St. Mary's Church Yard — July 2010, Evening
The fire pit behind the church had been built for youth group marshmallow nights and sat unused since Coach Buzzer's last cookout three summers ago, according to the plaque on its stone rim: DONATED BY THE FERDINANDO FAMILY, 2004. Somebody had cleaned it out. Somebody had stacked firewood beside it. And somebody — Eric, based on the grocery bag containing four different brands of marshmallows because he couldn't decide — had organized an impromptu last-evening gathering for the families before tomorrow's lakehouse departure.
The fire caught on the third match. I'd built the pyramid structure the BBQ skill suggested — kindling center, logs stacked loose for airflow — and the flames climbed with the slow confidence of a fire that knew it had somewhere to go. The church yard filled with the smell of woodsmoke and the sound of children discovering that marshmallows and sticks were a combination older than civilization and twice as satisfying.
Becky Feder caught her marshmallow on fire within thirty seconds. The scream was pure delight — the reaction of a five-year-old who'd just discovered that food could be dramatic. Greg, her older brother, demonstrated the slow-rotation technique with the seriousness of a teenager who'd found something he could be an expert at. Keithie attempted to toast two marshmallows simultaneously and lost both to the fire. Andre McKenzie sat beside Charlotte and they argued about optimal browning temperature with the intensity of their father's observational precision.
The adults settled into lawn chairs arranged in a loose circle. Not the formal wake seating — something more organic, chairs angled toward the fire and toward each other, the unconscious geometry of people who'd decided to be together rather than being held together by obligation.
I'd found the guitar in the choir closet that afternoon. An old Martin acoustic, well-maintained, the kind of instrument that lived in churches because someone had donated it and nobody had the heart to throw it away. I'd asked Nora's permission — a calculated move, approaching her on practical grounds rather than personal ones. She'd looked at the guitar, looked at me, and said "It's out of tune" with the neutral tone of a woman offering a fact instead of a judgment.
I'd tuned it in the parking lot. The Basic Guitar skill made the tuning process instinctive — my ear identified the pitches and my fingers turned the pegs with the quiet confidence of someone who'd done this a thousand times. The skill was Tier 0, campfire-grade, but the instrument was good and the evening was warm and the fire was casting the kind of light that made everything look like a memory even while it was happening.
I played quietly at first. Background music — simple chord progressions, finger-picked patterns that wove under the conversation without interrupting it. Kurt glanced over. Lenny's head turned slightly, acknowledging without commenting. Rob leaned back in his chair and closed his eyes, and the expression on his face was the one I'd first seen in his apartment three days earlier: the look of a man who was present and not measuring his distance to the exit.
Nobody asked me to play a song. I played one anyway.
The opening chords of "Take It Easy" by the Eagles rolled off the Martin's strings with the easy, loping rhythm of a song built for exactly this kind of evening. I'd heard it in 1978, bleeding through a gymnasium's PA system, a radio accidentally left on that had accidentally changed the shape of a conversation that had accidentally changed the shape of thirty years. The song wasn't rare. It was the definition of a classic rock staple — ubiquitous, overplayed, the kind of song that wallpapered dentist offices and grocery stores across America.
But here, beside a fire, three days after burying the man who used to hum it while he cooked dinner, the song landed differently.
Lenny stopped talking. His hand, which had been gesturing to Roxanne about lakehouse logistics, dropped to his knee. His eyes found the fire and stayed there, and something behind them went very still — the specific stillness of a man hearing a sound that connected to a memory he couldn't quite locate but could feel in his chest.
Rob leaned forward. The chair creaked. His hands clasped between his knees and his eyes opened and they were wet.
Eric's mouth moved. Forming words. The lyrics, half-remembered, mumbled at a volume only Sally could hear. She put her hand on his arm and didn't say anything.
Kurt's knee stopped bouncing. For the first time in the four days I'd known him, Kurt McKenzie's knee was perfectly still.
Marcus was the first to sing. Not loud — Marcus didn't do loud anymore, or maybe he did it differently now, the comedy redirected into a comfort that expressed itself in smaller gestures. He hummed the melody, dry and off-key, and the humming was permission. Eric joined. Then Rob. Then Lenny, whose voice was better than it had any right to be, the talent agent revealing that he'd been around performers long enough to pick up their habits.
