Cherreads

Chapter 84 - CHAPTER 84: THE PERFECT ALIBI

THE MIDNIGHT CONFRONTATION

The following day arrived not with sunlight, but with the heavy, suffocating weight of an impending execution.

Sana did exactly what she had promised herself she would do on the cold marble floor the night before: she ran. She threw herself entirely into her police duties. From the moment the sun rose over delhi , she buried herself in the darkest, most demanding corners of her district. She supervised raids, reviewed endless stacks of criminal files, and patrolled the chaotic commercial sectors until her feet went entirely numb.

Her phone buzzed relentlessly in her pocket. Papa. Papa. Papa.

She ignored every single call.

By the time the minister and his arrogant son were scheduled to arrive at the Saini estate for the formal viewing, Sana was intentionally miles away, standing in the middle of a dusty precinct courtyard, staring blankly at a brick wall. She didn't return when the sun set. She didn't return when the evening turned cold.

It was exactly 12:00 AM when her heavy police boots finally clicked against the stone steps of the grand Saini mansion.

She pushed the heavy front door open, the hinges whining softly in the dead silence of the night. She stepped into the foyer, not even bothering to take off her cap, her eyes fixed firmly on the staircase.

"Stop right there."

The voice sliced through the shadows like a poisoned blade.

Sana froze. She slowly turned her head. Sitting in the center of the dimly lit drawing room was her father. He wasn't in his usual relaxed evening wear; he was still dressed in his sharp, formal suit, his tie loosened, a crystal glass of whiskey gripped so tightly in his hand that his knuckles were bone-white. Standing behind his chair, looking absolutely terrified and pale, was her mother.

Her father stood up, his massive frame casting a terrifying shadow across the Persian rug. The air in the room instantly dropped ten degrees.

"Where were you?" her father demanded, his voice dangerously low, vibrating with a lethal fury. "Why didn't you come home?"

Sana didn't flinch. She adjusted the heavy utility belt on her waist, her expression locking into a mask of absolute, unfeeling stone. "I am not in the mood to talk, Papa. I was busy with work. The district had emergencies."

"Work?!" her father roared, the sudden, explosive sound making her mother violently flinch.

He lunged forward and slammed his heavy fist down onto the polished dining table. The expensive crystal vases violently rattled. "Stop ignoring me! Do you know how much shame I felt today when they came?! The Minister and his son sat in my house for two hours waiting for you! They eventually got some excuse from their office and had to leave, but the damage is done! You have absolutely zero respect for your father!"

"Respect?" Sana let out a cold, bitter laugh, her dark eyes flashing with a dangerous, defiant fire as she looked him dead in the eye. "You already lost your respect in front of them the moment you tried to sell me like a piece of property, Papa. I told you I wouldn't be here."

Her father's face twisted into an ugly, terrifying sneer. "Don't you dare talk back to me! I am still your father! Let me tell you something, Rashi. If you continue to behave like this—wild, disobedient, and arrogant—nobody is going to marry a woman like you!"

Rashi took a slow step forward, her posture rigid, her police training radiating from her every movement. "What do you mean by a 'woman like me', Dad? Tell me."

"You know very well what I mean!" he shouted, pointing a furious finger at her face. "You have no respect for your elders! You are aggressive, you don't think about society, and you don't care at all about my respect or our family's standing in the political circle! You think that uniform makes you invincible, but you are nothing!"

Sana stared at the man who had raised her. The man who cared more about a cabinet seat than the beating heart of his own daughter. The last remnants of her childhood innocence entirely withered away and died in that exact moment.

Without saying another word, Sana turned on her heel and began marching up the grand staircase.

"Listen to my last words!" her father screamed after her, his voice echoing violently through the massive halls. "You will marry the man I choose! Do not forget, you do not have a choice! I will break you before I let you ruin my name!"

Sana reached the top landing, stepped into her bedroom, and violently slammed the heavy oak door shut behind her, the sound echoing like a gunshot through the estate. She twisted the deadbolt, leaning her forehead against the cool wood.

