Benítez had promised Liverpool supporters a response after losing the UEFA Super Cup, and his players delivered one.
At Anfield, Liverpool defeated Arsenal 1-0.
New Manchester United's analysts had already identified Arsenal's biggest weakness during their pre-season work: once Patrick Vieira left, the depth and balance of Wenger's midfield deteriorated sharply.
Mathieu Flamini had potential, but he was still developing physically and did not yet look completely comfortable as the deepest midfielder in demanding matches. He worked hard and used the ball intelligently, but he was not a natural destroyer.
Alexandre Song offered more defensive aggression after arriving from Bastia, yet Wenger remained reluctant to trust him in major fixtures.
That was partly philosophical.
Wenger had always demanded more from his midfielders than tackling alone. He wanted players who could receive under pressure, circulate possession and contribute to Arsenal's passing game.
Song's defensive qualities were obvious, but his distribution still needed refinement.
There was nothing inherently right or wrong about that preference. Every manager built according to his own principles.
The problem was that Arsenal's current squad no longer offered enough alternatives.
Their attacking players contributed relatively little defensively, while Gilberto Silva was carrying too much responsibility in front of the back four.
Against weaker opposition, Arsenal could often compensate through possession and attacking quality.
Against elite midfields, the weakness became much easier to expose.
Liverpool exposed it at Anfield.
Aimar, rested for the Super Cup in Monaco, returned to Benítez's starting eleven and immediately transformed Liverpool's attacking play.
He moved constantly between Arsenal's midfield and defence, demanding the ball in difficult areas and turning before Wenger's players could close him down.
Throughout the match, he created several excellent chances.
Michael Owen failed to convert one.
Luis García wasted another.
Cissé also had opportunities.
Eventually, Aimar appeared to decide that creating chances for everyone else was not enough.
He scored the winner himself.
Liverpool won 1-0 and maintained their perfect start.
New Manchester United also collected three points, although Birmingham made them work considerably harder.
Steve Bruce's side had already caused Manchester City major problems and arrived determined to do the same at New Manchester United's stadium.
They succeeded for long stretches.
Birmingham scored first and defended stubbornly.
Mourinho's side had to remain patient before Kaká equalised and Beckham completed the comeback.
The final score was 2-1.
It was nothing like the demolition of Portsmouth, but Mourinho valued the result almost as highly.
Championship campaigns were not built entirely on spectacular victories.
Sometimes the important thing was winning when the opponent had made the match ugly.
Elsewhere, Chelsea travelled across London and defeated Tottenham 2-0.
Shevchenko continued his strong return from injury by scoring again, while Ashley Cole added the other goal.
Manchester United also won 2-0 away from home, beating Newcastle through goals from Robinho and Ruud van Nistelrooy.
Manchester City hosted Portsmouth hoping to build on their difficult victory at Birmingham.
The first half was poor.
Neither side found rhythm, and City's expensive midfield struggled to translate possession into clear chances.
Yaya Touré finally broke the deadlock after half-time with a powerful shot from distance.
Portsmouth refused to disappear.
They equalised and then enjoyed a spell in which Manchester City looked uncomfortable again.
Van Gaal responded with several tactical changes.
The winner arrived in the seventy-ninth minute when Ibrahimović converted to make it 2-1.
City had recovered from their humiliating opening defeat with three consecutive league victories.
Liverpool, however, remained the story of the opening month.
Four matches brought four wins and twelve points.
Few people had expected Benítez's side to begin the season at the top of the table, particularly after their inconsistent pre-season.
Behind them, New Manchester United, Manchester United and Chelsea each had ten points.
The Red Rebels had won three and drawn one.
Manchester United's only dropped points had come in an unexpected 2-2 draw at home to Droylsden.
Goal difference separated the three clubs, leaving New Manchester United second, Manchester United third and Chelsea fourth.
Manchester City had nine points despite their opening-day defeat.
Everton and Tottenham were also on nine, though inferior goal difference placed them below City.
Arsenal's start was considerably more worrying.
Two wins and two defeats left Wenger's side on six points and down in tenth.
That alone was not disastrous after four matches.
The wider picture was more troubling.
Vieira had gone.
Ashley Cole had gone.
Henry, Pires and Ljungberg were no longer surrounded by the same dominant structure that had once carried Arsenal through matches almost automatically.
Wenger still possessed enormous talent, but for the first time in several years, there were serious questions about whether the squad remained deep enough to challenge for the title.
After the fourth round, the Premier League stopped for international football.
European qualification for the 2006 World Cup entered another crucial phase, while national teams in Africa, South America and elsewhere also called up players for competitive fixtures and friendlies.
For New Manchester United, international breaks had become increasingly difficult.
