Chapter 83: Final Judgment! Suspected Unfair Competition! Heavy Penalty!
The trial bench.
'Bang bang bang!'
At the seat of the presiding judge, Cao Liqiang cast a discreet glance at Su Bai and struck the gavel: "The defendant refuses settlement, the trial shall continue."
"Plaintiff, please state your litigation arguments, legal reasoning, or submit evidence regarding your determination that the defendant Holding Co., Ltd. engaged in unfair competition against your side."
"Understood, Presiding Judge."
Su Bai slowly spoke: "However, before that, our side needs to ask the defendant one question."
"First: according to the defendant counsel's earlier statement, the delisting was an internal platform handling regulation, but may I ask, under which specific internal platform regulation was the delisting carried out?"
This question.
They had already gone through many times before.
Chen Chao was also not unfamiliar with this kind of question, and slowly replied:
"It was based on a risk assessment of external mini games, taking into account the safety of our platform, and therefore the mini game produced by the plaintiff was subjected to delisting."
Facing this kind of question, Chen Chao answered immediately.
He directly shifted the blame.
Your meaning is to accuse me of unfair competition, but I acted out of consideration for my own safety, so on what basis do you say that my delisting constitutes unfair competition?
If you ask what safety issue it affected, my apologies, I do not know.
Or alternatively, this was a certain operational error on our part, and we are sorry, we will correct it immediately.
The attitude in admitting fault was sincere.
In this way, even if there were any problems, they would not implicate issues of legal competition.
This was equivalent to waving a large banner and shifting blame everywhere, without having to bear any responsibility.
'Tsk tsk.'
The corner of Su Bai's mouth slightly rose, this safety department had truly taken a massive burden of blame.
But he had studied the defendant thoroughly.
He knew that as soon as his side accused them of anything such as suspected monopoly or suspected unfair competition, the other side would have eight hundred reasons, among which six hundred and ninety nine would be shifting blame to the risk control and safety department.
But did the defendant think that finding a scapegoat would be useful?
What a joke.
It was still the same statement, I have already studied you completely, what are you going to use to fight me?
The corner of Su Bai's mouth slightly rose as he continued questioning:
"May I ask the defendant, with respect to delisting conduct involving the risk control department."
"According to the enterprise standardized management and cooperation management regulations, a public notice should have been issued, or detailed notice should have been given to our side, Nanyou Studio."
"However, our side, Nanyou Studio, did not receive any detailed notice, only a single delisting notice without any reason whatsoever, and in addition, the defendant had expressed an intention to cooperate with our side."
"But after our side refused, we received the delisting notice from the defendant Holding Co., Ltd."
"And after Crazy Match Match Match was delisted, Happy Match It was immediately launched, and it was launched through plagiarism."
"There was no detailed notice, the objective of cooperation was not achieved, and during the period of cooperation, our product was directly delisted."
"Based on the above conditions, may I ask the defendant, how exactly did your side determine that our side had violated rules, resulting in delisting by risk control?"
Faced with Chen Chao finding a temporary scapegoat, Su Bai directly threw back a whole series of counter questions.
Self proof.
You say you did not do it, then produce the evidence showing you did not do it.
Once you produce evidence, a loophole will appear.
Then I will start from that loophole and search further.
If you truly produce evidence showing that there was something wrong with Crazy Match Match Match.
Then you should prepare to go in.
It must be known that Su Bai had already thoroughly studied the defendant's relevant rules.
He had also long since asked Lin Quan to have professional institutions test whether there were any issues in that regard with Crazy Match Match Match.
It had already gone through multiple rounds of testing, guaranteeing absolutely that there were no problems whatsoever.
Therefore, he dared to speak so directly.
Faced with Su Bai's question, Chen Chao for a moment did not know how he should respond.
Because he discovered that the other party seemed to be particularly familiar with their litigation process.
As a result, no matter which angle he started from, he was completely blocked off.
Beside him, Kong Hao slightly frowned and muttered in a low voice: "This lawsuit has effectively been ruined in our hands."
When it came to his own colleague, Kong Hao understood him better than anyone else, and by the point this lawsuit had reached, it could be said that they had already lost completely, the kind of loss where not even their undergarments would remain.
