Chapter 38: Owen's Offensive
North Shore High School. The Auditorium. After school.
Will Schuester checked his watch with the expression of a man trying not to look like he was enjoying something.
"How long has it been?" he asked.
Finn looked at his own watch. "Hour and fifteen minutes."
"And the sign-up sheet?"
"Still blank," Finn said, with the uncomplicated satisfaction of someone reporting good news.
The New Directions members were scattered across the auditorium seats — nominally present for an extended rehearsal block, actually doing what teenagers do when given unstructured time near a developing situation. Watching. Waiting. Updating each other on the view from the stage.
From their seats, through the open auditorium doors, the stage was visible: Owen at a table with a registration form in front of him, Ms. Morrison beside him, the audition notice posted on the board behind them, and the register conspicuously, comprehensively empty.
Noah leaned back in his chair, arms behind his head. "I thought he'd get at least one person," he said, with the mild disappointment of someone whose wager had not paid out. "He's Owen Carter. The guy wins things."
"Not this time," Quinn said, in a voice that was flat and careful and did not match her expression.
Noah caught the expression and let it go. He and Quinn had arrived at a functional arrangement since the summer — civil, honest in a minimal way, co-existing around a shared fact neither of them fully discussed in public. He'd learned to read her tells. The flat voice plus the specific look meant she was thinking something she wasn't saying.
He didn't push.
"Students," Will said, with the bright energy of a man trying to focus a room that was focused on something else. "This is good news. It means we can use this time for actual rehearsal without worrying about—"
"How did he get Ms. Morrison to be the advisor?" Mercedes asked.
"She's the AP Music Theory teacher," Tina said. "Probably just asked her."
"He always just asks people," Kurt said, "and they say yes, which is genuinely unfair."
Will clapped his hands. "Okay. From the top, everyone—"
On stage.
The auditorium registration table had the specific atmosphere of a lemonade stand on a cold day — fully operational, correctly positioned, receiving zero customers.
Ms. Morrison had a gradebook open and was doing other work, which Owen appreciated as a gesture of normalcy.
Owen sat with the blank sign-up sheet in front of him and looked at it without distress.
Morrison glanced at him sideways. "You're fine," she said. It was not quite a question.
"I'm fine," Owen said.
"Most people would find this humiliating."
"Most people haven't had the kind of previous experience that recalibrates what humiliating means," Owen said, which was true in ways he couldn't fully explain. In his previous life — the one before the System, before the second chance — he'd had years of setbacks that made an empty sign-up sheet feel like a minor Tuesday.
This was data. Not defeat. The passive approach hadn't worked. He'd move to the active approach.
Morrison looked at him for a moment with the expression she sometimes wore during their Thursday morning sessions — the one that meant she was revising an earlier estimate.
"You're not done," she said.
"Not remotely."
"What's the plan?"
Owen looked at the blank sheet. "One-on-one," he said. "I go to the people I want, individually, and I make the case directly. Passive recruitment — posting a notice, sending a text, setting up a table — assumes people will come to you. It works when there's already momentum." He paused. "I don't have momentum yet. I need to go get it."
"That's a lot of individual conversations."
"I don't need twelve separate conversions," Owen said. "I need three or four. The right three or four — people with social weight at this school — and the rest becomes easier. Once the right names are attached to Gungnir, the hesitation for everyone else drops significantly."
Morrison considered this. "You've thought about which names."
"I have a list," Owen said.
She nodded slowly. Then: "I want to raise something."
"Okay."
"I can run rehearsals," she said. "I can manage the music theory side, the arrangement structure, the technical elements. What I can't give you is performance coaching. Stage presence, choreography, the performance craft that takes a good choir and makes it something an audience can't look away from." She paused. "Will Schuester is genuinely good at that. I know you two have a complicated situation—"
"I'm not asking Will," Owen said.
"I know. Which is why I want to suggest someone else." She turned slightly in her chair. "Holly Holliday. She's been subbing at North Shore on and off this year. She has a background in performance — real performance, touring, choreography. Her technical level is comparable to Will's and her style is different enough from New Directions that Gungnir would have its own identity."
Owen had thought about Holly Holliday.
