Cherreads

Chapter 456 -  How Could a God Ever Be Wrong?

Beyond the Heavenly Curtain—

People watching across the shinobi world stood frozen in place.

The surroundings fell into instant silence.

No one spoke.

No one moved.

It seemed as though no one even dared to breathe.

They had witnessed so much. They had watched the Heavenly Curtain reveal so many things, yet they had never considered the matter from this perspective.

Now that Indra's words had awakened them to it, enormous waves of shock and turmoil surged within their hearts.

"I..."

Someone muttered to himself in disbelief, his voice filled with confusion and uncertainty.

It was an elderly man. His face was deeply lined by the passage of time, while complex emotions churned within his clouded eyes.

"I saw those people being sacrificed in the Heavenly Curtain... Their screams. Their despair. Even now, I can't forget them."

"So when I heard that the Sage of Six Paths had defied the goddess and sealed away that terrifying being, I was genuinely happy. I thought that, at last, he had stood up for ordinary people like us..."

He paused, his voice trembling slightly.

"But now... hearing Indra put it this way... I... I find myself thinking that... every word he says makes sense..."

As soon as his words fell, a bitter, cold laugh came from beside him.

It belonged to a middle-aged man with a resolute face, though his eyes were filled with helplessness and clarity.

He shook his head. His voice was low, but every word was perfectly clear.

"What Indra says is the truth."

He raised his head and looked toward the lone figure in the Heavenly Curtain, standing without support yet with a gaze as bright as fire. His voice carried a complicated emotion that bordered on reverence.

"Life back then may have carried the risk of being sacrificed—but at least you could grow up in peace."

"At least you never had to worry about food or clothing."

"At least the world was peaceful, and you didn't have to fear waking up tomorrow to find your village reduced to ashes."

He turned to the silent crowd around him, and his voice suddenly rose.

"But what about now?"

"Now we don't have to worry about being sacrificed—but going hungry and without adequate clothing has become normal."

"We have to constantly watch out for bandits, for shinobi who possess power, and for those rulers sitting high above us."

"One wrong step, and someone might take your life. You might not even know how you died."

Word by word, he asked them:

"If it were you—which world would you choose to live in?"

No one answered.

Because everyone already knew the answer in their hearts.

Someone else let out a silent sigh filled with endless melancholy.

"Fate..."

A voice murmured softly, as light as a passing breeze.

"When have ordinary people at the bottom of society ever... possessed a will of our own? When have we ever truly controlled our own fate?"

"Hasn't our fate always... belonged to someone else?"

He looked up at Indra's cold face within the Heavenly Curtain. There was an indescribable longing in his voice—or perhaps the clarity that came only after despair.

"Forget a thousand years ago. Even in today's shinobi world... how many people can truly break free of their shackles and control their own lives?"

"How many people carry no chains?"

"If there were a world where I could simply live out my life like a dream... how wonderful would that be?"

The noisy crowd gradually fell silent.

Only soft sighs rose and fell from all around.

Indra's words were like an icy blade, cutting open the false facade of the world.

Those beautiful words—freedom, will, control over one's own destiny—had been stripped away layer by layer beneath his piercing questions, exposing the bloody reality underneath.

The people of the shinobi world found themselves plunged into an unprecedented moment of reflection.

They all understood—

Indra's methods might have been too extreme.

His cold gaze, his ruthless willingness to kill, and his complete rejection of every gentle illusion were enough to send a chill down anyone's spine.

And yet—

He had seen through the essence of it all.

He had seen through the rules by which the world operated.

He had seen through the seemingly insurmountable gulf between those in power and ordinary people.

That clarity weighed heavily on their hearts.

So heavily that it was hard to breathe.

And somewhere beyond everyone's sight—

Inside the Moon.

Within the sealing space.

Kaguya floated silently in the boundless darkness. Yet her pale eyes seemed to stare straight beyond the void, as though piercing through layer upon layer of seals, through a thousand years of time, to witness everything unfolding within the Heavenly Curtain.

She... was stunned.

More precisely, she had not experienced such emotional turbulence in a very, very long time—not since being sealed away.

She had never expected that—

Even after being sealed away and trapped in this lightless place for centuries—

People would still occasionally talk about her.

And... in this way, no less.

That child named Indra, Hagoromo's son, was actually speaking on her behalf.

He was actually using what she had done in the past to question that rebellious son of hers, Hagoromo.

He was even saying that the "god of the past" had brought peace and prosperity to the world, and that Hagoromo was "unworthy of being called a god"...

For the first time in a thousand years, the corners of Kaguya's lips curved ever so slightly.

This wasn't so bad.

She thought silently to herself. Deep within the consciousness that had remained cold for a millennium, there arose a faint... malicious delight.

At the very least—

That bastard Hagoromo was going to be cursed behind his back by plenty of people again.

The sealing space remained boundlessly dark and silent.

Yet within that darkness, a faint trace of amusement seemed to flash by and disappear.

Within the Heavenly Curtain!

"Have you finally run out of things to say?"

Indra looked at the Sage of Six Paths, who had remained silent for so long upon the raised platform. A pleased yet mocking smile slowly formed on his lips.

There was no warmth in that smile—only the cold satisfaction of finally having driven his opponent into a corner.

"Or are you... admitting it?"

Indra pressed forward step by step. Every word was like a poisoned needle, striking precisely at the being who had sat above others for a thousand years and had never been questioned so directly.

The Sage of Six Paths remained silent for a long time.

Finally, he slowly shook his head. His voice was low, but it carried a conviction so stubborn it bordered on obstinacy.

"No. I have never believed that what I did was wrong."

"I know."

Indra nodded lightly. There was no surprise on his face, only increasingly intense mockery.

"After all, you're a traitor."

He spoke casually, as though stating the simplest of facts.

"You betrayed the mother who gave birth to you and raised you, then took her place and became the new god."

"How could you possibly believe you were wrong?"

His voice suddenly rose, filled with biting ridicule.

"Gods are never wrong."

"When something is wrong, it's always someone else's fault."

"Isn't that right?"

Every word struck straight at the heart.

The Sage of Six Paths' expression changed dramatically.

One moment pale, the next livid, complex emotions churned within his Rinnegan—anger at being exposed, fury at being insulted, and something else... an awkwardness born of having the very core of his convictions laid bare, something even he could not put into words.

◇ BONUS & SUPPORT 

◇ 1 bonus chapter for every 10 reviews — drop a comment!

◇ 1 bonus chapter for every 100 Power Stones.

◇ Read 70+ chapters ahead on P@treon → patreon.com/Sagamaster789

More Chapters