CHAPTER 44: MIND GAMES — Part 2
Day eight. The breaking point.
I knew it was coming the moment I saw Doakes' face in the morning briefing. The exhaustion was visible now—dark circles under his eyes, a tightness around his mouth that spoke of sleepless nights and mounting frustration. He'd been following me for over a week while I ran him in circles, documenting every suspicious glance, every hostile comment, every moment of professional dysfunction.
The trap was ready. All I needed was for him to walk into it.
"Good morning, everyone," LaGuerta said, taking her position at the front of the room. "Quick updates before we get started. Agent Lundy's team has identified three more potential Butcher victims based on the victim profile. We're coordinating with—"
I tuned out the briefing, watching Doakes from the corner of my eye. He was watching me too, as he always did. But something was different today. The usual cold calculation had been replaced by something rawer. More dangerous.
He was reaching his limit.
Perfect.
The briefing ended. People dispersed to their various assignments. I lingered near the coffee station, making myself visible, accessible, a convenient target for whatever Doakes was building toward.
He didn't disappoint.
"Morgan." His voice was low, controlled, but I could hear the strain underneath. "We need to talk."
"Of course, Sergeant." I kept my tone pleasant, cooperative. "What can I do for you?"
"Not here." He jerked his head toward the elevator. "Parking garage. Five minutes."
He walked away before I could respond. I watched him go, calculating probabilities.
This was it. The confrontation I'd been engineering for over a week. Doakes was about to make a mistake—I could feel it in the way he moved, the tension in his shoulders, the barely contained fury that had been building since the first cheerful greeting.
I gave him exactly five minutes. Then I took the elevator down to the parking garage, making sure to pass through the bullpen on my way. Witnesses who could confirm where I was going, when I left, how calm and cooperative I'd been.
The parking garage was cool and dim, fluorescent lights casting everything in shades of institutional grey. Doakes was waiting near my car, arms crossed, face carved from stone.
"Sergeant Doakes." I approached slowly, keeping my body language open and non-threatening. "What did you want to talk about?"
"Cut the bullshit." He stepped forward, closing the distance between us. "I know what you're doing. The friendly act, the gifts, the HR complaint. You're trying to make me look crazy."
"I don't know what you mean." I maintained my confused expression, letting a hint of concern creep into my voice. "I filed that complaint because I was genuinely worried about you. The way you've been acting—following me, watching my apartment, making accusations—it's not healthy, Sergeant."
"Not healthy." He laughed—a harsh, bitter sound. "You want to talk about not healthy? Let's talk about you, Morgan. Let's talk about how a blood analyst who can't handle fresh violence somehow killed a serial killer with his bare hands. Let's talk about why you own a boat in a city where the Bay Harbor Butcher dumps his victims in the ocean."
"Lots of people own boats in Miami."
"Lots of people aren't you." He jabbed a finger toward my chest, stopping just short of contact. "I know what you are. I've known since the first day I met you. And I'm going to prove it."
"Prove what, exactly?" I let hurt creep into my voice. "That I'm a good analyst? That I survived a traumatic experience? That I've been trying—really trying—to be a better colleague despite your constant hostility?"
"Don't." His voice dropped to a whisper. "Don't stand there and pretend you're innocent. I've seen your eyes, Morgan. When you think no one's watching. There's nothing there. No feeling, no conscience, no humanity. You're wearing a mask, and one day it's going to slip."
"Sergeant, I think you need help." I let compassion color my tone. "This obsession—it's not good for you. Maybe you should talk to someone. A professional."
Something snapped behind his eyes.
The shove came fast—faster than I'd expected. His hands hit my chest with enough force to drive me backward, my shoulders slamming against the driver's side door of my car hard enough to dent the metal.
"I don't need help!" His voice echoed off the concrete walls. "I need people to listen! You're a killer, Morgan! A fucking monster hiding in plain sight, and everyone's too blind to see it!"
I didn't fight back. Didn't raise my hands. Just stood there, absorbing the impact, letting him see the hurt and confusion on my face.
Behind him, I heard footsteps. Voices.
"What the hell?"
Two Metro employees—uniforms, probably heading to their patrol cars—had emerged from the elevator. They stood frozen, staring at the scene: Sergeant James Doakes, hands still on my chest, pinning me against a car.
Me, looking shocked and frightened.
"Sergeant Doakes." I kept my voice small, wounded. "Please. I don't want any trouble."
He looked at me. Looked at the witnesses. Realization dawned slowly—the understanding that he'd done exactly what I wanted him to do.
His hands dropped. He stepped back.
"This isn't over," he said quietly. "You hear me, Morgan? This isn't over."
