Cherreads

Chapter 443 - Chapter 401: The Scalpel on Constitution Avenue

Chapter 401: The Scalpel on Constitution Avenue

October 6 – October 8, 1979

The Eccles Building, Washington, D.C. • The Federal Reserve Bank of New York • Bombay

At eight-fifteen on the morning of Saturday, the sixth of October, 1979, the marble corridors of the Marriner S. Eccles Federal Reserve Board Building on Constitution Avenue were supposed to be empty.

Outside, the autumn oaks along the National Mall were just turning bronze under a crisp, fifty-two-degree October sky. A block away, tourists in windbreakers were lining up outside the Bacon Memorial with cameras slung around their necks, completely unaware that inside the white Georgia-marble fortress across the street, the guards at the C Street underground garage had been checking the credentials of unmarked black limousines since seven-thirty in the morning.

In the corner office on the second floor—a high-ceilinged room already hazed with the pungent, unmistakable blue smoke of a twenty-five-cent Antonio y Cleopatra cigar—Paul Adolph Volcker Jr. sat behind his massive mahogany desk in his shirtsleeves, his six-foot-seven-inch frame folded over a stack of green-bar computer printouts from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

Two months had passed since Jimmy Carter had summoned Volcker from the presidency of the New York Fed in August to take the helm of the nation's central bank.

Across the desk from Volcker sat two men who were not members of the Federal Open Market Committee, and whose presence in the building had been kept off the official Saturday security log: Secretary of the Treasury W. Michael Blumenthal, and Under Secretary of the Treasury for Monetary Affairs Anthony M. Solomon.

In the centre of Volcker's blotter lay two thick, classified folders that no regional Federal Reserve Bank president waiting down the hall had ever seen.

The first folder was bound in dark blue Treasury buckram and stamped SECRET — NEW DELHI CONCORDAT (ANNEX II & ANNEX III CAPITAL SCHEDULES).

The second folder was bound in olive-drab Pentagon cardstock from the Office of the Secretary of Defense, stamped TOP SECRET — CONTINGENCY MOBILIZATION LIQUIDITY REQUIREMENT (FY 1980–Q1).

Volcker took the stub of his cheap cigar out of his mouth, tapped the ash into a heavy glass saucer, and looked across his reading glasses at the Treasury Secretary.

"Let's get the cards face-up on the table before I walk into the Boardroom at ten o'clock, Mike," Volcker said, his deep, resonant bass voice rumbling like a freight train in a tunnel. "I have twelve regional bank presidents and governors sitting down the hall drinking coffee right now. Four of them—led by Larry Roos from St. Louis, Phil Coldwell, and Henry Wallich—flew into Washington last night spoiling for a monetarist bloodbath.

"They've been reading Milton Friedman's columns and watching the Zurich gold price touch four hundred and twelve dollars an ounce on Thursday. They want me to announce at six o'clock tonight that the Federal Reserve is abandoning interest-rate targets altogether, locking down non-borrowed bank reserves, and letting the Federal Funds rate shoot straight from eleven percent to sixteen, eighteen, or twenty percent by Tuesday morning to shock the inflation expectations out of the system."

Michael Blumenthal did not reach for his coffee cup. He leaned both forearms on the edge of Volcker's desk, his face dead serious.

"Paul," Blumenthal said quietly, "if you let the monetarists talk you into jacking the Federal Funds rate to eighteen percent tonight, you won't be shocking inflation. You will be detonating a demolition charge directly underneath the foreign policy, the industrial recovery, and the military readiness of the United States Government—and by nine o'clock Monday morning, Jimmy Carter will be facing a catastrophic two-front financial rupture."

Volcker did not bristle at the Treasury Secretary trespassing on central-bank independence; he and Blumenthal had worked together for years in the trenches of international monetary crises, and Volcker had invited him here at eight in the morning for precisely this briefing.

"Walk me through the exact numbers on the Concordat tranche that cleared on Monday, Tony," Volcker said, turning his gaze to Under Secretary Anthony Solomon. "And then tell me what Harold Brown's people at the Pentagon are actually asking the bond market to swallow over the next sixty days."

