The second run was harder because the second run meant walking back into something he'd just walked out of.
The theater air hit him like pressure — not physical, but the way a room full of concentrated human terror has a specific weight to it, an atmospheric quality that the gas mask filtered for chemistry but did nothing about in any other respect. He moved down the left wall aisle, staying low, away from the bodies stumbling through the middle rows. The alarm was still sounding. The projector was still running, Crane's last slide frozen on the screen — a bell curve graph labeled THREAT PERCEPTION vs. ACTUAL THREAT — and the irony of it was so perfect it made his jaw tighten.
Crane was gone. The podium was empty, the stage-left door stood open, and a cold draft cut through the room from that direction. The man had deployed his compound and walked out at the forty-second mark, which was exactly what the character profile suggested: Crane ran experiments, he didn't stay to watch them. He had what he needed already.
Elijah filed that away and kept moving.
Fifteen people in the second run. He couldn't get them all coherently moving — three were too far into the hallucination to follow directions, and he made the decision to leave them, which he'd be examining for a long time. The twelve he got were less organized than the first five; several tried to go back for bags, for phones, for other people they'd been sitting with. He moved them like cattle toward the partition, voice steady through the mask filter, hands on shoulders when steering words stopped working.
[SP: 62/80. Physical exertion moderate. Toxin trace detected — mask integrity holding.]
Outside, the campus was beginning to respond. Distant sirens, campus security radio crackling from the direction of the main building, three students who'd gotten out earlier sprinting toward what they probably hoped was help. The air outside the theater smelled of October cold and river iron and he breathed it deliberately, two deep pulls, before going back.
The third run was twenty-two people. It was also where he took the elbow.
A professor — fifties, salt-and-pepper hair, the specific stocky build of someone who'd played rugby in their twenties and retained the mass without the conditioning — was deep in a hallucination and moving through the row at a low crouch, arms up, defending against something Elijah couldn't see. When Elijah put a hand on his shoulder to redirect him, the man spun and drove an elbow into the left side of his jaw with the committed power of genuine animal fear.
White. The world went white for approximately one second, then orange, then resolved back into the lecture theater.
His ears were ringing. He ran his tongue across his back teeth — all present, no crack he could feel, which meant nothing was broken, which meant he'd gotten lucky. The bruise was going to be architectural.
The professor was still in the hallucination, backing away, hands up.
"Hey." Elijah kept his voice flat and even. "Hey. Follow the sound. Move toward the sound."
Something in the command-register — the stripped-down certainty of it — cut through just enough. The professor moved toward him, still not seeing anything recognizable, but moving in the right direction.
[SP: 41/80. HP: 92/100. Jaw impact — minor. Mask seal: intact.]
He got them out.
The fourth run started twelve minutes after the attack began.
By then the theater was in different territory. The students still inside — maybe sixty remaining, not counting those unconscious or hiding under seats — were past the panic stage and into the sustained toxin experience, which meant their hallucinations had developed narrative logic. They were seeing coherent terrors, not fragmented sensory chaos. The screaming had given way to something worse: a thick, low-register sound of dozens of people breathing wrong and murmuring to their nightmares.
The mask filter had a two-hour rating. It had been twelve minutes. He had time, technically. Physically, the question was whether he did, because his legs had the heavy quality of muscles that had been running on adrenaline long enough to start checking the bill.
He made it six rows in before the smell came through.
Not through the filter — the filter was working. But through the seal at his left cheek, where the elbow hit had shifted the mask fraction of a millimeter off true. Barely perceptible. Less than a breath's worth of compound, mixed seventy-to-one with clean outside air.
The edges of his vision warped. Just slightly. The shadows at the far end of the row lengthened by a half-second before correcting. His own fear — the normal, operational fear he'd been running on since 2:31 PM — spiked and then settled, the WIL stat doing what it was rated to do: dampen the amplification effect.
He reached up and reseated the mask with both palms. Better. Not perfect.
Move faster.
The students near him in the fourth run were in deep. Their brains were pattern-matching everything through fear-filter, pulling the most available archetypes from their own cognitive libraries and projecting them onto whatever their eyes told them was present. Elijah had studied this mechanism academically, written a seminar paper on it, understood it in structural terms.