Kurt didn't sing. Kurt sat with his still knee and his watchful eyes and his silence, and the silence was its own kind of participation — the observational intelligence of a man who knew that some moments were better witnessed than performed.
By the second verse, five grown men were singing along badly and beautifully and not caring who heard, and the children had stopped toasting marshmallows to stare at their fathers with the confused, fascinated expression of kids seeing adults be un-adult for the first time.
I played through to the end. The final chord hung in the air alongside the smoke and the firelight. Then silence. The good kind — the kind that follows something real, where nobody wants to be the first to break it because breaking it means admitting it's over.
"Buzzer used to hum that," Eric said. Quiet. To nobody and everybody.
"Every Sunday," Rob said. "While he grilled."
Lenny nodded. His jaw was working. He didn't speak.
Footsteps behind me. The specific cadence I'd learned to identify over four days: deliberate, unhurried, clipboard-energy even without the clipboard.
Nora settled into the empty chair beside mine. Not across the circle. Beside. The proximity was a statement, even if the statement was small.
"He hummed that while he cooked dinner," she said. Her voice was low enough that only I could hear. "Every Sunday. Standing over the grill in the backyard with a beer he'd nurse for two hours and that song on repeat. He had a record of it. Vinyl. Played it so many times the grooves wore smooth."
I kept my eyes on the guitar strings. Meeting her gaze would break whatever fragile architecture had been assembled by the song and the fire and the four days of suspicion that were, for the first time, competing with something warmer.
"Sounds like a good man," I said.
"He was the best man I've ever known." A pause. The fire popped. "I still don't know who you are, Holden."
"I know."
"But you play his song like you know what it means."
"I'm learning."
She stood up. Walked back toward the church. I watched her go in my peripheral vision and saw her hand rise once, quickly, to her face — wiping something away before anyone could see. Nora Buzzer grieved the way she did everything else: efficiently, privately, on her own schedule.
The fire burned lower. Marshmallows were consumed. Becky fell asleep in Lenny's lap with chocolate on her chin. Marcus told a joke about s'mores that was perfectly timed and genuinely funny and that the old Marcus — the pre-mission Marcus, the armor-Marcus — would have delivered the same way but for different reasons. This Marcus told it because the fire was warm and the joke was there and making people laugh on a Tuesday evening was a gift, not a shield.
Roxanne watched me from across the fire. The evaluating eyes hadn't dimmed — if anything, the guitar had sharpened them. A stranger who grilled and cooked and now played the exact right song at the exact right moment was either a remarkably thoughtful person or a remarkably calculated one, and Roxanne Chase-Feder had built a career identifying the difference.
She's going to be a problem at the lakehouse. She's going to be a problem everywhere, because Roxanne doesn't stop watching until she has her answer, and the answer she's looking for is the one I can never give her.
Rob stood from his chair as the fire collapsed into embers. He walked over, didn't speak, and clapped me on the shoulder. The hand lingered for a beat — the specific weight of a man who communicated through touch because words had failed him too many times.
"Good song," he said.
"Good night."
"Yeah." Rob adjusted his toupee — a habit, not a fix. The thing was straight for once. "It is."
The families drifted toward their cars. The fire died to coals. The Martin guitar rested against my chair, still warm from my hands, and the church yard settled into the quiet of a place that had done its job and was ready to be empty.
My phone buzzed.
[Stat Update: CTM +1 (successful musical performance with genuine emotional impact). SRE +1 (voluntary trust signal from high-resistance target: Nora Buzzer).]
[New Averages: TST 15, CIN 13, SRE 20, CTM 12, PIN 10, SSY 8 = Average 13.0]
[Rank E: CONFIRMED AND STABLE.]
The gap was closed. Rank E, solid, no longer hanging by decimal points. The system pulsed green once and settled back to amber, content with the progress, patient with the pace.
Tomorrow was the lakehouse. Tomorrow was the beginning of everything the system had been building toward — the weekend where five families reconnected, where children learned to swim and play and exist without screens, where the rope swing and the basketball hoop and the lake itself became the setting for whatever the remaining forty-four bugs looked like up close.
I returned the Martin to the choir closet. Closed the case. The strings still hummed faintly from the last chord, the sound dying so slowly it was almost breathing.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!