Cherreads

Chapter 39 - Chapter 39:The Greatest Mistake of Our Lives

Leo walked out of the hospital into the cool night air. The sky above was dark, dotted with stars that seemed indifferent to everything that had happened tonight. He reached into his pocket and pulled out the phone.

It was a simple phone, the kind with buttons instead of a touchscreen. It was 2009, and smartphones existed but were not yet everywhere. This phone was practical, functional, the kind Alistair would carry for reliable communication. Leo remembered the moment Alistair had handed it to him.

"Alistair," he had said, stopping the older man just as he was about to leave. "My phone was damaged in the accident. Can I borrow yours for tonight? You can pick it up tomorrow morning from my house, or I will arrange a new one for you."

Alistair had not hesitated. He had reached into his pocket, pulled out the phone, and extended it toward Leo without a moment's thought.

"No worries, Master," he had said. His voice was calm, as always, as if lending his personal phone to his employer in the middle of the night was a completely normal occurrence. Then he had nodded once and walked away, his car starting a moment later and pulling out of the hospital parking lot.

Leo looked at the phone in his hand now. It was small, silver, with a small screen and a keypad of raised buttons. He opened it and began to press the numbers.

Elena had given him her number when they exchanged phone numbers. It was a normal thing, something friends did, sharing contact information for calls and texts and plans. His memory, enhanced by the powers he possessed, had stored every digit perfectly. He did not need to think about it. His fingers moved automatically, pressing 5, then 5, then 5—no, that was wrong. He corrected himself, smiling slightly at the momentary confusion. Even with perfect memory, the physical act of dialing could still trip him up.

The phone rang. Once. Twice. Three times.

Then a voice answered. It was a woman's voice, mature, a little sleepy but alert. "Hello? Who is this?"

Leo recognized it immediately. Jenna Sommers, Elena's aunt. The woman who had become a guardian to two teenagers after their parents died, who was doing her best to hold a family together in the aftermath of tragedy.

"Aunt Jenna," Leo said. He kept his voice calm, friendly, the voice of a boyfriend calling to check in. "It's me, Leo Whittemore. Elena's friend."

"Oh, Leo!" Jenna's voice warmed slightly. "It's you. I've heard about you from Elena. She talks about you quite a bit, you know."

Leo smiled at that. "All good things, I hope."

"Mostly," Jenna said, and he could hear the smile in her voice. Then her tone shifted, becoming more practical. "Leo, is Elena with you? She hasn't come home yet, and I was starting to wonder."

"Yes, Aunt Jenna," Leo said. "Elena is with me. She's already fallen asleep, actually. She asked me to call you before she fallen asleep and let you know so you wouldn't worry."

Jenna's voice, when she spoke again, was relieved. Happy, even. "Oh, that's good." A pause. "Take care of her, Leo."

"Of course," he said. It was not just a polite response. It was a promise. "Good night, Aunt Jenna."

"Good night, Leo."

The line went dead. Leo closed the phone and slipped it back into his pocket. He took a deep breath, filling his lungs with the cool night air. It smelled of pine and asphalt and the faint chemical scent that always hung around hospitals. He looked up at the sky again, at the stars scattered across the darkness like careless brushstrokes on a black canvas.

Everything was solved, he thought. Elena was safe. And everything is going in a good way.

Then he saw the lights.

Red and blue, flashing in the darkness, growing closer. A police car, its siren silent but its presence unmistakable, turned into the hospital parking lot and rolled to a stop directly in front of him.

The door opened. A woman stepped out.

She was mature, around forty years old, with blonde hair pulled back and the kind of face that had seen too much and learned to hide it behind professional calm. She wore a police uniform, and the badge on her chest marked her as someone important. Elizabeth Forbes. Sheriff of Mystic Falls. Caroline's mother.

On the other side of the car, a male assistant emerged. He wore the same uniform but with fewer stars, fewer markers of rank. He stood slightly behind the sheriff, deferential, waiting for her to take the lead.