Anthony Solomon opened the blue New Delhi Concordat binder first, turning to the confidential wire-transfer ledgers of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York's Foreign Account Desk.

"Twenty-six days ago, on September 10th in New Delhi," Solomon said, his voice crisp and exact, "Mike and Dr. Manmohan Singh signed Annex II of the Concordat. Under that agreement, the Federal Reserve and the SEC granted Qualified Sovereign Institutional Investor status to India's four largest capital pools: the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC), the General Insurance Corporation, Shergill Capital, and the State Bank of India.

"They committed to deploy five billion dollars a year of long-term, low-turnover Indian insurance and sovereign float directly into three specific American fixed-income sectors: tax-exempt US municipal water-and-power bonds, Texas and Louisiana Gulf Coast energy commercial paper, and long-dated industrial debentures in the Midwest Rust Belt.

"Five days ago—on Monday, October 1st—the Indians kept their word to the letter and to the minute," Solomon said, tapping the New York Fed clearing printout. "At nine-thirty Monday morning, one billion two hundred and fifty million dollars ($1.25 billion) of the first quarterly Indian tranche wired in from Bombay and Singapore.

"By Friday afternoon's close, LIC and Shergill Capital had purchased: "First: $450 million of twenty-year municipal infrastructure bonds issued by the cities of Detroit, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, and Chicago at an average coupon of 6.85%. "Second: $400 million of ten-year corporate industrial modernisation debentures issued by Ford, Chrysler, Republic Steel, Inland Steel, and Caterpillar at an average coupon of 9.20%. "Third: 400million∗∗ofGulfCoastrefineryanddeep−waterdrillingpaperinHoustonandBatonRouge,plustheinitial∗∗400 million of Gulf Coast refinery and deep-water drilling paper in Houston and Baton Rouge, plus the initial 400million∗∗ofGulfCoastrefineryanddeep−waterdrillingpaperinHoustonandBatonRouge,plustheinitial∗∗500 million US–Indian escrow deposit for the Panama Canal Third Locks excavation."

Solomon looked across the desk at the towering Fed Chairman.

"Paul, do the bond-duration math in your head," Solomon said starkly. "Those municipal bonds and ten-year Rust Belt debentures have an average modified duration of seven-point-four years.

"If the FOMC walks out of this building tonight and announces a monetarist shock that drives the Fed Funds rate to eighteen percent and long-term bond yields up by four hundred basis points on Monday morning, the market price of those newly issued bonds will instantly crash by twenty-five to二十-eight percent!

"Within seventy-two hours of India wiring one-point-two-five billion dollars into America's cities and factories in good faith under a bilateral treaty signed by the President, the Federal Reserve will have inflicted a $340 million mark-to-market capital loss on the Life Insurance Corporation of India and the Reserve Bank in Bombay!"

Blumenthal leaned in beside Solomon.

"And what do you think Dr. Manmohan Singh and Karan Shergill will do at ten o'clock Monday morning if we burn them for three hundred and forty million dollars four days after their check clears, Paul?" Blumenthal asked grimly. "They will invoke the material-breach clause of the New Delhi Concordat before noon! They will freeze the remaining $3.75 billion of Indian float; they will halt the phased reduction of their 1971 tariff wall from 100% to 40% that our machinery exporters are counting on for January; they will pull their $2.25 billion co-financing out of the Panama Canal Third Locks; and Citibank and Chase Manhattan will be locked out of the AADB Series-C Rupee bond market!"

Volcker puffed slowly on his cigar, his eyes narrowing as he scanned the New York Fed clearing ledger.

"I saw the October 1st inflows on the New York wire sheet on Tuesday," Volcker rumbled. "That $1.25 billion bid from Bombay actually knocked twenty-two basis points off borrowing costs for Cleveland and Detroit and stabilized the whole corporate bond market all week. Now—what is in the green Pentagon folder, Mike?"

Blumenthal reached over and opened the olive-drab Defense Department dossier.

