Chapter Fifty-One – Let's Be Mates Forever
Despite his earlier courage, Jack couldn't help but be acutely aware of Theo's mighty presence. Mighty because everything about the alpha fit that description. Jack let his fingers move over Theodore's sculpted shoulder, feeling the muscles beneath the smooth skin, and his own skin began to burn. What fire? No one needed that when a simple touch was enough to make him feel like this.
Vince had somehow managed to end up right behind him which meant that he was in danger of becoming the meat in a hunk sandwich. Seeing what a thin slice of meat he was, not even counting the bones, of which there were plenty, that sandwich risked being a sorry excuse for a meal. Jack saw no reason why anyone would prefer him instead of just opting for the two buns, aka hunks, instead and have their meal that way.
Theodore's eyes, deep, blue, and demanding, were so close that they were making him dizzy.
"What are you thinking about, Wolfie?"
Jack shivered and let out a short, nervous laugh. "By now, you should know what calling me that does to me."
"I'll know only if you tell me."
Jack tried to pull back so he could have a better look at Theo and his amazing eyes, but his retreat was cut short by Vince's strong body. They were both so hot – literally and not so literally.
"How on earth did I end up in this sandwich?" Jack wondered, without realizing that he had said it out loud.
"Are you afraid, Jack?" Vince asked, always so serious and kind. "We will be gentle. We promise."
"It's not about being afraid. It's more about… do I deserve this?" Jack blurted out.
Theodore took his hand and kissed it. "You've been at the center of the most important events in my life since you appeared in it. Why would you think you don't deserve this?"
"Well," Jack started, still fighting to ignore the heat pooling in his lower belly the more these two hunks were pressing against him. "I mean, I suppose you're right because I'm like the Sun's son and the Moon's… also son, though I'm still struggling with understanding how they made me."
"See? You're quite the catch, Jack," Vince hurried to assure him.
"Hey, is that your--" Jack swallowed his words. He could definitely feel Vince's large manhood resting against his lower back. "Maybe we should start," he added, as means to encourage himself, though he didn't feel any braver than he had a few moments ago.
Theodore cupped his cheek in his palm and held him in his blue stare. "It's been a while since we enjoyed each other's bodies, and I believe you need a reminder of how good it feels."
"Yeah, without a doubt. Although we did extremely little if I recall correctly."
"Nothing was little," Vince teased him. "Come on, Jack, touch Theodore a little. Can't you see that you're torturing him?"
"I'm doing nothing like that," Jack protested. "And if you mean that I'm enticing him with my as good as non-existent sexiness--"
His protests turned into a muffled moan as Theodore kissed him. Ah, a soft sigh was rising from his chest, while Theo's warmth engulfed him. He couldn't even tell what he was afraid of. Not that he was afraid-afraid. After all, yeah, he'd been through so much and contributed to the defeat of the most evil of evil forces.
What was being penetrated by an alpha's huge dick compared to all of that?
An alpha's huge dick. Vee was right. He needed to put his hands on Theo and remember exactly how big that thing was.
Theodore moaned as they kissed once Jack began to touch his body blindly. There it was, majestic as ever and, of course, huge. He was holding it with both hands; rubbing it a little was only bound to make it bigger but Jack couldn't help himself. The more he did it, the harder and bigger Theo's not so little friend grew.
"Wow, look at it," he exclaimed, pulling his mouth away from Theo's lips. "Damn, I want to feel that in my mouth."
"Are you sure, Jack? You won't be able to save your ass even if you insist on sucking me off multiple times."
"I wasn't doing anything like that," Jack denied right away. "Come on, you can't blame me for trying. And, anyway, I do want to suck your cock. Wow, I've started talking dirty."
Vince laughed in his ear, tickling him. "It's all right, Jack. You are really good at it."
"You are only saying that because you like me."
"I can both like you and say such things to you because they're true," Vince argued.
Caught up as he was in bantering with Vince, he didn't realize that he had increased the rhythm of his rubbing. Theodore was making all kinds of sounds, manly and sometimes cute for an alpha his size.
"Jack, if you continue--" he grunted.
"Oops." Jack let go only to earn himself a miserable whimper from Theo. "I'm bad at this mating thing, right? Wait, I know what I must do."
"Really?" Theodore asked, still stricken over having his impending orgasm ruined like that.
"Yes." Jack snapped his fingers. "Wait for it… light bulb moment… I need to stop talking and start sucking."
***
Jack was simply too cute for his own good. And he seemed to have a penchant for ruining things and putting them back together, managing to make them even better in the process. Because, right now, Theodore didn't even think of the mechanics of mating while he had Jack between his legs, filling his lovely mouth with enough cock to last him a week.