Leo looked at them and understood immediately why they were here. The car accident. The burning wreckage on a narrow road. Someone would have reported it by now. Someone would have called the police. And the sheriff, being the sheriff, would have come to investigate.

Sheriff Forbes held two photographs in her hand. She glanced down at them, then up at Leo. One photo showed a boy. The other showed a girl. The girl's face was familiar to her—it was her daughter's school friend, the one who came over sometimes, the one Caroline talked about. The boy's face matched the young man standing before her now.

She stepped forward. Her voice was professional, calm, the voice of someone conducting official business.

"Hello, young man," she said. "Are you the one involved in the car accident tonight?"

Leo met her gaze. His voice was calm, steady. "Yes."

The sheriff's expression softened slightly. "How is Elena? Is she okay?"

"She's fine," Leo said. "She needs a few days to recover completely, but she will be fine. The doctors said so."

Sheriff Forbes nodded, and a small sigh of relief escaped her. She knew Elena. She knew what that girl had already been through, losing her parents, trying to hold her life together. The thought of her being seriously hurt in another accident was a sad one. It was good that she was okay.

"I've researched the accident," the sheriff said. "I also spoke with the other two survivors. Lexi and Stefan." She paused, watching his face for any reaction. "They said the road was too narrow. That there wasn't anyone's fault. It was just one of those things that happens." She looked at him directly. "Do you agree with that?"

Leo held her gaze. His expression did not change. "Yes," he said. "That's what happened."

The male assistant stepped forward, a small notepad in his hand. He scribbled something down, recording Leo's statement for the official record. Then he nodded to the sheriff, indicating that he had what he needed.

Sheriff Forbes looked at Leo for a moment longer. Something flickered in her eyes—curiosity, perhaps, or suspicion. But she did not act on it. She simply nodded.

"Alright," she said. "Take care of yourself. And take care of Elena."

"I will," Leo said.

She turned and walked back to the car. The assistant followed. The doors closed, the engine started, and the police car pulled away, its red and blue lights fading into the night until they disappeared completely.

Leo stood alone in the parking lot, watching the spot where the car had vanished. His hands were in his pockets. The night air was cool against his face.

A thought formed in his mind, quiet but persistent.

Leaving those two vampires alive. Was it the right choice? Or was it a mistake that would come back to hurt him? To hurt Elena?

He did not know. He could not know. The future was always uncertain, always shifting, always full of possibilities he could not predict. All he could do was wait and watch and be ready for whatever came next.

He looked up at the hospital, at the window where Elena's room was, where she lay on the bed and recovering and waiting for him to return. Then he looked back at the empty road where the police car had gone.

The night was quiet. The stars were cold. And Leo Whittemore, who was also Lucifer Morningstar, stood alone in the darkness and wondered if he had made the right choice.

….

The Salvatore house stood silent in the darkness. Its old walls, which had witnessed centuries of supernatural history, now contained two vampires who had just experienced something that should not exist.

Lexi walked through the door first. Her movements were sharp, agitated, the movements of someone whose mind was still racing, still trying to process something that made no sense. She had not spoken since they left the road. She had not been able to find words big enough to contain what she felt.

Stefan followed behind her. He closed the door slowly, carefully, as if the normal act of shutting a door could somehow restore order to a world that had just been turned upside down. The click of the latch was loud in the quiet house.

Lexi turned to face him. Her eyes were wild, unfocused, still seeing the image that had burned itself into her memory: Leo, walking out of the fire. Walking out of flames that would have reduced her or Stefan to ash in seconds. Walking out untouched, unharmed, calm.

"Stefan," she said. Her voice was rough, strained. "Leo is beyond common sense. Beyond anything I have ever seen. Our attacks—they were like a child attacking an adult. Less than that. Like nothing." She paused, swallowing hard. "And the fact that he left us alive. He could have killed us. He should have killed us. But he didn't. That shows how much humanity he still has in him."

