The first Uruk-hai died with an arrow through its eye.
Legolas loosed and nocked in a single fluid motion, the rhythm of combat settling over him like a familiar cloak. Glorfindel's training surfaced without thought—body positioning, target selection, the dozens of micro-adjustments that turned archery from skill into art.
A second arrow. A third. Each found its mark in the massive bodies that crashed through the undergrowth, Saruman's bred warriors falling before they could close the distance.
But there were so many.
Uruk-hai poured through the forest in numbers that defied his count—fifty at least, maybe more, their white hand marks bright against dark armor. They moved with coordination that spoke of training, of purpose, of orders that went beyond simple slaughter.
They're after the Ring, Legolas realized. This is a capture mission, not a raid.
Boromir fought beside him, his sword carving paths through enemies that got too close for arrows. The captain of Gondor moved with desperate fury, each strike carrying the weight of his guilt and the desperate need for redemption. Whatever the Ring had done to him, whatever moments of weakness had nearly broken him—he was fighting now with everything he had.
"There!" Boromir's shout cut through the chaos. "The hobbits!"
Legolas followed his gesture and saw them—Merry and Pippin backed against a boulder, their small swords drawn, facing a cluster of Uruk-hai that circled like wolves around trapped prey. The hobbits' faces showed terror but also defiance, the same stubborn courage that had carried them from the Shire to this moment.
"Protect them!" Boromir charged without waiting for response, his sword taking an Uruk-hai in the throat before the creature could react.
Legolas followed, his arrows finding targets with precision that bought Boromir the seconds he needed. One Uruk down. Two. Three. The bow sang its deadly song, each note punctuated by falling bodies.
They reached the hobbits just as the circle began to close. Boromir planted himself between the small figures and their attackers, his blade weaving a wall of steel that nothing could penetrate.
"Get behind me!" His voice carried command that brooked no argument. "Stay close!"
"Boromir—" Pippin's voice trembled. "There are so many—"
"I will not fail you." The words came out fierce, absolute, carrying echoes of the conversation in the clearing. "Not you. Not anyone. Not again."
Legolas fell into position at Boromir's flank, his bow abandoned now for the close-quarter knives that served better in this kind of fight. The Uruk-hai pressed forward in waves, their crude weapons seeking gaps in the defense that didn't exist.
For a moment—one brilliant, impossible moment—it seemed like they might hold.
Then Legolas saw him.
The Uruk captain emerged from the trees like a nightmare given flesh. Taller than the others, broader, his face marked with scars that spoke of battles survived and enemies killed. In his hands, he carried a bow—crude by Elvish standards but deadly nonetheless.
Lurtz. The name surfaced from knowledge Legolas shouldn't have, memories of a story that had played out differently.
The Uruk captain raised his bow.
Legolas moved without thinking, his own bow coming up, arrow nocked and drawn in the space between heartbeats. He released—
Too slow.
Lurtz's shaft was already flying, crossing the distance between them in the time it took Legolas's arrow to leave the string. The black-feathered bolt struck Boromir in the shoulder, spinning him half around with the impact.
Boromir grunted but didn't fall. His sword arm still worked—wounded but functional—and he turned to face the new threat with eyes that held no fear.
Lurtz nocked another arrow.
This time Legolas's shot found its mark, burying itself in the Uruk captain's bow arm. Lurtz roared with rage, the weapon dropping from his fingers. But another Uruk pressed forward, covering its captain, and in the moment of distraction—
The second arrow took Boromir in the chest.
He staggered. Blood bloomed across his tunic, spreading from the shaft that protruded just below his collarbone. His sword dipped, the weight suddenly too much for arms that had held it through countless battles.
"BOROMIR!"
Legolas's scream echoed through the forest as he fought toward his fallen ally. Two Uruk-hai fell to his knives. A third. But more pressed forward, the endless tide of bodies blocking his path.
Boromir raised his sword.
Somehow, impossibly, he raised his sword. The man who should have been dying, who had two arrows in his body and blood pouring from wounds that would kill anyone—he planted his feet and prepared to fight.
"Run." His voice came out wet, labored. "Merry. Pippin. RUN."
The hobbits stared at him with horror and grief. "We can't leave you—"
"NOW!"
