Chapter 14 : The Stuttering Professor
Defence Against the Dark Arts Classroom — September 5, 1991, 2:00 PM
The garlic hit Matt three steps inside the door.
It was overwhelming — not the pleasant aroma of a kitchen, but the aggressive, saturating stink of something used as a weapon against the air itself. Cloves hung from the ceiling. Braids of bulbs festooned the walls. The combined effect was less protection against vampires and more chemical warfare against anyone with a functioning nose.
Matt's eyes watered. Behind him, Terry Boot gagged.
"Blimey," Terry whispered. "Is this a classroom or a greenhouse?"
"I think it's supposed to be defensive," Matt muttered, sliding into a desk near the middle of the room. Not too close to the front. Not far enough back to seem disengaged. Inconspicuous. Watchable.
Professor Quirinus Quirrell stood behind the teacher's desk, hands folded, turban a vivid purple against the garlic-yellowed walls. He was thin — gaunt, almost — with the fidgeting posture of someone who expected to be startled by his own shadow. When the class settled, he cleared his throat with a sound like crumpling parchment.
"W-welcome to D-Defence Against the Dark Arts. I am P-Professor Quirrell." The stutter was pronounced, catching on consonants and swallowing whole syllables. "This year, we will c-cover basic defensive theory, c-common dark creatures, and p-protective charms."
Matt activated Creature Sense.
The skill had become second nature over four years of daily use — a background hum, like peripheral vision but for magical signatures. In the classroom, it registered thirty-two humans (students and teacher), one rat in someone's pocket (mundane), and various ambient magical traces from the castle's architecture.
And then there was Quirrell.
The professor registered as human. But over the human signature, layered like oil on water, something else. Cold. Parasitic. A dark magical presence that existed in the same space as Quirrell's body without being part of it. The system couldn't classify it — Creature Sense was designed for magical creatures, not possessions, not fragments of dark wizards grafted onto living hosts.
[ANOMALOUS MAGICAL SIGNATURE DETECTED. HOST: HUMAN. OVERLAY: UNKNOWN. CLASSIFICATION: UNABLE TO RESOLVE. DARK MAGIC INDICATORS: EXTREME.]
Matt's hand tightened on his quill. The notification confirmed what he already knew, but confirmation and meta-knowledge were different animals. One was theory. The other made the hair on his arms stand up.
Voldemort. Right there. Twenty feet away. Wearing a man like a suit.
Quirrell launched into a lecture on defensive stances. It was terrible — poorly structured, frequently interrupted by his own stammer, delivered with the nervous energy of someone who desperately wanted to be anywhere else. The textbook material was sound, but the presentation stripped it of all utility. Students' attention drifted within ten minutes.
Matt didn't drift. He watched.
Quirrell's left hand touched the turban four times in twenty minutes — quick, unconscious movements, like checking that something was still in place. His stutter vanished for three seconds during a passage about the Shield Charm, his voice going smooth and confident before the mask snapped back. When a student dropped a textbook, Quirrell flinched — but his eyes went hard before they went frightened, and the recovery took a fraction too long.
Two people in that body. One is performing. The other is watching.
The class dragged. Matt took notes — real notes, detailed and accurate, because Defence would be critical in the years ahead regardless of who was teaching it. He also took mental notes, a separate ledger: turban, stutter pattern, hand movements, garlic placement — positioned to mask another smell? Decay? Dark magic has a scent.
When the hour ended, Matt packed slowly. Quirrell's gaze swept the departing students — professional, dismissive, the assessment of someone who didn't care about eleven-year-olds except as camouflage.
Their eyes met for a fraction of a second. Quirrell's stutter was in his voice but not in his gaze. Those eyes were steady, calculating, and far older than the man wearing them.
Matt looked away first. Deliberately. Nothing to see here. Just another first-year leaving class.
In the corridor, his shoulders were tight. The back of his neck prickled — the same instinct that had made him walk faster past certain streets in his old life, the animal brain recognising a predator before the conscious mind caught up.
Whisper was waiting at the first landing. She'd tracked him through the castle — she always did, these days — and her fur was puffed, tail low, ears flat. Through the bond, her assessment was clear and sharp: wrong-dangerous-stay away.
"I know," Matt murmured, scratching behind her crooked ear. "I know."
---
Great Hall — 6:30 PM
The Gryffindor table was half a hall away, but Matt had learned to time his meals so the groups overlapped. He sat at the Ravenclaw end nearest the lions, close enough for shouted conversation during the noise of dinner.
Harry was picking at shepherd's pie when Matt caught his eye and crossed the gap.
"How was Defence?" Matt asked, sitting across from him.
Harry rubbed his forehead — an unconscious gesture, fingers tracing the line of his scar. "Fine. Weird. Quirrell's a bit —" He searched for the word.
"Nervous?"
"Yeah. But also — my scar hurt. During class. Just a bit. Like a headache, but only here." Harry tapped the lightning bolt. "Probably nothing."
Matt's stomach dropped. He kept his face neutral — the same clinical mask he'd worn in surgery when an animal's vitals went wrong and panic would kill them faster than the wound.
"Does it happen often?"
"First time." Harry shrugged. "Maybe it's the garlic. Giving everyone headaches."
Ron, seated beside Harry, pointed his fork in agreement. "My head's killing me too. That classroom should be classified as a biohazard."
Matt forced a smile. The shepherd's pie on his plate had gone cold. His appetite had left with Quirrell's eyes.
The scar reacts to Voldemort. It hurt near Quirrell. Confirmation on top of confirmation. The thing on the back of his head is real, it's active, and it's three corridors from Harry's dormitory every single day.
"Probably the garlic," Matt agreed. "If it keeps happening, though, tell me. My family had some old remedies for magical headaches."
Harry nodded, already distracted by Ron's analysis of the day's flying lesson disaster — Neville had fallen off his broom, been caught by Harry in a spectacular dive, and somehow lost his Remembrall to Draco Malfoy, who'd thrown it and watched Harry catch it midair. McGonagall had seen the whole thing.
"She looked furious," Harry said. "Pulled me out of class. I thought I was expelled."
"And?"
Harry's grin was incandescent. "I'm on the Quidditch team. Youngest Seeker in a century."
Ron punched the air. "TOLD you! Natural talent!"
Matt congratulated him. Meant it. Filed the information — Harry on the Quidditch team meant more exposure, more time on the grounds, more opportunities for Matt to track him. Also more danger, because Harry Potter attracted chaos the way certain flowers attracted bees: inevitably, persistently, and with stinging consequences.
He walked back to the Ravenclaw table. Terry had saved him a seat and a bread roll, which Matt ate in three bites because his body was eleven and his metabolism was relentless.
That night, in the dormitory, Matt lay in bed and stared at the canopy. Terry's breathing was slow and steady. Anthony muttered in his sleep — something about Transfiguration grades. Michael Corner was a silent lump.
Whisper lay against his side, amber eyes open in the dark.
Voldemort is in the castle. Attached to a teacher. Metres from Harry every week. And I have to pretend everything is normal because if I move too early, I change the timeline, and if I change the timeline, I lose the only advantage I have.
He closed his eyes. Mapped the corridors in his mind. Counted the days.
Forty-six until Halloween.
Want more? The story continues on Patreon!
If you can't wait for the weekly release, you can grab +10, +15, or +20 chapters ahead of time on my Patreon page. Your support helps me keep this System running!
Read ahead here: [ patreon.com/system_enjoyer ]