Cherreads

Chapter 13 - The Wrong Question

I didn't sleep well.

Not because of the drug accusation, though that sat heavily enough on its own. Not because of the dress on the runway, or Diane's carefully measured voice on the phone last night walking me through next steps, or the security room with its evidence bag and its neutral faced woman asking questions.

I didn't sleep because every time I closed my eyes I saw flashbulbs.

And Bryan's hand around mine.

And the internet, which never slept, assembling stories from images the way it always did, fast and certain and completely unbothered by accuracy.

I'd made myself put the phone down at midnight.

I'd picked it up twice since then.

By five thirty I gave up on sleep entirely and made coffee and sat by the window and watched the city come slowly back to life in the grey early morning and tried to prepare myself for whatever today was going to be.

I looked at my phone properly for the first time at six.

The notifications had multiplied overnight into something that required a moment just to absorb.

I opened Twitter first.

#ZoeHarlow, was trending at number three.

I scrolled.

@fashionfiles

The way he just walked through that crowd and took her hand like EXCUSE ME who is this man and why is he so calm

47.3K likes

@runwayrealist

I'm sorry but can we talk about what he SAID?? "The people responsible know who they are" — he came prepared. He came with INTENTION. This man did not come to play.

31.8K likes

@beautyandtheblog

Does anyone know who he is?? I've been on the internet for three hours and I cannot find this man anywhere and that somehow makes him more attractive

28.4K likes

@glamgossipgh

Not me rewatching the video seventeen times. The way he looked at her before he turned to the press. Like she was the only thing in that crowd that mattered.

19.2K likes

I put the phone down.

Picked it back up.

Scrolled further.

@truthteller

Let's not forget why she was outside that venue in the first place. Drugs found at her station and y'all out here simping over some random man holding her hand. Stay focused.

12.1K likes

@fashionwatchgh

The Harlow show dress incident + substance found backstage + mystery man = this girl's team is working OVERTIME to control this narrative and it's not working

8.9K likes

@modelindustryinsider

Something doesn't add up about the Harlow situation. That dress seam didn't fail on its own. And substances don't walk themselves into dressing rooms. Someone needs to be asking harder questions.

15.6K likes

That last one I stared at for a long time.

Someone in the industry paying attention. Someone who understood that two things going wrong in the same show wasn't coincidence, it was choreography.

I kept scrolling.

@gossip247

Wait wait wait. Is this not the same Zoe that's been seen on internet with that tall guy? John something? Because the man in this video is DEFINITELY not John. So what's going on exactly?

22.7K likes

@nanadoes\_lifestyle

I went through her tagged photos from the last year and there's a whole boyfriend. John. They've been everywhere together. So who is mystery man and why is he the one showing up when things go wrong?

18.3K likes

@askingquestions_gh

No but seriously where is John? Your girlfriend is all over the news and you're not the one holding her hand? Something is very off here.

31.4K likes

Where is John.

The question sitting in thousands of strangers' timelines.

I set the phone face down on the windowsill and looked out at the street below.

Where was John.

I knew exactly where John was.

John was wherever John always was, in his office, or on his way to it, or somewhere in between that involved a woman named Rose and a hand held across a restaurant table and a smile that belonged to someone who wasn't me.

John was completely fine.

John had not shown up.

Diane called at seven thirty.

I answered before the second ring.

"How are you?" she said. First thing. Before anything else.

"I'm standing," I said. "That's something."

"It's everything, actually." A brief pause. "I spoke to Harlow's legal team last night and again this morning. They've reviewed the dressing room access logs from yesterday." Her voice was measured and careful. "Zoe, your station was accessed by three people during the window when you were in makeup. Camille, who we already know. A junior runner who has since confirmed he was collecting accessories from the rail and never went near your station directly." She paused. "And one other person."

I waited.

"The access log shows a model badge," Diane said carefully. "We don't have a name confirmed yet. The badge system records entry but not always individual identification at secondary stations." Another pause. "But the legal team is pursuing it. This is being taken seriously. Harlow does not want this associated with their show and they are motivated to find the truth."

I closed my eyes briefly.

A model badge.

Backstage access.

A woman who had sat beside me at my mirror that morning and asked if she looked okay and laughed at her own joke about being tired.

"Okay," I said quietly.

"The substance has gone for testing," Diane continued. "Standard procedure. Results take time but when they come back and show no connection to you, and they will, that becomes the evidence that clears you formally." A pause. "Until then we say nothing publicly. We do not engage with press. We do not respond to online speculation."

"And the footage?" I asked. "Bryan and I outside the venue—"

"Is everywhere," Diane said evenly. "I'm not going to pretend otherwise. But Zoe, what he said? The people responsible know who they are?"

A brief pause. "That is the quote being repeated most. And it positions you as someone being targeted, not someone with something to hide." She paused. "Whoever this man is, his instincts were good."

I said nothing for a moment.

"His instincts have always been good," I said quietly.

Diane let that sit without comment.

"Rest today if you can," she said. "I'll call when there's more. And Zoe," Her voice shifted slightly, warmer. "You stood on that runway and you finished that walk. I need you to remember that."

She hung up.

I sat with the phone in my lap.

You stood on that runway and you finished that walk.

Emma called at eight.

"Tell me everything," she said immediately. "From the beginning. I saw the footage, I saw the press, I saw, Zoe who is that man and why did I not know about him"

"Emma."

"I'm serious. The internet is losing its mind and I am ALSO losing my mind because my best friend is trending and I found out from Twitter."

"Emma." Firmer this time.

She stopped.

"I'm okay," I said. "I'll tell you everything. Just, not yet. Give me today."