Because the Twin Hammer joint US–Indian military pincer directive on Iran and Iraq had been restricted by President Carter and Zbigniew Brzezinski to a compartment of six people in the entire US Government, neither Volcker nor Solomon knew a single word about Mosul, Kirkuk, or Basra. What the Treasury and the Federal Reserve had been formally notified of—under the National Security Act's war-financing protocols—was that the Joint Chiefs of Staff had placed the 82nd Airborne, the 101st Airborne, the V Corps mechanized brigades, the Military Sealift Command, and the Military Airlift Command on seventy-two-hour combat mobilization alert for an imminent, multi-division overseas expeditionary operation.

Given the dramatic showdown in Panama ten days earlier and the Cuban buildup in Managua, both Volcker and Solomon assumed without question that the United States was preparing to launch Operation Central American Shield into Nicaragua and the Caribbean basin within weeks.

"Read Harold Brown's liquidity schedule on page two, Paul," Blumenthal said in a low voice.

Volcker picked up the Top Secret sheet and read the figures through a curl of cigar smoke:

"Between October 15th and December 31st," Volcker murmured aloud, "the Treasury will have to auction an additional $14.5 billion in ninety-day and one-year Treasury bills to fund emergency sealift, airlift, fuel stockpiling, and combat mobilization. Simultaneously, the Defense Production Act credit window requires four billion dollars in guaranteed, low-interest working-capital lines from money-center banks to Boeing, McDonnell Douglas, General Dynamics, Lockheed, Raytheon, and FMC Corporation to surge production of tactical aircraft, munitions, and armoured vehicles."

Volcker set the Pentagon folder down on top of the New Delhi Concordat binder and looked out the tall window toward the Washington Monument.

"You cannot finance a multi-division military mobilization and surge the defense aerospace base with eighteen-percent call money," Volcker said flatly. "When Marriner Eccles sat in this exact chair in 1941 and 1942 as the war mobilization started, he didn't jack interest rates to fifteen percent to fight inflation; he pegged the Treasury curve and choked off non-essential speculative credit so the factories could build the planes and the Treasury could fund the troops without bankrupting the tax base."

"Exactly," Blumenthal said, slapping his palm softly on the leather armrest of his chair. "Look at the real economy out there today, Paul! Why are Larry Roos and Henry Wallich screaming for a twenty-percent interest rate sledgehammer? Because they are looking at theoretical M1 money-supply equations drawn on a blackboard in 1974, instead of looking at what actually happened to the physical supply chain of the United States over the last twelve months!

"Let's look at the actual drivers of inflation in October 1979: "In November 1977, when the Indians hit us with the Festive Gratitude Protocol, our inflation spiked because we ran out of domestic refining capacity and spot oil went to forty-eight dollars. "What did the President do over the last twenty months? We poured thirty-four billion dollars of Defense Production Act loans into Beaumont, Port Arthur, and Baton Rouge! Twelve massive catalytic-cracking refinery expansions came online between April and August! Prudhoe Bay in Alaska is pumping one-point-five million barrels a day; West Texas is deregulated; and we locked two hundred and forty million barrels of Saudi and Qatari crude into the Louisiana salt domes! The United States is at ninety-four percent domestic self-sufficiency in diesel and winter heating oil right now!"

"And on July 3rd at the Tokyo G8," Anthony Solomon added, "when the Iranian civil war threatened to push global spot oil to fifty dollars, New Delhi opened its taps by three million barrels a day at a hard forty-dollar (₹300) ceiling and cut Rotterdam out of the loop! Global crude oil has been frozen flat at $39.85 a barrel for ninety-five straight days!

"Because energy costs flattened in July, our domestic Producer Price Index dropped from an annualized eleven percent in the spring to 6.8% in August and 6.4% in September! Our Rust Belt factories in Ohio, Michigan, and Pennsylvania are running at eighty-six percent capacity building Shikari auto parts, Bechtel hydroelectric turbines for Africa, Boeing sub-assemblies for Indian wide-bodies, and digging equipment for the Tarim Basin and the Panama Canal!"