For all that he lacked in technique and experience, Jack was clearly great at compensating through enthusiasm. He was only halfway swallowing Theodore's cock, but his nimble fingers were teasing the ball sac underneath, which definitely made a difference.
"Jack, be careful," Theodore warned.
Jack's eyes fleeted to him, and as his eyelids dropped, Theodore got the message. It wasn't inside Jack's cute ass, as he had planned, but he was a man, after all, and one who hadn't gotten around to enjoy this in so long.
Vince held Jack's head, adjusting his position slowly so he could swallow properly. Theodore couldn't say why, but that care on the guardian's part seemed completely erotic and sensual to him. He wrapped a hand behind Vince's head and kissed him as he shot inside Jack's mouth. The clever seer was now happily swallowing an alpha's load, which meant that they were on the right path as far as their mating was concerned.
He leaned on his back, eager to catch his breath and Jack moved to straddle him. The taste of his own seed in his mate's mouth was heavenly, but he wanted and needed more. A lot more.
"Vince," he called for his other mate. "Give us your cock."
The guardian didn't need to be invited twice to join in the fun. Theodore wrapped one arm around Vince's thick, muscular thigh as the guardian came to kneel by his alpha's head.
Jack understood the job description. He took Vince's cock, dark and leaking delicious precum and ran his lips and tongue over it, offering Theodor a front-row seat to one of the most sensual scenes he had witnessed in his life when it came to having a sexual experience.
"Would you like some?" Jack asked, holding Vince's cock and pointing it toward Theodore.
"Of course." Theodore mimicked Jack's moves from earlier, flicking his tongue over the head.
Seeing his mate's reactions gave him satisfaction for having to endure his unintended teasing earlier. Jack was getting hard, maybe without even knowing it, because his gaze was enraptured, taken with what he was witnessing.
Theodore wanted to be a generous lover for his mates. He moved Vince's cock between him and Jack, so they could both enjoy it at the same time. Their mouths met over the hard meat, and they were kissing and having a go at Vince's manhood, making their beloved guardian curse softly and praise them, all the while encouraging them to do a good job.
The fruits of their labor didn't hesitate to appear. Theodore placed his mouth over Vince's cock and swallowed a great deal, ignoring Jack's pleas to have some, too. His mate would have enough, but he would get his portion from his alpha's mouth.
They kissed again, and Jack began rubbing against him desperately.
"You two came already," he complained. "I'm the only one who didn't."
"Would you like me to blow you? Or do you think you're ready for what I have in mind for you?"
"Are you talking about butt-fucking? Can I take some butt-fucking?"
"I can't see why you couldn't," Theodore replied. "Are you up for it?"
Jack hesitated, but no more coaxing was needed. He slid from Theodore's body and proudly and bravely presented his lovely behind.
"Is this how I'm supposed to take it?"
Theodore's cock, while still in withdrawal after the earlier blow, twitched to show its interest.
"That's a good position, Jack. You make me want to mount you."
Jack snickered, but then he recalled that he was supposed to be at least a little concerned about the size difference. "Is there any magic we could use so my ass will be spared?"
Theodore came behind his mate and happily bit into Jack's scrumptious buns.
"Ouch," Jack protested right away. "Actually, you could do that again. Yeah, it feels good. Like it's tickling me a little."
"I know a better way to make you feel good." Theodore didn't offer other warnings and pushed his tongue between Jack's butt cheeks, going straight for the prize.
"Oh," Jack exclaimed. "You're right. This feels amazing!"
Theodore was about to ask Vince to join them when he felt a hot tongue on his ass. For a moment, he stopped. Should an alpha accept that from one of his mates?
He couldn't see why not. In this place where mating happened for alphas, he knew he could do no wrong. There were no wrong choices, and he was starting to see why he needed two mates, and not only one, as was the case for most alphas.
He wanted both ends of the stick. Yes, he'd eat his cake and have it, too. Great, and now he was thinking just like Jack, who'd surely approve of his choice of words.
***
Vince had sensed Theodore's hesitation, but he didn't plan on letting it get in the way. He'd give his alpha all the reassurance he needed about accepting his mate's cock inside him. It wouldn't make him less of a man, or less of an alpha.
A burning desire had started inside him the moment they had walked into this magical place. His role had become clear. He would be the one to claim the alpha's body while Theodore would claim Jack's, and together they would become inseparable.
"Jack, do you have any idea what I'm doing now?"
"You're licking Theo's butt, right?" Jack's voice came out hitched and broken. It was only normal. After all, Vince could tell Theodore had to have half his tongue at least buried inside Jack's ass. Alphas never did things by half, though, which meant that Theodore had a little more work to do. Vince planned on doing the same and not lagging behind.
"I am, and it's pure heaven. But I'm not doing this only to have our alpha shiver and curse from too much desire. I'm doing it because I'm getting him ready to receive his first cock ever."
