Chapter 51: Eddie's Vindication
Eddie
The bunker walls were covered in evidence of the impossible.
Dimensional maps marked with red infection sites. Photographs of demo-dogs—actual monsters, not D&D monsters. Charts tracking tunnel spread. Will Byers sleeping on a medical cot, occasionally whispering in voices that weren't his.
And Steve Harrington, sitting at the command console, upper torso completely black with corruption. Veins like circuit boards tracing patterns across pale skin.
Three years. Steve had been preparing for this for three goddamn years.
"You were actually right," I said aloud.
Steve glanced up from the tunnel map. "About?"
"Everything. The paranoia. The training. The stockpiling. The weird questions about dimensional theory." I gestured at the chaos around us. "You were preparing for actual apocalypse."
"Told you it was coming."
"Yeah, but I thought you were just... I don't know, dealing with PTSD creatively. Not accurately predicting interdimensional invasion."
Robin snorted from her corner. "Welcome to the 'Steve Was Right' club. Population: everyone."
"Steve Was Right About Everything," I amended. "That's my new catchphrase. Someone does something stupid, I'll just say 'Steve was right' and move on."
"Please don't," Steve muttered.
"Too late. Already committed." I pulled out my notebook—the one I'd been keeping since this started. "Someone needs to document this. For posterity. So when we all die horribly, future generations know what happened."
"That's morbid," Chrissy said.
"That's realistic. Look at him." I pointed at Steve. "He's half-shadow now. That's not normal. That's documentary-worthy."
Steve
Eddie had been documenting everything for days. Photographs, detailed notes, dramatic narration that made everyone want to strangle him.
"Day 10," he announced, writing. "Steve's corruption spreads. The black veins now cover his torso completely. We may lose him to darkness. His eyes hold the weight of knowledge no teenager should carry. He stands between us and the abyss, one corrupted hand gripping hope, the other—"
"Eddie."
"What?"
"I'm right here. You don't need to narrate me like I'm dying."
"Posterity needs context!"
"Posterity needs you to shut up so I can think."
He grinned, unrepentant. "Future historians will thank me. 'The Eddie Munson Chronicles: How Steve Harrington Saved Hawkins While Everyone Mocked His Hair.'"
Despite everything—the exhaustion, the corruption, the approaching assault—I smiled.
Eddie noticed. "See? Comic relief is essential to survival. Someone's gotta keep morale up."
"By treating us like a documentary?"
"Exactly." He took another photo—me at the command console, corruption visible, surrounded by maps. "This one's called 'Command and Corruption: Portrait of a Reluctant Hero.'"
"I will destroy that camera."
"You'll try. But I'm fast and motivated."
Eddie
The bunker felt smaller at night. When most people had gone home or were sleeping, when the SuperComm chirped softly with distant check-ins, when the weight of everything settled heavy.
I found Robin in the equipment room, organizing medical supplies. Her hands shook slightly.
"You okay?" I asked.
"Fine."
"Liar."
She set down the bandages, rubbed her face. "I'm terrified, Eddie. We're coordinating a military assault against literal monsters. People are going to die. Maybe us. Maybe people we love. And I'm supposed to just... be okay with that?"
I sat beside her. "You don't have to be okay. You just have to show up."
"That's what Steve said."
"Steve's right about everything, remember?" I forced lightness into my tone. "It's annoying, but useful."
"He's dying," Robin whispered. "The corruption's consuming him. El can't stop it. And he's still absorbing more from infected people because no one else can. He's literally killing himself to save everyone."
"I know."
"Doesn't that terrify you?"
"Constantly. But Steve's been terrifying me for three years." I picked at my rings. "Remember when he started stockpiling weapons? Training like doomsday prepper? We thought he was crazy. Turns out he was just... informed."
"That doesn't make it less scary."
"No. But it makes it survivable. Steve sees things we don't. Plans for outcomes we can't imagine. If anyone's getting us through this, it's him."
Robin leaned against my shoulder. "What if he doesn't make it?"
"Then we finish what he started. Honor his insane three-year preparation by not dying stupidly."
She laughed wetly. "You're terrible at pep talks."
"I'm a metalhead drug dealer. Pep talks aren't my forte."
Steve
Found Eddie later, sitting alone near Dart's containment cell, journal open but blank.
"Writer's block?" I asked.
He jumped. "Jesus! Announce yourself!"
"Sorry. Stealth is Phase 2 benefit."
"Your Phase 2 benefits are creepy." He closed the journal. "Can't figure out how to write today's entry. Everything feels too big. Too real."
I sat beside him, corruption pulsing dully. "Then write small. Write what you saw. What you felt."
"I felt scared."
"So write that."
"'Dear Diary, I'm terrified. Actual monsters exist. My friend is becoming shadow-man. We might all die tomorrow. Love, Eddie.'" He laughed bitterly. "Pulitzer-worthy."
"Honest, though."
"Yeah." His voice cracked. "I sell weed and run D&D campaigns, Steve. I'm not built for war. For watching people I care about bleed. For seeing things that shouldn't exist."
"None of us are built for this."
"You are. You've been preparing—"
"I'm scared too." The admission came easier than expected. "Every day. Every decision. Terrified I'm wrong, that my plans will fail, that everyone dies because I wasn't smart enough or fast enough or prepared enough."
Eddie stared at me. "You never show it."
"Can't afford to. Everyone's looking to me for answers. If I break, they break."
"That's exhausting."
"Yeah."
We sat in silence, watching Dart sleep. The creature clicked softly—content, trusting Dustin would visit tomorrow like always.
"I can do scared and useful," Eddie said finally. "Document everything, support where I can, try not to die stupidly. That's enough, right?"
"That's more than enough." I squeezed his shoulder. "You show up when most would run. That's courage, Eddie. Real courage."
"Steve was right," he whispered.
"About?"
"Everything. Including courage being showing up scared."
Eddie
Wayne found me at the trailer near midnight. I'd snuck home to grab clean clothes, found him waiting up.
"Edward." His weathered face held concern. "Where have you been?"
I sat at the kitchen table, exhausted. "Steve's place. Helping with... a situation."
"What kind of situation requires you gone for days?"
Dimensional invasion. Monsters. Apocalypse prep.
Couldn't say that. Wayne was solid, practical, wouldn't believe impossible truths.
"Someone released toxic chemicals near the farms. Contaminated crops, made people sick. Steve's coordinating cleanup and medical treatment. I'm helping with documentation."
Partial truth. Better than lies.
Wayne studied me with knowing eyes. "That why you look scared?"
"Yeah. It's bad, Wayne. Really bad. People could die if we don't handle this right."
"Then you handle it right." He squeezed my shoulder—same spot Steve had touched earlier. "You're a good kid, Eddie. Smarter than you think. Trust yourself."
"What if I'm not smart enough?"
"Then you do your best and accept the rest. That's all anyone can do."
After he went to bed, I wrote in my journal by candlelight:
Day 10. Steve's corruption spreads. We may lose him to darkness. But maybe that's the price—one person bearing the weight so others don't have to. If we survive this, no one will believe what happened. But it did happen. Steve Harrington saved Hawkins, and all it cost was his humanity.
If he dies, I'll make sure everyone knows. That's my job now. Chronicler. Witness. The one who remembers when everyone else wants to forget.
Steve was right about everything. Including the cost of being right.
I blew out the candle, tried to sleep.
Dreamed of monsters.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0