Chapter 54: The Three Broomsticks (The Jealousy Game)
The Three Broomsticks was packed. Every table was full of Hogwarts students taking advantage of the first Hogsmeade weekend of the term. The air was warm, thick, and smelled of sweet butterbeer and chimney smoke.
Hermione barely noticed.
She was sitting in a noisy booth with Harry and Ron. Harry, as always, was absorbed in a conversation about Quidditch, while Ron tried to tell a story about Scabbers with his mouth full of meat pie. She pretended to listen. She nodded, smiled, but her attention was elsewhere. Her eyes kept scanning the pub, searching for a dark, messy head of hair that wasn't Harry's.
She had seen him come in.
In a quiet corner, away from the main noise, there he was. Timothy Hunter. And he wasn't alone.
He was sitting across from Daphne Greengrass.
Hermione felt that familiar cold pang in her stomach. Jealousy. It was an emotion she hated—so illogical, so uncontrolled—but it had become her constant companion that year.
She watched the scene with a hawk's intensity. They weren't flirting. They weren't laughing. They weren't doing any of the things Ron and Lavender Brown did in the common room.
They were working.
There was a thick scroll spread between them on the table, covered in what looked like potion diagrams and intricate rune matrices. Daphne, Slytherin's "Ice Princess," was speaking with a quiet intensity, her finger tracing a line on the parchment.
And Timothy was listening to her.
He was leaning forward, his expression one of passionate concentration that Hermione knew very well. It was the same look he had when he solved a conceptual problem in the library. It was the look he had directed at her when they debated frequency theory. It was his "this is fascinating" look.
And he was using it with Daphne Greengrass.
Hermione gripped her butterbeer mug so hard her knuckles went white. It was one thing to receive that perfumed letter from that... French Veela. Fleur was a distant threat, an abstract idea of mythical beauty. But this was different. This was worse. Daphne Greengrass was right there. She was a Slytherin. She was cold, calculating, and—Hermione had to grudgingly admit—beautiful in a cold, aristocratic way. And she was intelligent.
Timothy wasn't just being polite. He wasn't "maintaining social anchors." He was actively collaborating with her. Sharing his ideas. Giving her that exclusive, burning attention that Hermione had come to treasure as her own.
She hated Daphne for it. She hated Timothy for giving it. And she hated herself for the fact that she cared so much.
"Hermione, are you even listening to me?" Ron said, waving a hand in front of her face.
"What? Yes, Ron. Scabbers. Fascinating," she said, her voice a taut thread.
She couldn't bear to watch anymore. She lowered her gaze to her butterbeer, the sweet foam now tasting bitter. Her afternoon was ruined. And she knew, with absolute certainty, that she would have to confront him that night.
The library was almost empty. It was late, the autumn sun had already set, and the only lights came from the torches flickering on the walls and a handful of student lamps glowing like lonely islands in the darkness.
Timothy was in his usual corner, deep in the Advanced Theory stacks. He was completely absorbed. On the table before him lay an ancient-looking grimoire, bound in snakeskin. It was his first "payment" from Daphne Greengrass. It was written in a German runic dialect that made The Standard Book of Spells look like a children's story.
He was fascinated. His Archive was devouring the syntax of blood curses, his mind humming with the conceptual beauty of such brutally pragmatic magic. The alliance with Daphne was proving to be the smartest decision he had made that year.
He didn't hear the footsteps, but he felt the change in the air. A presence, tense and vibrating with contained rage.
He looked up.
Hermione Granger was standing by his table.
She didn't look like a student. She looked like a storm about to break. Her books were pressed against her chest so hard her knuckles were white. Her bushy hair seemed to vibrate with repressed energy, and her cheeks were flushed, but not from the cold.
"I saw you," she said. Her voice wasn't Hermione's. It was tense, low, and dangerous.
Timothy felt a wave of genuine amusement. The game. He loved this game. It was almost as fascinating as the blood runes.
