The first round of the game ended, leaving Utaha both expectant and incredibly nervous.
The first time, she had managed to blurt out the answer before they even started by catching Eriri off guard when she made a noise. But she knew she wouldn't get such a lucky break again.
For Utaha, her rival Eriri was just as bad as Elf. Her bet with Elf meant she only got toyed with if she lost, but now Eriri was allowed to toy with her directly.
She had stopped Eriri before the first round truly began, but this time wouldn't be so easy. She absolutely did not want to be dominated by Eriri.
"It's about time~"
Rin Ito helped Utaha into the position Elf had just occupied. She was a mix of anticipation, fear, and a tiny bit of stubbornness... They have to swap people this time, right?
Even though Megumi had been corrupted by him and enjoyed teasing them now, anyone was better than Eriri.
The person indeed changed.
However, it wasn't Megumi Kato—it was Sagiri. Holding the double-ended toy, Sagiri looked like a brave hero ready to dive deep into the Black-Stockinged Demon's lair.
Heh heh heh...
Sagiri had originally planned to do what Eriri did, but after seeing Eriri fail, she decided using her hands was a safer bet!
SLAP!!
Sagiri raised her hand and delivered a stinging blow to Utaha's plump, firm rear. Then, she took the "Holy Sword," still coated in Eriri's juices, and thrust it into Utaha's asshole. Utaha's back arched as she suddenly had a "little tail."
"GUH!!!!!"
Utaha's frame wasn't as petite as Elf's, but being filled from both sides still sent a wave of throbbing, aching pressure through her body. Rin's distinct shape was clearly visible through the skin of her flat stomach.
SLAP!!
Two more slaps left red handprints on Utaha's porcelain cheeks. Sagiri's own hand stung from the impact, but she didn't stop raining blows... Damn it (〃＞皿＜)!!! This ass is so big and she's always wearing black pantyhose. It's clearly made for seducing men!
Fueled by envy, Sagiri continued to spank Utaha ruthlessly. Every twist of those hips under the slaps made the Holy Sword wobble erotically.
"Stop... don't hit my butt... EEK!!!"
As Sagiri worked the back, Rin showed no mercy in the front, lifting Utaha's waist with every thrust.
Eriri and Megumi didn't stay idle. Once Sagiri's hand got tired, they took turns. Utaha's white butt cheeks were soon covered in a messy map of red welts.
A few moments later, after Utaha reached her first climax, Rin finally paused.
"Alright, time to answer... who is it?"
Utaha panted for breath, her mind racing with hesitation.
Rin had spanked her before, but his slaps were playful and teasing—the kind of spanking you'd expect at a normal party meant to evoke shame or submission.
Megumi had spanked her too, and her goal was the same as his.
But just now... it was different. Completely different.
The slaps she just received weren't playful. They were filled with a deep, concentrated resentment. She could feel the pure "hate" in every strike!
Eriri! It has to be Eriri!
"It's... it's still Eriri!"
"Wrong~" Rin wickedly lifted Utaha's hips and then... FLICK~
"HISS!!! THAT HURTS!!!!"
Utaha furrowed her brows in pain, trying to recall the sensation. But Rin wasn't going to give her time to think... In reality, if she had been more observant at the start, she would have felt that the hand hitting her was much smaller than Eriri's.
But now, it was too late.
"Eriri! It's definitely Eriri!"
FLICK~
"This time... it has to be Eriri!"
FLICK~
"E-Eriri..."
FLICK~
"Megumi... fine, it was Megumi!"
FLICK~
Utaha reached the limit five times and guessed wrong five times. Both of her delicate nipples were now red and swollen from Rin's relentless flicking!
Wait... how can I be wrong every single time? Is it really just that much of a coincidence?
She couldn't wrap her head around it, but she refused to give up!
"L-Let me rest... for a second..."
"Quick, quick, my turn! I'm not as unlucky as you." Elf was already chomping at the bit. Since Utaha took the first turn and failed, if Elf guessed correctly, she could increase the difficulty for Utaha and get to spank her herself!
Rin was fair. He helped Elf straddle him and started the exact same process he had with Utaha.
Unlike Utaha, however, Elf felt something was off immediately... This technique feels so familiar!
It felt like... Sagiri!?
Elf and Sagiri had helped each other develop their rears before, and they had played the "human chain" game with Ami's group using double-enders. Elf was intimately familiar with Sagiri's specific "grip." The moment the Holy Sword was buried inside her, Elf knew.
He must have snuck out while we were showering to call Sagiri over... No wonder Utaha couldn't get a single guess right.
Elf pressed her body down as low as possible, whispering into Rin's ear under the cover of the wet, squelching sounds of their union.
"It's Sagiri, right?"
"Correct guess~"
"HUH!?" Thinking about the spanking technique, Utaha didn't hear Elf's whisper, but she heard Rin's loud confirmation. "Correct!?"
"That's right~ Phew..."
Elf shook her numb, bound arms and pulled off her blindfold. After letting her eyes adjust to the blurry, sticky scene, she opened them to see Eriri, Megumi, and a grinning Sagiri holding the Holy Sword.
It really was Sagiri!
The barefoot Elf padded over to Sagiri and gave her butt a revenge slap. Then, she actively helped Utaha back onto Rin, pressing her down so that Rin was buried as deep as possible inside her.
"Hehe... now it's my turn to hit your fat ass~"
SLAP!
Elf delivered a heavy palm strike to Utaha's now-reddened rear.
Elf made the threat, but she only delivered the one slap and didn't take the Holy Sword from Sagiri.
"You have three options now," Rin said, patting Utaha's hip. "If you keep guessing wrong, you'll be getting spanked until dawn... After all, I'm not a demon. If you accept one specific punishment, I'll forgive you for the prank."
"What punishment?" Utaha asked desperately. Whatever it was, even if it was being treated like Karen, anything was better than being ruthlessly fucked in the ass by Eriri or Elf!
"Hey~ that's not fair~" Elf pouted.
"You guys were the ones who pranked me first, so I decide the punishment and the forgiveness," Rin smiled, giving Utaha's butt a playful pat. "Well? Do you accept? Once you agree, there's no backing out."
"I..." Utaha was about to agree but hesitated. Punishment... heaven knows what he has in mind. If it's something even more cruel than this...
No. There can't be anything more cruel than being toyed with by Elf and Eriri!