Chapter 450: The Karstark Calculations
For a split second, Egger thought Robb had seen through his delaying tactics and decided to flip the table, striking first against the Gift by sending the Karstark army to cut off his rear... but on second thought, that wasn't likely.
Karhold was situated in the northeastern corner of the Seven Kingdoms, east of Last Hearth, separated from the Northern heartland and Winterfell by the Last River and the Lonely Hills. When Robb Stark received the alarm from the Wall a week ago and summoned the banners to Last Hearth, the Karstarks would have naturally marched directly west rather than taking a long detour. Due to the distance and road conditions—which were nowhere near as smooth as the Kingsroad Egger had refurbished—their marching speed was average, causing them to miss the Others' genocidal assault on the Umbers. It wasn't until the wight host had passed and the Gift's army had already rushed south in pursuit toward the Long Lake that they arrived. Whether it was luck or a wasted trip, they had taken over the abandoned castle and cleaned up the remains of the Umber family left behind by the Night's Watch.
Robb Stark had no way of sending a message from Long Lake to the Karstark army while they were already on the move. This meant that the Northern army currently occupying Last Hearth likely had no idea the war was over, nor that Egger had broken his oath of neutrality to join the Dragon Queen's camp!
Egger ordered the dragon sledge to halt far off and stay clear of the castle, sending a vanguard ahead to scout. Their reception confirmed his judgment: upon spotting the black-flagged scouts, several Karstark soldiers came out to verify their identity. Once confirmed as Night's Watch, they lowered their guard and opened the gates, allowing them free passage.
After confirming there was no ambush, Egger informed the Queen and entered the castle with his guards. There, he met the leader of the occupying force—Lord Rickard Karstark.
"Are you eating sh*t, Lord Commander!" Rickard barked the moment they met, spraying Egger with a barrage of insults. "I gathered my men and rushed here the moment I got Robb's letter. In just three or four days, I arrive to find nothing but corpses! Were you sleeping while the dead marched south? If everyone was truly dead, that would be one thing, but I can't even find the bodies of those I know—Crowfood, Whoresbane, Mors, and Hother Umber... where are they?! Did they escape? Why aren't you looking for them?"
The Umbers? They had likely been turned into wights and reduced to ash by dragonflame during the Battle of Long Lake.
Egger thought to himself. The scouts who had previously surveyed the ruins of Last Hearth had reported this: the bodies left in and around the castle were mostly the old, the weak, women, and children. The Umber men—well-fed, robust, and strong—had undoubtedly been handpicked by the Others to become thrall soldiers. Of course, he saw no need to explain it in such detail.
"Lord Karstark, the Gift lost over ten thousand warriors holding back the invasion of the Others." Egger hadn't had time to tally the exact numbers, but he figured it was close enough, so he exaggerated for effect. "Even though the enemy bypassed Queenscrown to head south, we pursued them all the way to Long Lake and did not stop until every last one was destroyed. We suffered heavy losses but ultimately fulfilled our mission. Even if I am ashamed that we failed to keep the enemy outside the North's gates, it is not the place of someone who arrived late, lost not a single man, and killed not a single wight to point fingers!"
"What?" Rickard was momentarily speechless, his face flushing red. He was indeed ignorant of the full situation. Despite appearing as a total brute, he still listened to reason. His aggressive momentum dissipated significantly, and his expression softened. "The fighting is done? Then where is Stark, who should have marched here by now? And the missing Umbers... where are they?"
Left with no choice, Egger patiently recounted the events: the Others' failed lightning strike on the Wall and Queenscrown; their detour south; the fall of Last Hearth and the selection of male warriors to be turned into wights; the pincer attack by Robb Stark and the Night's Watch at Long Lake to annihilate the remnants; the fact that the War for the Dawn was essentially over and the Northern lords could return home... and the Watch's plan for an expedition beyond the Wall to clear out any stragglers. He told the old Karstark everything to lay the groundwork for his next request.
...
"Hmph—so that's how it is. Damn it, we missed it." Rickard listened with a frown and cursed in frustration, his anger subsiding. "Fine. I apologize for my previous rudeness. The brothers of the Night's Watch have worked hard; the fate of the Umbers isn't entirely on you. The vegetables and meat they had stockpiled in their warehouses are of no use to anyone now. Have your men haul it away and take it back to the Gift as a reward for the garrisons at the Wall."
"Thank you for your kindness." This was a textbook case of being generous with someone else's property. Egger didn't even know what he was thanking him for, but he soon shrugged. "There is one more matter. Many of my soldiers were wounded fighting wights at Long Lake. They need a warm, safe environment sheltered from the wind and snow to recover. The battlefield is too far from Queenscrown, so I must find a place nearby in the North. I request the temporary use of Last Hearth until the wounded are fit to return to the Gift."