Success created one unavoidable problem: more players were selected by their countries.
Drogba was captain and first-choice striker for Ivory Coast.
Essien was indispensable to Ghana.
Spain had now called Villa into the senior squad.
Ishmael Miller had also established himself around the England setup. He was not yet a guaranteed starter, but his performances at the World Youth Championship and for New Manchester United had earned him regular consideration.
That development left players such as Peter Crouch facing a more difficult route into the England squad.
Ishmael offered many of the same advantages as a tall centre-forward while adding far greater pace, strength and explosiveness.
Ronaldo remained central to Portugal.
Robben was important to the Netherlands.
Ribéry had become increasingly influential for France and worked particularly well alongside Zidane.
Robben's call-up worried Mourinho most.
The winger had only recently returned after a long injury.
New Manchester United would have preferred his workload to remain tightly controlled.
The Netherlands, however, needed him.
Robben wanted to represent his country.
The club could advise, but it was not going to create a confrontation with a player who was medically fit and eager to go.
Messi received another Argentina call-up after his extraordinary World Youth Championship.
Whether he would start was uncertain, but his progression into the senior national-team picture was accelerating rapidly.
Kaká was already one of Brazil's major players.
Beckham remained England's captain and central organiser.
De Rossi had become a first-choice midfielder for Italy alongside Pirlo.
Mikel's performances for Nigeria at youth level and his increasingly assured club displays earned him a place in the senior Nigerian squad as well.
Fàbregas did not receive the same opportunity with Spain.
That had less to do with his quality than with the extraordinary competition in Spanish midfield.
At eighteen, he could afford to wait.
The defenders were equally busy.
Evra's performances had finally carried him past Abidal in France's left-back hierarchy.
His balance between attack and defence suited the national team, and he had become increasingly difficult to displace.
Lahm was firmly established with Germany.
Maicon had strengthened his position with Brazil as Cafu approached the later stages of his international career.
His newest competitor came from his own club.
Dani Alves received his first senior Brazil call-up.
Alves was not yet seriously threatening Maicon's position, but the rivalry that Mourinho wanted at club level was beginning to appear internationally as well.
England had settled on Terry and Curtis as its preferred centre-back pairing.
Curtis's consistency had pushed Rio Ferdinand into a more competitive position for minutes.
At only twenty, the New Manchester United vice-captain had already accumulated enough senior football to look completely comfortable at international level.
Vidić remained one of Serbia's defensive leaders.
Chiellini received another Italy call-up, although he still had experienced players ahead of him.
Čech joined the Czech Republic.
Kasey Keller reported for United States duty.
By the time the squad dispersed, Newton Heath looked almost empty.
The training complex itself did not.
England were using it again.
The national team had become increasingly comfortable at New Manchester United's facilities, and supporters had begun joking that Newton Heath brought them luck.
England's performances had improved significantly since Eriksson began using Beckham as the central reference point of the midfield.
Gerrard and Lampard were still important, but rather than asking all three to perform similar jobs, Eriksson had gradually developed clearer roles around Beckham's distribution.
The result had been a significant improvement in England's qualifying campaign.
Now came Poland.
The match carried enormous importance.
A victory would move England ahead of the Poles and give them control of the group.
Eriksson again trusted several New Manchester United players.
Beckham started.
Terry started.
Curtis started.
Ishmael was named among the substitutes.
From the opening minutes, England looked the stronger team.
Beckham controlled the tempo from midfield.
England did not rush attacks unnecessarily.
They circulated the ball patiently, forcing Poland to defend for long periods and preventing their counter-attacking game from developing.
In the thirty-fourth minute, Rooney forced Jerzy Dudek into a strong save.
The Polish goalkeeper tipped the shot over the crossbar.
England had a corner.
Beckham walked across to take it.
His delivery curled towards the far post.
Terry attacked through traffic, rose above the defender challenging him and powered his header towards goal.
Dudek could not reach it.
1-0.
England continued to dominate after the interval.
In the sixty-third minute, Beckham received possession with time and spotted Rooney's run behind the defensive line.
The pass split Poland open.
Rooney stayed onside, entered the penalty area and drove a low finish beyond Dudek.
2-0.
England created further chances but did not need another goal.
The match ended 2-0, and England moved above Poland into first place in the group.
For Eriksson, it was another confirmation that the structure built around Beckham was working.
For Mourinho, watching from Manchester, it was something else entirely.
It was another ninety minutes in Beckham's legs.
And Beckham was hardly alone.
Drogba played heavily for Ivory Coast.
Essien did the same for Ghana.
De Rossi played major minutes for Italy.
Several others were used for almost complete matches, sometimes twice within the same international window.
