Chapter 5: Controlled Stumble
[Quarry Camp — Late October 2010, Morning]
The idea arrived during second watch, somewhere between two and four a.m., when the quarry sat black and still and the only sounds were crickets and the occasional groan drifting from the distant tree line.
I was too good.
Three days at camp. One supply run, flawless. Every suggestion I'd made about routes and timing had been correct. I'd avoided a threat I couldn't have known about, redirected the group without breaking stride, and returned with a haul that made the previous attempts look like amateur hour.
Shane was watching. Andrea was thinking. Dale was patient, but even patience had a shelf life.
If I kept performing at this level — effortless, accurate, never wrong — the questions would stop being casual. How'd you know that route? What made you go around back? Why are you always in the right place? Sooner or later, the questions would become suspicions, and suspicions in a survival camp were one step from exile.
I needed to make a mistake. A small one. Controlled. Enough to sand the edges off my competence and make me look human.
It was a terrible idea. I knew it was a terrible idea even as I committed to it.
---
[Atlanta, Commercial District — Midday]
The run team this time was smaller — me, T-Dog, Andrea, and Morales. Shane stayed behind, which suited me. Fewer trained eyes meant more room to maneuver.
I picked a route that was mostly clear and led the group toward a strip of shops two miles east of the ValueMart. The danger sense hummed at a low frequency the whole time — background radiation, the ambient unease of being in a dead city — but nothing sharp. Nothing urgent.
The building I chose was a two-story commercial space. Ground floor retail, upper floor offices. Intact windows, closed doors, no visible movement.
The cold whispered through me as we approached the back entrance. Mild. The equivalent of a raised eyebrow, not a scream. Something in there, but not much. One walker, maybe two. Manageable.
I ignored it.
"Looks clear," I said, and pushed the door open.
The retail floor was dim, lit by daylight filtering through dirty windows. Shelving units lined the walls — hardware supplies, cleaning products, a few racks of work clothes. T-Dog and Morales moved left, checking corners. Andrea stayed near the entrance with her pistol drawn.
I drifted toward the stockroom at the back. The cold pulsed once, steady, patient.
The door was ajar. I reached for the handle.
Commit to the bit. One walker. You can handle one walker. Let it stumble out, look surprised, let someone else put it down. You're a pizza guy who got lucky, not a soldier.
I pulled the door open.
The walker came out faster than expected.
It had been pressed against the door — leaning on it, maybe, drawn by the sound of our entry — and when the barrier disappeared, it spilled forward with arms outstretched and a moan that ripped through the store's silence like a gunshot.
Not toward me. Toward Andrea.
She was fifteen feet to my left, turning at the sound, and the walker was already between us, lurching toward the living thing closest to its trajectory. Andrea's pistol came up but the angle was wrong — the walker was too close, and she backpedaled into a shelving unit that caught her between the shoulder blades and stopped her cold.
Her scream was short and sharp and real.
T-Dog materialized from the left aisle. The crowbar swung in a flat arc and connected with the walker's temple. Bone caved. The thing dropped like a marionette with cut strings, twitching once on the linoleum, then still.
Andrea stood with her back against the shelves, pistol still raised, aimed at something already dead. Her breath came in ragged bursts. A line of dark fluid had splashed across her forearm — walker blood, not hers, but she stared at it like it was acid.
Morales checked the stockroom. "Clear. Just the one."
T-Dog pulled the crowbar free with a wet sound. "Everybody good?"
"Good," I said. My voice came out flat. Professional. As if my insides weren't twisting into a configuration that had nothing to do with danger sense and everything to do with the fact that Andrea had almost died because I'd played a game.
She could have been bitten. Fifteen feet. Three seconds. If T-Dog had been two steps further away, if the crowbar had caught on a shelf, if her foot had caught on a floor mat—
Three seconds and a civil rights attorney who survived a zombie apocalypse to find purpose and fight and eventually die in a place called Woodbury would have bled out on a hardware store floor because I wanted to look incompetent.
---
[Andrea]
The shaking started in her hands and worked outward.
Andrea held her pistol at her side and watched T-Dog drag the walker's body behind the counter, out of sight, and the tremor moved from her fingers into her wrists, her forearms, her shoulders. The adrenaline dump was massive and disorienting — like stepping off a cliff and finding ground six inches below, the relief almost worse than the fall.
She'd been close to walkers before. The camp had its scares. But this one had been right there, close enough that she could catalogue its features — a man, middle-aged, wearing a polo shirt with a name tag still pinned to the chest: DOUG. Doug from the hardware store, who'd probably clocked in one morning and never clocked out.
Glenn stood near the stockroom door. He hadn't moved to help. That registered somewhere behind the adrenaline, in the part of her brain that filed inconsistencies for later examination. He'd opened the door. The walker came out. And Glenn had stood there, not frozen exactly, but delayed. Like a person watching something they expected to happen.
She couldn't prove that. She wasn't sure she believed it. But the thought lodged itself and wouldn't shake loose.
He approached now, wordless, and held out a handful of blister packs — ibuprofen, the good kind, 400mg — that he'd found on a shelf somewhere. A peace offering, or an apology, or just a kid who'd grabbed useful things because that's what he did.
Andrea took them. Their fingers didn't touch.
She said nothing. There was nothing to say that wouldn't sound paranoid or ungrateful or both, and Andrea had spent enough years in courtrooms to know that silence was sometimes the sharpest tool in the box.
---
[Glenn — Quarry Camp, Evening]
The ride back was quiet in a way that pressed against the inside of the vehicle like rising water.
I sat in the back and stared at my hands and made a decision that settled into my bones with the permanence of a tattoo.
Never again.
Not once. Not under any circumstances. I would not dull myself to fit someone else's expectations of what a pizza delivery kid should be capable of. People died when I second-guessed the instinct. Andrea's scream would live inside my enhanced memory in perfect fidelity — every frequency, every decibel — for the rest of however long this life lasted, and that was the cost of my little experiment in mediocrity.
The truth was simpler than I'd made it. Be competent. Be careful. When people asked how I knew things, lie well. I got lucky. I delivered to that neighborhood. I had a feeling. A consistent set of small deflections was always more believable than a single spectacular failure.
Suspicion I could manage. A body on my conscience I could not.
---
First watch fell to me that night, and I didn't argue. The quarry spread below the ridge like a wound in the earth, its water catching the last copper light before the sun dropped behind the western hills. Beautiful and useless — you couldn't drink it, couldn't fish in it, couldn't do anything with it except stare and pretend the world was still worth looking at.
My back pressed against a pine trunk, rifle across my knees — Shane's concession, a .22 he didn't trust me enough to give ammo for. The gesture was the point. Responsibility without capability. A test wrapped in a chore.
I thought about Maggie.
Not the Maggie I'd watched on a screen — Lauren Cohan's performance, the camera angles, the scripted dialogue. The real one. The one living on a farm somewhere north of here, feeding horses, arguing with her father about whether the world would go back to normal, not yet knowing that a pizza delivery kid from Atlanta would change the shape of her life.
Patience. The farm came after Rick. Rick came in four days. Four days of supply runs and campfire meals and Shane's sideways glances, and then the radio would crackle and a man in a sheriff's hat would crawl out of a tank, and everything would start moving in the direction I needed it to move.
Footsteps in the gravel behind me. Andrea, heading toward her tent, paused at the edge of the firelight. Her silhouette was rigid, arms folded, chin down. Processing. Deciding what she'd seen and what it meant.
She opened her mouth, closed it. Walked on.
I tracked her until her tent flap zipped shut, then turned back to the quarry.
Tomorrow. Another run. This time, no games.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0