He looked up from the grimoire, marking his page with a quill. "I'm afraid you'll have to be more specific, Hermione," he said, his voice calm, almost mocking. "Lots of people see me. I'm remarkably visible. I'm not as good at hiding as Harry."
"Don't play games with me, Timothy!" she snapped, her voice cracking slightly. "In Hogsmeade! At The Three Broomsticks! With Daphne Greengrass!"
He arched an eyebrow. "Ah. That."
"You two looked very... cozy!" she accused, the word "cozy" sounding like an insult.
Timothy had to suppress a smile. Cozy? They had been discussing whether a blood curse could be "cured" or whether it could only be "put in stasis" through a runic counter-curse. It had been the most passionate and least romantic debate of his life.
"'Cozy'?" he repeated, savoring the word. "We were debating the application of the Kenaz rune to stabilize generational blood curses. A fascinating topic, actually. Not something you'd find in Hogwarts: A History."
Using the title of her favorite book was a deliberate low blow. And it worked.
"Stop doing that!" she shouted, her voice finally breaking. She slammed her own stack of books onto the table, making a nearby inkwell jump. "Stop treating me like I'm stupid! And stop mocking me with your... your Slytherin and French girlfriends!"
The silence that followed was heavy. The mocking smile on Timothy's face faded.
He had been having fun. The whole thing—Fleur's letter, the conversation with Daphne—had been a delicious game. He loved watching Hermione's logical mind wrestle with the illogical emotion of jealousy. It was fascinating. But this... this was different.
The anger in her voice was real, but beneath it, he saw something else. He saw genuine frustration. He saw that her bright eyes were not just from anger, but from unshed tears. He saw that his "game" was truly hurting her. And that... that wasn't what he wanted. Not entirely.
The game stopped. The amusement evaporated, replaced by a different intensity.
He rose from his chair.
His movement was swift, silent, and utterly predatory. Hermione stepped back instinctively, a small gasp of surprise escaping her lips. She took a step back and her spine hit a tall bookshelf of Divination books.
Before she could move, he was there.
He was faster than she thought possible. In an instant, he had cornered her. He placed one hand on the shelf, right beside her head, blocking her escape. Suddenly, the vast space of the library shrank to the two feet of air between them.
Hermione's heart raced, pounding against her ribs with a force that left her breathless. She was trapped. She was furious. And, to her utter horror, she was terrified and wildly excited.
He was too close. She could smell him. It wasn't the Quidditch sweat smell of Harry or Ron. It was the scent she now associated only with him: old parchment, ink, and that strange, clean smell of static electricity, of ozone. She remembered what Luna had told her. ~"They smell like ozone and old books"~.
She opened her eyes and, in the dim light, she could see them. The small blue sparks, the echoes of his magic, hummed faintly around his shoulder, stirred by his sudden movement. They were real.
"Timothy..." she said, her voice now a trembling whisper, her anger forgotten, replaced by panic.
His voice was no longer mocking. It was low, serious, and incredibly intense. He wasn't looking at her like a game. He was looking at her like a problem he needed to solve.
He raised his other hand, slowly. She flinched. He didn't touch her. He used a single finger to gently tilt her chin, forcing her to meet his gaze. His eyes, clear and passionate, locked onto hers.
"Are you jealous, Hermione?"
It wasn't a taunt. It was a real question. A gathering of data.
The question, his proximity, the ozone smell, the blue creatures humming... it was all too much. Her logical mind shattered.
"I don't know!" she cried, and this time the tears of frustration did spring forth. She pushed him in the chest with both hands, but it was like pushing a stone statue. He didn't move an inch.
"I don't know!" she repeated, her voice breaking. "I don't know what to feel about you! One minute you're the most brilliant person I've ever met, and we talk about magic and it's... it's wonderful! And the next, you're the most arrogant, insufferable, and exasperating man I've ever known! I don't understand you!"
She stood there, trembling, the tears of anger finally spilling down her cheeks.
The mocking smile vanished from Timothy's face. The game stopped definitively.
He had pushed her too far. He had been so fascinated with the jealousy game that he hadn't realized she was genuinely hurt. He saw her there, cornered and crying, and he didn't feel triumph. He felt... something complicated. A pang of guilt.