"In his butt?" Jack asked. Excitement was easy to read in his voice. "Are you going to do Theo in the butt?"
"Leaving aside your unceremonious choice of words, yes, that is precisely what I have in mind," Vince confessed. "That is if our alpha doesn't take issue with being on the receiving end."
"That sounds so hot," Jack said. "Theo, your tongue is just so good. What happens if I come while you lick my ass and balls?"
"I haven't licked your balls yet," Theodore cared to correct his naughty mate. "If you come, you come. Don't worry for a moment that it's going to make you any less in my eyes. Or in Vince's eyes."
"Cool. I worried there for a moment. So, if I come too soon, I won't ruin our mating and ritual or anything?"
"No, not at all. We are free to go about this mating thing as we see fit," Theodore assured Jack.
"So, we're freestyling. That's good to know. Oh, that lick was something new. Vee, you have to try Theodore's tongue. It's something else."
"I plan on doing that," Vee said. "But all in due time. I'm now carefully preparing our alpha for being penetrated the same way you will be soon, I'm sure."
Jack whimpered in arousal. "We're both virgins in the butt," he said.
Theodore interrupted his mate's chatting by smacking his ass. "Yes, we are. But if we want our ritual to succeed, you'll need to shut up, Jack."
"Okay, okay, I get it. Ah, magic place, give me strength. I'm about to get poked in the butt. Take good care of me."
"I'll be the one to do that," Theodore said and returned to his licking with renewed vigor.
***
If this ass-licking continued, Jack saw no reason why he wouldn't come on the spot, but a new ambition was taking root in his mind. If he wanted to be worthy of being Theodore's mate, he needed to show a little bit of self-restraint. Also, he had the idea that he wanted to come with Theodore's huge cock inside him.
The thought, one that earlier made him break into a cold sweat, was a lot more appealing now that he was getting his ass licked with so much gusto. Theo loved making a meal out of it for real. And Jack's ass – whether that was only his imagination or not, it didn't matter – was slowly opening up to possibilities.
Theo squeezed his butt cheeks, giving Jack another proof of how much he wanted to fuck him. It was good to feel wanted like that. More than that, actually. It filled him with pride.
But he also needed something else to fill him up, which meant that he had to express his desires out loud.
"Theo, I think you should start the mating thing. I'm ready to take it." While he wasn't entirely convinced of the truth of his own words, there was hardly a better time for him to start surrendering to the wishes of his alpha.
Theodore adjusted his position and leaned over him. "Ready to mate?"
"Oh, yes, I'm so ready," Jack hurried to assure him. "Is Vee still licking your ass?"
"He's playing with my balls now," Theodore replied. "They're quite heavy and filled with so much seed."
Jack could tell his throat was getting dry only hearing about such naughty things. He didn't even have to close his eyes to picture Theodore's heavy balls. Ah, to think that Vee was getting his pleasure out of taking those huge nuts in his mouth. Jack licked his lips. Too bad he couldn't be in several places – or at least different positions – at the same time. But it was for the better. There was always a possibility for him to implode and combust and therefore, end up as a pile of ash and not much else.
Determined that he didn't want his alpha to end up with a mate who was hardly corporeal, Jack invited trouble in of his own accord:
"Give me all that mighty seed then. I want to feel it in me."
There. He'd done it. Now all that was left was—
"Oh, ouch, I mean, wow." Something big and mighty was trying to get in. And his ass definitely had other plans. "Just a moment. I need to send good thoughts and a memo to my ass. I don't think it understands what its role in this mating thing is."
"It will be fine," Theodore said. "I know I'm big for you, but you will be fine, Jack."
Jack sighed and accepted Theodore's kiss. It was much better this way. His ass was slowly giving in, and small shivers of pleasure were going through him, again and again. If it were after him, they would enjoy this for a while.
"I'll have to go deeper," Theodore said.
"Deeper than this? Isn't this enough to call it mating?"
"I'm afraid not, Jack. I'm afraid," Theodore said teasingly, "that you will have to take it all before you can call yourself my mate. Unless you want us to stop, of course."
"Stop? No way." Jack hadn't come this far to prove himself a coward. "Go all the way, Theo. By the way, I hope Vince is poking you in the butt right now, just so you know what you're getting you, me, and Vee into."
Theodore laughed but he stopped abruptly to gasp in surprise. That was quite the sweet revenge.
"Come on, Theo. You can do it. Say with me: mating is the most beautiful thing in the world. Don't be chicken."
"I'm not a chicken. I'm a wolf. Stop teasing me, Jack."
Vince appeared ready to intervene. "You two, shut your lovely mouths right now. Are you fucking or what?"
Theodore and Jack snickered at the same time. Vee, after all, had a very good point.
TBC