Chapter 74: Billy's Transformation
Billy
Pain woke me. Dull, throbbing pain across my chest where demo-dog claws had torn through.
Hospital room. Sterile white. Beeping monitors. And Max, asleep in the chair beside my bed.
I tried to sit up. Agony flared. Bandages restricted movement.
"Don't," Max said, jerking awake. "You'll tear stitches."
"How long?"
"Fourteen hours. You died, Billy. Clinically. Steve brought you back." Her voice cracked. "Why did you do it? Throw yourself at that thing?"
"Because someone had to."
"That's not an answer."
I met her eyes. "Because Steve showed me I could be someone else. Someone who protects instead of hurts. And because you're my sister. I couldn't let that thing hurt you."
"Step-sister," she said automatically.
"No. Sister. Don't care what paperwork says." The words felt right. Honest. "You're family. I protect family."
Max's eyes filled with tears. "I was so scared you'd die. That your last act would be saving someone and I'd never get to tell you... that you were getting better. That I was proud of you."
"You're proud of me?"
"Yeah. You saved Steve. Fought monsters. Chose to be different. That takes courage I didn't think you had."
Max
Billy looked different lying in that hospital bed. Vulnerable. Young. Not the aggressive threat I'd grown up fearing.
"I'm sorry," he said quietly. "For everything. For being cruel, for making you scared, for taking Neil's shit out on you. You deserved better brother than I was."
"You can still be that person."
"I want to be. That thing almost killed me, Max. Made me realize I don't want to die as Neil's clone. Don't want my last moments to be rage and pain and violence." His hands clenched the sheets. "Steve believed I could change. Saved my life because he believed it. I owe him—owe you—proof he was right."
"You already proved it. You took a hit meant for him."
"One action doesn't erase years of abuse."
"No. But it's a start. And starts are important." I reached out, tentatively took his hand. "We can be different. Both of us. Leave Neil's poison behind."
He squeezed my hand carefully. "Yeah. We can."
Susan
I stood in the doorway, watching my children reconcile. Tears streamed down my face.
For so long, I'd been helpless. Watching Neil destroy Billy, watching Billy's anger hurt Max, unable to stop either cycle. Paralyzed by my own fear and weakness.
But Billy was changing. Fighting to be someone different. And Max was giving him chance to prove it.
"Thank you," I whispered to whatever power had brought them to this moment.
Billy
Neil arrived that evening. Still in his work uniform, face already twisted with disapproval.
"You embarrassed this family," he said instead of asking how I felt. "Getting yourself mauled by... whatever official story is. Making us look weak."
Max tensed. Susan flinched. Old patterns activating automatically.
But I'd died and come back. Had felt Steve absorb mortal wounds to save me. Had made choice to protect instead of hurt.
Neil didn't own me anymore.
"Get out," I said.
"What?"
"I said get out. I'm done. With your abuse, your control, your making me into your punching bag." My voice shook but held steady. "You don't own me. Next time you touch me, I press charges. Next time you threaten me, I call the police. I'm eighteen. I'm done."
Neil's face flushed red. "You ungrateful—"
"OUT. Or I scream for security."
For ten seconds, we stared at each other. Abuser and victim. Monster and target.
Then Neil turned and walked out. No blow, no violence, no escalation.
Because I'd set a boundary. Finally. After eighteen years.
My hands shook violently after he left. Susan cried. Max hugged me.
"That was the bravest thing I've ever seen you do," Max whispered.
"Learned from the best."
Steve
I woke in the hospital bed beside Billy's. The corruption had receded, leaving permanent scars—black veins visible under skin, no longer pulsing but never fully disappearing.
The Mind Flayer's connection was severed. But I'd never be fully unmarked by it.
Billy was awake, talking quietly with Max. They looked... peaceful. Like siblings who actually cared about each other.
"You're awake," Billy said, noticing me watching.
"Yeah. You?"
"Alive because of you." He touched his bandaged chest. "You absorbed mortal wounds to save me. Why?"
"Because you deserved to live. Because your redemption was real. Because I promised myself I'd break fate's pattern." I smiled weakly. "And because you threw yourself between me and a monster. Debt goes both ways."
"I don't deserve—"
"Billy. Stop. You do deserve it. You chose to be different, to protect people, to break Neil's cycle. That's worth saving."
Max leaned forward. "Steve? Thank you. For believing in him when no one else did."
"I believe in all of you. That's the point."
Billy
Steve fell back asleep. Exhaustion and corruption recovery claiming him.
I watched him—this corrupted, scarred, exhausted boy who'd fought dimensional monsters and saved everyone. Who'd seen something worth redeeming in me when I'd seen only Neil's legacy.
"You believed I could be better," I whispered. "I won't forget that. Won't waste this chance you gave me."
The scars on Steve's skin pulsed faintly—permanent marks from bridging dimensions, from absorbing too much darkness, from sacrificing himself repeatedly.
He'd never be fully free of the corruption. But he'd saved everyone anyway.
That's what heroes look like, I thought. Not perfect. Not unmarked. Just people who keep fighting despite the cost.
I could be that. Not hero maybe, but better person. Someone who protected instead of hurt. Someone who chose love over rage.
Steve had shown me it was possible. Now I had to prove him right.
Max dozed off in her chair. Susan sat quietly in the corner, watching her children heal.
And I lay there, alive against all odds, building plans for who I'd become next.
Someone different. Someone better. Someone worthy of the second chance Steve Harrington had died a little to give me.
Not Neil's son. Mine. Billy Hargrove on my own terms.
The thought felt like freedom.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0