planned to escape with Neal, but before she could board the plane, she was killed in an explosion orchestrated by the corrupt FBI agent Fowler.
Devastated by Kate's death, Neal had later crossed paths with Sara while they were both searching for a lost submarine. That was when sparks flew between them, eventually leading them to sleep together.
But in this timeline, Castle had intervened early.
Because of him, Kate had never fallen under Fowler's control, drastically altering how events unfolded.
Still, for someone like Neal—an absurdly handsome man exuding effortless charm—Sara's reappearance was bound to create new drama.
And for Castle and Gianna, that meant brand-new entertainment.
Neal and Kate might still have a strong relationship, but he was not the type of man to remain strictly faithful.
Back when Castle had sent Kate to the West Coast to hide from Vincent Adler's pursuit, Neal had stayed in New York, working with Castle to steal from the thief—Adler's salvaged submarine.
And what had Neal done during that time?
He had hooked up with Alex—the descendant of one of the original survivors connected to the lost submarine's treasure.
Though Alex had left New York after getting her share of the loot, Neal's inability to keep his pants on was an established fact.
Castle, on the other hand, was forcibly monogamous.
Due to the utterly ridiculous circumstances of his transmigration, the system bound to him had, for reasons beyond explanation, restricted him to being with only Beckett.
So, how could he not be jealous of Neal?
That pretty-boy bastard could charm any woman with a glance!
Castle wasn't bitter. Not at all.
(Okay, maybe just a little.)
But even more than his mild envy, he was deeply invested in seeing what kind of trouble Neal would land himself in this time.
Would Sara end up in bed with Neal again?
Castle didn't care.
He just wanted a front-row seat to the chaos.
Gianna, like Castle, had a refined taste for lowbrow entertainment.
She was also well acquainted with Neal and Kate, having once hosted them in Italy after Castle sent them there for safety.
Though she personally wasn't into Neal's type—his charm did nothing for her—she had to admit that the guy was ridiculously good-looking.
His deep blue eyes, combined with his artistic sensibilities, practically guaranteed that he would always attract trouble.
In fact, Gianna was certain that whatever love Neal and Kate had once shared had long since faded.
At this point, their relationship had settled into a bond more akin to the companionship of a long-married couple rather than romance.
And now?
A gorgeous woman determined to reclaim a stolen Van Gogh—a woman who wouldn't stop until she got what she wanted—was about to re-enter Neal's life.
Gianna could smell the drama from a mile away.
Especially because something about Neal's behavior didn't add up.
Over the years, Neal had acquired plenty of valuable artwork—both legally and less legally.
When they had looted Adler's submarine, Neal had personally chosen several paintings for himself.
And when Castle had plundered the Freemasons' hidden treasure beneath Trinity Church, Neal had been allowed to pick even more lost masterpieces from the stash.
So, why was Neal clinging to one particular painting that Sara had been trying to reclaim?
Castle had once casually asked Neal how many priceless works of art he had stolen over the years.
Back when Castle was just a novelist, Neal had never given him a straight answer.
It wasn't until Castle helped Neal break out of prison, rescue Kate, and then rob Adler that Neal finally admitted the truth.
And that truth?
Too many to count.
After Adler had scammed all of Wall Street and vanished, Neal—who had initially been trained by Mozzie to con Adler—was left to fend for himself.
But by that point, Neal was no longer the naive rookie he had once been.
In the following years, he and Mozzie had stolen from some of the world's most prestigious museums and private collections.
At this point, Neal had an entire hidden storage facility filled with stolen treasures.
When Castle had heard the sheer scale of Neal's collection, even he had been stunned.
According to Neal, the total value of all the artwork he had taken over the years was already astronomical.
And yet—Neal never sold them off.
Why?
Because, at first, they were too hot to move.
And later?
Because Neal genuinely loved them.
He didn't want to part with them.
Now that Neal had achieved financial freedom, why would he ever sell his prized collection?
He didn't need the money.
And he certainly wasn't about to sell those masterpieces for a fraction of their worth.
Neal loved his stolen artwork.
He enjoyed looking at them.
So why the hell was he still holding onto that one painting—the one Sara was after?
Castle gleefully posed this question to Gianna.
And just as expected, he immediately saw the gleam of gossip in her eyes.
Meanwhile, John Wick—who had been holding his daughter in the corner—looked at both of them in utter disbelief.
His wife and his best friend were supposed to be discussing serious matters.
Instead, they had completely derailed the conversation into gossiping about Neal's love life.
"Seriously?" John sighed internally.
How bored do you have to be to act like this?
One moment, they were discussing Beckett's political campaign.
The next?
They were cackling over Neal's potential romantic scandals.
John knew Castle well enough to recognize exactly what he was thinking.
And Gianna—well, she was practically glowing with excitement.
Grinning mischievously, she leaned forward.
"So what you're saying is… Neal might have feelings for this insurance investigator?"
John finally had enough.
"Alright, that's enough! We have children here!"
John shot both Castle and Gianna an exasperated glare.
"Can we please focus on the actual issues before you two get lost in your gossip addiction?"
Castle and Gianna, momentarily silenced, exchanged knowing glances.
Fine.
They'd pause the conversation.
For now.
They hurriedly wrapped up their discussion about Beckett's campaign.
They quickly finalized plans for how to inform the Indian government about their stolen treasure—deciding to melt everything into gold bricks and store them back in New York.
And then?
Meeting officially over.
John, completely fed up, grabbed his daughter and left.
He needed a break from these two troublemakers.
His plan?
Drag their hacker friends—who had been holed up in the supercomputer lab—outside for some fresh air at the beach.
Meanwhile, Castle and Gianna?
The moment John left, they exchanged a smirk.
Then, immediately, they followed after him.
Not because they cared about the beach.
But because they needed to find a good place…
…to continue discussing the Neal situation.
