Cherreads

Chapter 9 - Chapter 8: The Paladin's Objection

The woman arrived on a Tuesday.

Solomon knew something was coming before she did, the household had a specific quality of tension in the hour before an uncomfortable visitor, different from the tension before a pleasant one. Pleasant visitors made the staff move faster. Uncomfortable ones made them move carefully, the way people move around something fragile they have been told not to break.

He was at the upstairs window with his grammar text when the carriage came up the drive.

No house colours. Church colours, white and gold, the Cross Anthem institutional palette, worn with the deliberateness of someone who wanted the affiliation visible before anything else about them was.

A woman stepped out.

Tall. Armoured in the ceremonial sense, not battlefield plate, the formal dress armour of a Cross Anthem Paladin, which managed to be simultaneously impractical for combat and absolutely unambiguous about what the wearer was. A sword at her hip that was not decorative. A bearing that had been built over years of absolute certainty that she was standing on the right side of every line she had ever drawn.

She looked at the estate with the expression of someone conducting an inspection they expect to find wanting.

'Paladin,' Solomon thought. 'Cross Anthem. And she did not send word ahead.

'You do not arrive unannounced at a king's estate unless you are making a point with the arrival itself.'

He found his father in the entrance hall ten minutes later.

Aldric Valdraig was wearing the expression he reserved for situations he found genuinely puzzling, the open, faintly troubled look of a man who understood people as fundamentally decent and occasionally encountered evidence that complicated this theory.

Beside him, the Paladin.

Up close she was perhaps thirty-five. Sharp features. Eyes that had the quality of someone who had decided what they were looking at before they looked at it. She was looking at Solomon now with the brief, dismissing assessment of someone who had filed child and moved on.

Solomon filed her back and said nothing.

"Lady Commander Ashton," his father said, with the careful courtesy of a man who had been raised to treat every guest as a guest regardless of circumstances, "my son, Solomon."

She nodded. A single movement. The minimum acknowledgment courtesy required.

Solomon nodded back with precisely the same economy.

'She came to talk to my father,' he thought. 'She has decided I am not relevant.

'People who decide I am not relevant are always my favourite kind of people to be in a room with.'

His father did not send him out.

This was, Solomon had long since understood, less about Aldric's awareness of Solomon's unusual qualities and more about his father's general theory that rooms were better with his son in them. Aldric Valdraig was a man who liked company and expressed this by simply not dismissing people.

Solomon took the chair in the corner.

Lady Commander Ashton sat across from his father with the posture of someone who had not come to sit comfortably.

"Your Majesty," she said. "I will be direct."

"I would appreciate that," his father said, with complete sincerity.

"The proposed construction. The structure to be built on the land adjacent to Saint Clement's." She said the word structure the way you say a word when the accurate word is one you have decided not to use. "I am here on behalf of the Order and, I would suggest, a significant portion of the Church's concerned membership, to formally register our objection."

Aldric's expression shifted, not to defensiveness, not to irritation. To genuine confusion. The confusion of a man revisiting a problem he thought was already solved.

"I arranged the matter with Cardinal Beaumont," he said. "Three weeks ago. He raised no objection."

"Cardinal Beaumont," Lady Commander Ashton said, with a precision that communicated exactly what she thought of Cardinal Beaumont's judgment without saying it, "does not speak for the Order."

"The Cardinal speaks for the Church in Britain," Aldric said. Still patient. Still genuinely puzzled. "I understood that to be the relevant authority on a question involving Church-adjacent land."

"There are questions," she said, "that exceed administrative authority."

'She is telling my father,' Solomon thought from the corner, 'that she has a higher authority than the Cardinal. She is not wrong, technically, the Order sits outside the standard Church hierarchy, reports directly to someone. I do not know the Cross Anthem institutional structure well enough yet.

'But she is also using that higher authority to overturn an arrangement my father made in good faith with the person he reasonably believed was the correct authority.

'My father is confused because he followed the correct process. She is here because she does not accept the process produced the correct result.

'Those are two different arguments and she is treating them as one.'

"The people in question," Aldric said, "came from Al-Andalus. They lost their homes. Several lost family members. They have been camped outside the city for six weeks in conditions I would not consider acceptable for anyone, let alone people who came here seeking refuge." He was patient. He was always patient. "I am providing them shelter. The mosque is part of providing shelter, a place where people can practise their faith is not a luxury. It is a basic dignity."

"There are suitable locations further from—"

"There are not," Aldric said. And something shifted slightly in his voice, not anger, something quieter than anger. The voice of a man who had already thought about this thoroughly and was not going to be moved by the argument he had already addressed. "I looked. The land beside Saint Clement's is the only plot within reasonable distance of where the community is housed that has adequate space and is not currently in use for another purpose. I checked this personally."

"The proximity to the church—"

"Is considerable," Aldric said. "There is a full street between them and open ground beyond that. Cardinal Beaumont walked the land with me. He agreed the proximity was not a pastoral concern."

Lady Commander Ashton's jaw tightened by a fraction.

'She did not expect him to have done the work,' Solomon noted. 'She came prepared to argue that it was too close. He has already measured it. He has the Cardinal's agreement on record.

'She is revising her approach in real time.

'She is not bad at this. She is just dealing with a man who is better prepared than she assumed he would be.

