Chapter 19: The One Where Everyone Sees Things They Shouldn't
The door situation was, in retrospect, entirely preventable.
Ethan had been the one to suggest they go check on Rachel — she'd been quiet at dinner the previous evening, the kind of quiet that wasn't peaceful but was doing a convincing impression of it, and he'd wanted to loop back. Chandler had come along because Chandler was between things and going somewhere was better than not going somewhere.
Neither of them had knocked.
This was the error.
The door had been unlocked, which in the Monica-and-Rachel apartment meant either Monica was home or someone had forgotten, and the someone who had forgotten was Rachel, who was mid-transit between the bathroom and her bedroom, wearing a towel in the specific way that indicated she had not anticipated an audience.
The three of them arrived at the mutual realization of the situation at approximately the same time.
Rachel made a sound.
Chandler made a different sound and turned immediately toward the wall with the focused attention of a man discovering an intense interest in the paint color.
Ethan, who had been half a step behind and had processed the situation marginally slower than the others, said — and this was, he would later acknowledge, not his best moment — "Sorry, the door was—"
"OUT," Rachel said.
They went out.
The door closed behind them with the specific force of someone communicating a feeling through architectural hardware.
They stood in the hallway.
"We should have knocked," Chandler said.
"We should have knocked," Ethan agreed.
"I turned away immediately," Chandler said.
"You did," Ethan said. "That was correct."
"Did you—" Chandler started.
"I was behind you," Ethan said. "The sightline was different."
"How different?"
"We're not doing this," Ethan said. "We're going to wait until Monica gets home and then we're going to be very normal about everything."
They sat on the couch in the hallway like people waiting for a verdict, which was functionally what they were doing. Monica and the others arrived back twenty minutes later, came through the door, clocked the two of them sitting in the approximate positions of the recently chastened, and Chandler immediately started explaining, which Ethan had specifically recommended he not do but which Chandler was constitutionally incapable of not doing.
Monica listened to the explanation. Then she looked at Ethan.
"We didn't knock," Ethan said simply.
"I gathered," Monica said.
"It was genuinely an accident," Ethan said. "The door was unlocked."
"Knocking," Monica said, "is not contingent on whether a door is locked."
"I know that now," Ethan said.
Joey had come in behind Monica, and he was now doing the particular Joey calculation of someone trying to determine whether to be amused or sympathetic, and landing somewhere in the middle that expressed itself as a very poorly suppressed grin.
"Don't," Ethan said.
Joey suppressed it better.
Rachel's door was still closed. The door being closed communicated things clearly and without ambiguity.
"Give her a few minutes," Monica said.
"However many she needs," Ethan said.
"Chandler," Monica said, "please stop looking at the ceiling like you're inspecting it."
"I'm just—" Chandler stopped. "Okay."
Rachel emerged approximately fifteen minutes later with the expression of a woman who had decided exactly how she was going to handle this and was handling it.
She sat down on the far end of the couch, crossed her arms, and looked at the room generally rather than anyone specifically.
"Accidental," Ethan said.
"I know it was accidental," Rachel said. "That doesn't make it—" She stopped. "It was accidental. Fine. Moving on."
"Moving on," Ethan agreed.
A pause.
"You should have knocked," Rachel said.
"We absolutely should have knocked," Ethan said.
"I'm going to start locking the door," Rachel said.
"Very reasonable," Ethan said.
Ross, who had arrived in the middle of this and had been briefed in fragments, said: "What exactly did—"
"Moving on," Ethan said.
"But what happened is that they—"
"Ross," Chandler said. "Moving on."
"I just want to understand the—"
"You don't need to understand it," Ethan said. "Nobody needs to understand it. The understanding would not improve anyone's life."
Ross considered this with the expression of a scientist who found the withholding of information philosophically uncomfortable but was choosing to accept it.
"Fine," he said. "Moving on."
Phoebe, who had been sitting through all of this with the expression of someone watching a weather system pass, said: "For what it's worth, I think the awkwardness is actually healthy. It means everyone cares about appropriate boundaries, which is a sign of a mature group."
"Thank you, Phoebe," Rachel said.