Volcker leaned back in his creaking leather chair, blowing a thick cloud of smoke toward the ceiling as his sharp, sixty-year-old central banker's mind dissected the anomaly.

"Then answer me the question I'm going to ask the FOMC at ten o'clock, Mike," Volcker said, pointing the wet end of his cigar at Blumenthal. "If physical energy prices have been capped at forty dollars since July, if wholesale industrial inflation dropped to six-point-four percent in September, and if our factories in the Midwest are humming... why the hell did gold jump from $310 to $415 an ounce in Zurich this week, why is silver at $16.50 on the COMEX, and why did corporate bank borrowing in New York jump by nine billion dollars in September?"

Anthony Solomon smiled grimly and pulled a third, thin yellow folder from his briefcase—compiled by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and the New York Fed's Bank Supervision Division.

"Because of where the hot money went after July 3rd, Paul," Solomon said.

"Remember what happened on the morning of July 3rd when India announced the forty-dollar oil ceiling and banned Rotterdam, London, and New York commodity brokers from touching a single barrel of stabilization crude?

"Overnight, forty billion dollars of speculative margin capital in New York, Chicago, London, and Zurich that used to make its living flipping paper oil tankers five times at sea got locked out of the global petroleum market!

"Those commodity speculators, offshore Eurodollar trading desks, and bullion syndicates—like Nelson Bunker Hunt and William Herbert Hunt down in Dallas, who have borrowed eight hundred million dollars from Bache Halsey Stuart, Citibank, and Swiss banks over the last eight weeks to corner fifty-five million ounces of physical silver—had nowhere else to play!

"So what are the big New York and Chicago banks doing?" Solomon tapped the bank-supervision audit sheet. "Because the Federal Funds rate is at 10.5% and they can borrow unlimited reserve-free Eurodollars from their London and Nassau branches, the money-center banks are lending billions of dollars on five-percent margin to commodity houses, bullion hoarders, foreign-exchange carry-traders, and corporate takeover raiders!

"The real productive economy of the United States is healthy and stabilizing," Solomon concluded forcefully. "The only thing on fire in October 1979 is the Wall Street and Zurich paper casino!"

Paul Volcker sat very still for ten seconds.

In his mind, the entire strategic picture locked into crystal focus.

To raise the general Federal Funds rate to eighteen or twenty percent—as the monetarist zealots on the FOMC were about to demand at ten o'clock—would be like burning down a healthy hospital to kill a colony of rats in the basement. A twenty-percent general interest rate would bankrupt auto dealers in Ohio, crush homebuilders in California, ruin farmers in Iowa, blow up the $5 billion Indian bond pipeline, and cripple the Pentagon's war mobilization—while the Hunt brothers and the Zurich gold speculators, who expected a thirty-percent monthly jump in bullion prices anyway, would keep right on borrowing at twenty percent!

"You don't kill a speculative casino by starving the factory floor," Volcker murmured in his deep gravel voice, a cold, formidable glint appearing behind his spectacles. "You leave the water running to the factory floor—and you cut the pipe leading to the casino."

Volcker reached across his desk, pulled a legal pad toward him, and uncapped his black felt-tip pen.

"Mike," Volcker said, looking up at the Treasury Secretary, "under the Credit Control Act of 1969 and Section 19 of the Federal Reserve Act, if the President signs a three-line executive authorization—which you can get from the Oval Office by telephone before noon—the Board of Governors has the statutory authority to impose selective marginal reserve requirements and differential credit ceilings on any specific category of non-productive bank lending, Eurodollar borrowing, or commodity margin credit, without raising the discount rate on productive industrial, agricultural, defense, or municipal credit by a single basis point."

Blumenthal's eyes lit up. "President Carter will sign that authorization in five minutes, Paul. We already drafted the contingency order with White House Counsel last night."

"And on the international currency front," Volcker added, looking at Anthony Solomon, "if we are going to crush the Zurich and London currency speculators who are shorting the dollar into gold and Deutsche Marks on Monday morning, we don't need eighteen-percent interest rates. We need two central banks with deep pockets standing on both sides of the market at the opening bell.

