Chapter 28: The One Where Joey Comes Back
The birthday party had been going for two hours when Ethan checked his watch and registered, for the third time, that Joey's spot on the couch was still empty.
Nobody said anything about it directly. That was the group's particular diplomacy around things that were both obvious and sensitive — you didn't name it until naming it was useful. But the empty spot was present in the room the way empty spots always were, taking up a specific kind of space.
Phoebe was, by every visible measure, having a good birthday. She was in the armchair with the bracelet on her wrist and The Road Less Traveled in her lap, and she'd laughed genuinely at three different things in the last twenty minutes, and the cake Monica had made was the kind that required everyone to close their eyes briefly on the first bite.
But Ethan had known Phoebe long enough to read the difference between happy and completely happy, and there was a small gap between those two things tonight that sat in exactly the shape of Joey's absence.
Ross was on the floor with his back against the couch, telling Phoebe about the prenatal class in the way he told stories when he was trying to be funny about something that had also moved him — the breathing section, the moment when the instructor had asked the partners to make eye contact with each other during a practice contraction simulation and Susan had taken this extremely seriously while Ross had been ambushed by the reality of the situation in a way he hadn't fully anticipated.
"She just looked at me," Ross said. "Susan. Very steady. Very — committed to the exercise. And I looked back, and I thought — there's a person coming. An actual person. And this is the room where we're all figuring out how to be ready for that person."
"Were you ready?" Phoebe said.
"No," Ross said. "But I think that might be the point of the class."
"It's definitely the point of the class," Ethan said.
"The breathing helped though," Ross said, with the slightly surprised expression of a man who had been skeptical about the breathing and had been proven wrong about the breathing. "I didn't think it would help. It helped."
"It always helps," Monica said, from the kitchen, where she was doing something with the leftover cake that didn't need doing but that she was doing anyway because Monica's hands needed to be occupied.
Chandler, from the armchair across from Phoebe, had been quiet for a while in the particular Chandler way that meant he was actually thinking about something rather than just waiting for the next thing to say.
"Can I ask you something?" he said to Phoebe.
"Always," she said.
"The writing thing," he said. "You mentioned it at dinner. That my aura has been doing something different." He paused. "What does it look like? From outside."
Phoebe looked at him with genuine attention. "It looks like someone who's been keeping a room locked for a long time and has recently started standing outside it," she said. "Not opening it yet. Just — being near it."
Chandler absorbed this.
"That's accurate," he said.
"I know," she said.
"How do I open it?" he said.
"You already know that," Phoebe said. "You're just waiting until it doesn't feel as scary."
"When does it stop feeling scary?" Chandler said.
"Probably when you're doing it," Phoebe said. "Not before."
Chandler looked at the ceiling for a moment. Then: "That's frustrating."
"It is," Phoebe agreed. "But it's true."
Rachel, who had been on the couch with her legs tucked under her and her glass of wine doing slow rotations in her hand, said: "I called the store on Madison this morning."
Everyone looked at her.
"The buying department," she said. "I talked to the assistant director for about twelve minutes. She wants me to come in Friday." She said it with the specific tone of someone who had done a thing and was still calibrating how to feel about having done it — not quite celebrating yet, holding the news at a slight distance while she verified it was real.
"Rachel," Monica said, appearing from the kitchen.
"It's just a meeting," Rachel said. "It's not the job."
"It's the meeting that gets you the job," Monica said.
"I know," Rachel said. "I'm just not—" She stopped. "I don't want to want it too much before I know if I can have it."
"That's the least Rachel Green thing I've ever heard you say," Ethan said.
Rachel looked at him.
"You've always wanted things at full volume," Ethan said. "That's one of your best qualities. Want this at full volume. It's more honest than wanting it quietly and pretending you're not."
Rachel was quiet for a moment. Then she uncurled her legs and sat up straighter. "I want it," she said, at a volume that was, in fact, full. "I want the job and I think I can do it and I'm going to go in on Friday and be very good."
"There it is," Ethan said.
"There it is," Phoebe agreed.
Monica raised her glass from the kitchen doorway. "To Rachel being very good on Friday."
"To Rachel," Ross said.
They drank. Rachel looked like someone who had just put something down that she'd been carrying carefully and discovered her arms were fine.
It was ten-fifteen when the door opened.
Joey came in with the specific walk of a man who had experienced something and hadn't finished processing it yet. His jacket was slightly wrong — one collar up, one down, the subtle dishevelment of someone who had put it on in a hurry or taken it off and put it back on again. He looked around the apartment, registered the remnants of a birthday party — the streamers Monica had put up, the cake plate with its evidence, the group arranged around the living room in the way they arranged themselves when an evening had been good — and his expression did something complicated.
"Hey," he said.
"Hey," Phoebe said.
The room held itself carefully.
Joey sat down on the edge of the couch — not his usual sprawl, something more provisional — and looked at Phoebe with the expression of a man who had rehearsed something and was now finding the rehearsal insufficient.
"I missed your birthday," he said.
"You did," she said.
"I'm sorry," he said. And it was the real version — not the Joey performance of an apology, not the charm offensive. Just the two words, delivered with the specific weight of someone who meant them completely. "I made a bad call. I knew it was your birthday, and I made plans anyway, and I told myself it would be fine, and it wasn't fine, and I'm sorry."
Phoebe looked at him for a long moment.
"How was the date?" she said.
Joey exhaled. "It ended early."