Chen Chao took a deep breath, lightly patted Kong Hao on the shoulder to indicate that there was still a chance, and continued speaking:
"With respect to our risk control side not giving detailed notice, I am not very clear about that aspect and can investigate it further, but the plaintiff cannot accuse our side of unfair competition merely on the basis that our side did not present the detailed rules for risk control delisting."
'Tsk.'
The issue had been thrown back again?
Fine.
Since your mouth is so hard, this time I will crush your head completely.
Su Bai took out a large stack of materials from the litigation materials and spoke:
"Presiding Judge, these materials are the defendant company's most recent risk control rules, along with the risk control assessment report our side has already prepared."
"If the defendant does not agree, our side has already invited relevant professionals who can conduct on site testing of the risk control issues in the earlier delisted version of Crazy Match Match Match, to determine whether it met the defendant company's requirements."
"The defendant may apply for on site testing!"
Chen Chao: "?!?"
What are you doing?
You prepared everything this thoroughly just to hammer the evidence to death right here in court?
Chen Chao was utterly speechless.
After letting out a long breath and receiving the relevant materials from the hands of the staff member, he was immediately struck into silence.
Given the other side's evidence and preparation, even if the director of their legal affairs department came personally, he would probably still lose the case.
At this time, on the trial bench at the seat of the presiding judge, Cao Liqiang looked toward the defendant's seat and asked:
"Does the defendant apply for on site testing?"
Taking a deep breath, Chen Chao steadied his emotions, whether there would be on site testing or not was already unnecessary.
He had already seen it.
The other party was determined to flatten their heads right here in court, and had prepared very thoroughly with respect to accusing them of unfair competition.
There was a very high probability that on site testing would also be exactly as described in the materials, and there would not be any major deviation.
Chen Chao slightly shook his head: "Our side does not apply for on site testing."
'Bang bang!'
Cao Liqiang struck the gavel: "Does the defendant have any objection to the evidence provided by the plaintiff?"
Chen Chao: "Our side has no objection."
'Bang bang bang!'
Cao Liqiang lowered his head and glanced at the trial materials, then turned his gaze toward Su Bai at the plaintiff's seat:
"Does the plaintiff have anything further to supplement?"
The trial had already been firmly established, and the other side had been completely pressed down, so further supplementation had no significance.
It might even have the opposite effect.
Su Bai spoke: "Presiding Judge, our side has nothing further to supplement."
'Bang bang!'
Cao Liqiang slightly nodded, gave the trial materials a rough glance, and then looked toward the defendant:
"Defendant, is your side able to accurately explain why Nanyou Studio's mini game Crazy Match Match Match was delisted?"
Chen Chao let out a long sigh, he no longer had the energy, the other side's evidence had him completely pinned down, and now nothing he said had any significance.
Moreover, this was a loophole left by the game department.
He also could not answer it.
Chen Chao spoke:
"Our side cannot accurately explain why Nanyou Studio's game Crazy Match Match Match was delisted."
'Bang bang!'
"May I ask the agent of the defendant Holding Co., Ltd., are you unable to provide an effective answer to the plaintiff's question?"
Chen Chao: "Yes."
"Very well."
After confirming this, Cao Liqiang briefly reviewed the trial materials, confirmed that there were no other issues, and let his gaze pass from the plaintiff's seat to the defendant's seat before drawing it back.
He struck the gavel.
'Bang bang bang!'
"The court statement stage now begins, please have the plaintiff make its statement."
Upon hearing Cao Liqiang's voice, Su Bai let out a long breath.
At present, this lawsuit could be regarded as already won.
As for the final court statement stage, it was simply a matter of raising a great banner.
Were your little wings not flapping vigorously, this time those little wings would be broken.
"Understood, Presiding Judge."
Su Bai slightly nodded, and then began his statement:
"With respect to this case, our side states as follows:"
"According to Article 1 of the Anti Unfair Competition Law, this law is formulated in order to promote the peaceful development of the social economy, encourage and protect fair competition, stop acts of unfair competition, and protect the lawful rights and interests of business operators and consumers."
"With respect to certain situations."
"When products produced by small studios are subjected to severe suppression, this already completely violates the relevant legislation."
"Therefore, our side believes that serious sanctions should be imposed upon conduct that relies on one's own massive foundation to oppress certain small and medium sized enterprises."
"Presiding Judge, our side has completed its statement."