Something in his voice—command or desperation or love—broke through their paralysis. Merry grabbed Pippin's arm and pulled, dragging his cousin toward a gap in the Uruk line that Boromir's last stand had created.
Lurtz advanced, his sword drawn now, blood streaming from the wound in his arm. The Uruk captain's eyes held something that might have been respect for the man who refused to fall.
Boromir met him blade to blade.
The fight was brutal and brief—a dying man against a creature bred for killing. Lurtz's strikes drove Boromir backward, each parry weaker than the last, each counter-attack failing to find its mark. Blood soaked the captain's tunic, his movements growing sluggish, his breath coming in gasps that bubbled with red.
The third arrow struck as Legolas finally broke through the last rank of Uruk-hai.
It took Boromir low, in the stomach, and this time he did fall—to his knees, his sword dropping from fingers that could no longer grip. He knelt in the blood-soaked grass, head bowed, waiting for the killing blow.
Lurtz raised his sword.
Legolas's knife took him in the throat.
The Uruk captain's eyes went wide with surprise, then empty. He toppled sideways, his blade falling harmless to the ground. Around them, the remaining Uruk-hai hesitated—their leader dead, their target scattered, the battle turning against them.
They fled.
Legolas barely noticed. He caught Boromir as the man collapsed, lowering him gently to the ground, cradling his head against the chaos that still echoed through the forest.
"I tried." Boromir's voice was barely a whisper, blood trickling from the corner of his mouth. "I tried to take the Ring."
"I know." Legolas's throat was tight. "I know. But you stopped. You let go."
"Not fast enough. Frodo—"
"Is safe. You saved him by stopping when you did. By fighting here. By giving him time to run."
Boromir's eyes found his, searching for truth. "The hobbits?"
"Escaped. They fled when you told them to." Legolas hoped it was true—he'd lost sight of Merry and Pippin in the chaos, didn't know if they'd truly gotten away or been captured in some corner of the battle he hadn't seen. But Boromir needed this. Needed to believe his sacrifice had meaning.
"Then I have not failed." The words came with something that might have been relief. "Tell them—tell my father—"
"Tell him yourself." Legolas pressed his hand against the worst of the wounds, knowing it was futile, knowing nothing could stop the blood that flowed too freely. "You'll see Gondor again. You'll see Faramir—"
"You're a poor liar, Elf." But Boromir smiled—a real smile, free of corruption, free of the Ring's shadow. "Thank you. For stopping me. For giving me this... this chance to be myself again."
Footsteps crashed through the undergrowth. Aragorn burst into the clearing, sword drawn, his eyes taking in the carnage—the dead Uruk-hai, the scattered arrows, the man dying in Legolas's arms.
"Boromir—"
"Aragorn." Boromir's hand reached up, grasping the Ranger's tunic with strength that shouldn't have remained. "I would have followed you. To the end. To whatever end."
Aragorn knelt beside them, his face carved from stone but his eyes bright with grief. "I know. I know, my friend."
"My king." The words carried reverence that the Ring had never corrupted. "My brother. My captain."
Boromir's eyes found Legolas's one last time. "You were right. Gondor's strength... was never in artifacts."
His hand fell. His eyes closed.
The captain of Gondor died with the sun on his face and friends at his side, his last battle fought not for a ring of power but for the lives of those who needed him.
Legolas held him until Aragorn gently pulled him away.
"The hobbits," Aragorn said, his voice rough. "Frodo and Sam—they've taken a boat. They're heading for Mordor alone."
"And Merry and Pippin?"
Aragorn's jaw tightened. "Scattered into the forest. The Uruk-hai were pursuing, but they broke off when we killed their captain. They might be safe. They might not."
Gimli appeared at the clearing's edge, his axe bloody, his face grim. "The enemy is retreating. For now."
Legolas looked down at Boromir's peaceful face, then at the forest where friends might be lost, then at the river where the quest continued without them.
The Fellowship was broken.
But they were not finished.
"We find the hobbits," Legolas said, his voice steady despite everything. "We honor Boromir by completing what he died defending."
Aragorn nodded slowly. "The Three Hunters."
"The Three Hunters," Gimli agreed.
They lifted Boromir's body together, carrying him to the river where he would receive the farewell he deserved. And as they walked, Legolas felt something shift in his chest—grief for a man he couldn't save, but also gratitude.
Because in the end, Boromir had saved himself.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.