Chapter 179: The Second Trial
JAEHAERYS
Four days after they carried the dead out of the family wing, the great hall filled to its walls, and Jaehaerys had a chair.
That was the part he kept turning over. Not the chains, not the crowd. The chair. Plain oak with a straight back, set on the dais at his mother's right hand, and Ser Criston Cole had walked him to it that morning without a word about why. He wasn't there to be looked at. He was there to watch. Emberscale rode his shoulder with his claws hooked into the padded leather sewn there for him, hissed once at the noise, and settled against his neck, warm as a covered brazier.
The noise frightened him more than the prisoner did. Three hundred people down the length of the hall, and they hadn't come to see law done. He could hear it in the churn under the talking, and in how it swelled when the side door opened.
His sister came to the dais steps before it started, holding a rolled page out in front of her in both hands, level.
"I painted the face," she said. "It's on the page. Whoever needs it can look at the page."
"You aren't called," their mother said. "The tribunal has enough without you."
"I would have stood up."
"I know that." Helaena took the roll and set it on the table beside her, and didn't unroll it. "That is why you don't have to."
Jaehaera looked at the crowd for a moment, counting something, and went and sat down with Maelor.
They brought Lord Denys Beesbury in through the side door and he walked on his own legs. Fifty-eight years old, grey to the jaw, castellan at the Hightower for three-and-forty years and Otto Hightower's right hand for most of them. His boots had been taken. He came up the aisle in wool stockings on cold stone, chained at the wrists, and he didn't hurry.
Jaehaerys had expected to hate the look of him. The man was ordinary, and that was worse.
His father sat second from the left on the tribunal bench, forearms on the table, sleeve buttoned over the bandaging. Three judges, and a set order they had to keep to. That was Cregan Stark's work, cut into the realm's law in the Hour of the Wolf when Jaehaerys was too young to remember any of it. He'd grown up hearing about it. It had always sounded like something that happened to other people, in a colder year, before him.
"Denys of House Beesbury," Helaena said, and the hall that hadn't quieted for the guards went still for her. "You are accused of conspiracy against the crown, attempted murder of the royal children, and the deaths of those who fell during your attacks on the realm's peace. How do you answer?"
"I answer that this court knows the verdict already."
"Then it will take the morning to prove it anyway. How do you answer?"
The evidence went first, and it took two hours, and in those two hours Jaehaerys learned that the crowd hated nothing so much as being made to wait. A clerk from the Hightower's counting house testified to eleven years of ledgers and named the weight of a purse he'd never opened. Corlys Velaryon's factors traced a third of the Hightower's loose silver out through the Oldtown wool trade into banks in Lys and Braavos and home again as foreign coin in the bellies of wine ships. Ser Criston Cole read the household rolls into the record, forty extra hands signed on in three days for the feasting, six of the names false, and he read all six of the false names aloud slowly. Lord Fossoway's parchment went in with six seals still on it. Lord Tarly's confession went in as he'd given it.
Twice a man near the doors shouted that they were wasting daylight. Twice the hall was called to order, and the second time Ulf spoke, without raising his voice at all.
"If we could shorten it for this one, we could shorten it for the next one," he said. "The next one might be innocent. Sit down."
They sat down. Three hundred people, sitting down for a rule, with his father's hands resting still on the table.
When it came to Beesbury to speak, he took it, and turned his back on the bench so the hall could hear him. Nobody stopped him. The rules gave a man his own words.
"Eleven years ago this court sat where it sits now," he said, "and it took my seat at Honeyholt, and my name off it, and every acre my grandfather's grandfather held. It took my wife's dower. It took my two trueborn sons, who had never carried a spear in their lives, and it called that peace. I went out of the Reach with what I could put in a saddlebag, and nobody wrote a word of it down." His chains rang once against his hip. "So write it down now. I did what I did because you built your quiet on my ruin, and then stood a bastard boy up in front of the Faith and taught the realm to love him out loud. I wanted it understood that there's a price on that. I ran out of regret at Honeyholt."
Someone in the crowd screamed at him to hang. He waited it out.
"That is entered," Helaena said. "All of it, exactly as spoken."
She let the hall sit in its own silence, and then she gave them the verdict.
"The realm doesn't belong to any one man. It belongs to everyone who lives in it, and the law that was established by Lord Stark and upheld by this court doesn't distinguish between grievances and crimes. You may have been wronged. But you chose to answer that wrong with murder." She met his eyes. "The court finds you guilty. Your name and your remaining gold are forfeit to the crown, and the gold goes to the households of the dead in the family wing. Your sentence is the Wall. You will take the black and serve the realm in the Night's Watch for the remainder of your life. The same mercy that was extended to others during the Hour of the Wolf is extended to you, not because you deserve it, but because the realm has decided that justice is stronger than vengeance."
The hall made a sound. Not agreement. Something rougher, and it broke apart into people arguing with each other instead of with her.
Jaehaerys nodded once when the sentence landed, and found he'd decided it days ago without knowing.
They took him back down the aisle in his stockings. Eight feet from the doors he stopped, picked a face out of the crowd, and pitched his voice for everyone.
"Ask Lord Tarly what he burned the night before he walked into the Tower of the Hand," he said. "He didn't give you all of it. He gave you me."
The guards moved him along. The doors let in a slab of white midday and swallowed him, and behind him half the hall was already turning to look at where he'd been looking.
Jaehaerys found his father in the corridor behind the dais, where the noise came through the stone as a low hum.
"You could have killed him," Jaehaerys said. "During the fight. You had him. I could feel it through Emberscale, the power you used. You could have ended him."
"Yes."
"But you didn't."
"No. Because killing him would have proven his point. That power is the only thing that decides anything. That a stripped man is nothing but what was taken from him. That the realm's justice is vengeance in better robes." Ulf turned and looked down at him properly. "Beesbury is going to spend the rest of his life at the Wall, serving the realm he tried to destroy. That's not vengeance. That's justice. And justice, real justice, the kind Stark taught us, is the only thing that lasts."
Out on the steps the cart was being loaded, the crowd thinning into the yard in knots, still arguing. Jaehaera and Maelor stood with their mother at the top of the stair.
"I want to watch it leave," Jaehaerys said, and went, and his father came down the steps beside him.
