The first Orc died with an arrow through its eye before it fully cleared the doorway.
Legolas's hands moved without conscious thought, nocking and loosing in a rhythm that Glorfindel's training had burned into his muscles. Three arrows, four, five—each finding a throat or a face, each buying seconds that the Fellowship desperately needed.
But seconds weren't enough.
The Orcs poured through the shattered doors like water through a broken dam, their numbers overwhelming any defense that nine could offer. Aragorn and Boromir held the doorway with steel and fury, their blades carving paths through the press of bodies. Gimli's axe rose and fell from Balin's tomb, each stroke accompanied by a cry of grief transformed into rage.
And still they came.
Legolas shifted his aim, targeting the Orcs that slipped past the warriors' defense—the ones reaching for Gandalf, for the hobbits, for Frodo with his precious burden. An arrow took an Orc in the back as it lunged for Sam. Another found the neck of a creature trying to flank Merry.
His quiver grew lighter with every shot.
"Fall back!" Gandalf's voice cut through the chaos. "To the rear door!"
The Fellowship began a fighting retreat, giving ground in exchange for lives. Legolas covered their withdrawal, his arrows buying time that couldn't be measured in any normal way. Each shaft was a heartbeat. Each kill was another breath for someone who might otherwise have died.
The sound that followed froze every combatant in place.
A roar, deeper than thunder, accompanied by the splintering of stone. Something massive was forcing its way through the doorway—something too large for an opening designed for Dwarves and Elves and Men.
The cave troll burst through in a shower of rubble.
It was enormous—twelve feet tall at least, its grey hide scarred from countless battles, its eyes small and stupid and hungry. A massive hammer swung in its grip, each casual arc capable of crushing bone to powder.
Legolas put an arrow in its eye.
The troll roared but didn't fall. Its free hand clawed at the shaft protruding from its face, tearing it free with a spray of dark blood. The wound was terrible—would have killed anything natural—but the creature was beyond such simple limitations.
Morgoth's work, Legolas thought, nocking another arrow. Twisted from something else, made to feel no pain that would stop it.
His second arrow found the troll's other eye. Still it fought, blinded now but guided by sound and smell, its hammer sweeping in deadly arcs that forced the Fellowship to scatter.
Sam was screaming. Legolas spun toward the sound and saw Frodo on the ground, the troll's hammer descending—
He couldn't reach them. Too far, too slow, too late.
The hammer struck.
Legolas felt his heart stop as Frodo crumpled beneath the blow. Sam threw himself over his master's body, sword raised against a creature that could crush him with a gesture. The troll drew back for another strike—
—and Aragorn drove his sword through its chest from behind.
The creature's roar became a gurgle. It staggered, turned, tried to reach the Ranger who'd wounded it. But Boromir was there too, hacking at its legs, bringing it to its knees. And then Legolas's arrow—his last arrow—found the base of its skull, and the cave troll finally fell.
The remaining Orcs fled.
They scattered through the doorways like roaches exposed to light, their courage broken by the troll's death and the fury of defenders who'd refused to die. In moments, the chamber was silent except for the heavy breathing of the Fellowship and the distant echo of drums.
Legolas was already moving toward Frodo. The hobbit lay motionless, Sam crouched over him with tears streaming down his face.
"He's dead," Sam sobbed. "Mr. Frodo's dead."
"No." Aragorn reached them first, his hands checking for signs of life. "He breathes. Look."
Frodo stirred, groaning, his eyes fluttering open to find the Fellowship gathered around him. His hand went to his chest—to the place where the troll's hammer had struck.
"I thought—" Sam's voice broke. "I thought you were—"
"I'm all right." Frodo sat up slowly, Legolas steadying him with a hand under his elbow. "Something... something protected me."
The mithril shirt gleamed beneath Frodo's torn clothing—Dwarvish mail worth more than the Shire itself, a gift from Bilbo that had just saved the world without anyone realizing it.
"You are full of surprises, Master Baggins," Gimli breathed.
But there was no time for wonder. The drums had resumed—deeper now, more urgent. And beneath them, something else. A sound that Legolas felt in his bones rather than heard with his ears.
Heat.
Rising from below. Ancient fury given form, climbing through depths that light had never touched.
"We must leave," Gandalf said, and his voice carried a weight that silenced all other concerns. "Now. Immediately."
They ran.
Through corridors that twisted and turned, down stairs that seemed to descend forever, past chambers whose grandeur was lost in the desperate flight. Legolas recovered arrows from Orc corpses as they passed—not enough, never enough, but better than empty hands.
The heat grew stronger with every step.
"What is it?" Boromir's voice carried confusion rather than fear. "What pursues us?"
Gandalf didn't answer. But Legolas saw the wizard's face in the pale light of his staff, and the expression there was answer enough.
He knows, Legolas realized. He knows what's coming. And he knows what it will cost.
They burst into a vast hall—pillars stretching toward a ceiling lost in darkness, their ancient stone carved with runes that spoke of ages before the world was bent. Ahead, visible in the distance, a narrow bridge spanned a chasm whose bottom couldn't be seen.
The Bridge of Khazad-dûm.
"Over the bridge!" Gandalf commanded. "Fly!"
The Fellowship ran. Legolas's Elvish speed kept him near the front, but he held back—waiting for the hobbits, ensuring that Frodo and Sam didn't fall behind. Aragorn and Boromir flanked the group, their swords ready for threats that might emerge from the darkness.
And behind them, something emerged.
Fire bloomed in the corridor they'd just fled—not ordinary fire, but flame that seemed to burn with hatred, that cast shadows reaching toward them like grasping hands. The temperature in the hall spiked, cold stone becoming warm beneath their feet.
The Balrog stepped into the light.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.