A pause. "Are you sure you're okay?"

"I'm standing."

"You keep saying that."

"It keeps being the most accurate thing."

She was quiet for a moment. "Do you need me to come over?"

I thought about it. "Not yet. I just need a few hours of quiet."

"Okay." Her voice was soft now. "But Zoe, I'm here. Whatever you need. Whatever comes next."

"I know," I said.

And I meant it completely.

Bryan's message came at eight forty five.

Bryan: Morning. How'd you sleep?*

Me: Barely.

Bryan: Same.

Bryan: Have you been on X?

Me: Unfortunately.

Bryan: For what it's worth, group one is my favorite.

Despite everything I almost smiled.

Me: Of course it is.

Bryan: How are you really?

I looked at that question for a moment.

How are you really.

Me: Tired. Angry. Grateful you came yesterday.

Bryan: Don't thank me again.

Me:I mean it.

Bryan: So do I. Stop.

A pause. Then —

Bryan: Whatever today brings, you've already survived yesterday. Remember that.

I read that twice.

Set the phone down.

Picked up my coffee.

Looked out the window.

You've already survived yesterday.

John called at nine fifteen.

I saw his name on the screen and something in me went very still.

Not the warm careful stillness of someone bracing for bad news.

Something cooler than that.

Something that already knew, before I answered, that this call was not going to be what it should be.

I answered anyway.

"Hey," I said.

"Hey." His voice was different from his usual morning tone. Tighter. Controlled in the way voices get when someone has been sitting on something for a while and has finally decided to say it. "How are you?"

"I've had better days," I said carefully.

"Yeah." A pause. "I saw the footage."

"Okay," I said.

Waiting.

"Zoe." Another pause. Longer. "Who is that man?"

There it was.

Not are you okay. Not what happened at the show. Not what can I do or I'm coming over or I saw the news and I've been worried sick.

Who is that man.

I sat very still.

"His name is Bryan," I said. My voice came out even and quiet.

A beat of silence.

"Bryan." He said the name slowly. Like he was turning it over. Looking for something on the other side of it. "That's, Zoe, is that the same guy from the party? Months ago? The one who said you just looked familiar?"

"Yes," I said.

Another silence. Longer this time.

"So you do know him," John said.

"Yes."

"You told me you didn't."

"I told you we hadn't met before," I said carefully. "That was true at the time. We have a history. I didn't think it was relevant."

"You didn't think it was, " He stopped himself. I could hear him recalibrating. "Zoe. The man is holding your hand on camera in front of half the internet. He's making statements to the press about you. He showed up to get you when," He stopped again. "When I didn't even know you needed getting."

That last sentence landed in the room and sat there.

When I didn't even know you needed getting.

Because you weren't there, I thought. Because you are never there. Because your phone goes dark a half beat too fast and you have lunch at nice restaurants with women whose hands you hold across tables and your girlfriend stood alone outside a venue yesterday while the press descended and the person who came was not you.

I said none of that.

"I was going to call you," I said instead. "Yesterday was a lot. I needed time before I could talk to anyone."

"You needed time," he repeated. "But you called him."

"He called me," I said. "He saw the news and he came."

"And you let him."

"John." My voice was quiet and very controlled. "I was standing alone outside a venue being surrounded by press asking me about drugs that are not mine while my career was being held over a fire. Someone showed up. I let them."

A silence.

"I would have come," he said. "If you'd called me—"

"I shouldn't have to call you," I said.

The words came out before I'd decided to say them.

Quiet. Clear. The truest thing I'd said in this conversation.

Silence on his end.

A long silence.

"What does that mean?" he said finally.

"It means what it means John."

"Zoe—"

"I'm tired," I said. "I barely slept. I have a lot to deal with today. Can we talk about this later?"

A pause. "Fine." His voice had shifted, colder now, the warmth completely gone. "But this conversation isn't over."

"I know," I said.

"I want to know who Bryan is to you," he said. "Properly. Not the version where he just looks familiar."

"I heard you," I said.

"Zoe—"

"I said I heard you John."

A silence.

"I love you," he said.

I looked at the wall across from me.

The morning light falling across it in a clean stripe.

Bryan's message still on my phone screen.

You've already survived yesterday. Remember that.

"Goodbye John," I said softly.

I ended the call.

Sat in the quiet of my apartment with the phone in my lap.

And felt the particular specific exhaustion of a woman who has just been interrogated about the wrong thing by the wrong person on the worst week of her life.

He hadn't asked about the drugs.

Hadn't asked about the dress, or whether I'd slept or eaten or was holding myself together.

He had asked about Bryan.

I opened my journal.

Found the page.

The four questions I'd been adding to and circling and never quite answering.

I read them all.

Then I turned to a clean page.

And wrote one sentence.

Not a question this time.

Not a reflection.

Just a fact, stated plainly, the way facts deserve to be stated when you've finally stopped arguing with them.

The person who should have shown up yesterday didn't.

And the person who had no obligation to show up did.

I think I've known for a while what that means.

I just needed to stop being afraid of it.

I closed the journal.

Looked out the window.

The city moved below, indifferent and continuous.

My phone buzzed.

Not John this time.

A number I didn't recognize.

I stared at it for a moment.

Then answered.

"Hello?"

A pause on the other end. Brief and deliberate.

Then a voice, female, smooth, perfectly composed.

"Zoe. This is Eve Laurent."

Some weeks take everything from you.

The reputation.

The sleep.

The boyfriend who asks the wrong question, on the day you needed the right one.

And then, just when you think the ground, has finished shifting beneath you. the person who started the fire.

calls to introduce herself properly

More Chapters