CHAPTER 21: FAMILY DYSFUNCTION 101
Morning after Klaus's arrival, and the compound looked like a war zone.
Kol descended the stairs from his attic to find furniture demolished, claw marks scoring the walls, and three of his siblings glaring at each other across what used to be Marcel's breakfast table. The table now had a Klaus-shaped hole through its center.
Klaus stood with hybrid eyes still gold, power radiating from him in waves. Rebekah had positioned herself between him and Hayley, magic crackling faintly around her hands despite having no witch powers—just reflexive protective stance. Elijah looked like he hadn't slept, exhaustion evident in the rare slump of his shoulders.
Hayley sat hunched in a chair Marcel had wisely placed far from Klaus's reach, one hand protective over her stomach.
"Good morning," Kol said into the tense silence. "I see we're all processing healthily."
"Your brother," Rebekah hissed, "is being an arse."
"Which brother?" Kol asked mildly. "We're all arses occasionally. Family tradition."
"The one demanding Hayley move into his custody like she's property instead of a pregnant woman with autonomy."
Klaus's jaw clenched. "I'm demanding she accept protection. There's a difference."
"Is there?" Hayley's voice was quiet but sharp. "Because from where I'm sitting, 'protection' sounds a lot like 'imprisonment.'"
"You're carrying my child—"
"I'm carrying my child," Hayley interrupted. "Who happens to be yours too. That doesn't give you ownership of my body or my choices."
Klaus's eyes flashed dangerously. "In my thousand years—"
"Your thousand years of experience mean nothing if you can't grasp basic respect," Kol cut in, moving to stand beside Hayley's chair. "She's not a possession, Klaus. She's the mother of your daughter. Start treating her like a partner instead of a problem to solve."
"Stay out of this, Kol—"
"No." Kol's voice hardened. "You want relationship with your daughter? It starts here. With respecting her mother's autonomy. Hayley stays where she feels safe. If that's with me, in the safehouse I arranged, then that's where she stays."
Klaus moved with hybrid speed, slamming Kol against the wall. "You don't get to tell me how to protect my family."
"Someone has to," Kol replied calmly, despite the pressure on his chest. "Because your instinct is to cage what you love until it breaks."
The words hit Klaus like a physical blow. He stumbled back, fury warring with something that looked like shame.
"Niklaus," Elijah said quietly, moving to place himself between the brothers. "Kol is correct. Hayley needs safety, yes. But also dignity. Autonomy. If you begin this relationship by taking away her choices, you'll destroy any chance of genuine connection."
"I don't want her destroyed," Klaus said, voice breaking slightly. "I want her protected."
"Then protect her by giving her power, not taking it away," Rebekah said, softening marginally. "Let her make choices. Support those choices. Be the father Mikael never was—one who trusts instead of controls."
Klaus looked at Hayley, really looked at her, and seemed to see the fear beneath her defiance. "You're terrified of me."
"Yes," Hayley said honestly. "I've heard the stories. Klaus Mikaelson doesn't protect people. He possesses them. Uses them. And when they stop being useful or dare to disobey, he destroys them." Her hand tightened on her stomach. "I won't let you do that to my daughter."
"Our daughter," Klaus whispered.
"Prove it," Hayley challenged. "Prove she's ours by respecting my role as her mother. Let me make choices about her upbringing. Trust that I want what's best for her as much as you do."
Klaus stood frozen, a thousand years of paranoia and control issues warring with the desperate hope that he could be better than his own father.
Kol made a decision.
He grabbed Klaus's hand before his brother could react, channeling void energy into the connection. Klaus tried to pull away, but Kol held firm, forcing a void vision link between their minds.
"See," Kol commanded. "See what you could create or destroy."
Images flooded between them—possible futures bleeding through dimensional barriers.
Hope at age five, laughing as Klaus taught her to paint, Hayley watching with fond exasperation. A family. Imperfect but loving.
Hope at age ten, cowering in a locked room while Klaus raged outside, Hayley long dead from trying to escape his possessiveness. A prison. Gilded but cruel.
Hope at age fifteen, powerful and kind, leading supernatural factions toward peace. Her father's strength tempered by her mother's compassion.
Hope at age fifteen, powerful and broken, destroying everything she touched because love had been twisted into control until she couldn't tell the difference.
Klaus saw himself in each vision—the father he could be, gentle and supportive, teaching his daughter to embrace her nature. And the father he feared becoming, Mikael's legacy perpetuated through new generation.
The visions fractured further. Hope losing her mother to Klaus's paranoia. Hope growing up believing love meant chains. Hope becoming the monster Klaus had always feared he was.
Or—
Hope surrounded by family who trusted each other. Klaus learning to let go of control. Hayley and Klaus as partners instead of adversaries. A daughter who knew love without possession.