Rickard Karstark was famously stubborn. If Egger told him, "The Queen's dragon is injured and needs a place to recover, so I'm requisitioning your Northern castle," he wouldn't get anything done; he might not even leave the castle in one piece. While the combination of the dragons and the Gift's army could crush the two thousand Karstark men, Egger still needed the North to supply his first batch of saltpeter. He needed time to prepare before he could afford to break with the Seven Kingdoms, especially the North. If he could achieve his goal through a little deception and avoid a premature conflict, that was the best path.
"The wounded? Then let them pick houses in the winter town outside the castle... the original owners won't be needing them anyway." Lord Rickard was quite agreeable on this point. "If there are those with severe injuries, I brought healers with my army. Bring them into the castle, and they will receive proper care."
To be fair, this was a generous offer. Unfortunately, it wasn't what Egger wanted.
"You don't understand." He put on a troubled face and spoke helplessly. "I have over four thousand men. Combined with your Karstark forces, that's nearly seven thousand. Staying in Last Hearth together would be incredibly cramped. Now that the war is over, remaining here with your army is merely a waste of time and provisions. If you would return to your lands and lend Last Hearth to the Watch for a few weeks, I would be eternally grateful."
"What do you mean?" Lord Karstark's expression shifted, anger flaring up again. "Lord Commander, remember your place! Setting aside that we haven't reached a final conclusion yet, even if every last Umber on this earth is dead, Last Hearth has nothing to do with you. Why are you trying so hard to drive me away?!"
The war against the dead was over, yet the Karstark army remained fully armed at the assembly point... not because they had too much food, but for several strategic reasons.
The Others did not use fire. After slaughtering those in and around the castle, they hadn't bothered to damage the structures or destroy the wealth and resources stored within. A strong, fortified seat filled with granaries and larders prepared for winter could not be left for any common looter to ransack. As the first Northern lord to arrive, Rickard Karstark had a duty to guard it and prevent a broken window effect that would lead to unnecessary secondary damage.
Beyond this noble pretext, there were other reasons he wouldn't share.
Just as the people of the Gift didn't all huddle in Queenscrown when the Others attacked, Northern residents didn't all flock to their liege lord's castle for winter. Depending on distance, residents belonging to different lords would gather in several winter towns consisting of a castle and several large villages. They would huddle together by the thousands to exchange resources and labor to survive the long winter. While Last Hearth was currently unpopulated due to the slaughter, the Umber family's total population of fifty to sixty thousand remained largely intact. This castle, its lands, and its people were still highly valuable. Rickard had to occupy Last Hearth—the heart of the Umber lands—to ensure the Karstarks maximized their interests in the aftermath of this tragedy!
Yes, it was for interest. But calling Rickard a vulture would be biased. Years of experience had taught Northern nobles that if one acted too knightly and refused to compete out of a sense of propriety, all the benefits would fall into the pockets of ambitious, shameless families like the Boltons. The Karstarks and Umbers had long been close; the downfall of the latter was by no means good news for the former... but since the tragedy had happened, no amount of posturing would bring the dead back. As a lord, Rickard had to consider the long-term interests of his house!
Of course, he wasn't occupying Last Hearth with the hope that House Karstark would simply swallow the Umber inheritance whole. If subsequent investigations found a surviving Umber who had been away during the attack, Rickard would return the castle and its contents without a word. But if House Umber was truly extinct, such a fine castle and its lands could not be left to go to waste or be taken by wildlings. The likely resolutions were:
House Stark annexes the lands. In principle, Robb had the power to do this, but it would leave him with more land than he could manage, and seizing the assets of a fallen vassal would earn him a reputation for greed and malice—unlikely given the Starks' obsession with honor.
Robb designates a loyal or meritorious follower to take over the castle and lands. Whether there was a suitable candidate was one thing, but Umber was a name nearly as old as Stark, an ancient, royal house ruling a territory nearly the size of the Gift. Even if Robb chose a new Lord of Last Hearth, the newcomer would not be entitled to the full original territory immediately. To prevent such a mismatch of merit and reward, the new Lordship would inevitably have its borders trimmed—forests and villages would be sliced away and given to the surrounding established Great Lords to distribute to their own vassals. If this happened, the family physically occupying Last Hearth would certainly get a larger slice of the pie.
The most likely scenario: Even if everyone named Umber died, the centuries of intermarriage meant the blood of the Umbers ran through many Northern houses. If Robb didn't want the name to vanish, he would likely pick a distant relative with Umber blood who was far down their own family's line of succession and command them to take the name and the castle—a "reasonable adoption" to keep the ancient name alive in the North.
As neighbors, the Karstarks had marriage records with the Umbers within the last century and had several candidates who fit this criteria. The hard work of cleaning up and the physical occupation of Last Hearth would be significant points in favor of their candidate when the time came to choose a new Lord Umber.
Regardless of how he looked at it, Rickard Karstark had no intention of abandoning Last Hearth and marching away now!
Support me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/MistaQuartz
On Patreon, you can explore Extra Chapters in advance!