He understood it differently when he watched three separate students — from different rows, without exchanging a word — look at his silhouette in the gas mask and the HUD glow that wasn't quite visible but wasn't quite not, and whisper the same word.
"Rider."
The third one said it louder. "The Rider."
Not a hallucination, exactly. More like a recognition. Their terrified minds reaching for a protective archetype and finding one that existed in this city's mythology — the colonial-era figure from the pamphlet, the thesis subject, the thing that rode into Gotham's worst moments and shepherded people out.
They'd been primed. Three weeks into a semester on Gotham's protector legends, half of them writing papers on urban mythology, and here was a masked figure in a crisis leading them toward exits.
The Belief Meter pulsed.
[SPONTANEOUS RECOGNITION EVENT. Persona archetype identified: THE PALE RIDER. Active Witnesses: 47. Average Belief Tier: 3 — Suspicion. Total BP Generated: 47. Activation Threshold: 100 BP.]
Forty-seven. He needed one hundred.
He was standing in the middle row of a room full of toxin-hallucinating students who were halfway to believing in a three-hundred-year-old Gotham myth. Fifty-three more BP at current witness tier and belief rate would take — he didn't do the math, he didn't have the brain capacity for the math — several more minutes at minimum. Minutes he didn't have before the filter degraded further.
He made the choice.
Not because the math was clean. Not because he'd resolved the ethics in the dorm room last night. He made it because the alternative was leaving these people in a burning building he happened to have an exit route for.
He straightened his spine. Dropped his voice a full register, below the mask filter's distortion, into something that came from the chest rather than the throat. The drama training — three weeks of it, barely — wasn't enough. The body memory the previous Elijah had left behind was. Something in the ribcage settled, posture correcting, the way an instrument settles into its resonant position.
"Follow me," he said. "Nothing in the dark touches you while I ride."
The performance grade appeared in his peripheral without him asking for it.
[Performance Grade: B+. Authenticity: 71%. Witness Response: escalating.]
The Belief Meter climbed. Not instantly — belief didn't work instantly, even toxin-amplified belief, because the human capacity for faith had friction in it regardless of neurology. But it climbed with the specific acceleration of something that had been held back and was no longer held.
Forty-seven people in this run. He moved through them methodically, touching shoulders, redirecting bodies, his voice staying in that register. Dr. Kaplan was in this group, toxin-blind, one hand locked around a student's elbow for balance. Her face had the rigid blankness of someone whose conscious mind had been stripped down to survival function. He guided her by the shoulder, and she went without resistance, and she didn't know whose shoulder she was touching.
The Belief Meter passed eighty.
[BP: 83/100. Threshold approach.]
He had them moving, a column of forty-plus people shuffling toward the north exit, the partition, the cold air. His legs were burning. The jaw was a steady, insistent ache. The mask seal was holding — barely, the cheek contact uneven enough to feel — and the peripheral warp from his partial exposure had settled to a hum at the edge of his vision that he'd decided to simply ignore.
He got them through the door.
Ninety-one BP.
Outside, the campus had become a different kind of chaos — organized chaos, the kind that emergency services generated when they arrived and started imposing structure on entropy. Two ambulances at the south building entrance. Campus security creating a perimeter. One fire truck visible past the library corner, probably the GCPD chemical response team. In another few minutes this scene would be locked down and the remaining people inside would become their problem, not his.
He turned back to the theater.
One more run. He didn't know if he had one more run in him, but there were still people inside and the mask had time left and the math said yes even if his body was voting no.
He pulled the partition door open.
At the far end of the corridor — the main corridor, not the north hall, visible through the propped-open emergency exit and fifty meters of institutional flooring — a figure moved through the toxin haze with the specific decisive efficiency of someone who had never once in their life moved through a space without knowing exactly where they were going.
Dark suit. Cape. The silhouette that the city had been arguing about for eight years.
Batman was already inside.
The Belief Meter sat at ninety-one, warm and bright, nine points from something that didn't exist yet and couldn't exist yet and would have to keep not existing for a few more minutes while Elijah stood at the threshold of Robinson Hall and made a very quick decision about whether to go back in or stay out and let the professional handle it.
Nine BP.
Batman moved deeper into the theater without looking down the corridor.
Elijah went in anyway.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!