The throne room blazed with light as Thranduil's court assembled to witness the interrogation of captured prisoners. Torches lined the walls, their flames reflecting off the gold and gemstones that adorned the Elvenking's antlered throne. Every noble of consequence had claimed their position, eager to watch the spectacle of Dwarves brought before Elvish judgment.
Legolas stood in the shadows near the eastern wall, close enough to observe but distant enough to go unremarked. The position was deliberate—he needed to see without being seen, to watch the interaction play out while gauging opportunities for subtle intervention.
The doors opened.
Thirteen Dwarves entered in chains, their expressions ranging from defiant to exhausted to barely-contained fury. Guards flanked them, weapons ready, though the prisoners showed no signs of attempting escape. They were too pragmatic for futile gestures.
And there, at the front of the procession, walked Thorin Oakenshield.
Legolas had seen him from a distance during the patrol, but proximity revealed details that observation couldn't capture. The Dwarf moved with the bearing of royalty despite his chains—shoulders back, head high, eyes that swept the assembled Elves with contempt barely held in check. He was shorter than the guards who escorted him, broader in the shoulder, and possessed a gravity that made height seem irrelevant.
King Under the Mountain, Legolas thought. Or he will be, if he survives what's coming.
Thranduil rose from his throne as the Dwarves were arranged before the dais. The Elvenking descended three steps—a calculated display of engagement without equality—and studied his prisoners with the cold patience of someone who had seen empires rise and fall.
"Thorin, son of Thráin, son of Thrór." Thranduil's voice carried through the chamber with effortless authority. "King Under the Mountain."
The title dripped with mockery. Thorin's jaw tightened, but he held his silence.
"You trespass in my realm," Thranduil continued. "You disturb the creatures of my forest. You are found lost and starving, requiring rescue by my patrols." A pause. "One might think gratitude would be appropriate."
"Gratitude." Thorin's voice was rough with barely-contained emotion. "To the Elf who watched my people burn. Who turned away when the dragon came. Who left Erebor to its fate while Smaug slaughtered my kin."
The chamber fell silent. Even the guards seemed to hold their breath.
"That ancient grief again." Thranduil's expression didn't change, but something flickered in his eyes. "You Dwarves cling to your grievances like gold to your coffers. Tell me—would you have had me sacrifice my army for a battle already lost? Would more Elvish blood have cooled your rage?"
"Your cowardice has a name. Don't dress it in strategy."
The temperature in the room seemed to drop. Legolas watched his father's face, recognizing the subtle signs of anger that others might miss—the slight tension in his jaw, the narrowing of his eyes, the way his hands had stilled at his sides.
"I could leave you in our dungeons until the world changes around you," Thranduil said softly. "Dwarves are patient. We can be more so."
"Then do it. I will not beg."
They stared at each other—two kings whose hatred ran deeper than living memory, whose conflict was a pale echo of older battles between Elf and Dwarf that had shaped the world before the sun rose.
Thranduil smiled. It was not a pleasant expression.
"My hospitality is not so easily refused. You will remain our guests until you see reason. Perhaps a few decades of reflection will improve your perspective."
He turned to the guards, dismissing the prisoners with a gesture.
Legolas moved.
"The dungeons are overcrowded."
His voice cut through the chamber, drawing every eye. Thranduil turned slowly, his expression unreadable.
"The spider attacks have filled our holding cells with survivors requiring treatment," Legolas continued, stepping forward from the shadows. "The guest quarters in the western wing are secured but comfortable. Practical concerns, Father—nothing more."
The silence that followed was different from the earlier tension. Legolas felt dozens of eyes on him, measuring, evaluating, wondering why the strange prince was intervening on behalf of Dwarven prisoners.
Thranduil's gaze held something Legolas couldn't interpret. Suspicion? Curiosity? The calculation that seemed to drive every interaction between them now?
"The guest quarters," the Elvenking repeated flatly.
"Secured, as I said. And it sends a message—we are not petty captors but reasonable hosts to those who have... strayed onto our lands." Legolas held his father's gaze. "Thorin's stubbornness will not soften regardless of where he sleeps. But our treatment of him will be remembered when circumstances change."
