Cherreads

Chapter 420 - 421: I must not tell lies

The two torturous Defence Against the Dark Arts classes finally ended, and Harry, Ron, and Hermione squeezed out of the classroom with the rest of the silent crowd, mental exhaustion written across all three of their faces.

"I can't believe it," Ron grumbled, rubbing his temples. "She actually made us copy 'The Importance of Ministry-Approved Defensive Theory' three whole times."

Harry and Ron dragged their feet towards the North Tower, preparing themselves for whatever new omens of death Professor Trelawney had in store for them this term.

An hour later, when they met Hermione, who had been waiting for some time near the castle staircase, both boys looked hollow-eyed and exhausted, having just been told several different ways they were apparently going to die within the next week.

"She predicted your death again, Harry?" Hermione asked sharply as she rearranged the heavy books in her bag.

"Drowning this time," Ron answered for him with a yawn. "In a lavatory."

The trio headed silently towards the Great Hall, hoping dinner might soothe their battered spirits.

But before they even reached the doors, they heard an unusual commotion from the entrance hall, including screams of terror and shrill cries in a voice that was irritatingly familiar.

They quickened their pace.

The moment they entered the entrance hall, the sight before them made them forget all their earlier misery and nearly burst out laughing.

Professor Umbridge stood in the middle of the hall, spinning and bouncing like a wind-up pink top, her hands flailing uselessly above her head.

Her screams were almost deafening.

"Get them off! Get them off! Ahhh!"

The culprit was, unsurprisingly, Peeves.

The poltergeist floated in mid-air, gleefully performing somersaults and cackling at the top of his voice.

In his hands were several squeaking grey mice, apparently stolen from a Transfiguration lesson, which he kept throwing into Umbridge's dishevelled hair.

The mice seemed just as terrified as she was. Some clung tightly to her hair with their claws, while others had crawled behind the ridiculous red bow at her chest and latched on there.

"Peeves! I order you to get these... these disgusting creatures off me at once!" Umbridge shrieked, desperately trying to grab the mice.

"Won't! Won't! Silly Professor! Ugly Professor! Pink Toad Professor!" Peeves sang in a tune of his own invention.

Then he hurled a Dungbomb at her, which she narrowly dodged.

When Umbridge noticed the students gathering around, she immediately turned to them as though clutching at a lifeline.

"You! Quickly! Someone help me get these things off! Now!"

What she received instead were dozens of faces desperately trying not to laugh.

Ron deliberately raised his voice, sounding perfectly innocent.

"But Professor, didn't you just teach us that school rules must be strictly obeyed? School rules say students aren't allowed to use magic in the corridors. We can't break the rules."

"Exactly!" Dean Thomas immediately added, struggling to keep a straight face. "We should solve this problem using 'sound, safe, and theoretical' methods, shouldn't we, Professor? Why don't you show us how?"

A wave of muffled laughter spread through the crowd.

Seeing the usually pompous Umbridge in such a miserable state filled the students with a deep sense of vindictive satisfaction.

Harry looked at her panicked expression, and all the anger and frustration he had accumulated that afternoon suddenly found an outlet.

He could not hold it in any longer and burst out laughing.

Amid the suppressed snickering, his laughter sounded especially loud.

Umbridge suddenly managed to seize one of the mice clinging to her bow and slammed it hard onto the floor.

Then she stopped moving.

Her malicious gaze locked onto Harry.

Peeves and the mice still tangled in her hair seemed to stop mattering entirely.

"Potter!"

Her voice was cold.

"For openly mocking a professor in distress and encouraging disorder, your detention will be extended. Starting tonight, every evening at seven, for one week! Now get out of here immediately!"

She pointed her wand towards the Great Hall doors, her chest heaving violently.

Harry's smile froze for a moment, then twisted into a dismissive sneer.

He shrugged and, under the sympathetic yet somewhat admiring looks of his classmates, walked into the Great Hall first.

Ron and Hermione hurried after him.

"Harry," Hermione whispered worriedly, "you really shouldn't provoke her like that..."

"It doesn't matter, Hermione."

Harry took a deep breath.

Although he knew the coming week of detention would probably be miserable, he felt strangely exhilarated.

"Someone has to resist her. What she wants is complete obedience. If everyone just does what she says, then she's already won."

The trio sat down at the Gryffindor table.

Before they could even begin serving themselves, Draco Malfoy approached with the hulking Goyle at his side.

"I heard about your impressive little performance, Potter," Malfoy said.

There was no amusement in his eyes. Instead, he wore a slight frown.

"Openly defying the new Defence Against the Dark Arts professor? I honestly can't decide whether to call you brave or simply stupid."

Harry looked up.

He was too tired and irritated to truly argue with Malfoy, but he still shot back, "And what do you think is useful? Sitting there like you, obediently copying pointless theory and pretending everything is fine?"

Malfoy's lips curled into a sneer.

"At least I'm not like you. All you've accomplished is giving yourself a week of detention and inviting even more trouble. You haven't changed anything, Potter. You're just venting."

