Hermione explained her thoughts very clearly, and Sherlock listened very attentively.
After she finished saying everything she had to say, the office fell silent.
Fleur leaned back in her chair, arms crossed over her chest, very interested in how Sherlock would respond.
Hermione became restless again; her breathing grew slightly rapid, and she looked at Sherlock with nervous eyes.
Sherlock's expression had not changed from beginning to end. Only after Hermione's voice trailed off and the two young women's gazes were fixed on him did he reveal an expression of admiration.
"From the perspective of all sentient beings, this is a very good, excellent idea, Miss Granger!"
His affirmation stunned Fleur and left Hermione dumbfounded.
"Are, are, are you complimenting me, Professor?" Hermione asked, her voice trembling.
Sherlock stared into her eyes, meeting her gaze without flinching, and said with a very serious expression, "Your idea is very good, very correct, and very righteous; it is something worthy of affirmation."
Hermione covered her face, her body trembling as if she were about to cry.
Ever since she proposed that House-Elves should be independent, everything around her had been voices of opposition. Even her two closest friends, her dorm mates, Hagrid, and other Professors had all told her without hesitation that this was an impossible and meaningless endeavour.
Sherlock's affirmation was very important to her!
"Championing the oppressed and seeking liberation for the enslaved—there is nothing more righteous in this world than that, Hermione."
Sherlock's voice was calm, like a sea breeze soothing the waves, causing the teary-eyed Hermione to lower her hands from her face and listen quietly as he continued.
"No matter the era or the country, as long as one stands on the side of all sentient beings, those willing to do such things can be called heroes. But do you know why there is so much obstruction around you when you propose this idea?"
Hermione sniffled and nodded vigorously.
"I know. Harry thinks that those House-Elves like serving wizards themselves, that this kind of servitude is something they enjoy doing. But in truth, he doesn't understand that such thoughts about 'liking' it were all instilled in them by wizards. As for the adults who truly understand these things, they all feel that House-Elves are not human and have no value in being liberated; only by keeping them serving wizards will the entire Wizarding community benefit."
"But everything I've been taught since I was young tells me that enslaving a sentient being is inherently wrong. No self-aware being should be categorised this way. Books have always taught us what justice is, but adults always talk to me about interests. I don't want that. Someone has to do what is just, even if it's only me."
"But everyone says I am wrong." Hermione's voice was choked with sobs.
"Because the standpoint you occupy is much higher than others. No one will be as magnanimous as you. Most people only consider things from the perspective of their own group. Those who oppose you are standing from the perspective of wizards. From this point of view, you are indeed doing something wrong, Hermione."
Sherlock's voice did not pause.
"True liberation has never been peaceful. The amount of obstruction you are encountering now will be encountered by House-Elves in the future when they truly seek freedom, perhaps even a hundred or a thousand times greater. And there will only be one consequence of this, just like the Goblin rebellions, which will ignite war in the Wizarding World."
Hermione was stunned, and she said hurriedly, "There must be a peaceful way. As long as wizards are willing to pay wages to the House-Elves working for them, then everything will get better after that..."
"These are just ideal scenes in your imagination, Hermione." Sherlock calmly interrupted her. "You are a smart and diligent student. You should have read quite a bit of Muggle history and History of Magic. Reading history makes one wise. In the history of any civilised society, if the oppressed want to truly obtain their own rights, a war is necessary."
"Only war can secure true, concrete interests, and only sufficient force can protect the status and respect gained. Your current idea is effectively the catalyst that will trigger a war between House-Elves and wizards in the future. For those wizards who truly see the whole picture, they will naturally reject your ideas entirely, because no one wants to see such a war—a war that brings no benefit to the Wizarding community, whether it ends in victory or defeat."
Hermione sat in her chair with a vacant gaze, saying unconsciously, "So, what I want to do now is still wrong?"
Sherlock crossed his hands and placed them on the desk.
"That depends on where you place yourself, Hermione. I cannot make this choice for you; you have to think about it yourself. I can only explain your choices to you on different levels. Similarly, my affirmation of you is not false at all; you are doing something righteous, but justice is never absolute."
"A hero in one country might be a heinous villain to another. That is the situation you are facing now: whether you choose to stand on the side of wizards or on the side of House-Elves."
The office fell silent. Hermione stared blankly at the ceiling, not knowing what she was thinking about.
Sherlock stood up and patted her shoulder.
"You can go back and think about it carefully, Hermione. What are your true thoughts? Which kind of justice is it, and justice for whom? If there is anything you still can't figure out, you can come and ask me again. I can't know everything, but I should be able to give you some advice and hints."
Hermione eventually left Sherlock's office. She hadn't fully obtained the result she wanted, but she hadn't been completely rejected as before either.
Sherlock had told her many things that no one had told her before, enough to make her think for many days.
After Hermione left, Fleur finally spoke her first words to Sherlock.
"Why didn't you just tell her it was wrong? Why go around in circles saying so much?" Fleur asked, puzzled.
Sherlock poured himself a cup of tea. He had said quite a lot, and his mouth was very dry now.
"Hermione is very smart; she has just walked into a dead end in her thinking. Besides, she needed my recognition, so I gave her the recognition she wanted. A complete rejection is no way to make a person accept their own mistakes."
