Cherreads

Chapter 36 - Not Just a Lie Anymore

Sophia stared.

She couldn't help it.

Jane sat in the passenger seat, the emerald dress catching the golden light of early evening, her hair falling in soft waves, her hands folded carefully in her lap.

She looked... breathtaking.

Sophia turned.

And stopped breathing.

Her eyes widened, just a fraction—taking in the dress, the hair, the quiet confidence Jane wore like new skin.

For a long second, neither spoke.

Then Sophia exhaled, voice low and rough.

"You... you look—"

She didn't finish.

She didn't need to.

"Hi," Jane said softly, a nervous smile pulling at her lips.

Sophia blinked. "Hi."

Another beat of silence.

Jane shifted slightly. "Is it... okay? The dress?"

"It's perfect." Sophia's voice came out quieter than she intended. "You're perfect."

Jane's cheeks flushed. "I don't know about that."

"I do."

Their eyes met, and for a moment, the world outside the car faded—just the two of them, the hum of the engine, the weight of what was about to happen.

Then Sophia cleared her throat, tearing her gaze away. "We should go. We don't want to be late."

"Right." Jane nodded, fastening her seatbelt. "Let's do this."

Sophia pulled away from the curb, her hands steady on the wheel, but her heart anything but.

The drive was quiet at first.

Jane watched the city pass by, her fingers twisting together in her lap.

"Nervous?" Sophia asked.

"A little."

"You don't have to be. Just... be yourself."

Jane glanced at her. "I thought the whole point was to not be myself."

Sophia's lips twitched. "Fair. But what I mean is—don't try too hard. My father will like you. Ethan will definitely like you. And Marissa..." She paused. "Marissa will try to find something wrong. That's just who she is."

"And if she does?"

"Then we handle it together."

Jane's chest tightened at the word 'together'.

Sophia glanced over, her expression softening. "You're not alone in this. I promise."

Jane nodded slowly. "Okay."

They drove a little longer, the houses growing larger, the streets wider and quieter.

Then Sophia pulled through a set of iron gates, up a long driveway lined with perfectly manicured hedges.

The house loomed ahead—white stone, tall windows, elegant in a way that felt both inviting and imposing.

Jane's breath caught. "This is where you grew up?"

"Part of the time. After my mother died, my father bought this place. A fresh start, he called it."

There was something in Sophia's voice—something distant.

Jane didn't push.

Sophia parked near the entrance, turning off the engine.

For a moment, neither of them moved.

"Ready?" Sophia asked.

Jane exhaled slowly. "As I'll ever be."

Sophia reached over, her hand briefly covering Jane's. "Thank you. For doing this."

Jane looked down at their hands, then back up at Sophia. "You keep saying that."

"Because I mean it."

Jane's heart thudded. "I know."

Sophia squeezed once, then pulled back, opening her door.

Jane followed, stepping out into the evening air.

The front door opened before they even reached it.

A man stood in the doorway—tall, broad-shouldered, with kind eyes and an easy smile that looked almost mischievous.

"The guests of honor!" Ethan stepped forward, his grin widening. "Come on in—Mom's been sharpening her knives."

"Ethan." Sophia's voice carried a warning. "Behave."

"I always behave. You just never appreciate my charm." He turned to Jane, extending his hand. "Ethan. The better-looking sibling."

Jane couldn't help but smile as she shook his hand. "Jane. Nice to meet you."

"Trust me, the pleasure's mine. Anyone who can get Sophia to stop working for five minutes deserves a medal."

Sophia shot him a look, but there was warmth beneath it.

They stepped inside.

The interior was as immaculate as the exterior—marble floors, soft lighting, art on the walls that probably cost more than Jane's entire education.

Jane tried not to stare.

Ethan led them down a hallway into a sitting room where a man sat in an armchair, reading glasses perched on his nose, a tablet in his hand.

He looked up as they entered, and Jane recognized him immediately—Harris Whitmore. The quiet authority. The sharp intelligence in his eyes.

He stood, setting the tablet aside. "Sophia."

"Father."

He stepped forward, his gaze shifting to Jane with open curiosity. "And this must be.....?"

