Chapter 29: THE OBSERVER
The band room was empty when I arrived, but Robin's trumpet case was already on its usual chair.
I'd been back at school for two days. The Phase 3 recovery was mostly complete—still some residual fatigue, still more hungry than usual, but functional. Functional enough to maintain the cover of normal high school student, at least. Functional enough to keep building the connections that might save lives later.
Robin appeared from the back storage room, carrying not her trumpet but a spiral notebook. Her expression was different today—focused, purposeful, like she'd been waiting for this conversation.
"No music today?"
"Later maybe." She sat down across from me, the notebook closed on her lap. "I've been doing research."
"Research on what?"
"On Hawkins." She opened the notebook. Pages of handwritten notes, diagrams, newspaper clippings taped to margins. "This town has secrets, Billy. Big ones."
I kept my expression neutral, but my pulse quickened. Robin Buckley, amateur investigator. Of course she'd been digging. It was what she did—noticed things, asked questions, refused to accept easy answers.
"What kind of secrets?"
She flipped to a page covered in bullet points. "The Byers boy. Will. Disappeared last year for a week. Official story: got lost in the woods, hypothermia, nearly died." She looked up at me. "Except he wasn't found in the woods. He was found in the government lab on the edge of town. And nobody talks about that."
The hair on my arms stood up. She was closer to the truth than I'd expected—closer than she should be without direct experience of the Upside Down.
"Government lab?"
"Hawkins National Laboratory. Department of Energy, supposedly. But I know people who've worked there, or tried to. Security clearances. Non-disclosure agreements. The kind of stuff you don't need for energy research." She flipped to another page. "And then there's Chief Hopper. He's been acting weird for months. Driving out to the edge of town at odd hours. Meeting with people in suits. Something happened last year that nobody wants to talk about."
I looked at her notes. They were thorough—dates, names, locations, connections drawn between seemingly unrelated events. The work of someone who knew how to research and wasn't afraid to ask uncomfortable questions.
"You believe any of this?" I asked carefully.
Robin met my eyes. "I believe something happened. Something the government covered up. Something that involves that lab and probably half the authority figures in this town." She closed the notebook. "And I believe you know more than you're telling me."
Not a question. An observation. Robin Buckley, seeing through my carefully constructed facade.
"What makes you think that?"
"Because you're not surprised." She leaned forward. "I just told you there's a government conspiracy in Hawkins, and you didn't blink. Didn't laugh. Didn't tell me I'm crazy. You already knew."
She was right. And she was too smart to be fooled by denial.
"The town's secrets are dangerous," I said slowly. "Knowing them is dangerous. People have died, Robin. People have disappeared. Getting too close to certain things can put you in the crosshairs."
"And you know what those things are?"
"Some of them."
She processed that. Her expression didn't change—still that intense focus, that determination to understand—but something shifted in her posture. She'd expected denial. She'd gotten confirmation.
"Last year," she said. "The Byers kid. The government lab. You know what really happened?"
"I know enough to be scared." True. "I know enough to be preparing." Also true. "And I know that telling you everything would put you in danger."
"I'm already in danger." She gestured at the notebook. "I've been asking questions for months. If there's a cover-up, they probably know I'm poking around. Ignorance isn't protection—it's just blindness."
She had a point. Robin was already on a collision course with the truth. Keeping her ignorant wouldn't keep her safe; it would just leave her unprepared when the collision happened.
"When you're ready to share," she said, "I'm here. I can help."
"Help how?"
"Research. Investigation. An extra pair of eyes." She smiled slightly. "I'm good at finding things. Ask anyone who's tried to keep a secret in this school."
I thought about the future. About Starcourt Mall and the Russian base and the way Robin had handled the truth when Steve finally told her. She'd been scared—anyone would be—but she hadn't broken. Hadn't run. Had stood her ground and fought alongside people she barely knew because it was the right thing to do.
Robin Buckley was going to be an ally. The only question was when.
"Soon," I said. "When I'm sure you're ready. When I'm sure I can tell you without making things worse."
"How will you know when that is?"
"I'll know." I stood up, headed for the door. "Until then—keep your notebook safe. Don't show it to anyone you don't trust absolutely. And be careful who you ask questions to."
"Billy?" Her voice stopped me at the threshold.
I turned.
"Whatever's dangerous about this town?" She held up the notebook. "I can handle it. I've been preparing too."
I believed her. Robin Buckley, preparing for a battle she didn't fully understand yet. Gathering intelligence. Building defenses.
We were more alike than she knew.
"I know you can," I said. "That's why I'm going to tell you. Soon."
The walk to the parking lot gave me time to think. Robin was halfway to the truth already—she just needed the supernatural pieces to complete the puzzle. Hawkins Lab. Government cover-up. Strange disappearances.
She didn't know about the Upside Down. Didn't know about the Mind Flayer or the Demogorgons or the little girl with psychic powers who'd escaped from the lab. But she had the framework. The understanding that Hawkins wasn't what it seemed.
When the time came to tell her everything, she'd be ready to listen.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0