A single, hot tear escaped her eye, tracing a burning path down her cheek, but she quickly wiped it away. There was no time for tears. The war had officially begun.

The next three days passed a feverish, agonizing blur.

Each hour felt like a second, yet the sheer emotional strain of maintaining her massive deception made the time drag endlessly. To avoid the toxic, volatile environment of her father's wrath, and to maintain the lie she had told Woonseok about being busy with a "wedding," Sana threw herself into the most dangerous field missions the district had to offer. She commanded midnight raids, chased down suspects through narrow, unforgiving alleys, and practically lived in the back of her armored police cruiser.

She was constantly tensed. The physical danger of the missions was nothing compared to the psychological torture of her double life. The absolute need to keep Woonseok calm, while knowing she was living a painful, destructive lie, entirely consumed her.

Finally, on the evening of the third day, she returned to the empty sanctuary of her bedroom.

She was exhausted. Her body ached in places she didn't know existed. During a particularly chaotic raid the night before, she had been pushed against a rough concrete wall, leaving a series of faint, stinging scratches across her jawline and a small bandage wrapped tightly around her left wrist. But despite the physical pain, she was immensely relieved that the three-day "wedding" timeline she had fabricated was officially over.

She dropped her heavy gear onto the floor and picked up her phone from her desk.

The screen immediately lit up with a massive stream of several messages from Woonseok. She scrolled through them, her heart clenching painfully. The messages from day one were light and playful—demanding photos of her outfits and teasing her about dancing. But as the days progressed, the tone escalated into genuine, frantic, worried check-ins.

Woonseok: "Butterfly, it's been two days. Are you okay?"

Woonseok: "I know you're busy with the ceremonies, but please just send a single dot so I know you are safe."

Woonseok: "Sana, please. My patience level is literally zero right now. Call me."

Sana swallowed the thick lump of guilt in her throat. She knew she had to call him back immediately before he panicked and did something incredibly reckless.

She quickly rushed into her en-suite bathroom, turning on the harsh overhead lights. She stared at her reflection. She looked like a ghost. Her skin was pale, deep purple bags hung beneath her eyes, and the faint scratches on her cheekbone were glaringly obvious.

With trembling fingers, she opened her cosmetic bag. She carefully applied a thick layer of concealer over the scratches, blending it flawlessly until her skin looked perfectly unblemished. She added a touch of bright pink blush to her cheeks to fake a healthy, well-rested glow, and tied her hair up into a messy, casual bun to hide her exhaustion.

She stepped out of the bathroom and quickly changed out of her stiff, sweat-stained police uniform into a soft, comfortable cream-colored tunic. She pulled the long sleeves down carefully, ensuring the bandage on her wrist was completely hidden from view.

She walked back to her bed, took a deep, stabilizing breath, forced her facial muscles into a perfectly relaxed, joyful expression, and hit the video call button.

The call connected almost instantly.

Woonseok was sitting in his large, quiet, incredibly luxurious living room in Seoul. He was wearing a simple black t-shirt, his hair slightly messy, looking absolutely exhausted but intensely focused. The moment her face appeared on the screen, he sat up completely straight.

"Hey, Woon!" Sana chirped loudly, flashing her practiced, carefree smile, keeping her voice incredibly light and just slightly breathless, as if she had just run up the stairs from a massive party. "Sorry, I just got back!"

She flopped dramatically backward onto her pillows, holding the phone above her head. "You know exactly how these massive traditional weddings are. I just managed to escape the crowd and change my clothes. I'm so tired. You wouldn't believe the drama, Mr. Idol!"

Woonseok didn't smile immediately. His dark eyes scanned her face through the digital lens, searching for any signs of distress.

"I was incredibly worried, Sana," Woonseok stated, his deep voice holding a very clear, sharp note of accusation. He crossed his arms over his chest, his brow furrowed deeply. "You explicitly said you would send a picture of your outfits. Why didn't you send anything for three days? I told you my patience level was zero. I was literally a second away from calling Minho Hyung to book a flight."