He turned and walked away, past the uniformed officers, into the elevator. The doors closed behind him.
I sagged against my car, letting the tremors show. The witnesses approached, concerned.
"You okay, man? What was that about?"
"I don't know." I rubbed my shoulder, wincing. "He's been... I don't know. Something's wrong with him."
"You should report this. That was assault."
"I don't want to get anyone in trouble." The magnanimous victim, turning the other cheek. "He's going through something. Maybe he just needs help."
[WITNESS COUNT: 2] [ASSAULT: DOCUMENTED] [DOAKES' CREDIBILITY: CRITICALLY DAMAGED] [PHASE 2: COMPLETE]
[MIAMI METRO — LAGUERTA'S OFFICE — 4:15 PM]
The meeting was brief and devastating.
LaGuerta sat behind her desk, expression carefully neutral. Doakes stood before her, spine rigid, face showing nothing. I sat in a chair near the door, ice pack pressed against my shoulder—an injury that didn't hurt nearly as much as I was pretending.
"Sergeant Doakes." LaGuerta's voice was cold. "You're being placed on administrative leave, effective immediately. Pending a review of your conduct and the assault complaint filed by Mr. Morgan."
"I'm not filing a complaint," I said quickly. Generous. Understanding. "I told you, Lieutenant, I don't want anyone to get in trouble. I just want the harassment to stop."
"That's very gracious of you, Mr. Morgan." LaGuerta's tone suggested she appreciated the gesture but wouldn't let it change her decision. "Nevertheless, Sergeant Doakes' behavior has become a departmental concern. The obsessive focus on a colleague, the documented harassment, and now a physical altercation in front of witnesses—this cannot continue."
"He's playing you." Doakes' voice was flat, controlled. "Both of you. Morgan is the Bay Harbor Butcher. I know it. I've been trying to prove it."
"You've been trying to prove your personal theory by stalking a colleague and assaulting him in a parking garage." LaGuerta shook her head. "That's not investigation, Sergeant. That's obsession. And it ends now."
"Lieutenant—"
"You're done, Doakes. Turn in your badge and your weapon. When—and if—you return to duty, you will have no contact with Mr. Morgan. None. Is that clear?"
The silence stretched for a long moment. I watched Doakes' face, saw the fury and frustration war with his professional training. He knew what had happened. He knew I'd maneuvered him into this position, used his own obsession as a weapon against him.
And there was nothing he could do about it.
"Crystal clear," he said finally.
He placed his badge on LaGuerta's desk. His weapon followed. Then he turned and walked out, not looking at either of us.
I watched him go, maintaining my expression of concerned relief.
Goodbye, Sergeant. Enjoy your suspension.
[DEXTER'S APARTMENT — 11:30 PM]
The shadow was gone.
For the first time in weeks, no dark sedan sat parked on my street. No predator's eyes tracked my movements. No obstacle stood between me and the hunt I'd been craving.
I stood at my window, staring at the empty space where Doakes usually waited. The absence felt strange—almost unnatural after so long under surveillance.
"You won," Harry said.
"For now." I turned away from the window. "He'll be back. Suspension isn't permanent. And his obsession won't fade just because LaGuerta told him to stand down."
"Then you'll need to be ready when he returns."
"I will be." I crossed to my closet, pulled down the bag that held my kill kit. "But first, I have unfinished business."
Santos Jimenez. The man who helped murder Laura Moser. The man who'd walked free for thirty years while two orphaned boys grew into damaged men.
The man whose death I'd been denied by Doakes' constant surveillance.
"The hunt resumes," Harry observed.
"The hunt resumes."
I began packing my kit with the careful precision of ritual. Plastic sheeting. Surgical tools. The M99 and its syringes. Everything I needed to honor the Code and satisfy the Passenger.
Tomorrow, I would drive to Naples. Tomorrow, I would find Santos Jimenez in his modest house with its vinyl siding and chain-link fence.
Tomorrow, the debt would finally come due.
[HEAT STATUS: -10 (DOAKES NEUTRALIZED)] [SURVEILLANCE: REMOVED] [TARGET: SANTOS JIMENEZ] [HUNT: AUTHORIZED]
Reviews and Power Stones keep the heat on!
Want to see what happens before the "heroes" do?
Secure your spot in the inner circle on Patreon. Skip the weekly wait and read ahead:
💵 Hustler [$7]: 15 Chapters ahead.
⚖️ Enforcer [$11]: 20 Chapters ahead.
👑 Kingpin [$16]: 25 Chapters ahead.
Periodic drops. Check on Patreon for the full release list.
👉 Join the Syndicate: patreon.com/Anti_hero_fanfic