Mourinho hated it.
Not because he opposed international football.
He understood what representing a country meant to players.
He understood why supporters cared.
His frustration was practical.
The club employed the players, paid their wages, managed their conditioning and dealt with the consequences when they returned exhausted or injured.
International managers had different priorities.
If a World Cup qualifier mattered, they naturally wanted their best players for ninety minutes.
Club schedules were someone else's problem.
That tension had become one of the central disputes between Europe's leading clubs and the international governing bodies.
G14 had been pushing FIFA and UEFA for a more formal system governing player release, insurance and compensation.
The Charleroi dispute had already intensified the argument over what happened when a player was injured while representing his country.
Legal cases surrounding the issue were moving through European courts, and some of the compensation figures discussed publicly had reached extraordinary levels.
Ethan regarded much of the rhetoric from both sides as negotiating pressure.
The clubs had legitimate concerns.
So did the governing bodies.
FIFA could not simply allow clubs to decide that important internationals were inconvenient and refuse to release players.
At the same time, expecting clubs to carry every financial and sporting risk without meaningful compensation was becoming increasingly difficult to defend.
A complete victory for either side was unlikely.
Compromise was the realistic outcome.
One possibility under discussion was a more coordinated international calendar, reducing the number of separate interruptions to club seasons.
Insurance and compensation arrangements were another.
The issue was especially difficult for competitions held during the European club season.
The Africa Cup of Nations created exactly that problem.
New Manchester United had already received preliminary call-up notifications for Drogba, Essien and Mikel ahead of the tournament scheduled for early 2006.
All three were important players.
Losing them simultaneously for several weeks in January and February would create a serious problem during one of the busiest periods of the English season.
Mourinho could complain.
He could plan.
He could not reasonably ask them to reject their countries.
The immediate concern was simpler.
Getting the players safely back from the international break.
The Lab had become even stricter since Robben's injury.
Reputation no longer mattered once a player entered the performance centre.
If the medical and conditioning staff believed someone had not recovered sufficiently, Mourinho did not use him.
There were no exceptions for stars.
By the time the squad reported back to Newton Heath, the testing produced exactly the result Mourinho feared.
Too many players were below the required physical threshold.
Several had played two internationals within two weeks.
Many had completed close to the full ninety minutes in both.
Drogba was restricted.
Essien was restricted.
Mikel was restricted.
Robben was unavailable.
Messi needed recovery.
Beckham was ruled out.
Terry was rested.
Kaká had accumulated too much workload.
Maicon and Evra also failed to meet the performance staff's preferred recovery markers.
Mourinho stared at the report and swore.
The next Premier League match was against Droylsden.
Three days later came the Champions League trip to Udinese.
He could not simply ignore the medical advice.
That was how soft-tissue injuries happened.
So Mourinho turned to the academy.
Theo Walcott received the call.
The young English forward had become one of Newton Heath's most exciting prospects.
His defining quality was immediately obvious.
He was extraordinarily quick.
In internal testing, few players at any level of the club could match his acceleration and top speed.
The difference between Walcott and many other fast young players was that his game had not been built around pace alone.
Years of technical work under coaches such as Moniz and Meulensteen had given him excellent close control.
He could change direction without losing much speed.
He could receive on the move.
He attacked defenders willingly.
At academy and reserve level, he had already produced scoring numbers that compared favourably with the early records of Ishmael and Messi.
Supporters had begun paying attention long before Mourinho called him into the senior squad.
The obvious comparison was Thierry Henry.
Walcott encouraged it himself.
Henry was his favourite forward.
He studied footage of the Arsenal striker constantly, particularly his movement from the left, his changes of pace and the way he opened his body before finishing into the far corner.
That imitation could be seen in Walcott's game.
The upright running style.
The sudden acceleration.
The preference for attacking from wider starting positions.
Even some of his finishing movements carried traces of Henry.
Meulensteen was cautious about the comparison.
Technically, he believed Walcott at the same age was already extremely advanced.
That did not mean he would become Henry.
Youth football was full of players whose development changed dramatically once their bodies matured.
Walcott still needed greater strength.
The club's performance staff were carefully managing that process.
Adding muscle could help him survive senior football, but too much, too quickly, might interfere with the mobility and fluidity that made him special.
Everything had to be gradual.
For now, Mourinho was not asking Walcott to become the next Thierry Henry.
He was asking him to train with the first team.
Then, if necessary, to play.
International football had taken half the senior squad away and returned several of them exhausted.
For the biggest clubs in Europe, that was why international breaks had earned such a bitter reputation.
They were supposed to celebrate the world's best players representing their countries.
For managers trying to survive four competitions at once, they often felt more like days of disaster.
(To be continued.)