"You're very welcome," Phoebe said. "Also, Ethan, I think you meant to say 'I apologize unreservedly,' not 'the door was unlocked.'"
"Those are both things I meant," Ethan said.
"The first one should have come first," Phoebe said.
"Phoebe's right," Ethan said. "Rachel, I apologize unreservedly. It was an accident and we should have knocked and I'm sorry."
Rachel looked at him for a moment. "Thank you," she said. "That's the right version."
"I know," Ethan said. "I got there eventually."
The room had almost entirely recovered when Joey came through the door from across the hall, and the expression on his face changed the temperature of the room immediately — not dramatically, but definitively, the way a shift in weather changes things before the weather arrives.
He sat down on the couch and didn't say anything for a moment, which for Joey was its own kind of statement.
"Ronnie," Monica said. "Your dad."
"Six years," Joey said.
The room absorbed this.
"They've been—" Joey stopped. "Six years. My mom doesn't know. Ronnie is—" He shook his head. "She's not a bad person. She's actually nice. That's almost worse."
"What did you say to him?" Ethan asked.
"I gave him a choice," Joey said. "Either he tells my mom, or he ends it. One or the other." He looked at the table. "I don't know which is worse. Telling her — that's going to destroy her. And if he ends it and doesn't tell her — then she never knows, and everything just continues like it was, except now I know."
Silence.
"Joey," Ethan said. "You did the right thing by giving him the choice."
"Did I?" Joey said. "Because right now it doesn't feel like anything. It just feels like everything got complicated and I can't uncomplicate it."
"You can't," Ethan said. "But you also can't not know what you know. The choice you gave your father — that's the honest move. What he does with it is his."
"He's my dad," Joey said.
"I know," Ethan said.
"He's a good dad," Joey said. "He coached my little league team. He drove me to every audition in Queens until I could drive myself. He—" Joey stopped. "How do you be a good dad and also do this?"
"People are more than one thing," Ethan said. "That's not an excuse. It's just true. Your dad is a good father and he's also doing something that isn't okay. Both of those things are real."
Joey sat with this for a long moment.
"I let Ronnie stay in Chandler's room," he said finally. "She had nowhere to go tonight."
Everyone looked at Chandler.
Chandler had the expression of a man who had been informed of this decision and was processing his feelings about it. "She's very polite," he said carefully. "She knocked before she came in."
"Unlike some people," Rachel said, without heat, which meant the earlier situation had sufficiently deflated.
"Unlike some people," Ethan confirmed, in the same tone.
He walked Phoebe home that evening, which had become their habit when the evening ended in this direction. The spring night was mild — the kind of April night that made promises about what May was going to be — and Phoebe had her guitar case over one shoulder and her coat open because she was always slightly warmer than the weather.
"Roger," Ethan said.
"I know," Phoebe said.
"You've thought about it."
"I've thought about it," she said. "He's very smart. And he's very — he notices things. But noticing things and knowing what to do with what you notice are different skills, and he's only developed one of them."
"That's accurate," Ethan said.
"He said things that were true about Monica," Phoebe said. "But he said them like they were problems to be fixed. And Monica isn't broken. She's just — Monica. The cooking, the organizing — that's how she holds the people she loves. Naming it as dysfunction is like..." She thought about it. "Like calling a hug a boundary violation."
Ethan looked at her. "That's a really good way to put it."
"I have my moments," Phoebe said.
"Are you okay?" he said. "About ending it."
Phoebe was quiet for half a block. "I liked him," she said. "The version of him I thought he was. The version that noticed things because he cared about people." She shifted the guitar case. "The actual version notices things because he finds them interesting. That's — different."
"It is different," Ethan said.
"I'll be okay," she said. "I'm always okay eventually. It's one of my better qualities."
"It really is," he said.
She smiled — the full one, not the one she used when she was being brave. "What about you? Julia's back next week?"
"Thursday," he said.
"And the Fox meeting?"
"Two weeks," he said. "After that, if it goes well, things start moving differently. The scale changes."
Phoebe looked at him. "Are you ready for that?"
He thought about it honestly. "I think so," he said. "The PhD I can see the end of. The script — that's something I built from scratch, on a different kind of trust. Putting it in a room with people who are going to evaluate it commercially—" He paused. "That's a different kind of exposure than academic work."