Stefan moved to a pillar near the entrance of the living room. He leaned against it, folding his arms across his chest. His face was pale, thoughtful, the face of someone trying to piece together a puzzle with half the pieces missing.

"Lexi," he said slowly. "I think he is not old like us. Not ancient. I think he is just a normal teenager boy who maybe awakened some kind of family power. Think about it. That Night, he didn't kill Damon. He only locked him in the cell. Maybe he knew Damon too well, knew what kind of threat he was. And now, tonight, he didn't kill us either." He paused, letting his words settle. "I think we have made the greatest mistake of our lives by becoming his enemy."

Lexi walked to the table where a bottle of wine sat, half full. She did not bother with a glass. She grabbed the bottle by the neck, raised it to her lips, and drank directly from it. The wine was dark, strong, the kind of drink that could dull the sharpest edges of fear and confusion. She drank deeply, then lowered the bottle. Some of the tension in her shoulders relaxed.

"Stefan," she said. Her voice was calmer now, steadier. "I know he is a good person. If you put it that way, yes, he showed mercy. He let us live. But you forget one thing." She looked at him directly. "The humiliation. What he did to us at the Grill. What he did to me. That does not go away. That does not heal just because he let us live." She took another drink. "And maybe you are right. Maybe he is not old like us, not someone who has seen centuries of killing and learned to do it without thought. But what happened has happened. We are his enemies now. And enemies only have one ending. One of us has to die."

Stefan unfolded his arms. He pushed off from the pillar and took a step toward her.

"Lexi," he said with a wry smile."If that is true, then that ending is ours. Because we cannot handle him. You saw it tonight. Two of us, attacking together, with all our strength and speed, and we could not even scratch his skin. He is beyond us. He is beyond anything we have ever faced."

Lexi took another drink from the bottle. Then she shook her head.

"No, my dear Stefan." Her voice was calmer now, more controlled. The initial shock was fading, replaced by calculation. "We are not going to attack him again. Not now. Not soon. That would be foolish." She paused. "But we are going to find more information. We are going to learn everything we can about him. About this 'devil' identity. I do not believe he is invincible. I do not believe he has no weaknesses. Everyone has weaknesses. Everyone can be killed. We just have to find the right way."

Stefan hesitated. His expression was uncertain, conflicted.

"Can't we just leave it?" he asked. "Can't we just live our lives separately? I don't think he will attack us again. He had the chance tonight and he didn't take it. Maybe he is done with us. Maybe we can just... go back to how things were."

Lexi drank again. The wine was half gone now. She lowered the bottle and looked at Stefan with something like pity in her eyes.

"That is the best choice for the present," she said. "For now, we stay away. We live our lives. We pretend this never happened." She paused. "But not forever. What if he changes his mind? What if one day he decides that leaving us alive was a mistake? What if he comes for us? We need to be ready. We need to know what he is, what he can do, how to stop him if it becomes necessary."

She did not wait for his answer. She turned and walked toward the stairs, crossing the distance between the living room and the staircase in an instant, using her vampire speed without thinking about it. Her footsteps echoed on the wooden steps as she climbed.

Stefan stood alone in the living room, looking down at the floor. Her words circled in his mind, heavy with implication. She was right, of course. She was always right about these things. But the thought of continuing to fight Leo, of eventually having to face him again, made something cold settle in his stomach.

Then Lexi's voice came from upstairs, carrying clearly through the quiet house.

"Stefan! I am leaving Mystic Falls tomorrow. I have to meet someone."

He heard her footsteps continue down the hallway. A door opened, then closed. Silence returned to the Salvatore house.

Stefan remained where he was, staring at the floor, thinking about enemies and endings and the boy who walked out of fire.

....

Leave power stones and reviews.

On our Patreon, we're already 15 chapters ahead of everyone else!🏃💨

Come to Patreon,Baby 😘

Don't get left behind farming in the newbie village while we're already dominating the endgame content! 👑🔥

👉 Patreon-Beyblade245

It's time to jump the queue and get that VIP treatment. Your throne is waiting~ 💎

More Chapters