'My father has one move and it is thoroughness. He does not outmaneuver people. He simply does everything so carefully that outmaneuvering him requires you to argue against his actual position rather than the position you assumed he held.

'It works surprisingly often.'

"Your Majesty." She set her hands on her knees. A deliberate reset. "I will speak plainly."

"I have been hoping for that," Aldric said.

"These people, the refugees from Al-Andalus, I do not dispute their suffering. I do not dispute your right to offer them shelter." A pause. Each word placed with care. "What I dispute is the permanent establishment of a mosque on British soil. Within sight of a Christian church. In the capital." She held his gaze. "Britain is a Christian kingdom."

Aldric looked at her.

He was quiet for a moment.

"Britain," he said, "is a kingdom with Christian people in it. And Jewish people. And now, as of six weeks ago, Muslim people as well. And it has always been my understanding that a king's obligation is to all the people in his kingdom, not only the ones who share his faith."

"Your Majesty—"

"I worship at Saint Clement's every Sunday," Aldric said. "I have done so my entire adult life. I have a great deal of respect for the Church and for the tradition it carries. I also have six hundred people sleeping in inadequate shelter in the cold who have done nothing except survive something terrible." He paused. "I do not think God requires me to choose between those two things. And Cardinal Beaumont agreed with me."

Lady Commander Ashton looked at him with an expression that had moved past disagreement into something harder.

'She came here expecting a negotiation,' Solomon thought. 'She is leaving with a refusal. And the refusal is wrapped so thoroughly in genuine decency that she cannot find the edge to argue against.

'She is not wrong that she disagrees. She is finding out that disagreeing with my father is different from winning an argument with him, because he is not making an argument. He is simply describing what he is going to do and why, in terms that are very difficult to characterize as wrong.

'She is angry.

'The anger is looking for a place to land and not finding one.'

Her eyes moved to Solomon.

Briefly. The second assessment, longer than the first.

'She is recalibrating,' he thought. 'She is looking at the child in the corner who has said nothing and deciding, slightly too late, whether he has been listening.

'He has been listening.

'He always listens.'

She looked back at Aldric.

"This is not finished," she said. Controlled. Precise.

"My door is always open," Aldric said, with the warm and genuine hospitality of a man who had completely won an argument without noticing he was in one.

She left.

Solomon watched from the window as she crossed to the carriage, her back straight, her stride unchanged, carrying herself with the careful dignity of someone who had absorbed a blow and was making sure nobody saw it land.

The carriage moved down the drive and turned out of sight.

"Well," his father said, from behind him. "That was unpleasant."

"Yes," Solomon said.

"I think she's a good person," Aldric said, with the thoughtful tone of a man working something out. "I genuinely do. I think she cares about something real. I just think the thing she's using it to justify is—" He trailed off. "Not right. Not as right as she thinks it is."

'He is not wrong,' Solomon thought. 'She came from a tradition that has spent centuries defining itself partly by what it is not. The Cross Anthem in its pure theological form, Grace, the Incarnation, the radical claim that divine love is freely given, has nothing in it that requires hostility to a mosque on British soil.

'But traditions accumulate history. And the history of the Christian tradition in Iberia, specifically, has been a long war. You do not fight a long war without the war becoming part of what you are.

'She is not the tradition. She is the tradition plus several centuries of a specific conflict.

'There is a difference. My father sees it without having the language for it.

'I have the language and no power to do anything with it yet.

'Yet.'

"The mosque will go ahead?" Solomon asked.

"The mosque will go ahead," Aldric said, with the complete calm of a man who had made a decision three weeks ago and had not found a reason to unmake it. "Cardinal Beaumont has the plans. Construction begins in spring."

He patted Solomon's shoulder and went to find his secretary.

Solomon stayed at the window.

Al-Andalus. Six hundred people who had lost their homes to a war that, in his previous life, had ended two and a half centuries before he was born. In this world that war was still turning. The Iberian kingdoms still pushing. The Muslim communities of Iberia still losing ground, street by street, city by city, the long slow arithmetic of a conflict that called itself holy and produced the specific kind of displacement that made people walk until they ran out of land.

They had run out of land at the English Channel.

And on the other side was a king who had looked at six hundred cold and homeless people and thought: I have land. I have resources. This is a solved problem.

'That is what he is,' Solomon thought. 'That is precisely what he is. And Lady Commander Ashton arrived with her objection and her Church colours and her straight back, and she was no match for him because she came prepared to argue against selfishness and he is not selfish.

'She had no move against genuine decency.

'Nobody does.

'That is why he is so useful.

'And so dangerous to plan around.

'Because a man who operates from genuine decency is unpredictable in ways that a man operating from calculation never is. You can predict calculation. Calculation always goes somewhere.

'Decency goes wherever it is needed.

'Which means my father will keep doing things like this.

'And I will keep finding out about them after the fact.

'And rearranging the plan accordingly.

'For the rest of my life, probably.'

He watched the empty drive for a moment longer.

'Al-Andalus,' he thought. 'Six hundred people.

'There will be more.

'There are always more.'

He went upstairs to his grammar text.

He had eleven new words from today's session to memorize before dinner.

He opened the book.

The first word was al-adl.

Justice.

He looked at it for a moment.

Then he began.

More Chapters