Kol released the connection, and they both staggered backward.
Klaus gasped, hands trembling, eyes wide with horror and understanding. "I saw... everything. Everything I could destroy if I don't change."
"Yes," Kol said quietly.
"She could be happy," Klaus whispered. "Or broken. Depending on my choices."
"All of our choices," Elijah corrected gently. "But yes. You have power to build or destroy here, brother. Choose carefully."
Klaus sank into a chair—one of the few still intact—and put his head in his hands. For several long moments, he sat in silence. When he looked up, something had shifted in his expression. Less rage, more vulnerability.
"What do you need?" he asked Hayley. "To feel safe. To trust that I won't... become him."
Hayley studied him warily. "I need autonomy. To make decisions about my own care. Where I live, who I spend time with, how I prepare for the baby. I need you to ask before controlling. To trust that I want what's best for her."
"I can try," Klaus said. "I'll fail sometimes. Thousand years of paranoia don't vanish overnight. But I can try."
"That's all I'm asking."
Rebekah cleared her throat. "I have a suggestion. What if I stay with Hayley? As companion, protection, buffer between her and Klaus's... Klaus-ness. I can help with the pregnancy, provide company, and intervene if anyone—" She looked pointedly at Klaus. "—oversteps boundaries."
"You'd do that?" Hayley asked.
"I've always wanted to be an aunt," Rebekah said with a small smile. "And keeping my brothers from destroying good things is practically a full-time job anyway."
"I'd appreciate that," Hayley said softly. "Thank you."
Kol took charge before Klaus could complicate the fragile peace. "Ground rules. Everyone agree or we're doing this the hard way. One: Hayley has autonomy over her own choices. No compelling, no imprisonment, no controlling who she sees. Two: Klaus gets involvement—doctor appointments, baby planning, being part of the process. But he asks first. Three: We all protect her together. No lone wolf heroics that endanger the mother while trying to protect the child."
"Four," Elijah added. "No murdering people Hayley befriends. That includes witches, werewolves, or anyone else Klaus deems 'suspicious.'"
Klaus growled but nodded. "Agreed. But if someone actually threatens her—"
"Then we handle it together," Kol interrupted. "As family. Not as Klaus versus the world."
"Fine." Klaus stood, moving toward Hayley slowly. She tensed but didn't flee. "I'm terrified," he admitted quietly. "Of failing her. Of becoming my father. Of losing both of you before I learn how to love properly."
"Then we'll learn together," Hayley said. "How to be family. How to protect without possessing. How to love this baby we're both terrified of ruining."
Klaus laughed, sharp and slightly broken. "Quite the pair, aren't we?"
"Quite the pack," Hayley corrected. She gestured to the assembled Mikaelsons. "All of us. Figuring out how to be family."
The grimoire manifested at Kol's shoulder, displaying a message only he could see:
Progress. Don't expect miracles. But this is better than I feared. Klaus may actually learn. Eventually.
Later, after Klaus had gone to inspect possible safe houses and Hayley had retreated to rest, Kol found himself alone on the compound balcony. Exhaustion pulled at him—sharing void visions drained magic he couldn't spare right now.
Davina appeared with coffee and understanding. "Babysitting a thousand-year-old hybrid harder than expected?"
"Immeasurably," Kol admitted, accepting the cup gratefully. "He's like a tornado made of trauma and poor impulse control."
"He's also terrified," Davina observed, settling beside him. "All that rage, all that posturing—it's just fear of failing his daughter."
"I know." Kol sipped his coffee, savoring the warmth. "Doesn't make him less exhausting."
"You're good for him," Davina said. "Terrifying, but good. You give him honesty instead of platitudes. Show him consequences instead of enabling destruction."
"I show him himself," Kol corrected. "The void visions just make it visceral instead of theoretical."
They sat in comfortable silence, watching New Orleans wake up. Three months ago, Kol had been a desperate transmigrator trying to survive hour by hour. Now he was mediating family dysfunction, protecting pregnant werewolves, and apparently serving as Klaus Mikaelson's emotional support vampire.
"What are you thinking?" Davina asked.
"That my life has become incredibly strange," Kol said. "And that I wouldn't change it."
She smiled, leaning against his shoulder. "Good. Because you're stuck with all of us now."
Across the compound, Klaus watched them from a window. The ease between them, the comfortable affection—it looked so simple from the outside. Klaus had never managed simple. Every relationship became complicated, twisted by his need for control and fear of abandonment.
But watching his little brother navigate intimacy with apparent ease made something crack in Klaus's chest.
Maybe change was possible.
Maybe he could learn.
For his daughter, he would try.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0