Cao Liqiang looked at Su Bai with a faint smile, nodded subconsciously, and then turned his gaze toward the defendant's seat:
"The plaintiff has completed its statement, the defendant shall now make its statement."
The legal affairs side of the defendant had a certain understanding of the various presiding judges and senior personnel of the Nanshan Court.
Therefore, Chen Chao also had some understanding of Cao Liqiang's disposition.
The trial had already reached the court statement stage, and Presiding Judge Cao likely already had the result of the judgment in mind.
For this presiding judge, court statements would not have a substantial impact.
Therefore, the more one said, the more one might err, and saying more would never be as effective as evidence, so Chen Chao simply gave up the statement entirely.
"Presiding Judge, our side waives the statement."
'Bang bang!'
"Does the defendant confirm that it waives the statement?"
"Confirmed."
"Mm!" Cao Liqiang slightly nodded, and after confirming that the defendant waived the statement, he again struck the gavel.
'Bang!'
"At present, do both parties still have any objections to the evidence or legal reasoning presented by the opposing side?"
Su Bai: "No objection."
Chen Chao: "No objection."
'Bang!'
"Since neither party has any objection, the court shall now enter recess, the recess shall last one hour, and court shall reconvene in one hour for the announcement!"
'Bang!'
"Recess!"
As the words fell, Cao Liqiang, Jiang Hongyan, and He Yongan, the two adjudicators, left the courtroom.
Inside the courtroom, at the defendant's seat.
Kong Hao's brows were tightly furrowed: "This recess. Once it ends, there is a very high possibility that the judgment will be announced."
"This case."
"In your view, how great is the possibility of winning?"
Facing Kong Hao's question, Chen Chao looked deeply troubled: "How great is the possibility of winning?"
"Once game plagiarism has already been determined, the case has already been lost, there is no longer any possibility of victory, it is only that with respect to unfair competition, the sentence may perhaps be lighter."
"Let us wait for the judgment."
"The result of the judgment in this case has not yet come out, and no matter how much is said, it is useless."
Chen Chao took a deep breath as he spoke, he was currently agitated and did not want to continue discussing this topic.
Seeing this, Kong Hao nodded seriously and did not continue.
At the same time.
The plaintiff's seat appeared much more relaxed and cheerful.
Su Bai unscrewed a bottle of mineral water from the table, took a drink, felt the moisture nourish him, and let out a long breath.
During the earlier litigation argumentation, he had spoken so much that his mouth had become dry.
Beside him, Li Xuezhen smiled lightly, her small face filled with excitement: "Lawyer Su!"
"This time, have we broken the defendant's little wings?"
Su Bai narrowed his eyes slightly, to say that they had broken the defendant's wings was far too much of an understatement.
At present.
It was no longer a matter of wings, the key issue was that he had effectively smashed open the other party's skull.
The myth of Nanshan's invincibility was broken from this moment onward.
'Cough cough.'
Su Bai coughed lightly twice: "Of course it counts!"
Li Xuezhen smiled sweetly, her eyes curving into crescents: "Checking in, first civil case successfully completed!"
Oh no.
The judgment still had not yet been announced.
Forget it, regardless, in any event, there was no possibility of losing now.
Successful check in, wonderful.
At the same time.
The three members of the collegial panel were discussing the case.
Cao Liqiang slowly spoke: "I was rather surprised by today's trial argumentation."
"I did not expect that the defendant's legal affairs side would actually fall into the lower position in the litigation argumentation of an infringement case, it appears that the plaintiff's preparation was extremely sufficient."
"The defendant's loss is already certain, but I have not yet decided the scope of the penalty to be imposed on the defendant, we may discuss it."
Jiang Hongyan slightly nodded, agreeing with Cao Liqiang's view.
Regarding the defendant's loss, there was indeed no problem whatsoever with that point, and as for the penalty, according to the plaintiff's statement, the defendant did indeed appear to have engaged in unfair competition.
It even involved monopolistic conduct, and a stricter punishment could be imposed.
"And what about you, Yongan, what do you think?" Seeing that He Yongan was standing to one side without speaking, Cao Liqiang took the initiative to ask.
He Yongan remained silent for several seconds, then slowly spoke: "I agree with Hongyan's view."
Cao Liqiang slightly nodded and said with a smile: "It seems that when you served as presiding judges in the Higher Court, both of you had some resentment toward the defendant."
