[Klein Legal, Flatiron — November 29, 2012, 8:47 AM]
The refusal letter went at 8:47 AM, nineteen minutes after I arrived.
I had added one sentence to the draft from the night before: If Mr. Reyes's network produces future matters better suited to our practice scope, we remain available. Professional courtesy for the referring attorney. He had done nothing wrong.
The automatic read receipt confirmed delivery at 8:49.
I put the laptop aside and opened a new document.
The package required precision about two things: what to include and how to source it. What to include was straightforward — the specific discovery motion language that would put the Phase 2 biocompatibility study on the table. The study was not in the privilege log, which meant it had either been accidentally omitted or had never been listed as privileged because the document existed outside the normal document-retention workflow — meaning it existed, was known to exist by someone in the company, and had been kept out of the production in a way that was technically deniable. A targeted motion asking specifically for Phase 2 biocompatibility studies from the correct team and the correct timeframe would either produce the document or generate a motion-to-compel record that made the absence visible.
How to source it: the motion language had to look like it had come from competent opposing-counsel research rather than from an inside source. Plaintiffs' litigators were good, and the best of them had the pattern recognition to identify the specific gap themselves if someone put a sharp enough question in front of them. The tip had to read as a well-sourced question, not a document leak.
I wrote for ninety minutes. The Library helped with the motion precedents and the regulatory-affairs custodian structure — 1 LP for the precision. The final package was four paragraphs. It said, without saying: The study exists. Here is precisely how to ask for it.
I called Doyle at eleven.
He answered on the first ring. Not because he was expecting the call — because Mick Doyle answered on the first ring the way certain people do, as a form of professional reliability.
"I have a package," I said. "I need it routed to plaintiffs' counsel in a pharmaceutical class action. The source needs to be clean."
"Veridion."
"Yes."
A pause. Not long. He was running the calculation I had already run — the visibility of the move, the pattern it created against the backdrop of Klein Legal's refusal, the trace that would exist for someone looking for it.
"Someone careful will notice the timing," he said.
"I know."
"Klein Legal refuses the defense. Two days later, plaintiffs' counsel gets specific enough guidance to make a targeted discovery motion that goes exactly to the suppressed document." He was not accusing. He was itemizing. "Not proof. Pattern."
"I know."
"The pattern goes into your file. Whatever file exists."
"I know that too."
The pause was longer this time. In the background I could hear Doyle's environment — outdoor, midtown, the specific frequency of someone standing outside rather than in an office.
"All right," he said. "Give me the routing instructions."
I gave him the routing instructions. He wrote them down without asking me to repeat anything. He would use a legal news tipster service — a legitimate intermediary that plaintiffs' firms used to receive anonymous leads — with a second layer of misdirection through a paralegal contact at a mid-size plaintiff's firm in Chicago who received tips and passed them on with her own assessment. By the time the tip reached the actual Veridion plaintiffs' counsel, it would have traveled through three legitimate hands and would look like institutional pattern recognition rather than inside knowledge.
"Clean enough," Doyle said. "Risk is real but contained."
"Thank you."
"You already said that." He paused. "The Huntley thing."
"Yes."
"The Van Dyke investigation is moving. She has the financial wire." He said it flat, informational, neither connected to nor disconnected from the Veridion conversation. He was the kind of PI who kept two things in two compartments without trying to derive meaning from their adjacency.
"Thank you," I said again.
"Don't." He hung up.
I sat at my desk.
The coffee from this morning had gone cold again. I had a habit of that — making coffee and not drinking it when I had something else to focus on. The Breville machine behind me was the best piece of equipment in the office and I regularly treated it as a prop.
I opened the Veridion case folder on the laptop. All forty-two pages of it: the preliminary briefing, the Library analysis, the absorption notes, the deposition summaries, the four-paragraph package draft.
I selected all.
I deleted it.
The trash confirmation asked if I was sure.
I clicked yes.
Then I went into the Library's document cache and cleared the Veridion matter files. The Library confirmed: #veridion-files: cleared from active storage. 0 documents retained. Matter closed.
No copies. No record on my end. The only thing left was in Doyle's hands and the four paragraphs were already at the tipster service by now.
The desk had nothing on it.
I looked at the empty desk for a moment.
Klein Legal had just declined an engagement that would have anchored Q1 and Q2. The LP I had spent on the Veridion analysis — roughly 15 LP across case review, absorption, full strategy assessment, and routing work — had generated zero return. The library had burned those LP to tell me I could not take the case in good conscience, and then had burned a few more LP helping me route the information to the people who could use it, and the fee that would have covered two quarters of operating expenses was going to a firm that was willing to run the suppression play.
The desk was empty. The case was closed.
My phone showed a missed call at 11:47: Maren Vance. No message.
I looked at the missed call.
The fact of the call was its own communication: she had registered that something had gone wrong with the Veridion position. She was checking. She was not panicking — Maren Vance, from everything I had read of her, was not the kind of person who panicked over a single trade.
I picked up the scotch glass from the corner of the desk. It was empty. It was always empty — the ritual was the point.
I set it back down.
I had done the thing I was going to do. I had done it alone, without acknowledgment, and it had cost money I needed and LP I had purchased with personal savings, and somewhere in a Chicago paralegal's email inbox there was a four-paragraph document that would, within a business day or two, land on the desk of the attorney representing Carol Brant.
The Breville machine had a button that produced a genuinely excellent espresso in approximately forty-five seconds. Harold had made this argument in October 2011 and I had never once regretted giving him the equipment budget. I had never, in fourteen months of Klein Legal, made the espresso myself.
I got up, went to the Breville, and made the espresso myself.
It was excellent. It took forty-five seconds. Harold was right about most things.
I drank it at the window and then went back to work.
✦ ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ ✦
Read A LOT more chapters for free at unwrittenrealm.com
✦ ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ ✦
TL;DR — Patreon has the chapters ahead.
Silver / $6 / 15 or more chap ahead
Gold / $9 / 20 or more chap ahead
Platinum / $15 / 25 or more chap ahead, no weekly wait
That's it. patreon.com/fanficwriter1
If reviews aren't your thing, no pressure — they do help though.