Jane straightened, suddenly very aware of how closely he was studying her. "Jane. Nice to meet you, Mr. Whitmore."

"Harris, please." He extended a hand, his grip firm but not intimidating. "When Sophia mentioned seeing someone, I assumed..." He paused, something flickering in his expression. "Well, doesn't matter. Sit, both of you."

Before they could move, a voice drifted in from the hallway—smooth, controlled, deliberate.

"Yes, do sit. Dinner is nearly ready."

Jane turned.

Marissa stood in the doorway, stunning in a way that felt weaponized.

Her cream silk dress looked effortless but was anything but. Her hair was perfect.

Her smile was warm, but her eyes were calculating.

She moved into the room like she owned it—which, in a way, she did.

"We've met briefly," Marissa said, her gaze sweeping over Jane with surgical precision. "At the hospital, wasn't it? When Sophia decided to spring this... surprise."

Jane felt the weight of that pause, the way surprise landed like an accusation.

"Briefly, yes," Jane said evenly. "Thank you for having me."

Marissa's smile didn't waver. "Of course. Any friend of Sophia's."

The word friend hung in the air, sharp-edged.

"Shall we?" Marissa gestured toward the dining room.

The dining room was grand—a long table set with fine china, crystal glasses, candles flickering softly.

Jane sat beside Sophia, their chairs close enough that she could feel the warmth of Sophia's presence.

Across from them sat Ethan, who gave Jane an encouraging wink.

At the head of the table sat Harris, and beside him, Marissa—positioned perfectly to observe.

The first course was served—a delicate soup, perfectly presented.

Conversation began slowly, polite and measured.

"So, Jane," Harris said, his tone curious but not unkind. "What do you do?"

"I'm a student," Jane replied. "Business major. I work part-time at a café to cover expenses."

Marissa's voice cut in smoothly. "A barista. How... quaint."

Jane felt the sting but kept her expression neutral.

Marissa continued, her tone light but pointed. "And how did you two meet, exactly? Sophia's world is hospitals and boardrooms, not coffee counters."

Jane glanced at Sophia, who met her gaze with a subtle nod.

"I was working at the café," Jane said, keeping her voice steady. "Sophia came in one afternoon. We started talking."

"Just like that?" Marissa's smile was thin. "How... serendipitous."

"It was," Sophia said, her tone calm but firm. "Sometimes things happen when you're not looking for them."

Marissa's eyes lingered on Sophia for a beat too long. "Indeed."

Ethan leaned forward, his tone lighter. "Wait, is this the night you almost ran her over?"

Jane's eyes widened slightly.

Sophia shot Ethan a look. "I didn't—"

"You kind of did," Jane said softly, a small smile tugging at her lips. "But she stopped in time. And then she helped me. Took me to her place when I was locked out of my hostel."

Ethan's grin widened. "Heroic? Soph, you? That's a new one."

Harris chuckled quietly. "Sounds like her mother—always helping strays."

The word strays landed harder than he probably meant it to.

Harris seemed to realize it, his expression shifting. "Sophia, you didn't mention... well, that it was a she."

The room went still.

Jane's chest tightened.

Harris continued, his tone careful. "Not that it changes much in this day and age, but I suppose I pictured something more traditional."

Sophia's voice was steady, but there was an edge beneath it. "Does it bother you?"

Harris paused, then shook his head. "Bother? No. Surprised? A bit. But you're an adult, Sophia. As long as it's real and makes you happy, that's what matters. Life's too short for anything less—your mother taught me that."

Something in Sophia's expression softened.

But Marissa wasn't done.

"Real?" Her voice was sharp now, the pretense of politeness cracking. "Between two women? Impossible. This is just a phase, Sophia—a distraction from what you should be focusing on. Marriage. Stability. Not some... fling with a girl scraping by on tips."

Jane's hands curled into fists beneath the table.

But before Sophia could respond, Jane spoke.

"With respect, Mrs. Whitmore," Jane said, her voice calm but unyielding, "love isn't about stability on paper. It's about showing up when it counts."

Marissa's eyes narrowed. "Is that so?"