"Under the New Delhi Concordat, the Reserve Bank of India and the Asian-African Development Bank in Bombay are currently sitting on the largest liquid hard-currency and gold-backed Petro-Rupee clearing pool in the Eastern Hemisphere—receiving two thousand seven hundred crore rupees ($3.6 billion) a month from European and Japanese central banks buying forty-dollar oil.

"Tony—at nine o'clock this morning, before I walk into the FOMC room, get Dr. Manmohan Singh and Governor I. G. Patel of the Reserve Bank of India on the secure New York–Bombay wire. Tell them I am proposing an immediate $6 billion Reciprocal Federal Reserve–RBI/AADB Currency and Bond Stabilization Swap Facility. While we choke off the Eurodollar and gold speculators in New York today, Bombay tightens the Rupee-Mark-Yen clearing window against short-sellers on Monday morning."

Solomon stood up immediately, checking his watch. "It is six-thirty in the evening in Bombay right now—Dr. Singh and Governor Patel are standing by at the RBI tower waiting for our call. I'll have the swap confirmation on your desk before ten."

Volcker stood up to his full six feet seven inches, rolling down his shirt-sleeves and slipping on his rumpled pinstriped suit jacket.

"Good," Volcker rumbled, picking up a fresh Antonio y Cleopatra cigar from his humidor box and tucking it into his breast pocket for the battle ahead. "Now go down the back stairs so the regional bank presidents don't see the Treasury Secretary in the hallway—and let me go upstairs and explain the facts of life to the monetarists."

1005 Hours to 1545 Hours, Saturday, October 6, 1979 — The Boardroom, The Eccles Building

The main Boardroom of the Federal Reserve System on the second floor of the Eccles Building was built like a temple to the permanence of money: thirty feet high, with walls of cream travertine marble, a fireplace topped by a bas-relief of the Roman eagle, and a vast, twenty-eight-foot oval mahogany table around which sat the twelve voting members of the Federal Open Market Committee and the seven non-voting regional Federal Reserve Bank presidents.

At ten-oh-five, Paul Volcker walked in through the tall double doors, took his seat at the centre of the table beneath the eagle, and struck a wooden match to light his cigar.

To Volcker's right sat Vice Chairman Frederick Schultz and Anthony Solomon of the New York Fed/Treasury liaison desk, along with Open Market Account Manager Peter Sternlight.

Around the oval sat the five other Washington Governors—Henry Wallich, J. Charles Partee, Nancy Teeters, Emmett Rice, and Philip Coldwell—and the regional bank presidents, led by Lawrence K. Roos of St. Louis, Willis Winn of Cleveland, Robert Mayo of Chicago, Frank Morris of Boston, and John Balles of San Francisco.

"The Committee will come to order," Volcker said without ceremony, waving out his match and setting it in the crystal ashtray. "As all of you know, I called this special Saturday session—unannounced to the press—because the disorderly conditions in the international gold, silver, and Eurodollar markets over the past ten days require a structural response from this Board before Tokyo and London open on Monday morning.

"Before I place my proposal on the table, I know that Larry Roos, Henry Wallich, and Phil Coldwell have circulated a memorandum advocating a radical shift to pure M1 monetary-aggregate targeting and an un-capped Federal Funds rate. Larry—the floor is yours."

Lawrence K. Roos, the sixty-one-year-old President of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis—the Vatican of strict Milton Friedman monetarism—leaned forward eagerly, tapping a ten-page statistical packet filled with money-supply growth charts.

"Thank you, Mr. Chairman," Roos began, his voice vibrating with the missionary zeal of a true believer who felt his historical hour had finally arrived. "For ten years, this Committee has failed to conquer inflation because we have lacked the political courage to take our hands off the interest-rate wheel. Every time we raise the Federal Funds rate by a polite quarter of a point—from ten percent to ten and a half, or ten and three-quarters—we flinch the moment Congress or the homebuilders complain about the cost of credit, and we pump reserves back into the banking system to hold the rate down!