"Because you care about it differently," Phoebe said.
"Because I care about it differently," he confirmed.
"That's good," she said. "The things you care about differently are the things worth being scared about."
They stopped at her building. She hitched the guitar case up on her shoulder and looked at him with the expression she wore when she was about to say something true.
"For what it's worth," she said. "The script is going to do what it's supposed to do. I don't know exactly what that is. But it's supposed to do something."
"How do you know?" he said.
"Because you wrote it," she said. "And you only make things you believe in completely. And the things you believe in completely tend to be right." She turned toward the door. "Also, I had a feeling about it when you first mentioned it, and my feelings are quite reliable."
"They really are," he said.
She went inside, and he walked home through the April night, the city doing its evening thing, the conversation about the script settling into something that felt, oddly, like certainty.
The next morning, Central Perk had the particular energy of a group that had been through a day and was comparing notes on it.
The morning's first piece of news — delivered by Ross with the specific joy of someone who had been waiting to say something since he'd heard it — was that Phoebe and Roger had officially, as of ten o'clock that morning, ended things.
The table's response was unanimous and immediate.
"Finally," Chandler said.
"I know," Monica said.
"He said one more thing on the way out," Phoebe said. "He told me my guitar playing was an expression of unresolved grief about my mother."
Silence.
"Is he wrong?" Rachel asked carefully.
"Probably not entirely," Phoebe said. "But also — it's just guitar. Sometimes it's just guitar." She picked up her coffee. "He analyzed my guitar."
"He analyzed your guitar," Monica said.
"My guitar," Phoebe confirmed. "I asked him to leave after that."
"Good call," Ethan said.
The second piece of news was delivered by Chandler, and was about the morning at the apartment, and was received with the specific expression that news about unexpected bathroom encounters always received, and resolved with Monica saying "we're all moving on from this and never discussing it again" in the tone of someone issuing an organizational decree.
"Agreed," Ethan said.
"Agreed," everyone said.
"The door was unlocked," Ross said.
"Ross," everyone said.
"I'm just saying—"
"We're moving on," Monica said.
"Moving on," Ross said.
Joey was quieter than usual, which the group had clocked and was respecting in the way they respected things that needed space. Ethan caught his eye at one point — a brief look, nothing that required words — and Joey gave a small nod that communicated I'm okay, I'm working through it, thank you for not making it a thing.
Ethan gave a small nod back that communicated understood, whenever you're ready, we're here.
This was the particular language of people who had known each other long enough.
Monica had made something — she always made something — and it was on a plate in the center of the table, and people were eating it with the absent appreciation of people for whom Monica's food had become the backdrop of their lives rather than the event, which was either a measure of how good she was or a measure of how comfortable they'd all gotten, and probably both.
Outside, the April morning was doing its thing — the sun making an effort, the trees along the street having committed now, the city doing what it did in spring which was move slightly faster than it had all winter, like something that had been building.
Ethan sat back and looked at the room.
The ongoing situation of Joey's father and what it meant. Phoebe, lighter than yesterday, the guitar question answered on her own terms. Monica, who had been moved by something Roger said and was processing it the way she processed things — by making food and being precise and not mentioning it directly.
Chandler, who had offered his room to a woman who needed somewhere to stay and had not made it into anything, which was quietly one of the better things he'd done in a while. Rachel, who had decided to be gracious about an accident and had found the gracious version of herself relatively quickly, which was its own kind of growth.
Ross, who was going to be a father in a few months, and who had chosen not to know the gender, and who was practicing — every day, in small ways — the particular skill of being present without needing to control what was coming.
All of them, working through things.
All of them, fine.
He picked up his coffee.
Two weeks to the Fox meeting. The PhD defense after that. Julia on Thursday.
Everything moving, the way things moved when you were in the middle of it and couldn't see the shape of it yet but could feel the direction.
That was enough.
More than enough.
[Milestone: 500 Power Stones = +1 Chapter]
[Milestone: 10 Reviews = +1 Chapter]
Enjoyed this chapter? Leave a review.
20+advanced chapters on P1treon Soulforger