He'd thought about her and arrived at a conclusion that he recognized was not entirely rational but also wasn't entirely wrong: the people you built something with mattered beyond their skill set. The environment of a choir — twelve people, intensive rehearsal, high emotional investment — required a specific kind of chemistry.
He looked at Morrison.
"She's not the right fit," he said.
Morrison waited.
"I know that sounds vague," Owen said. "The skill is there. The availability is there. But the thing we're building has a specific — feeling to it. And I think there's someone else who fits that better."
"Who?"
"I'm still working on that part," Owen said honestly.
Morrison looked at him with the expression of someone deciding whether to push back on incomplete reasoning or accept that the person across from them occasionally operated on instinct that had a track record.
"Okay," she said. "But don't wait too long. You need the choreography piece in place before you have a full group, not after."
"Understood."
She went back to her gradebook.
Owen looked at the blank sign-up sheet one more time.
Then he picked up his pen and wrote Karen Jackson on the first line.
He'd do it himself if he had to.
From the auditorium seats, Noah Puckerman watched Owen write something on the sheet and nudged Kurt. "He just signed someone."
Kurt craned his neck. "Who?"
"Can't tell from here."
Quinn, without turning her head, said: "It doesn't matter who the first name is. It matters who the third and fourth names are."
Noah looked at her. "You've thought about this."
"I think about a lot of things," Quinn said, in a tone that ended the conversation.
Twenty minutes later.
"Owen."
Owen looked up.
Karen Jackson appeared at the auditorium door, slightly out of breath, looking around with the open curiosity of someone who'd navigated a school building they didn't usually navigate.
Owen stood. Waved her over.
Karen crossed the auditorium, took in the empty seats, the empty stage, the registration sheet, the situation — all of it in about four seconds with the ambient awareness that was her particular gift — and sat down across from him.
"Nobody came," she said.
"Not yet," Owen said.
Karen looked at the sheet. At the single name already written there. Looked at Owen. "Is that my name?"
"I was being optimistic," Owen said.
Karen smiled — the uncomplicated, unhurried smile that was simply what Karen's face did when something pleased her. She picked up the pen, found the next blank line, and wrote her name in the careful handwriting of someone who took the act of signing something seriously.
"Do I need to audition?" she asked.
"I know what you can do," Owen said. "You're on the list."
Karen put the pen down. "The audition notice said you need twelve."
"I know."
"Do you know where the other ten are coming from?"
"I have a good idea."
Karen nodded, accepting this with the straightforward trust she brought to most things Owen said. "Okay." She paused. "The New Directions kids are watching from the seats, you know. They've been here for a while."
"I know," Owen said.
"Does that bother you?"
Owen looked at the sheet. Two names. Ten blank lines below them.
"No," he said. "They're going to watch a lot of things over the next year. That's fine. Watching is how you get surprised later."
Karen looked at him for a moment. Then quietly: "Owen. I want to say something."
"Say it."
"Whatever happens with the choir — the competition, the whole Jesse thing — I just want to make sure I'm in it because it's going to be good. Not because it's a vehicle for proving something."
Owen met her eyes.
"I want that too," he said. "Both things can be true. We build something real and it proves something. One doesn't cancel the other."
Karen thought about this. Nodded slowly. "Okay. Yeah."
She picked up her bag.
"You said you'd drive me home," she said.
"I did say that." Owen started packing up the table — blank form folded and pocketed, Morrison's materials gathered. "I have four stops to make on the way. You can come or I can drop you first."
"Four stops," Karen repeated.
"First recruits," Owen said. "One-on-one."
Karen looked at him with the expression she occasionally produced — the one that was more perceptive than the room expected.
"The offensive starts tonight," she said.
"It started about ten minutes ago," Owen said.
He folded up the table. Morrison had already gone, with a nod that meant I'll see you Thursday, don't skip.
Owen picked up his jacket, pocketed the registration form with its two names, and looked at the empty auditorium one more time.
The New Directions section was empty too — they'd filtered out sometime in the last few minutes, the entertainment having concluded.
From the corridor, faintly, Owen could hear Will running them through scales.
Good. Let them practice.
He had work to do.
Chapter Rewards
500 Power Stones = 1 New Chapter
10 Reviews = 1 New Chapter
Thanks for reading!
20+ advanced chapters available on P1treon: DarkFoxx