"Look at what happened in Zurich and on the COMEX in New York on Thursday and Friday!" Roos pointed at the market summary sheet. "Gold hit four hundred and fifteen dollars an ounce! Silver is up two hundred percent this year! Why? Because the financial markets do not believe the Federal Reserve has the guts to break inflation!

"There is only one medicine strong enough to cure this disease, Paul," Roos declared, looking around the mahogany table. "We must announce tonight that the Federal Open Market Committee is abandoning the Federal Funds rate target completely! Beginning Monday morning, the Desk in New York must strictly ration the physical quantity of non-borrowed bank reserves to hold M1 growth below four percent—and let the Federal Funds rate go wherever the market takes it: to fifteen percent, eighteen percent, or twenty percent!"

"Even if an eighteen-percent Fed Funds rate pushes the prime lending rate to twenty-one percent and triggers a severe industrial recession across the United States in 1980, Larry?" Governor Nancy Teeters interrupted sharply from across the table, her eyes flashing behind her glasses.

Henry Wallich—the sixty-five-year-old Yale economics professor who had lived through the Weimar hyperinflation in Germany as a boy—answered before Roos could speak.

"A recession in 1980 is the unavoidable price of credibility, Nancy!" Wallich said in his crisp, German-accented English. "Yes, if we let the Funds rate rise to sixteen or eighteen percent next week, housing starts will fall by forty percent, automobile sales in Detroit will drop, and unemployment may rise from five-point-eight percent to eight or nine percent for eighteen months. It is harsh medicine. It is painful medicine. But unless we shock the wage-price spiral into submission by breaking the demand for credit across the entire economy, inflation will go to fifteen or twenty percent!"

"I second Henry and Larry completely," Governor Philip Coldwell said firmly. "Only a dramatic shock to interest rates will convince Zurich and Wall Street that the Fed means business."

For ten seconds, the monetarist hawks looked toward the centre of the table, fully expecting Paul Volcker—whom Wall Street viewed as the sternest anti-inflation hawk in America—to nod his heavy head and call the vote for the eighteen-percent shock.

Instead, Paul Volcker leaned forward over his blotter, took the cigar out of his mouth, and looked from Lawrence Roos to Henry Wallich with an expression of cold, devastating, empirical disdain.

"Larry, Henry," Volcker rumbled, his bass voice filling the marble room, "if I thought for one second that shutting down half the blast furnaces in Pittsburgh and throwing three million American auto and construction workers onto the unemployment line would stop the Hunt brothers from buying silver on the COMEX, I might listen to your theory.

"The trouble with your theory is that you are prescribing a 1974 medicine for a 1979 economy that has completely different physical plumbing—and if we take your advice tonight, we won't cure inflation; we will commit national economic suicide."

Roos blinked, taken aback. "Paul—inflation was running at eleven percent in the spring!"

"It was running at eleven percent in the spring, Larry—before July 3rd!" Governor Charles Partee, the Board's sharpest empirical macroeconomist, fired back, opening the green-bar Federal Reserve industrial and price survey books in front of him.

"Look at the actual third-quarter data in front of you instead of your 1974 monetarist regression equations!" Partee said, sliding the September sector-by-sector price breakdown across the mahogany table to Roos and Wallich.

"Why did inflation hit double digits in 1974 and again in late 1977 and early 1979?" Partee asked. "Because of physical petroleum and distillate supply shocks! When crude oil and diesel prices double, it costs twice as much to run a tractor in Iowa, twice as much to haul steel on a truck in Ohio, and twice as much to heat a factory in Massachusetts! No matter how high you raise interest rates, you cannot print barrels of diesel fuel at the Federal Reserve!

"Now look at what has happened to the physical supply side of the American economy over the last ninety days: "First: As of August, our twelve emergency Gulf Coast refinery expansions in Texas and Louisiana—built under the 1978 federal energy mobilization—came online at full capacity, bringing US domestic distillate and diesel self-sufficiency to ninety-four percent, with two hundred and forty million barrels of crude locked in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve! "Second: On July 3rd, at the Tokyo Summit, the global price of crude oil was capped at a hard ceiling of forty dollars a barrel by the three-million-barrel-a-day stabilization supply out of Bombay, which bypassed the Rotterdam spot exchanges completely! For three straight months, global crude has been flat as a pancake at $39.85!

