Chapter 19 : The Priest
St. Ignatius Church, South Philadelphia — March, 2006
Griffin is not a churchgoing man, in this life or the last, but the coffee shop is closed for a burst pipe and the walk needs to go somewhere, so it goes past St. Ignatius on Tasker Street where the Sunday service has just let out and the parishioners are filtering onto the sidewalk in their good coats.
He's passing on the opposite side of the street when the CPS does something new.
The HUD activates — not the usual scheme-rating pulse, not the Complicity tick, but a different mode. A slow, scanning flicker at the edges of his vision, like a camera adjusting focus. It locks onto a figure on the church steps — a man in black, young, clean-shaven, shaking hands with an elderly woman who's gripping his arm with the specific intensity of someone who considers her priest a personal lifeline.
Griffin stops walking.
The man is in his late twenties. Dark hair, neatly combed. White collar against black shirt. A face that's whole — symmetrical, clean-skinned, every feature where it should be. He smiles at the woman and the smile reaches his eyes and stays there, which is remarkable because in Griffin's experience smiles in South Philly are either performative (Dennis), defensive (Dee), or chemical (Charlie).
[DAMAGE PROFILE: MATTHEW "RICKETY CRICKET" MARA. CUMULATIVE DAMAGE POTENTIAL: EXTREME.]
One line. That's all Phase 1 gives him — not the timeline, not the specifics, not the sequence of losses that will turn this clean-faced priest into a man the show called "Rickety" because his body stopped working right and the name stuck because cruelty is funnier than compassion. Just the word EXTREME in the same neutral font the CPS uses for everything, the same font it used for Charlie's E-tier rat meat and Dennis's C-tier rebranding and Frank's unstable A.
EXTREME.
Griffin's hands tighten in his coat pockets. The thrift-store coat — getting thin, needs replacing, one more thing on the list of things he hasn't dealt with because the bets and the bar and the system eat his bandwidth. His right hand finds the flip phone and grips it like an anchor.
Matthew Mara. Father Mara. Cricket. The man who walks into Paddy's Pub as a priest and walks out, eventually, as something the show couldn't look at without making it a punchline.
He knows the arc. All of it. The show gave Cricket's degradation the same treatment it gave everything — comedy first, consequences never. Dee seduces him away from the priesthood. He loses his position. Loses his housing. Loses his teeth, one by one, across seasons that treat dental trauma as a running gag. Loses his dignity in increments so small the audience barely notices until the man sleeping under an overpass is the same man standing on these church steps shaking hands with an old woman who trusts him with her soul.
Cricket notices Griffin.
It's the standing-still that does it — everyone else on the sidewalk is moving, walking, heading to brunch or home or wherever Philadelphians go after church. Griffin is stationary on the opposite side of Tasker Street, and stationary draws attention the way motion doesn't.
Cricket raises a hand. Smiles. Crosses the street.
"Good morning. Are you looking for the parish?"
His voice is warm. Not warm the way Dennis's is warm — Dennis's warmth is a tool, calibrated and deployed. Cricket's warmth is structural, built into the foundation, the kind that comes from a person who believes the world is fundamentally good and hasn't been shown the evidence against that position.
"No, I—" Griffin clears his throat. "I was just walking. Passing through."
"Well, if you ever want to stop in. Sunday at ten, Wednesday at seven. We're not fancy, but the coffee's better than it looks."
"I work at Paddy's Pub. Down on—"
Cricket's face changes. Not a lot — a flicker, a recalibration, the micro-expression of someone who's heard a familiar name and is filing it under "complicated." His smile adjusts but doesn't leave.
"Paddy's. Sure. I went to school with some of that crew. Dennis and Dee Reynolds, Mac McDonald." He pauses. "Haven't seen them in years. How are they?"
"They're... themselves."
Cricket laughs. The laugh is clean. "That bad?"
"Consistently."
"I heard they got a new owner? Some older guy?"
"Frank Reynolds. Dennis's father. He's, uh. He's a presence."
"Sounds like the Reynolds family." Cricket extends his hand. "Matthew Mara. But everyone calls me Cricket — old school thing. Dee gave me the nickname. I used to make this sound with my neck..." He demonstrates. His neck is fine. His neck works perfectly. His neck will not always work perfectly.
Griffin shakes the hand. The grip is firm and dry and the bones beneath the skin are all where they should be and the hand is warm and clean and Griffin holds on for one second longer than the handshake requires because letting go means letting go.
"Griffin Finch."
"Nice to meet you, Griffin. You've got a good handshake. My mother always said you can tell a lot about a person by their handshake."
"Your mother sounds wise."
"She is. Scary, but wise." Cricket checks his watch — an actual wristwatch, which in 2006 is normal but in the context of a man who will eventually lose everything down to the concept of timekeeping feels like a detail Griffin will remember forever. "I should get back. The Hendersons want to talk about their marriage again, which means forty minutes of listening to them blame each other for things that happened in 1987. But it's the job."
"Yeah."
"Stop by sometime. Even if it's just for the coffee."
Cricket walks back to the church steps. His stride is even. His posture is straight. His collar is white and his shoes are clean and the CPS notification sits in Griffin's peripheral vision like a receipt for something that hasn't been purchased yet:
CUMULATIVE DAMAGE POTENTIAL: EXTREME.
Griffin watches until Cricket disappears through the church doors. The HUD dims. The notification fades.
He walks to Paddy's the long way — south on 8th, west on Wolf, south again on Broad — adding fifteen minutes to the route because the direct path goes past the coffee shop and the coffee shop is closed and he doesn't want to stand outside a closed building thinking about a priest who shook his hand and smiled like the world was worth trusting.
Dee is the first domino. She'll find him — or he'll find her, the way old connections resurface when they're needed most and least. She'll use his crush on her from school. She'll pull him into Paddy's orbit. And the orbit will grind him down the way orbits grind everything — not all at once, but in passes, each one taking a little more, until the object is dust and the gravity moves on.
The bar appears. The green sign. The brick in the door. Charlie is inside, which Griffin knows because Charlie is always inside, even when the bar is closed, even when the door is locked, even when nobody else would choose to be in a building that smells like this on a Sunday morning.
Griffin hangs his coat on the hook. Picks up a glass. Starts polishing.
COMPLICITY: 12%
Twelve percent. The ambient cost of employment. The tax I pay for standing in the building where Cricket's life will be dismantled.
He polishes the glass until it squeaks. Sets it down. Picks up another.
I'm going back to that church. Tomorrow. And I'm going to tell him.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!