Chapter 38: The Great Game — Part 2 (The Execution)
[Moriarty's Flat, Southwark — November 2, 2010, 6:00 AM]
The first pip went out at six in the morning. A phone call to a number Sherlock Holmes would recognise, because James had ensured it was the only number associated with every case: the number of the pink phone. A phone from a dead woman's luggage—Jennifer Wilson, the cabbie's first victim. A callback to the beginning.
Five pips. Greenwich time signal. Then silence.
Twelve hours later, the first hostage appeared on camera: a middle-aged man, trembling, reading words from an earpiece that James controlled from the Southwark flat. The explosive vest was visible beneath an unzipped jacket. The man's voice cracked on every third word.
"This is a message for Sherlock Holmes. Solve the puzzle. Or I die."
James monitored through Priya's surveillance network—not directly, never directly, but through the digital infrastructure that turned London into a transparent city for anyone with the right access. Police radio channels. CCTV feeds. Social media. The Met's internal communication system, accessible through Cooper's network.
Sherlock received the phone. Sherlock examined the evidence. Sherlock began to work.
---
The first three cases fell like dominoes.
Case One—the dead man's shoes—took Sherlock seven hours. The detective traced the trainers through manufacturing records, identified the victim from a missing persons database, and connected the body to a twenty-one-year-old murder case in Cornwall. The hostage was released. James noted the methodology: systematic, accelerating as pattern recognition engaged, with a characteristic burst of speed in the final hour as disparate threads converged.
Case Two—the missing businessman—took five hours. Sherlock dismissed the obvious conclusion within thirty minutes, identified the insurance fraud within two hours, and located the businessman within five. The hostage was released. James noted the adaptation: having been tested on basic observation, Sherlock shifted to counter-intuitive analysis, anticipating that the puzzle-maker would subvert expectations.
He's learning my design language. Already.
Case Three—the television presenter—took nine hours. Closer to the wire. The forensic detail was dense, the handwriting analysis required expertise that Sherlock had to acquire mid-case from a specialist contact. The hostage's fear was audible through the surveillance feeds—real terror, the kind that compressed time and made every hour feel like a sentence. Sherlock solved it with three hours remaining. The hostage was released.
Three cases. Three solutions. Three data points confirming what James had suspected since Baker Street: Sherlock Holmes was extraordinary. Not just talented—extraordinary in the specific, irreducible sense of a mind that operated at a frequency most people couldn't hear.
---
[Moriarty's Flat, Southwark — November 5, 2010, 10:00 PM]
Case Four broke the pattern.
The old woman was sixty-eight. A librarian from Kilburn. She'd been collected by one of Moran's assets from her flat—no violence, no struggle, just a man in a uniform saying there'd been a gas leak and would she please come with him. She'd gone willingly. Trusting. The bomb vest had been fitted while she was sedated.
She appeared on camera at ten PM. Reading from the earpiece. Her voice was steady—steadier than the previous hostages, the particular composure of someone who'd lived long enough to understand that panic served no purpose.
She relayed the puzzle. Sherlock worked. The hours passed.
And then she said something that wasn't in the script.
"He sounded so... ordinary." Her voice, through the earpiece, through the surveillance, through the digital chain that connected her to the flat where James sat. "Irish. Soft. Like a schoolteacher. You'd never think—"
James's hand moved to the phone. The detonator phone. Separate from every other device, purchased for this purpose alone, its single function a testament to the precision of his operational architecture.
She was describing his voice. The earpiece had captured his words during the briefing—a technical failure, a gap in the protocol that separated his voice from the hostage's awareness. She knew what he sounded like. She was telling Sherlock.
The rules exist for a reason.
He pressed the button.
The explosion was a notification on a police radio channel. A timestamp on a news alert. A number—one—added to a count that had been zero .
An innocent woman. A librarian from Kilburn who'd gone willingly with a man in a uniform because she trusted uniforms. Dead because a protocol had failed and the rules of the game demanded consequences for protocol failures.
James set down the detonator phone. His hands were steady. His breathing was normal. Inside, something shifted—a tectonic movement in the geography of his self-understanding, subtle enough to be ignored, significant enough to be permanent.
He picked up the Jim phone. One missed call from Molly. A voicemail.
He played it. Her voice, warm and tired and ordinary: "Just wanted to hear your voice. Love you. Call me when you can."
He listened to it three times. Then he put the phone down and returned to the monitors.
---
Case Five—the Vermeer—went out the following morning. The final test. The most complex puzzle, requiring Sherlock to connect art forgery with astronomical observation, seventeenth-century painting technique with nineteenth-century celestial events.
Sherlock solved it in six hours. Before lunch. The speed was contemptuous—not of the puzzle, but of the idea that he could be outpaced by anything short of an opponent operating at his own level.
James watched the solution unfold through surveillance feeds and police channels. The false painting identified. The forger traced. The mechanism explained with the precise, devastating clarity that was Sherlock's signature—the deductive equivalent of a scalpel, removing ignorance in clean, bloodless strokes.
Five cases. Four hostages released. One dead.
Evaluation complete.
Sherlock Holmes was everything James had hoped. Everything the fragmentary canon memories had promised. Everything the two years of preparation had been designed to meet.
Worthy.
The word felt inadequate. Like describing the ocean as damp. But it was the right word—the word that mattered, the word that justified the architecture and the game and the name and the dead woman from Kilburn whose trust in uniforms had been her last mistake.
James opened the encrypted file. Typed the final message—the one that would bring Sherlock Holmes to the place where they'd meet, where the name would become a face and the game would become real.
Come and play. Midnight. The pool. Bring the memory stick.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.