In the Liverpool end, there was only heavy silence.
Skrtel stood with his face buried in both hands, the heels of his palms pressed hard against his forehead. His shoulders were slightly rounded trying to compress the feeling down into somewhere it couldn't be seen.
Around him, his teammates' expressions moved between helplessness, frustration, and tried to redirect both into something useful.
Liverpool tried to reorganize. They pushed higher, tried to compress Hull's defensive shape, tried to manufacture the rhythmic, pressing movement that had torn Everton apart. But nothing linked.
Julien worked tirelessly up front, using his movement to drag defenders out of position, but the team as a whole was listless. The passing was arduous and slightly off not terribly, but enough that every move arrived a half-beat too slow, every pass landed fractionally behind the run or just ahead of the receiving foot, enough that the pattern that was supposed to emerge never quite formed.
Suárez was being suffocated. Hull had done their homework: wherever he moved, two blue shirts moved with him, and the spaces that had opened for him all season were thoroughly closed before he could occupy them. He barely got a touch on the ball in threatening areas.
Julien ran and probed and created—but with his teammates misfiring around him, it felt like trying to hold back a tide with his bare hands. Liverpool's attacks were toothless, and Hull's goalkeeper was barely tested.
Then, in the thirty-seventh minute, the deadlock finally broke.
Julien collected the ball to the right of the penalty area in a pocket of space that had briefly opened between Hull's two tracking defenders. He had perhaps two seconds before he was closed down by those two defenders.
He didn't look for a pass. He looked at the situation, at the angles his body was already reading and he committed.
The ball went back and forth between his feet in a rapid sequence of changes of direction creating a yard of space carved from nothing by sheer individual intelligence, by the slight misalignment of two defenders' weight as his movement fractionally outpaced their adjustments.
Then he struck.
Hard. Curling. With a low, dangerous velocity that had the goalkeeper moving before he could think. The ball flew into the top-left corner and stayed there.
1–1.
He ran toward the Liverpool end with his arms raised and his face was completely bright and open. It had been his first meaningful opportunity of the entire match, and he had taken it entirely on his own.
But the equaliser didn't shake Liverpool awake.
The goal was an intervention, not a revival—a single moment of individual brilliance that paused the afternoon's drift without reversing it.
Around Julien, the same problems reunited themselves: the midfield still couldn't hold the ball under pressure, the supply lines to Suárez were still blocked, and the shape that was supposed to carry Liverpool through the second half was still more aspiration than reality.
Hull came out after the interval playing with the compact, energized confidence after they had absorbed Liverpool's some best shots and come through it intact.
In the fifty-second minute, Livermore collected the ball in central midfield with barely any pressure and did not hesitate. He swung his foot through the ball from twenty-five yards cleanly without overthinking.
The strike was powerful and precisely placed, low enough to stay under Mignolet's dive, high enough to beat any attempt to block it at goal-line.
Mignolet got nowhere near it. The ball buried itself in the net.
2–1.
Liverpool were behind again. This time it was Gerrard who stepped forward.
In the sixty-fifth minute, Julien found him with a cutback that was one of the few pieces of genuine quality the two of them had managed to combine for all afternoon, arriving at Gerrard's feet just outside the area at exactly the moment when everything had aligned.
Gerrard took one touch to set himself. One touch. Then he drove a magnificent shot into the top of the net, the ball was kissing the underside of the crossbar on its way in with the ringing sound that a struck ball makes.
2–2.
The Liverpool fans dared to hope again.
Steven sprinted to the touchline, pumping his fist so fiercely his whole upper body shook, roaring at his teammates to push forward, his voice was booming above the noise of the Liverpool end.
It was a brief flicker of light in an otherwise dark afternoon. And like all brief flickers, it made the darkness that followed feel darker by contrast.
The flicker lasted thirteen minutes.
In the seventy-eighth minute, Meyler received wide on the right and shook off Johnson with a single movement of a slight drop of the shoulder and a burst of acceleration that caught Johnson's weight on the wrong foot and delivered a precise cross.
Livermore arrived at the near post in full flight. He connected cleanly, his header was powered low and hard, angling down past Mignolet's right hand and into the net before the goalkeeper could respond.
3–2.
The KC Stadium shook with noise. Hull's Players were piling on each other in a chaotic heap near the corner flag. Hull fans were gripping strangers by the shoulders. In the press box, several journalists were already rewriting their match reports in real time.
This goal had driven a stake through Liverpool's heart.
Liverpool spent the final twelve or so minutes attempting a siege that never fully formed.
Klopp threw forward every attacking option available to him in search of an equalizer, but Hull dropped deep and disciplined, and Liverpool could carve out nothing of quality. The ball went wide, over, into bodies—but never into the net.
The final whistle blew over a stadium still roaring.
Hull City 3–2 Liverpool.
Liverpool had fallen to a stunning upset, and their winning run was over.
Klopp stood on the touchline for a long moment after the whistle, jaw set, eyes dark. His pre-match words were still hanging in the air and reality had answered them bluntly.
The defeat sent shockwaves through the press.