"Oh! I completely forgot!" Sana exclaimed loudly, widening her eyes and lightly slapping her forehead to feign a sudden, embarrassing realization. "Woon, I'm so sorry! The dancing, the rituals, the massive amounts of food—it was absolute chaos! My phone was practically dead the entire time. Wait, wait, don't be angry. Let me send you one right now."

This is it, she thought, her heart hammering violently against her ribs. The final act of the lie.

Without breaking her cheerful expression on the camera, Sana quickly swiped her thumb across the screen, minimizing the video chat and opening her hidden, locked photo gallery. She didn't dare take a current photo—not with the heavy concealer hiding her wounds, and certainly not in her current state of deep exhaustion.

Instead, she scrolled back exactly one year.

She found it. A pristine, brilliantly lit, and absolutely unblemished photo of herself from a Diwali party last year. In the photograph, she was standing gracefully in front of a beautifully decorated archway, wearing the exact same heavy golden lehenga she had shown him three days ago. Her hair was perfectly styled, her skin was glowing, and the delicate gold kamarband rested flawlessly against her waist.

It was the perfect, entirely clean deception.

She tapped the photo, hit share, and sent it directly into their chat.

She brought the video call application back up, pushing the bright, teasing smile back onto her face. "There! Sent it! Do you see it? The magnificent golden lehenga in all its absolute glory. And look closely, I wore the kamarband too, just specifically to make you jealous."

Woonseok's phone chimed. He looked down at his screen, opening the image.

Sana held her breath, watching him intently. For a terrifying second, the silence in the digital space was deafening. If he noticed the background was slightly different, if he noticed her hair was styled differently than when she had tried it on in her room... it would all be over.

But Woonseok didn't see the discrepancies. He only saw the woman he loved, looking like a radiant, untouched goddess.

A massive, visible wave of absolute relief washed over his handsome face, instantly replacing the dark lines of worry and stress. His tense shoulders finally dropped, and he let out a long, shaky exhale.

The deception had worked perfectly.

"Wow..." Woonseok breathed softly, his deep voice completely full of a reverent admiration and a fierce, possessive certainty. "That is beautiful. You look exactly like I imagined, Butterfly. Perfect. And that jewelry... it is exactly where it should be."

He locked his phone screen and looked back up at the camera, finally allowing a genuine, devastatingly warm smile to completely surface on his face. He leaned closer to the lens, his dark eyes sparkling with affection.

"Alright, you are forgiven for the silence," Woonseok conceded softly. "Now, tell me everything. Did you survive all the jealous stares? How were the aggressive dance partners? Tell me every single detail. And do not leave out the details of the food. I'm waiting."

"Yeahh," Sana sighed happily, leaning back deeply against the soft pillows of her bed. She let the sheer, physical exhaustion of her real life bleed into her voice, allowing it to feel safe now that he believed the lie.

"The food was absolutely amazing, you know," Sana continued, staring at the ceiling as she spun a beautiful, fabricated reality out of thin air. "I ate so much. Endless platters of sweets, spicy curries, everything."

She lifted her free hand and playfully pulled at her own cheeks with her fingers, exaggerating the effect to make him laugh. "See? I literally think I became a little fatter from all the feasting," she joked playfully, desperately trying to sell the image of pure, unbridled celebration.

"And yes," Sana continued, turning her head back to the camera and launching into the detailed description he had requested, carefully keeping the details broad, cheerful, and entirely harmless. "I danced a lot! Like, literally until my feet were numb! I danced with my friends, and yeah, I danced with some guys, too. But don't worry, Mr. Jealous Idol, they are just old friends from college. And some were just completely unknown guests who jumped into the circle. I was perfectly safe."

She gave him a reassuring, incredibly warm smile, desperately trying to convey the absolute peace and normalcy of the event.

"It was just a massive, loud, joyful distraction, Woon," Sana said softly, her voice carrying a profound, hidden truth. "It was exactly what I needed after the heavy stress of the mission last week... Now, enough about my boring, chaotic wedding adventures. Tell me about you. Tell me about your new music video shoot."

