Chapter 544: The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore
How was he supposed to tell the Headmaster?
Sean walked into the office, his mind weighed down by the secrets of the dead.
Around the room, the portraits of past Headmasters and Headmistresses were
feigning sleep, their chests rising and falling in a rhythmic, painted slumber.
Fawkes, Dumbledore's phoenix, was perched on a golden stand near the door. The
bird was the size of a swan, with magnificent scarlet and gold plumage. He
fanned his long tail feathers lazily as Sean entered, a silent greeting from a
creature of fire.
"Our Assistant Green. You look troubled, child."
Dumbledore sat behind his desk, cradling a cup of tea. His deep, piercing blue
eyes searched Sean's face.
"I hope I'm not disturbing you, Headmaster," Sean said.
"In all our time together, Sean, you have never once been a disturbance.
Sometimes, I find myself wishing you would disturb me more often," Dumbledore
said with a grandfatherly smile. He set down his teacup and observed the young
wizard's hesitation.
It was rare to see Sean Green look this uncertain. "Tea? Or perhaps a pumpkin
juice?"
Dumbledore gave his fingers a slight twitch, and a goblet of thick, fragrant
pumpkin juice drifted across the desk to Sean. Sean took a sip, the sweet liquid
doing little to settle the thoughts swirling in his mind.
He thought of Ariana. She was still waiting for her brothers. She was a
wandering soul—a spirit that refused to move on to the world beyond, yet had no
place in the world of the living. Her memories were her only possessions, and in
the Lands Between, memories were the currency for a century of pain.
How could he tell Albus the truth? How could he describe those long,
heart-breaking years in the mist?
Was the truth simply too cruel?
"Professor Dumbledore," Sean finally began.
"Assistant Green." Dumbledore's expression shifted, turning grave.
"Did you... did you enter the realm of dreams last night?" Sean asked
tentatively.
Dumbledore stood up abruptly. The usual cloudiness in his eyes vanished,
replaced by a sharp, focused intensity. He moved toward Sean, his voice a ragged
whisper.
"That dream... what I saw..."
Sean watched as the Headmaster's composure momentarily buckled. "It was a dream,
yes," Sean said, his voice echoing in the quiet office. "But Headmaster... why
should that mean it wasn't real?"
Dumbledore sank back into his chair as if his legs had given way. He raised his
wand to his temple and drew out a long, shimmering silver thread of memory. He
placed it carefully into the Pensieve. The basin glowed like liquid silver, the
surface rippling like water in a breeze, swirling with the grace of moving
clouds.
Within the basin, the silver thread turned into liquid light—a solidified dream.
"She..." Dumbledore's voice was hoarse.
The wise, all-knowing sage was gone. In his place sat a man who was, at his
core, a very inadequate older brother.
"She is not well," Sean said bluntly.
Dumbledore's breath hitched. His face twisted into a mask of raw, visceral
agony.
"She is suffering," Sean clarified, realizing his previous words didn't quite
capture the depth of the tragedy.
"Sean..." Dumbledore's voice failed him completely.
"Forgive me, Professor. A lie might offer comfort, but I cannot hide the truth
from you," Sean sighed. "The world behind the Veil does not welcome wandering
souls. When I found her, she was a timid, frightened girl who couldn't find her
home. She has no hearth, no bed, no family... no brothers. She is alone,
shivering in the cold. The Lands Between take her memories as payment, forcing
her to pay for a century of wandering with the very things she holds most dear."
Sean's own eyes dimmed as he spoke. There are some things in this world that
cannot be looked at too closely; every detail reveals a new layer of injustice.
He watched as a single tear escaped Dumbledore's eye. It was the first time Sean
had ever seen the Great Albus Dumbledore cry. Sean looked away, giving the man a
shred of privacy.
"I see..."
Dumbledore closed his eyes. The memories of the previous night—the sharp stabs
of guilt and the crushing weight of shame—flooded back to him. He looked like a
man who wanted to scream but had forgotten how.
Silence returned to the office, broken only by the occasional rustle of Fawkes's
wings.
"Sean... tell me. Have I failed her so completely?" Dumbledore's face was a map
of confusion and ancient grief. The setting sun caught the bridge of his crooked
nose, making him look older than the stone walls of the castle.
"You are the greatest Headmaster Hogwarts has ever known," Sean said softly.
"But the worst brother," Dumbledore whispered, a small, tragic smile touching
his lips. "Speak to me, child. I know that one day, the weight of this world
will rest upon your shoulders."
Sean's eyes flickered. He didn't respond to the "successor" comment, but he let
out a low, mournful sigh. "You've made your choice, then?"
"What an inadequate man I am," Dumbledore said, his voice gaining a trace of
tenderness. "I did such terrible things to her, and yet I convinced myself the
world needed me too much to face the consequences. I used the needs of others as
an excuse to hide. Tell me... can I trust you, Sean?"
"I don't know," Sean said honestly.
Dumbledore was the high wall standing between the wizarding world and Voldemort.
He was the only man the Dark Lord feared. If he left... if he chose the path to
Ariana...
Sean's gaze hardened into resolve. The world needed Dumbledore, but Ariana
needed Albus.
"You've already decided, haven't you?" Dumbledore smiled kindly at the young
wizard. "You could have lied to me, kept the truth hidden to keep me here, but
you didn't. You don't know how to lie about things that matter, Sean. Even if it
means dealing with the fallout, you choose the path that is right, no matter how
difficult."
