Chapter 7 : The Wish
Paddy's Pub, South Philadelphia — October, 2005
The whiskey is the color of something that used to be better than it is now, and Griffin drinks it the way you take medicine — fast, grimacing, functional.
The bar is empty. Has been for two hours. The Gang left around eight — Dennis to "attend to his evening commitments," which means either a woman or a mirror, Mac trailing behind like a remora with biceps. Dee went home after three vodka sodas and a rant about a casting director who told her she had "an interesting quality" that was "almost but not quite right for anything." Charlie is somewhere in the basement doing something with Gerald that Griffin has stopped asking about because the answers never improve his quality of life.
October in Philadelphia. The heat broke three weeks ago and the city traded humidity for a flat gray chill that sits on everything. The bar smells the same as always — stale beer, old wood, the chemical undertone Griffin has identified as the combined output of Charlie's cleaning supplies, which are not cleaning supplies in any recognized sense. The jukebox is off. The TV above the bar plays a Phillies postgame to nobody.
Griffin pours another finger of the house whiskey. The house whiskey costs eleven dollars a bottle and tastes like someone described bourbon to a chemist who'd never had it. He drinks.
Two months.
Two months since he woke up on a mattress that smelled like someone else's life. Two months of pouring drinks and memorizing exit routes and watching five people who will never change prove it over and over with the enthusiasm of performers who don't know they're in a loop. Two months of knowing what comes next — every scheme, every victim, every escalation — and doing nothing about it because doing nothing is the job and the job is all he has.
The flip phone sits on the bar. Mike texted again last week: "yo griffin u ghosting me lol." Griffin typed "been crazy busy" and hit send and put the phone down and didn't think about it for four days. He still doesn't know who Mike is. Hasn't investigated. Investigating means engaging with the life of a man who died or disappeared or whatever happened to the original Griffin Finch, and engaging means this is permanent, and permanent means—
He pours another drink.
It's permanent. You know it's permanent. You've known since the first morning when the ceiling was wrong and your hands were wrong and the cereal tasted like dust and you ate it anyway because eating meant alive and alive meant real.
The Phillies lose. Griffin doesn't care about the Phillies. He cared about the Reds, once, in a life that's getting harder to hold onto. The specifics blur — his apartment in Columbus, the layout of the office, Dave's face, his mother's phone number. The show knowledge stays razor-sharp. Every episode, every scheme, every character beat. The things that matter in this world are preserved. The things that mattered in the old one are dissolving.
He finishes the glass. Washes it. His hands know the routine — water, soap, rinse, dry, shelf. He's washed more glasses in two months than he did in three years of bartending in the old life. Back in Columbus, the sports bar had a dishwasher. Paddy's has Griffin.
Charlie's abortion scheme. The cancer scam. Gun Fever. The dead man nobody cared about. Uncle Jack and his small hands and the word "resilient."
The list lives in his chest. Not his head — he filed the episodes there, clean and organized, cross-referenced by season and scheme rating. The list in his chest is different. It's the faces. Terrell leaving with that handshake. The Waitress behind the counter with her jaw tight. The dead man in the booth that nobody identified. Charlie laughing too loud while his uncle drank whiskey four seats away.
Griffin leans on the bar. The wood is smooth under his forearms — smoother than when he started, because he's the first person to maintain this surface in years, which is exactly the kind of accomplishment that makes a man feel both useful and pathetic.
And it gets worse. That's the thing nobody warned you about, because nobody warned you about any of this, because there's nobody to warn you.
Season 2 brings Frank Reynolds. Frank brings money, guns, connections to people who use the word "business" the way other people use the word "weather" — casually, constantly, as cover for whatever's actually happening. Frank's arrival upgrades every scheme from neighborhood embarrassment to potential felony. The D-tier disasters become B-tier. The B-tier becomes A.
And after Frank: Cricket. The priest who walks into a bar and walks out missing pieces of himself, a little more each time, until there's nothing left to take and the taking continues anyway. Griffin knows Cricket's entire arc. Teeth. Dignity. Shelter. Faith. Gone, in that order, with the methodical cruelty of a universe that writes comedy for an audience and doesn't check whether the extras survive the punchline.
He pours again. Fourth glass. The bottle is getting lighter and his judgment is getting softer and the bar is empty and the jukebox is off and the only sound is the TV and his breathing and the faint hum of the light fixture above the bar that has been dying slowly since before he arrived.
I can see all of it coming. Every single car wreck, lined up on the highway, and I'm standing on the overpass with binoculars and no phone to call 911.
The thought catches. Turns. Becomes a sound.
"I just..." Griffin says to the empty bar. His voice is hoarse from three hours of silence and four glasses of bad whiskey. "I wish I could see this trainwreck coming. All of it. Before it happens. So I could at least—"
He doesn't finish. The sentence trails into the stale air and the Phillies postgame and the permanent smell of beer ground into wood by decades of people who came here to feel less alone and left feeling exactly the same.
It's not a prayer. Griffin Finch — the new one, the transmigrated one, the one who died on a highway in Ohio and woke up in South Philadelphia — does not pray. It's not a dramatic declaration. There's no thunder, no light, no cinematic moment where the universe acknowledges the request with appropriate gravitas.
It's a complaint. Tired and drunk and aimed at nothing. The kind of thing a man says when he's been standing behind the same bar for two months watching people hurt each other and he's run out of ways to process it quietly.
The bar doesn't answer. The TV plays a commercial for a car dealership in Northeast Philly. The light hums.
Griffin finishes his drink. Washes the glass — water, soap, rinse, dry, shelf. Wipes down the bar. Puts the whiskey bottle back on the shelf, three fingers lighter than when the night started. Checks the register. Checks the lock on the back door. Checks the front door.
The dead bolt sticks. Lift, shove, turn. He's been doing this for two months and the door hasn't gotten easier and he's stopped expecting it to.
Outside, October. The streetlights are the same amber circles on the same cracked sidewalks. A man walks a dog on the opposite side of 8th Street. A SEPTA bus rounds the corner on Snyder with its lights blazing against the dark. Griffin zips his jacket — a denim thing he bought at a thrift store on Passyunk because the gray henley from his first day wasn't going to survive a Philadelphia fall.
The walk home takes seven minutes. He's timed it. The route is burned into muscle memory now — left on 8th, right on Mifflin, up the stairs, lift-shove-turn the apartment door. Same water stain on the wall. Same mattress. Same view of nothing from a window he keeps meaning to curtain properly and never does.
He drops the keys on the milk crate. Kicks off his shoes. Lies down without changing clothes because four glasses of whiskey and two months of accumulated something have made the gap between "standing" and "horizontal" feel like the most important transition of his day.
The ceiling stares back. Different from the first morning — he's stopped counting the water stains and started recognizing them, the way you recognize the features of a face you didn't choose but have to live with.
Sleep comes the way it always does in this body — slowly, reluctantly, like his brain knows something his body doesn't and is trying to stall.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!