Chapter 70: The SEC Resolution
The hearing was scheduled for March 15th. Two weeks away. I had expert witnesses lined up, documentary evidence organized, defense strategy polished until it gleamed.
But the night before final preparation presentation to the client, Morris called.
"We should talk. Off the record."
We met at a coffee shop near the courthouse—neutral ground, no recordings, just two lawyers assessing reality.
"Your defense is solid," Morris said, stirring his coffee without drinking it. "Expert testimony on quantitative methods, documented systematic analysis, demonstration that suspicious trades were small percentage of total activity. A judge might buy it."
"Will buy it. Because it's true."
"Maybe. But litigation is expensive. Years of appeals, millions in legal fees. Even if you win, the reputational damage destroys investor confidence." He finally looked up. "Let's settle this."
"You tried that already. Two million, I said half a million. We're still far apart."
"Two point five million. Enhanced compliance procedures. No admission of wrongdoing. Final offer."
I did the math. Two point five million was less than the cost of litigation, avoided years of uncertainty, let Silverpoint move forward clean. Client could absorb the cost. The compliance procedures were actually beneficial—better internal controls protected against future issues.
"I need to consult my client."
"Of course. But Scott?" Morris leaned forward. "Your client isn't innocent. They're just not guilty. There's a difference. Settlement acknowledges that difference without criminalizing their business."
He was right. Silverpoint hadn't committed insider trading, but they'd operated in gray areas, benefited from tips that prompted investigations, pushed ethical boundaries. Not criminal. Not quite clean either.
Settlement was honest resolution.
I called Marcus that evening, laid out the terms.
"Do you recommend accepting?" he asked.
"Yes. It's less than litigation would cost, avoids years of uncertainty, and lets you operate without SEC oversight hanging over everything. The compliance procedures are actually good practice anyway."
"And our reputation?"
"No admission of wrongdoing means you can tell investors the SEC investigation was resolved satisfactorily. Most will interpret that as vindication."
Silence on the other end. Calculating, weighing, deciding.
"Accept it," Marcus said finally. "And Scott? Thank you. You didn't just fight for us—you made us prove we deserved defense. You could have just taken our money and gone through motions. But you actually cared whether we were telling truth."
After we hung up, I sat in my apartment thinking about that comment. I'd defended Silverpoint aggressively but honestly. Never crossed ethical lines. Never built case on lies. Achieved outcome that served client interests while maintaining professional integrity.
This was how I wanted to practice law. Principled advocacy. Not unprincipled warfare.
The settlement finalized three days later. Morris and I signed documents in a conference room that smelled like stale coffee and bureaucratic exhaustion. Shook hands professionally. Neither of us had fully won. Both of us had achieved acceptable outcome.
That was the reality of complex litigation—clean victories were rare. Most cases ended in negotiated compromise where both sides walked away satisfied if not thrilled.
Silverpoint was happy. SEC was happy. I was happy.
Hardman was thrilled.
"Another win," he said when I reported the settlement. "SEC defense, favorable terms, client satisfied. This is exactly the work that earns partnership."
"Client's interests were served. That's what matters."
"And you're ready for partnership discussions next month. We'll schedule for early April." He leaned back in his chair. "One year at this firm. Three major victories—Kessler, Carlson, now Silverpoint. Multiple smaller wins. Portable client base. You've proven yourself beyond question."
"Thank you."
"Don't thank me yet. Partnership comes with expectations. Billable hours, business development, loyalty to firm interests. This is permanent commitment, not just salary increase."
"I understand."
After I left his office, I sat at my desk processing. One year ago, I'd joined Hardman & Associates angry at Jessica, determined to prove Pearson Hardman wrong, willing to be Hardman's weapon if it meant advancement.
Now I had reputation, clients, victories. Everything I'd wanted.
But I also had recognition that Hardman's agenda—revenge against Jessica and Harvey—conflicted with my principles. That building career on someone else's vendetta was hollower than I'd expected.
Partnership would lock me in. Golden handcuffs. Equity stake, financial obligations, professional commitments. Walking away after partnership meant buying out, non-compete clauses, potential litigation.
The question was whether I wanted to be locked into Hardman's firm long-term.
My phone buzzed. Text from Donna: How'd the settlement go?
Finalized. Client happy, SEC satisfied, case closed.
Congratulations. Dinner to celebrate?
Yeah. Pick the place.
Already picked. Angelo's, 7pm. Wear something nice.
I smiled and pocketed the phone. One year ago, I didn't have anyone to celebrate victories with. Now I had Donna—someone who understood the complexities, supported the principles, called me out when I lost perspective.
That was worth more than any partnership.
The SEC case was over. Partnership discussions were coming. Decisions about future needed making.
But tonight, I'd just celebrate the win and enjoy dinner with the person who made victories mean something.
Tomorrow would bring new complications. Always did.
For now, I'd just accept the moment.
Sometimes that was enough.
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!