The Times led with a verdict that was blunt enough to carry its own sting: "This was not a shock result—it was the inevitable consequence of Liverpool's own failings."
The piece argued that Klopp had overestimated his squad's stability and underestimated Hull's hunger; that the warning signs visible in the midfield structure had not been addressed; and that the comfortable winning run of recent weeks had, perhaps, allowed a degree of shared complacency to settle in beneath the surface of confidence—invisible in the good results, visible the moment a disciplined, direct opponent applied the right kind of pressure.
The Daily Mail ran the headline: De Rocca Carries the Burden Alone—Red Machine Breaks Down.
Their match report noted the bitter irony of the occasion with something that might, in a different context, have read as sympathy: this young Frenchman had just turned nineteen, and this defeat —his very first match as a nineteen-year-old—was how that chapter of his life had opened.
The paper noted that Suárez had touched the ball only twenty-three times in the entire match and created precisely zero chances becoming an unrecognizable player from his recent form:
"Hull's suffocating man-marking neutralized Suárez completely," the report read, "and Liverpool's midfield offered no supply line to release either of their forwards. Gerrard's equalizer was a moment of individual brilliance, but a single flash of class cannot mask a team-wide malaise."
Sky Sports aimed their sights at the manager directly. "He promised three points before kick-off. He left with nothing."
Their analysis praised Steve Bruce's pragmatic, disciplined game plan, compact defensive structure, specific tactical instructions for the double-team on Suárez, swift transitions through midfield into wide areas, and the explicit instruction to shoot from distance whenever the central channel opened.
"Both of Livermore's goals were the perfect response to Liverpool's inability to protect the center of the pitch."
The Liverpool Echo was the restrained voice of the morning, and perhaps the most honest.
"This defeat is painful, but it may prove useful. Consecutive wins can breed complacency without anyone realizing it. This match has held a mirror up to the squad—the defensive frailty, the thinness in central midfield, the over-reliance on individual moments. Julien's emergence gives Liverpool genuine cause for optimism. But Klopp must address these structural issues quickly if the club is to stay in contention for the title."
At the post-match press conference, Klopp did something that managers very rarely do with complete sincerity. He sat forward in the chair and spoke directly into the cameras.
"I want to apologize to every Liverpool fan. The responsibility for this result is mine entirely."
He paused and let the words sit in the room for a moment.
"Before kick-off I told everyone we would win. We didn't. Our passing was poor from first to last, we lost control of midfield, and we made basic errors at the back. Those are failures of my tactical preparation and my pre-match management. I said we were ready. We were not as ready as I believed."
He let another pause land. "I give the fans my word—we will learn from this. I will look hard at my own decisions and address the issues this match exposed. The season is long. One defeat does not end our ambitions. We will work harder, and we will repay the supporters' faith with results."
There was nothing performative in it.
Back in Liverpool, the reaction among fans was one of frustration tinged with pragmatism.
A thread titled "If You Want to Win the Title, You Have to Learn to Crush the Weak" had reached the top of the fan forums within an hour of the final whistle.
The original poster wrote bluntly: "Hull City are fighting to stay up. We should have put them away. This is how title races are won and lost—not just in the big games, but in the ones you're supposed to win. Today was a lesson we shouldn't have needed."
The replies ranged from analysis to frustration to the occasional burst of emotion.
One user, posting under "Anfield in the Wind," wrote: " The squad still needs time to gel. The midfield depth problem is there for everyone to see. Kanté is talented but he's young, and you can see the inexperience in moments like today. And when Gerrard dips, there's nobody ready to step in and fill that role. We need another midfielder. The defense needs steadier options too. Klopp has to find the right first eleven and build a system around it—and that takes time.""
In the Boot Room, the pints sat at slightly lower levels than usual, and the conversations moved at a pace that matched them.
The lights were warm above the dark tables, and people filled the chairs in ones and twos, not in the heaving groups of a derby celebration. The mood was thoughtful rather than defeated which, at this stage of a title campaign, is probably the right mood to have.
An older fan with grey hair exhaled slowly. "Losing hurts. But it's not all bad. The winning run was covering up problems that were always there. Better they come out now than in March when the title is on the line."
The younger man beside him nodded without disagreement. "Klopp's system is right. It just needs more time to click with the players."
Someone further down the bar slapped the table. "We need to spend in January. A creative midfielder, a commanding center-back—proper reinforcements. Not just for this season. What's the minimum? Top four. You'd take that right now. But let's at least make sure we're in the Champions League next year while we figure out the rest."
Ted banged the table with the flat of his hand, hard enough to make the glasses jump and rattle against each other.
"Don't worry—the club's going to move in the transfer window, I guarantee it. Once Christmas is done, we're into the real push for points, and we'll need proper reinforcements for that—not just for this season, but for next as well. At the very minimum we need to make sure we're in the Champions League next year. That's the floor. Everything else we figure out from there."
Not long after the final whistle, Julien made a phone call.
"Kevin…"
________________________________________________________
Check out my patreon where you can read more chapters:
patreon.com/LorianFiction
Thanks for your support!