"Yes." Jane met her gaze without flinching. "Like how Sophia shows up for her patients. Or for me that night. She's brilliant at it."

Ethan let out a low whistle. "Ooh, burn."

"Ethan," Marissa snapped. "Don't encourage this nonsense."

But Harris was watching Jane now, his expression thoughtful.

"Enough," he said quietly. "Jane seems sharp—business major, you said? Tell me, what's your take on hospital management? Sophia's always complaining about inefficiencies."

Jane blinked, caught off guard by the shift. "Well, from what I've seen shadowing Sophia a bit, it's like running a café on steroids. You've got supply chains, staffing, customer—or patient—satisfaction. The difference is the stakes. Get an order wrong at a café, someone's annoyed. Get it wrong at a hospital..."

"Someone dies," Harris finished. He nodded slowly. "Smart. Very smart. Sophia, you didn't mention she had a head for this."

Sophia looked at Jane, something unreadable flickering in her eyes. "I... guess I didn't know the half of it."

Marissa's smile was brittle. "Clever words. But let's see if they hold up under scrutiny."

The tension thickened.

Harris set down his fork. "Marissa, that's enough."

"I'm simply being realistic," Marissa said smoothly. "Sophia has responsibilities. A legacy to uphold. She can't afford to be sidetracked by—"

"By what?" Sophia's voice was cold now. "By someone who cares about me? By someone who doesn't see me as a means to an end?"

Marissa's expression hardened. "I see you perfectly clearly, Sophia. And I see this for what it is—a reckless decision that will only end in disappointment."

Jane's chest ached, but she forced herself to stay composed.

Harris cleared his throat. "Perhaps we should take a moment. Ethan, Sophia—why don't you step outside for a bit? Let things cool down."

Ethan stood immediately. "Good idea. Come on, sis. Let's get some air."

Sophia hesitated, her eyes on Jane.

Jane gave her a small nod. It's okay.

Sophia stood, following Ethan out toward the terrace.

The door closed behind them.

And Jane was left alone with Harris and Marissa.

Outside, the night air was cool, the garden stretching out in soft shadows.

Sophia stood near the edge of the terrace, arms crossed, staring out at nothing.

Ethan leaned against the railing beside her, his expression unreadable.

"Nice pretending in there," he said quietly. "Almost had me fooled."

Sophia's head snapped toward him. "What?"

"Come on, sis. The hand-holding under the table? Staged. And that 'heroic' story—too polished. This is fake, isn't it? To shut Mom up about dates."

Sophia's jaw tightened. "Ethan—"

"Relax. I'm not judging." He tilted his head, studying her. "Actually, I'm impressed. It's a solid plan."

Sophia exhaled slowly. "Fine. Yes. But don't tell anyone. Please."

Ethan was quiet for a moment. Then: "I won't. On one condition."

Sophia turned to face him fully. "What?"

"Help me win Jane over. I like her—smart, feisty. Way better than Mom's setups for you."

Sophia stared at him, her blood going cold. "No. Absolutely not."

"Then I might let it slip. Accidentally. Mom's already gunning for you to slip up so I get the hospital reins. Don't make me choose sides for real."

"You're bluffing."

Ethan's expression was calm, but there was steel beneath it. "Try me. Look, I support you—always have. But Jane? She's got spark. Just put in a good word."

Sophia's voice dropped, dangerous. "I can't, Ethan."

"Why?" He leaned closer, curious now. "Do you like her?"

Sophia looked away. "No. It's not like that."

"Then help me to win her."

Sophia's hands curled into fists.

She thought of Jane sitting inside, facing Marissa alone.

She thought of the way Jane had looked at her in the car.

She thought of the way her heart had stopped when Jane stepped out in that dress.

"Fine," Sophia said, her voice hollow. "One good word. That's it."

Ethan grinned. "Deal. Knew you'd see reason."

He turned and walked back inside.

Sophia stayed where she was, staring out at the dark garden.

Her chest felt tight.

Her hands were shaking.

And for the first time, she realized—

She'd lied.

Not to her father.

Not to Marissa.

To herself.

Because this wasn't pretend.

Not anymore.

More Chapters