"Mm!"
"Then let us settle the judgment against the defendant in this way. However, with respect to the amount of compensation, let it proceed according to the normal compensation standards, had the court not already prepared a table earlier, let it be handled according to that."
"Mm!"
"Understood!"
Jiang Hongyan and He Yongan both voiced their agreement.
Very quickly, one hour passed.
At the clerk's call for all to rise, Cao Liqiang, Jiang Hongyan, and He Yongan, the three members of the collegial panel, entered once again.
'Bang bang!'
Cao Liqiang struck the gavel, his voice stern:
"Court is now in session!"
"Regarding the case in which Nanyou Studio accuses the defendant Holding Co., Ltd. of plagiarism and unfair competition, the hearing shall continue!"
'Bang bang!'
The gavel fell.
"Do the plaintiff and defendant have any objections regarding the stage of proceedings before the recess."
"They may be raised in court."
Su Bai: "No objection."
Chen Chao: "No objection."
'Bang bang!'
"Since both parties have no objection to this, the court is now prepared to announce the judgment!"
Clerk: "All rise, the presiding judge will now announce the result of the judgment!"
Rustle rustle rustle.
All rose.
At the defendant's seat, both Chen Chao and Kong Hao appeared somewhat nervous.
Although they had already anticipated the result of the judgment.
After all, this litigation concerned whether the defendant's nearly one hundred percent record of victory in Nanshan would be broken.
Therefore, before the judgment was announced, they still held a trace of hope.
The gaze of both men fell upon the presiding judge.
Only to hear.
Presiding Judge Cao Liqiang slowly speak, announcing the result of the judgment:
"The cause of action in this case is that the plaintiff has sued the defendant for plagiarizing its produced game and accused it of unfair competition, and this case is heard by the Nanshan Higher Court of this court."
"This court has jurisdiction over this case, and all law applied in this case is based entirely on domestic law."
"The result of the judgment is announced below!"
"According to the deliberation and decision of the members of the collegial panel, with respect to the litigation applications raised by the plaintiff."
"First: it is determined that the game Happy Match It produced by the defendant company plagiarized the game work Crazy Match Match Match of Nanyou Studio. It caused enormous losses to Nanyou Studio, and the defendant shall compensate Nanyou Studio for economic losses in the amount of 8,685,465 yuan and 92 fen."
"And the plagiarized game work, Happy Match It, shall be removed from the shelves!"
After the first point was announced, Chen Chao and Kong Hao at the defendant's seat did not display much emotional reaction.
Because with respect to plagiarism, it had already been determined earlier.
What they cared about was the key issue of the determination regarding unfair competition.
Only to hear.
Presiding Judge Cao Liqiang continue to speak: "Second: it is determined that the defendant is suspected of unfair competition!"
"The defendant cannot produce accurate evidence for the delisting of the plaintiff's mini game, nor clearly state complete factual grounds explaining what kind of risk the plaintiff's mini game posed, and the defendant platform's statement was unclear, therefore it must bear a certain degree of responsibility."
"It is required that the defendant platform relist Nanyou Studio's mini game, Crazy Match Match Match."
"At the same time!"
"It shall issue a public apology for its conduct and its unfair competition conduct!"
"Third: in this case, since the cause lies in the defendant's plagiarism, the plaintiff's litigation costs shall be borne by the defendant, but attorney fees shall not be borne by the defendant."
"Fourth: all litigation applications raised by the defendant are rejected in their entirety!"
"According to the provisions of our country's Civil Procedure Law, if the defendant believes that the judgment is erroneous or has other doubts, it may initiate supervisory review or retrial procedures."
"The judgment is concluded, and within ten days the written judgment shall be sent to both the plaintiff and the defendant!"
'Bang bang!!'
"Court is adjourned!!"
As Cao Liqiang's stern voice fell, Chen Chao and Kong Hao at the defendant's seat were both stunned.
They knew that there was a possibility that unfair competition would be found, but they had not expected that the judgment would be this severe.
'Hiss.'
This time, their heads had truly been smashed open.
How were the two of them supposed to return and account for this to the legal affairs department?
Read the full book (500+ chapters) with faster updates and no ads at htt ps:// ravenarchives .com/book/the-outlaw-lawyer. Updates here may be irregular due to bulk upload limitations.
