[DEO Headquarters, Command Center — July 2017, 11:45 AM]
The emergency lights had stabilized, casting the command center in harsh white fluorescence. Agents moved with purpose—restoring systems, assessing damage, coordinating the search for Jeremiah. Professional chaos, organized around a wound that wouldn't stop bleeding.
Mon-El stood near the main display, a medical patch covering the scratch on his cheek, his ribs taped beneath his shirt. The DEO medic had been efficient—quick assessment, quick treatment, quick dismissal. There was no time for rest.
J'onn addressed the assembled team, his voice carrying the weight of command.
"At approximately 10:15 this morning, Agent Jeremiah Danvers was confronted with evidence of unauthorized data access and collaboration with Cadmus." His gaze swept the room. "He confessed to the charges, deployed an embedded EMP device, and fled the facility. He is to be considered armed, enhanced, and dangerous."
The silence that followed was absolute.
Alex stood at the far edge of the crowd, her face a mask of forced neutrality. Her hands hung at her sides, but Mon-El could see them trembling. Beside her, Kara had positioned herself like a shield—ready to catch her sister if she fell, ready to hold her together by force of will alone.
"The evidence was gathered by Agent Mon-El over a period of several days," J'onn continued. "He brought his concerns to me last night, and we proceeded with a private confrontation this morning. The decision to investigate was mine. The methodology was mine. Any questions about the operation should be directed to me."
He was taking responsibility. Shielding Mon-El from the worst of the fallout.
It didn't matter.
Alex pushed through the crowd, her eyes fixed on Mon-El with an intensity that made agents step aside. She stopped three feet from him, her jaw clenched so tight he could see the muscles straining.
"You were spying on my father."
Not a question. An accusation.
"I was investigating a security threat."
"You were spying on my family." Her voice rose. "At our dinner table. In my mother's house. You were gathering evidence to destroy everything—"
"To protect you." Mon-El kept his voice level. "Alex, I didn't want to be right. I wanted him to be the man you remembered. But he wasn't."
"You don't get to decide that!" Her control cracked. "You don't get to sit at our table, eat my mother's cooking, and then—"
She swung.
Mon-El saw it coming. Could have blocked it, dodged it, caught her wrist before the punch connected. Instead, he let it land.
Her fist connected with his jaw—not superhuman strength, but enough to snap his head sideways. Pain bloomed along his face. He tasted blood where his teeth had cut his lip.
She swung again.
This time he caught it—not to fight back, but because J'onn was moving forward and Kara was shouting and this couldn't be allowed to escalate further.
"I'm sorry," he said quietly, holding her fist. "I'm sorry it was me. But someone had to see. Someone had to act."
"Get off me." Alex wrenched her hand free. "Don't touch me. Don't—"
"Alex!" Kara stepped between them, her voice sharp. "He was right!"
"He went behind all our backs!" Alex rounded on her sister. "He suspected our father of treason and he didn't tell us. He gathered evidence like some kind of—"
"Like someone who's seen what happens when threats aren't taken seriously." Kara's voice cracked. "I'm angry too. I'm furious that our father is compromised. But Mon-El didn't do this to us. Cadmus did. They took him and they broke him and they sent him back as a weapon."
"And Mon-El exposed the weapon!"
"Would you rather he hadn't?" The question hung in the air. "Would you rather Dad had completed his mission? Delivered all that data to Cadmus without anyone stopping him?"
Alex's face crumpled. For a moment, she wasn't a DEO agent or a scientist or a warrior—she was a daughter watching her family shatter around her.
"I wanted him to be real," she whispered. "I wanted... just this once, I wanted something good to stay good."
Kara pulled her into an embrace. "I know. I know."
Mon-El stepped back, giving them space. His lip throbbed. His ribs ached. The weight of what he'd done—what he'd had to do—settled into his bones like cold water.
He'd been right. It didn't make him feel any better.
---
Winn found him in the observation corridor twenty minutes later.
"Hey." Winn approached carefully, like someone approaching a wounded animal. "You okay?"
"I've been better."
"Alex is..." He trailed off. "She's hurting. She'll come around."
"Maybe." Mon-El watched the activity below—agents coordinating the search, Kara and Alex huddled together, J'onn on the phone with government contacts. "Or maybe she'll hate me forever. I can live with that."
"Can you?"
The question was gentler than Mon-El expected. He turned to find Winn studying him with something like understanding.
"She's family," Winn said. "Not by blood, maybe, but family. And you just became the guy who told her the truth about her father. That's..." He struggled for words. "That's a hard position to be in."
"Someone had to do it."
"Yeah. But it didn't have to be you. J'onn could have handled this alone. You could have stayed out of it—let someone else gather the evidence, let someone else take the blame."
"Would you have?"
Winn was quiet for a moment. Then he stepped forward and hugged Mon-El—brief, awkward, but genuine.
"You did the right thing," he said. "Even if it doesn't feel like it right now."
Mon-El stood stiff for a moment, then returned the embrace. "Thanks."
"That's what friends are for." Winn stepped back, managed a weak smile. "Now come on. We've got work to do."
---
Kara found him in the training room two hours later.
He was just standing there, staring at the reinforced wall where he'd practiced so many times before. The punching bag hung untouched. The equipment sat idle.
"Your sister hates me," he said without turning around.
"She hates the situation." Kara moved to stand beside him. "You gave her someone to blame. Someone concrete, someone she can be angry at instead of the abstract horror of what Cadmus did."
"That's very understanding of you."
"I've had time to process." She took his hand. "And I know you. You didn't do this to hurt anyone. You did it because you saw a threat and you couldn't look away."
"I should have told you. Earlier. Given you time to—"
"To what? Warn Alex? Give Jeremiah a chance to cover his tracks?" She shook her head. "You made a call. The right call, as it turns out. I can't be angry at you for that."
"Alex can."
"Alex is angry at the universe. At Cadmus. At Dad. At herself, probably, for not seeing it." Kara squeezed his hand. "She'll work through it. Maybe not soon. Maybe not easily. But she will."
"And in the meantime?"
"In the meantime, we focus on the mission." Her voice hardened. "My father is out there, compromised, working for people who want to hurt us. I want him back. I want to save him, if that's possible. And I want to stop Cadmus from using whatever he stole."
"That's a lot of wants."
"I'm allowed to be greedy." A ghost of a smile crossed her face. "We'll get through this. Together."
Mon-El pulled her into his arms, felt her warmth against his battered body. The cut on his lip protested. His ribs complained. None of it mattered.
"Together," he agreed.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0