"Think whatever you like, Malfoy." Harry waved dismissively. "Someone still has to choose differently."

Malfoy looked Harry up and down, then shook his head.

"Typical foolish lion. Nothing in your head but recklessness and impulse. Hmph. Never mind. Talking to you is pointless."

Without giving Harry a chance to respond, he turned and walked away with Goyle.

Ron pulled a face at Malfoy's retreating back.

"Who does he think he is? Acting as though he knows everything!"

Hermione, however, watched Malfoy leave with a thoughtful expression.

"Much as I hate to admit it... he may be partly right, Harry. Openly confronting Umbridge like this is dangerous, and it could end up having the opposite effect from what you want."

"Then what am I supposed to do?"

Harry stabbed irritably at a potato with his fork.

"Sit there nodding along like she wants? Admit that Voldemort never came back? Admit that Professor Greengrass is a criminal? I can't do that! He saved my life from Voldemort, more than once!"

Hermione sighed and said nothing more.

At a quarter past seven that evening, Harry stood alone outside Umbridge's office on the 2nd floor.

He took a deep breath and knocked on the door with its lace-covered handle.

"Come in."

Umbridge's sickly sweet voice came from inside.

Harry pushed open the door and entered.

The sight of the office almost suffocated him. Pink and lace covered nearly everything.

A series of plates depicting cats hung on the walls, each one wearing a bow and mewing softly.

The air was thick with a cloying perfume.

Umbridge sat behind an ornate desk draped with a pink tablecloth.

That professional, utterly cold false smile was still plastered across her face.

"Good evening, Mr Potter. You are punctual," she said, her voice as mild as though she were discussing the weather.

"Good evening, Professor," Harry replied, keeping his tone as calm as possible.

They looked at each other in a strange, restrained silence, as though the farce in the entrance hall that afternoon had never happened.

Umbridge's small eyes lingered on Harry for a moment, her gaze like someone evaluating an unsatisfactory tool.

Her smile remained fixed as she took an exceptionally fine piece of parchment and a sharp-looking black quill from a drawer, placed them on the desk, and pushed them towards Harry.

"I think we need a method that will... impress upon you the importance of proper behaviour in class, Mr Potter."

Her voice remained sickly sweet.

"You will write the sentence: 'I must not tell lies.'"

"How many times?" Harry secretly breathed a sigh of relief. Thankfully, it was only lines.

"Until I tell you to stop," Umbridge said with a smile.

Harry looked at the quill, and an ominous feeling rose inside him.

There was no ink.

"Professor," he said, trying to keep his voice steady, "this quill doesn't seem to have any ink."

Umbridge's smile widened, revealing a row of small, neat teeth.

"Oh, it will write, dear. With a... very special ink. You'll see. Now, begin."

Harry hesitantly picked up the quill.

Its tip was unusually sharp and cold against his fingers.

He wrote the first word on the parchment.

I.

A searing pain instantly shot across the back of his hand.

Harry gasped sharply and nearly dropped the quill.

Looking down, he saw that the word he had just written on the parchment was now deeply etched into the skin on the back of his hand in a vivid red mark, as though carved with a knife. Tiny beads of blood were already welling along its edges.

He looked up at Umbridge in disbelief.

She was staring at the wound on his hand with an almost delighted expression, as though admiring a flower in bloom.

"What's wrong?"

Umbridge asked with feigned concern, her broad, toad-like mouth stretched into a smile.

"Nothing," Harry said quietly.

"Then continue, Mr Potter," she urged gently, with a faint excitement in her voice. "Remember, you will write until I am satisfied."

A wave of nausea rose in Harry's throat, but he clenched his jaw.

He knew that screaming, protesting, or throwing down the quill was exactly what this woman wanted.

It would mean that her punishment had been "effective", that she had succeeded in breaking his will.

Harry took a deep breath, endured the burning pain, and lowered his head again.

He gripped the hateful quill tightly and pressed its tip back to the parchment.

I must not...

With every stroke, sharp pain tore across the back of his hand.

New wounds overlapped the old ones, crimson letters gradually forming across his skin. Blood slowly trickled between his fingers and dripped onto Umbridge's spotless pink carpet, leaving dark red stains behind.

The office was eerily silent.

Only the faint scratching of the quill against parchment and Harry's heavy breathing could be heard as he struggled to endure the pain.

Umbridge said nothing more.

She simply sat there with her eternally unchanging false smile, quietly enjoying the torture she had created.

Harry remained silent as well.

He simply kept writing, resisting wave after wave of pain through sheer willpower.

He bit his lower lip until he tasted blood.

He would never show weakness in front of this woman.

The pain and the blood instead became a brand, making him remember her more clearly, remember the Ministry of Magic's lies, and remember the truth he had to uphold.

___

o(*≧▽≦)ツ💫 Read up to 12+ chapters in advance on Patreon/DarkDevil1

More Chapters