"What happened?" Monica said, which was what everyone was thinking.
"She's — Ursula is—" Joey stopped. "She's interesting. I wasn't wrong about that. But interesting and good are different things, and I think I got confused between them." He looked at his hands. "We were at dinner and she spent twenty minutes talking about an ex in a way that made me think the ex was still very much a current concern, and when I mentioned Phoebe — just in passing, just that I had a friend whose birthday was tonight — she went very quiet. And the quiet had a whole thing in it."
"What kind of thing?" Chandler said.
"The kind of thing that isn't about the friend," Joey said. "The kind that's about the fact that there is a friend. That I have people I care about." He shook his head. "She didn't say anything wrong. She just went quiet in a way that told me something, and I paid attention to it."
"And then what?" Rachel said.
"And then I paid the check and came here," Joey said simply.
The room absorbed this.
Ethan looked at Joey with the expression he reserved for moments when Joey exceeded the estimate. This was one of those moments — the paying attention, the reading of the quiet, the choosing to be here rather than staying somewhere that wasn't right.
"You okay?" Ethan said.
"Yeah," Joey said. "I think so." He looked at Phoebe. "I think I was looking for something in her that was actually already—" He stopped. "I don't know. I'm still figuring that part out."
Phoebe's expression was doing several things at once, which was not unusual for Phoebe, except that the specific combination was one Ethan hadn't seen before — something careful and warm and slightly surprised at itself.
"Joey," she said.
"Yeah," he said.
"You're here," she said.
"Yeah," he said. "I'm sorry it wasn't sooner."
"It's okay," she said. "You're here now."
Which was the Phoebe version of forgiveness — complete, immediate, without ledger. Joey received it with the expression of a man who understood he'd been given something he hadn't fully earned and was going to try to earn it retroactively.
Monica appeared from the kitchen with a plate. On it was a single slice of birthday cake — the good slice, the corner piece with the extra frosting, the one that had been set aside.
"I saved you a piece," she said to Joey.
"Monica," Joey said.
"Don't," she said. "Just eat it."
He ate it. It was, as previously established, excellent.
Later, after Ross had gone home to check on Marcel — who was fully recovered from the Scrabble tile incident and had reportedly been taking out his frustration about the whole experience on a throw pillow — and Monica had finished her post-party kitchen pass, Ethan and Phoebe sat on the couch in the way they sat when the evening was winding down and nobody was quite ready to end it yet.
Joey was asleep in the armchair. This had happened gradually and without announcement, the way Joey fell asleep — completely, immediately, with the total commitment of a person who had decided the evening was over for him specifically.
Chandler had gotten his jacket but was still standing by the door, which was the Chandler equivalent of lingering.
"The writing thing," Ethan said to him quietly.
Chandler looked at him.
"One page," Ethan said. "Not a draft. Not a project. Just — one page of something. See what comes out."
"What if nothing comes out?" Chandler said.
"Then you have a blank page," Ethan said. "Which is the same as what you have now, except you tried."
Chandler looked at the floor for a moment. "One page," he said.
"One page," Ethan confirmed.
Chandler nodded — the small, specific nod of someone making an agreement with themselves that happened to have a witness — and went out.
The apartment settled into its after-party quiet. Phoebe had the bracelet between her fingers, turning it slowly, the beads catching the lamp light.
"Good birthday?" Ethan said.
"Good birthday," she said. Then: "The book. I looked at the inscription."
He'd written something in the front — just a few lines, about how the roads people chose being less important than the fact that they chose them, and that Phoebe was the best example he knew of someone who chose her road completely and without apology.
"Did I get it right?" he said.
Phoebe looked at the bracelet turning in her hands. "You got it exactly right," she said. "Which is — you do that. You pay attention in a way that most people don't."
"You're worth paying attention to," he said.
She looked at him sideways with the expression she sometimes had — affectionate and slightly assessing at the same time. "How are you doing?" she said. "Actually."
"What do you mean?" he said.
"The defense is next week," she said. "Julia's still in Vancouver. The Fox thing. All of it landing at the same time." She tilted her head. "You're good at managing things, but managing things isn't the same as being okay."
Ethan sat with this for a moment.
"I'm okay," he said. "I think — I'm more okay than I expected to be at this point. The dissertation is what it is, and I know what it is. The Fox meeting went well. Julia and I—" He paused. "We talk every few days. It's fine."
"Fine," Phoebe said, in the tone that communicated she'd noted the word.
"It's good," he said, more accurately. "It's just — distance has a texture, and you notice the texture more at certain times than others."
"When she comes back," Phoebe said.
"When she comes back," he said.
"When is that?"
"Six weeks," he said. "Maybe five if the location shoot wraps early."
Phoebe turned the bracelet one more time and then held her wrist up so the beads caught the light properly. "Thank you," she said. "For the gift. For the inscription. For paying attention."
"Happy birthday, Pheebs," he said.
Outside, the March night was doing what March nights did when they were finally getting it right — the city settling into its late-night mode, the streets quieter, the lights going from full to selective, the particular New York quality of a night that had been a lot and was now becoming peaceful.
Joey snored once from the armchair, adjusted his position without waking, and settled back into the total unconsciousness of a man who had made the right decision and was at peace with it.
The bracelet caught the light.
More than enough.
[Power Stone Goal: 500 = +1 Chapter]
[Review Goal: 10 = +1 Chapter]
If you liked it, feel free to leave a review.
20+chapters ahead on P1treon Soulforger