Woonseok watched her intently through the screen. The deep worry lines around his beautiful eyes finally smoothed out completely as he listened to her cheerful, energetic narrative. The visual confirmation of the pristine old photo, combined seamlessly with the detailed, happy story, had done its job flawlessly.

He believed the battle was entirely over. He believed his beautiful Butterfly was simply reveling in the spoils of a normal, joyful civilian life.

"First of all, you look incredibly beautiful. You are definitely not fat, Butterfly, you look exactly the same—cute and beautiful," Woonseok stated firmly, shaking his head at her cheek-pulling antics, his words inadvertently praising an image from a year ago—a complete lie.

He rested his chin on his hands, a playful, challenging spark reigniting in his dark eyes.

"And secondly... I am very glad you danced and had fun. But I still firmly stand by my original threat," Woonseok declared, his deep voice dropping into that dark, possessive purr that always made her stomach flip. "I reserve the right to be intensely jealous of every single one of those unknown guys, simply on principle. How dare they look at my girl?"

Sana let out a bright, echoing laugh that entirely masked the sound of her heart slowly, inevitably breaking into pieces. She stared at the brilliant, shining star on her screen, cementing his smile into her memory for the dark days to come.

The track was a torrent of sound—dark, visceral, and laced with a frantic, pulsing energy. It wasn't about a fleeting crush or a commercial fantasy; it was a devastatingly beautiful, ferocious anthem about his first love.

As the lyrics hit the first chorus, the true, naked meaning became clear: it was a vow. A solemn promise that resonated with the intensity of their final goodbye. The music spoke of separation and immense distance, but the lyrics burned with defiant loyalty.

"...and when the light goes out, and you are lost and alone in this cold silence," his voice rang out, raw and vulnerable, "...I will be there for you. I will find you in every universe, in every single life."

I couldn't move. I closed my eyes, letting the sound wash over me, recognizing every passionate nuance—the desperation, the longing, the possessive love—that he had poured into this final mix. It wasn't just his music; it was his heart laid bare, a public, coded confession meant only for me.

When I opened them, I saw him on the screen. He saw my face, illuminated by the soft light of his phone, and he watched the tears I couldn't stop. The music suddenly felt too loud, too close, too honest.

My tears came out, tracing hot, silent paths down my cheeks. I tried desperately to control it, biting down hard on my lip, but the floodgates were open. The music and the pure, unwavering dedication in his eyes shattered my professional composure.

Deep down, beneath the surface of the silent admiration, I was screaming. "Whyyyyyyyy?" The silent complaint tore through my mind.

Why did you have to love me with such perfect, all-consuming devotion? Why did you make yourself the absolute truth of my life, when I am forced to be the villain in yours? Why, when destiny is demanding that I push you away, do you write a song that makes it impossible to leave you alone?

I snatched the headphones off, the silence rushing back, heavy and suffocating. I looked at Woonseok, who was still wearing his earbuds, his expression now completely heartbroken, knowing exactly what his music had revealed.

He didn't need to ask if I liked it. The tears were the answer. The song wasn't just a hit; it was a tragic, beautiful confirmation of the impossible choice awaiting me.

I tore the earbuds from my ears, the sudden return to silence shocking my system. I furiously wiped my tears with the heel of my hand, desperate to regain control before the confession in his song completely undid me.

He pulled his own earbuds out, his face etched with concern and the raw honesty of the artist who had just exposed his soul.

"Sana," he began, his voice barely a whisper. "The song—"

"Woon, it's... I..." I struggled to find the right words, the necessary lie to deflect the depth of his declaration. The truth—this song makes my father's mandate impossible—was too dangerous to utter.

"It's incredible," I forced out, reverting instantly to the language of his career, the language that protected him. I managed to summon a shaky, wet smile. "This is what I can't explain. Your fans will love this. It's going to be a global phenomenon. It's beautiful."

I avoided his searching gaze, focusing instead on the space just above his head. I praised the product to deny the personal agony it caused.