He stepped back, lowering his hand from the shelf, giving her space to breathe. His intensity softened, transforming from that of a playful predator to that of a patient observer. He waited, simply listening to her breathe through choked sobs.
"I know," he said finally, his voice now calm, devoid of all mockery. "It's confusing."
She wiped her tears away angrily, refusing to look at him. "No, you don't know. You don't... you don't feel anything. It's all a game to you."
"That's not true," he said. He leaned against the opposite bookshelf, crossing his arms. He looked at her, not as a target, but as an... equal. "Hermione, what's the solution to a charm you can't master?"
The question threw her completely off balance. "What?"
"A spell," he repeated, his voice patient. "You're in Charms class. Flitwick teaches you a new levitation charm and you fail. Your feather doesn't move. What do you do? Do you give up? Do you go to the library to read about Potions instead?"
She stared at him, confused by the change of subject. "No... of course not. I practice it. I research the theory. I try a different wand movement. I try again until it works."
He nodded slowly, a genuine, soft smile touching his lips. "Exactly. You don't give up. You don't let it go just because it's difficult."
He straightened up, and the passion she had seen in him when he talked about magic returned, burning in his eyes. "If you really want something, Hermione, the solution is never to let it go. It's to pursue it."
He took a step toward her, his voice filling with an almost religious conviction. "It's to pursue it with all your strength. With all your passion. With everything you have. You go for it. You don't let rules, or fear, or frustration get in the way. You go and you take it. Whether it's a goal, a concept, or..."
He paused, realizing how much he was revealing. "That's how I am," he admitted, his voice now softer. "But with magic. It's the only thing that's real to me. The only thing that encompasses everything. I'm... I'm in love with magic, Hermione. All of it. The system. Its beauty. Its logic. Its chaos. It's the only thing I truly care about."
There was a long silence. Hermione looked at him, seeing for the first time not the arrogant boy, but the passionate obsessive. She saw the truth in his eyes. And it crushed her.
"It's... it's all you care about..." she whispered, more to herself, her voice filled with a sudden, profound sadness. The fire of her anger had been extinguished, leaving only the cold ashes of understanding.
He frowned. "What?" He hadn't heard her. "Say that again."
Hermione took a deep breath, her own courage returning, her brown eyes fixed on his, desperately searching for an answer. "I said... are you only in love with magic?" Her voice was barely a whisper. "Or... or is there also... someone?"
It was the bravest question she had ever asked in her life.
Timothy looked at her. The architect, the archivist, the man with an answer for everything. He fell silent.
He had archived the Philosopher's Stone. He had archived a Horcrux. He could see Luna's invisible creatures and could speak with Salazar's Basilisk. But this question... this simple emotional variable...
He didn't have an answer.
"I don't know," he said finally, and it was the most honest admission he had ever made.
He stepped closer again, closing the distance between them once more. The air was charged. "But," he said, his voice a low murmur, "if you have something to say... if you have an answer to that question... now is the time to say it."
It was a challenge. He was turning the play back on her.
Hermione looked at him, her heart pounding painfully against her ribs. She saw the honesty in his eyes, the intense curiosity. He wasn't playing. He really didn't know. And he was asking her to define the variable.
She wanted to do it. She wanted to shout at him that yes, it was her.
But the fear, the uncertainty, the possibility that he would reject her or, worse, that he would analyze her... it was too much.
She pressed her lips together, broke eye contact, and shook her head, wordless.
She ducked, slipped under his extended arm, and without looking back, fled from the library, her footsteps echoing loudly on the stone floor.
Timothy was left alone in the Divination aisle, staring at the empty space where she had been.
Interesting, he thought, though for the first time, he didn't feel the satisfaction of a completed experiment.
The game had just ended. And something much more complicated had just begun.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Thanks for reading.
By the way, there's an open poll on my Patreon where you can vote on what my next fic will be. It's completely free to participate -- just pick the option that catches your attention the most.
That's all for today.
Mike