The fire in the Gryffindor common room crackled brightly, painting the circular chamber in deep shades of red and gold.
The air was thick with the scent of roasted sausages and butterbeer—sweet enough to make one dizzy.
It was a celebration.
"When the club swung down, it was this close to Harry's head!"
Ron's voice rang out loudly, pitched high enough to carry across the entire room.
He stood in the middle of a group of younger students, waving a half-eaten pumpkin pasty like a trophy. His cheeks were flushed from excitement and heat.
"But I didn't hesitate! I charged right in! Didn't even think about it! Even without my wand, I knew I couldn't leave my friend behind!"
Applause erupted.
Seamus let out an enthusiastic whistle.
Harry sat nearby, embarrassed but smiling.
The warmth of the room wrapped around him—the warmth of belonging. It was something he had never known at the Dursleys'.
Only Hermione sat apart.
She was curled tightly into a high-backed armchair in the corner, knees tucked in. A thick copy of Standard Book of Spells, Grade 1 rested open on her lap.
Her eyes were fixed on the words Wingardium Leviosa, but her fingers kept picking at the spine of the book.
Something was wrong.
The moment she stepped into the common room, a strange sensation had begun creeping into her thoughts—like sticky, cheap honey poured straight into her mind along with the cheers and laughter.
It felt as if two voices were fighting inside her head.
One voice insisted: Don't be silly, Hermione! Look at them. Look how happy everyone is. They came to save you.
You should thank them. If you stand up now, everything will be fine. You'll finally belong.
That voice was warm and syrupy, urging her to stop thinking. To soften. To let herself be carried by the celebration.
But the other voice screamed: He's lying! They didn't defeat the troll! Ron was shaking so badly he held his wand backwards! And it wasn't them who saved you!
"But... everyone believes it," Hermione thought hazily.
Her eyelids felt heavy. The horror of the bathroom scene was beginning to blur at the edges.
Go. Make peace. Don't be strange.
She almost stood.
Almost.
Then something snapped cold and sharp inside her mind.
This makes no sense.
It was like someone had shoved a fistful of snow down the back of her collar. Hermione jerked upright, shaking her head.
The honeyed haze wavered.
She reached into her robe pocket for something—anything—to steady herself.
Her fingers brushed against fabric.
Cool.
Lucian's handkerchief.
And inside it, the shattered pocket watch.
A thin thread of gray magic pulsed faintly from it, cool and sharp, nothing like the warm atmosphere downstairs.
Suddenly she was back in the bathroom.
Ron screaming.
Ron's legs trembling.
Ron gripping his wand the wrong way around.
Harry nearly tripping.
And the black-haired boy stepping forward, tapping once.
Crack.
The sound of bone shattering rang vividly in her ears.
The sugary haze fractured.
Reality flooded back in.
"I just gave my wand a swing like this—and boom! Troll down!" Ron was still talking.
Hermione looked at him carefully.
Her mind, trained to memorize footnotes and notice the smallest inconsistencies, saw what others missed.
Ron was laughing too hard.
Too loudly.
His cheeks were red, yes—but his eyes were pale and chaotic. The hand holding the pumpkin pasty trembled violently.
Not excitement.
Aftershock.
He wasn't lying. He was broken.
The terrified, shaking Ron from the bathroom was being overwritten by something larger—something that demanded heroism and narrative symmetry.
He was clinging to this story to escape the memory of almost dying.
And Harry…
Harry sat deeper in the shadows.
When Ron declared, "We faced it together," Hermione saw Harry flinch.
He remembered.
She was certain he remembered the sound of the knee joint snapping.
For a moment, Harry's lips moved, as if he might correct the story. Then Gryffindor students swarmed him.
Warm hands clapped his back.
"Well done, Harry!"
"You're brilliant!"
The warmth drowned him.
Hermione watched as resistance flickered in his green eyes—then dimmed. It was replaced by something softer. Almost blissful.
He had been alone his whole life.
To a boy who had lived in a cupboard, belonging was the most addictive poison imaginable.
Forget the Ravenclaw boy. Forget the horror. Here, you are loved. Here, you are safe. Just nod. Just accept it.
Harry lowered his head. And allowed himself to be reshaped.
Hermione felt her throat tighten.
They were celebrating. Celebrating what? Recklessness? Luck?
It was false.
All of it.
The one who had saved her had not even waited for thanks.
"Hermione!" Ron waved at her. "Come on! You're part of it too! If you hadn't been trapped, we wouldn't have had the chance to smash that thing!"
His tone was familiar, casual—like his earlier insult had never happened.
Go. Be friends.
For a moment, she nearly did. But the cold weight in her pocket reminded her otherwise.
She opened her mouth, intending to ask, "Did you see the troll's knee?"
Then she looked around at the flushed faces, the eager smiles.
Logic had no place here.
"I... I don't feel well," she said stiffly.
She forced a tight smile, closed her book, and hurried up the spiral staircase to the girls' dormitory.
Escape was the only rational choice left.
...
In her dormitory bed, Hermione pulled the curtains closed and wrapped herself tightly in blankets.
The laughter downstairs echoed faintly through stone.
After several minutes, she pushed her head out and lit her wand.
°Lumos°
Soft light filled the small space.
She wiped her eyes and opened her diary. On the pillow beside her lay the handkerchief and the shattered watch.
She picked up the watch.
It had stopped that afternoon.
Hermione believed in logic. She believed in rules. Tonight defied both.
[Problem: Troll attack.
Primary actor: Ashford.
Supporting actors: Harry and Ron.
Outcome: Harry and Ron celebrated as heroes.]
"This doesn't follow," she whispered fiercely.
Worse still—she had nearly believed it. The thought made her feel sick.
She remembered Lucian's eyes.
Cold. Detached. Not kind.
Yet undeniably real.
"Couldn't he at least have said 'Run'?" she muttered stubbornly, half offended, half frustrated.
Then a new thought surfaced.
Maybe this isn't about kindness. Maybe it's about strength.
Not domination. Not cruelty.
But the kind of strength that doesn't need applause. That doesn't need to lie. That doesn't need a crowd to confirm it.
He broke the troll's knee and walked away... And she had almost swallowed a false narrative just to belong.
Her teeth pressed into her lip until she tasted iron.
She refused to be a stray begging for scraps of friendship. Hermione Granger did not surrender—to exams or to reality itself.
She carefully folded the handkerchief and watch into her diary. Then she opened Magical Theory.
If the spells she knew were insufficient, she would learn harder ones.
One day, she would understand this distortion.
"I'll solve it," she whispered fiercely. "And when I do, I'll shove the correct answer in your faces."
She buried her hurt and fear deep inside.
Tomorrow, she would face their smiles again... But she would not forget.
...
From the Ravenclaw Tower, Lucian withdrew his gaze.
The light representing Hermione had flickered violently. Instead of extinguishing, it had condensed.
Sharper.
Denser.
"Pride and obsession," he murmured, "are stronger than gratitude."
The handkerchief had never been about rescue.
It was a variable test.
In a world where most drifted like wood along a river, he needed a stone—something that might resist the current.
If it shattered, it was useless.
If it lodged firmly against the flow—
"Do not disappoint me, Miss Granger."
He studied several thin gray threads coiled in his palm—remnants from the broken world he had visited.
In his experiments, these threads could sever—or even replace—the golden strands of fate.
For now, they were faint.
But not insignificant.
Lucian lifted his gaze toward the night sky. "Let all things stand ready, unbound."
The game was no longer simple interference.
It was refinement.
And the cracks were beginning to show.
__________
Upto 20 chapters ahead on patreon :-
patreon.com/ShadySmuggler