"The way you captured that... that intensity," I continued, speaking quickly to prevent him from breaking through my guard. "It's genius. It's exactly the sound you needed for the tour. You did it, Woon. You made something truly lasting."

I desperately hoped that praising the global genius would distract him from the private, painful meaning of the track.

I took a sharp, steadying breath, the image of my father's uncompromising face and the weight of the white lehenga driving me forward. I couldn't allow his song to make him vulnerable; I had to prepare him for the inevitable cut.

"Woon," I said, my voice softening, yet laced with a nervous tremor. "Can I ask you something?"

He immediately grew still, the artist's relief evaporating, replaced by the deep-seated concern of the man who knew my silences too well. "Yes, Butterfly."

I swallowed hard, forcing the dangerous words out. "I'm sorry for saying this, but don't really mean it," I began, the lie tasting like ash. "It's just... if the situation changes, Woon. If, eventually, it doesn't work—I mean, us..."

I trailed off, unable to complete the sentence, the mere suggestion of our failure feeling like a betrayal. I rushed to finish, focusing on the only thing I truly wanted to protect: his life, his art, his world.

"Um... if some situation came," I continued, meeting his gaze with agonizing honesty, "I wanted you to promise me that you will never spoil anything of your work. Your career, your reputation, your music. You will protect your career."

The final sentence was the most painful command yet.

Woonseok didn't shout. He didn't argue. He simply stared, the color draining from his face, leaving his eyes impossibly dark and wide. He understood instantly. This wasn't about a hypothetical future; this was about a present, non-negotiable threat I was facing right now.

His lips parted, but for a long moment, no sound came out. The easy flow of conversation had been replaced by a terrifying, absolute silence.

Finally, he spoke, his voice dangerously low, stripped of all warmth and celebrity charm—it was the raw sound of a man who realized his world was crumbling.

"What situation, Sana?" he demanded, the question a quiet, terrifying threat. "What did your father say? You are not asking me for a contingency plan; you are telling me you are being forced to choose an exit strategy."

He leaned into the camera, his expression transforming into one of fierce, wounded rage. "I just wrote a song that promised to find you in every universe, and your first thought is the terms of my surrender? Do you think my work means more to me than you do?"

"No," he answered himself, his jaw tight. "You don't get to ask me to prioritize my fame over you, Sana. Not after all of this. I told you: I will burn down my entire world before I let them take you. Tell me what they are threatening you with."

"Nooo!" I cried out, the denial sharp and immediate. I frantically shook my head, my tears now flowing freely again, unable to withstand the sheer force of his wounded accusation. "They didn't say anything! Nothing!"

I was lying, and he knew it, but I clung desperately to the shield of falsehood. I had to make him believe the threat came from within me, not from the outside world.

"Woon," I whispered, the sound thick with a pain that was becoming unbearable. "It's just... you wrote this in my entire life! Till now! I think I don't deserve this much love. I don't deserve this beautiful song, this promise to find me everywhere. I'm just an officer. You're an Idol. You can't put your whole world on the line for something so risky."

I looked at him, my eyes pleading. "And please, I want a promise, too, of yours."

Woonseok's face was a mask of cold fury and profound heartbreak. His jaw was set so tightly I could see the muscle twitching. The gentle Idol was gone, replaced by a desperate, cornered man.

"You don't get to tell me what you deserve," he said, his voice dangerously low, each word sharp and separate. "And you certainly don't get to insult my love by claiming it's too risky. Risk is irrelevant when the reward is the only thing that makes the world spin."

He stared at me, his gaze scorching. "Fine," he conceded, the word a reluctant growl. "You want a promise? I will give you a promise, Officer Sana."

He leaned into the camera, his voice dropping into a solemn, irrevocable vow. "I promise you this: If you ever walk away from me, if you ever try to execute this 'exit strategy' for the sake of my career, I will not let you. I will not compromise my work, no. But I will use the entire weight of my fame, my money, and my position to find you, to expose the truth, and to destroy whatever meaningless contract or rule forces you into that choice."