Dumbledore leaned back, a look of reminiscence on his face. "Let me tell you the
story, Sean. I have told it before, but now... now I will tell you the details.
The parts I left out. The parts that should make you despise me."
"I could never despise you, sir," Sean said.
"You should," Dumbledore countered with a sad laugh. "You know the secret of my
sister's health. You know what those Muggles did to her, and what she became.
You know my father went to Azkaban to avenge her and died there. You know my
mother gave her life to keep Ariana safe.
"And yet... at the time, I resented it all. I was selfish, Sean. I loved them,
yes, but I wanted to run. And then... he came."
Dumbledore looked into Sean's eyes, his voice dropping. "You know of him.
Gellert Grindelwald. You cannot imagine how his mind dazzled me. The idea of
Muggles forced into subservience, of wizards finally stepping into the light...
we were the glorious young leaders of a revolution."
A flicker of that old, manic fire appeared in Dumbledore's eyes for a heartbeat.
"Oh, I had my doubts. But I used empty words to quiet my conscience. 'For the
Greater Good.' I told myself any harm we caused would be repaid a hundredfold in
the new world we were building. Did I know what kind of man Gellert was? Deep
down, yes. But I turned a blind eye. As long as our plan succeeded, my dreams
would come true.
"The heart of our plan was the Deathly Hallows. He was obsessed with them, and
so was I. The wand that could never lose—the ultimate weapon. The Resurrection
Stone—he saw an army of Inferi, but I pretended not to see that. To me, it meant
bringing my parents back, being free of the responsibility of my siblings. And
the Cloak... we rarely talked about the Cloak. We didn't need it to hide. But we
wanted it because it was the third piece. The 'Master of Death.' To us, that
just meant 'Invincible.'
"Two months of madness. Two months of cruel dreams. And all the while, I ignored
the only two people left in the world who needed me."
The fire in Dumbledore's eyes died out. He looked tired again.
"Then... reality arrived in the form of my brother, Aberforth. He was rough,
uneducated, and far better than I was. I didn't want to hear the truths he
shouted at me. I didn't want to hear that I was being 'held back' by a fragile,
unstable sister. The argument turned into a duel. Gellert lost control.
"The thing in his nature—the darkness I had always sensed but ignored—erupted.
And Ariana... after all my mother's care... she was caught in the crossfire. She
died."
Dumbledore broke into a fit of weeping. Fawkes flew over, resting his head on
Dumbledore's shoulder. Sean reached out and gripped the Headmaster's arm firmly
until the old man regained control.
"Gellert fled. Everyone saw it coming but me. He vanished with his plans for
power and his dreams of the Hallows. He ran, and I was left to bury my sister
and learn to live with a guilt that would never leave me.
"Years passed. I heard rumors of his power. I was offered the post of Minister
for Magic many times, but I refused. I knew I couldn't be trusted with power.
While I stayed here, training young wizards, Gellert raised an army. They said
he feared me. Perhaps. but I think I feared him more."
Dumbledore looked at Sean. "Not because of his magic. I knew we were evenly
matched, perhaps I was even the stronger of the two. No... I feared the truth. I
didn't know whose spell had killed my sister. Call me a coward, Sean. You would
be right. I was terrified to find out that I was the one who delivered the final
blow—not just through my arrogance, but with my own wand.
"I think Gellert knew that. I think he knew I was afraid. I delayed facing him
until it was a disgrace to remain hidden. People were dying, and I had to act.
You know the rest. I won the duel. I won the wand. And now... history repeats
itself. Another young, brilliant wizard. One who is far more brutal than Gellert
ever was."
Dumbledore stood up and examined Sean closely. Could he really place all of this
on the shoulders of a fourteen-year-old? Dumbledore knew the answer. Sean would
take the weight, and he would carry it better than Albus ever had.
"Go and see him, Sean. Tell him I sent you. There are very few wizards left in
this world who can teach you the things you need to know."
Sean blinked, completely stunned. "What... what did you say?"
"Oh, child. You spent all those hours in the dungeon with Severus—did you forget
everything he taught you? Or have you reached a level where you think you no
longer need a mentor?" Dumbledore seemed amused by Sean's shock.
"But you... you're sending me to him?" Sean was baffled. Albus Dumbledore was
introducing him to Gellert Grindelwald to learn the Dark Arts? The world had
truly turned upside down.
"Creating a new magic is no simple feat, Sean. As for me... I am not ready to
face her yet. You told me not to retreat, but the hour has not yet come."
Dumbledore looked out at the twilight sky. "If I were to go there now, and meet
you again shortly after... that would be a tragedy no one could bear."
Sean realized he had underestimated Dumbledore's resolve. The man had suffered
immensely, yet he had emerged as a wizard of mercy, humor, and iron will.
"Tell me," Dumbledore asked as the tea finally grew cold. "Can you bring her
out? Truly?"
"Not today," Sean answered. "But soon. Very soon."
☆☆☆
-> SUPPORT ME WITH POWER STONE
-> FOR EVERY 200 PS = BOUNS CHAPTER
☆☆☆
-> 30 Advanced chapters Now Available on Patreon!!
-> https://www.pat-reon.co-m/c/Inkshaper
(Just remove the hyphen (-) to access patreon normally)
If you like this novel please consider leaving a review that's help the story a lot Thank you