The unspoken implication hung in the air: circumstances will change. Erebor will fall to these Dwarves or it won't, and either way, the Woodland Realm's response to this moment will matter.
Thranduil was silent for a long moment. Then, with a gesture that conceded nothing:
"Guest quarters. Secured." His eyes remained on Legolas. "You seem invested in our prisoners' comfort, ion nín."
"I am invested in our realm's future. Sometimes kindness serves where cruelty would not."
Something flickered across Thranduil's face—too fast to read, too complex to interpret. He turned back to the guards.
"As my son suggests. Guest quarters, secured. Feed them well—we are not barbarians." A pause. "But they do not leave until Thorin sees sense."
The guards moved to comply. The Dwarves were led away, their expressions shifting from resigned to confused as they realized their imprisonment would be more comfortable than expected.
Thorin paused as he passed Legolas. Their eyes met—Dwarf and Elf, future allies in a war neither could prevent, standing in a moment that felt weighted with significance.
Thorin nodded once. A single gesture of acknowledgment. Then the guards urged him forward, and he was gone.
I just made eye contact with the future King Under the Mountain, Legolas thought, watching the procession disappear. Sixty years before I'll meet him in battle.
The thought carried a strange weight. Time moved differently here—decades felt like months to Elves who measured their lives in millennia. Thorin would reclaim his mountain, fall to gold-sickness, and die in battle. And Legolas would watch it all happen, knowing the shape of tragedy but unable to prevent it.
Small adjustments, he reminded himself. Comfortable quarters instead of dungeons. A moment of unexpected kindness. Maybe it changes nothing. Maybe it changes everything.
The court dispersed slowly, whispers following in its wake. Legolas felt the weight of observation—the traditionalists who saw his intervention as proof of his strangeness, the neutrals who wondered what game he was playing, his father who measured him with eyes that revealed nothing.
Tauriel caught his attention from across the chamber. She raised an eyebrow—the silent question of someone who'd learned to read him despite his masks.
He shook his head slightly. Later. When there are fewer eyes.
The day's business continued around them, but Legolas's thoughts had already moved elsewhere. The Dwarves would escape—Bilbo would see to that, with his ring and his courage. They would reach the Lonely Mountain. The dragon would die. The Battle of Five Armies would reshape the politics of the north.
And somewhere in all of that chaos, threads would form that led to the War of the Ring.
Watch, he told himself. Wait. Intervene where you can without breaking what must happen.
The strategy was exhausting. Every moment felt loaded with potential consequences, every choice weighted with implications that stretched across decades. He missed the simplicity of code—the clean logic of problems that had solutions, errors that could be debugged, systems that behaved according to predictable rules.
Middle-earth didn't behave according to rules. It behaved according to stories, and the stories were darker and stranger than anything he'd consumed as entertainment in another life.
Evening brought quiet to the throne room, the day's business concluded and the nobles scattered to their private intrigues. Legolas remained in the shadows, watching the empty throne, thinking about the conversation that had never quite happened.
Thranduil had granted the request. But his eyes had asked questions his voice hadn't formed. Why do you care? What do you know? What are you becoming?
Legolas had no answers. Only actions, chosen moment by moment, hoping they added up to something worthwhile.
The Inheritance Space stirred at the edge of his consciousness—a familiar pull, strengthened by weeks of regular access. New chambers had opened since his last visit. The archive was revealing itself in layers, unlocking knowledge as he proved worthy of wielding it.
Ring-craft, the pull whispered. There are archives that speak of Rings.
The thought was seductive and terrifying in equal measure. Ring-craft was Sauron's domain—the knowledge that had created the Rings of Power, that had forged the One Ring in the fires of Mount Doom. Learning it would be useful. Learning it would be dangerous.
Legolas turned away from the empty throne room and walked toward his chambers. Tomorrow would bring new challenges—the Dwarves' imprisonment, the court's suspicion, the endless pressure of expectations he couldn't meet.
But tonight, the Inheritance Space was calling. And somewhere in its ruins, knowledge waited that could make him powerful enough to face what was coming.
Or destroy him in the attempting.
Either way, he would learn.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.