"I will protect my art," he finished, his eyes blazing with absolute certainty. "But you are my reason for having that art. And I promise you, I will never choose a world where you are not waiting for me. I will find you, in every universe, just like the song says. Now, you tell me the truth about what your family is forcing you to do."

I closed my eyes, absorbing the shattering force of his promise. The depth of his loyalty was my greatest weakness, and his refusal to surrender was the final confirmation that my deception had to be absolute. I couldn't allow his love to destroy his life.

I opened my eyes, the tears instantly dried by a chilling resolve. I forced the frantic emotion deep down, replacing it with the practiced ease of deflection.

"I wish I could hug you right now," I said, the quiet sincerity of the statement masking the lie. I managed to conjure a wet, yet genuine, smile. "But since I can't..."

I gave a dismissive, airy wave of my hand, shaking off the weight of the last five minutes. "Don't worry. Everything is fine. I'm just overthinking you. You know, I'm an overthinker."

I forced a light, dismissive laugh, making the entire heavy conversation sound like a moment of female hysteria, easily dismissed. "Hearing that song, and I just spiral into these 'what if' scenarios. You know me, Woon. Always planning for the worst-case scenario. It's the Officer in me."

I tilted my head, my eyes pleading with him to accept the easy out. "It's nothing real. It's just my brain being annoying. We're fine. Promise."

Woonseok watched me, his gaze still fiercely skeptical. He knew the 'Officer' explanation was a convenient shield, but he also recognized the finality in my tone. The sudden shift from terror to dismissive laughter was a clear signal that the conversation was now over, enforced by my emotional distance. He knew he wouldn't get the truth now.

He finally nodded, the movement slow and reluctant. "Fine, Butterfly," he conceded, the word edged with a profound weariness. "You are an overthinker. But my promise stands, whether the threat is real or just a scenario in your head. Now, go get some rest. And call me the moment you wake up." 

"You too," I said, my voice barely a whisper, the final syllable of the lie fading into the phone. "You need to take rest. Goodnight."

I ended the call instantly.

The screen went black, and the sound of my own ragged breath was the only noise in the room. I dropped the phone onto the bed, then collapsed backward onto the pillows, staring up at the ceiling. The enforced composure shattered completely. My eyes immediately filled with tears—hot, silent streams of grief and fear.

I was paralyzed, overwhelmed by the crushing weight of the future. The fear was a cold dread twisting in my stomach: What would happen in the future?

The decision that had started as a tactical escape was solidifying into a terrible necessity. The intention of going away, of creating a distance so absolute that he could never follow, was getting stronger. It was the only way to save his career from my father and his world from my duty.

"I don't know," I whispered, rubbing my temples with trembling fingers. "My gut is saying something big is coming." A confrontation that would demand the ultimate sacrifice. 

Thousands of miles away, in the luxurious silence of his apartment, Woonseok slowly lowered his phone. He didn't drop it; he placed it gently on the table, treating it like a fragile relic. His eyes were wide open, tense, and utterly sleepless.

He knew the sound of my lie. He knew the forced cheer, the abrupt ending, the frantic, dismissive laughter—they were all layers of armor I had erected to hide the truth.

He didn't believe the "overthinker" excuse for a second. The music, the question of separation, the visible tears, the defensive way I had parried his questions about my family—it all added up to a single, terrifying conclusion.

He knew something was wrong, something is not right, but I was not telling him.

Woonseok pushed himself up from the sofa. He walked to the vast glass wall, staring out at the city lights that mocked his solitude. He ran a hand over his tired face, the image of my tear-streaked face vivid in his mind.

"You want me to prioritize my work?" he thought, the silent question burning with defiance. "I will show you, Sana, that my work is now entirely devoted to anticipating your danger."

He grabbed his laptop, his exhaustion forgotten, replaced by a fierce, electric energy. He wasn't going to sleep. He was going to spend the night working—not on choreography, but on logistics, on research, on finding every hidden lever of power his fame provided. He was going to find out what was happening to his Butterfly, even if she refused to give him the map. His vigil had begun. 

More Chapters