Cherreads

Chapter 34 - Things We Can’t Take Back

The door shut with a sharp sound.

Emily was still trying to regain her balance when she looked up and saw Lucas… and Noah.

Tied.

Injured.

And, for the first time, completely defenseless.

— No… — she whispered, bringing her hand to her mouth. — No, this isn't happening…

— Emily, look at me — Lucas said, firm, even with his voice still heavy. — Are you okay?

She took a second to answer, as if she was still trying to understand if this was real.

— I… I think so…

"I think."

Not a good answer.

She took a few slow steps into the room, looking around as if the place might swallow her at any moment.

— What is this place…?

Noah let out a low, tired laugh.

— Our worst mistake.

Emily stopped.

— What?

Lucas closed his eyes for a moment.

— It was here.

Silence.

— We brought him here… that night.

Her expression changed.

It wasn't just fear.

It was recognition.

— No… — she murmured, taking a step back. — No, we didn't stay here long…

— It was enough — Noah said, flatly.

Emily shook her head, nervous.

— We thought he was dead!

— And that justified leaving? — Noah shot back.

— Don't start — Lucas cut in, but it was too late.

Something had broken.

Again.

Emily turned to Noah, her eyes shining with tears.

— You were there too! Don't act like you're better than us!

— I never said I was — he replied, his voice lower now — …but at least I'm not pretending it wasn't my fault.

That hung in the air.

Heavy.

Lucas took a deep breath, trying to stay in control.

— This is exactly what he wants.

Emily ran a hand over her face, nervous.

— Who?

— Him — Lucas replied. — Don't you see? He wants this… wants us like this.

Divided.

Guilt against guilt.

Silence against silence.

Emily stood still for a moment, absorbing it.

And then… she nodded, slowly.

— So what do we do?

Lucas opened his mouth to answer—

But stopped.

Because, for the first time…

He didn't have an answer.

Before he could say anything, a sound echoed through the room.

A click.

They all looked at the same time.

A small speaker in the corner crackled.

And then—

His voice.

— I was waiting for this.

Emily froze.

— What is that…?

— He's listening — Noah said, looking around.

— Always have been — the voice replied, calm. — You just took too long to realize.

Lucas clenched his jaw.

— What do you want now?

A brief silence.

As if he were smiling on the other side.

— I want you to talk.

— We are talking — Emily said, nervous.

— No — he replied. — I want the truth.

The air shifted.

— What truth? — Lucas asked.

— The one you never said.

Silence.

No one spoke.

— Then let's help — the voice continued. — Emily…

She flinched slightly.

— What…?

— Tell him.

Lucas's heart tightened.

— Tell me what?

Her breath faltered.

— No…

— Tell him — the voice repeated, firmer now. — Or I will.

Lucas looked at her.

— Emily… what is he talking about?

She didn't answer.

Her eyes avoided his.

— Emily.

Silence.

— I'm waiting — the voice said.

She closed her eyes.

As if gathering courage.

Or accepting she had no choice.

— That night… — she started, almost a whisper — …wasn't the first time he knew.

Lucas frowned.

— What do you mean?

She swallowed hard.

— He already knew before.

The world seemed to slow down.

— Before what?

She opened her eyes.

And this time…

She didn't look away.

— Before you.

Silence.

Heavy.

Impossible to ignore.

— I… — Lucas's voice came out lower than he wanted — …I don't understand.

But deep down…

He was starting to.

— He saw us — Emily said. — Long before that night.

Noah went still.

— And he didn't say anything?

— Not at first — she replied. — He just… watched.

A chill ran down Lucas's spine.

— Why?

Emily hesitated before answering.

— Because he wanted more than just telling.

Silence returned.

But now…

It was different.

More dangerous.

— The video… — Lucas said slowly — …wasn't made that night.

Emily shook her head.

— No.

— Then when?

She hesitated.

And then—

— Months before.

That shattered whatever logic was left.

— So this… — Lucas murmured — …has been happening for a long time…

— Yes.

The speaker crackled again.

— Now we're getting somewhere — the voice said, satisfied.

Lucas looked up, furious.

— You planned this.

— I waited — he corrected.

— This is sick.

— No — the voice replied, calm — …this is patience.

Emily took a step back.

— He never just wanted to expose us…

Lucas finished, almost without realizing:

— He wanted control.

Silence.

— Exactly — the voice said.

And then…

Another click.

The light flickered.

Once.

Twice.

And went out.

Darkness.

Total.

— Emily? — Lucas called.

— I'm here — she answered, closer now.

— Stay together — Noah said, tense.

And then—

A sound.

Footsteps.

Inside the room.

But no one had entered.

Or…

had they?

Lucas's breath caught.

Because now—

He no longer knew where he was.

🖤 Poem — Emily

I tried to hide the truth

like it would fade away

but secrets grow in silence

and never choose to stay

and the love I tried to bury…

found its way

More Chapters