"And look at what happened to our domestic Producer Price Index in August and September the moment the Rotterdam oil speculators were killed," Partee said, tapping the third column of the green-bar sheet: "Wholesale industrial inflation dropped from 11.2% in May to 6.8% in August and 6.4% in September!"

Across the table, Willis Winn, President of the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, and Robert Mayo, President of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago—the two men whose districts encompassed the entire industrial heartland of Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Indiana, and Illinois—nodded vigorously in unison.

"Chuck Partee is dead right, Paul," Willis Winn spoke up from the Cleveland chair, opening his Fourth District industrial survey. "In my district—in Cleveland, Akron, Toledo, Youngstown, and Pittsburgh—we are seeing the strongest capital-investment and productivity surge in fifteen years!

"Why? Because for the first time since the 1960s, American heavy industry is re-tooling to compete and to export! "In Ohio and Michigan, Shergill Motors' joint-venture plants are employing fifty-two thousand UAW workers and buying eighty percent of their stamped steel, glass, and engine components from American suppliers—which forced Ford, GM, and Chrysler to re-tool their own plants with fuel-efficient assembly lines! "In Pittsburgh and Chicago, Westinghouse, General Electric, Bechtel, and Caterpillar have just booked four billion dollars in heavy turbine, mining, and earth-moving equipment orders for the African hydroelectric dams, the Tarim Basin in Central Asia, and the new Panama Canal Third Locks—and starting January 1st, under the September 10th trade accords, the external tariff wall on American capital equipment entering the seven-hundred-million-consumer Indian market drops from 100% down to 40%!

"And how are Ford, Republic Steel, Caterpillar, and the cities of Detroit and Cleveland financing that massive factory modernization without driving up bank loans?" Winn asked, looking straight at Roos and Wallich. "Through long-term ten- and twenty-year debentures and municipal bonds—$1.25 billion of which was bought in cash this Monday morning by long-term Indian institutional insurance funds at 6.85% and 9.20%!"

Robert Mayo of the Chicago Fed leaned forward beside Winn.

"If this Committee walks out tonight and does what Larry Roos wants—if we let the Fed Funds rate shoot to eighteen or twenty percent on Monday morning—" Mayo said bluntly, "three catastrophic things happen inside forty-eight hours: "One: We crash the US corporate and municipal bond market by twenty-five percent, wiping out three hundred and forty million dollars of our new foreign institutional bondholders' principal in Week One and destroying the New Delhi Concordat before the ink is dry! "Two: We strangle the exact capital-investment and re-tooling boom in Ohio, Michigan, and Illinois that is actually increasing industrial supply and bringing unit labor costs down! "Three: We bankrupt thousands of small farmers and community banks across the Midwest to fight an oil-price spiral that already ended in July!"

Lawrence Roos frowned, shifting defensively in his chair. "Then if physical industrial inflation is coming down, Bob, explain to this table why M1 and bank credit jumped by nine billion dollars in September, and why gold is at four hundred and fifteen dollars an ounce in Zurich!"

"Because you are looking at the aggregate pipe instead of looking at who is borrowing the money, Larry!" Paul Volcker boomed from the head of the table.

Volcker gestured to Peter Sternlight, Manager of the System Open Market Account at the New York Fed, and Nancy Teeters.

"Peter," Volcker ordered, "read the Committee the New York Desk's audit of where that nine billion dollars of September commercial bank credit actually went."

Peter Sternlight opened his ledger from 33 Liberty Street.

"Out of the $9.1 billion surge in commercial and industrial bank loans at the twelve largest New York, Chicago, and San Francisco money-center banks in September," Sternlight read in a flat, clinical voice, "less than $1.4 billion went to actual manufacturing, agricultural, or construction companies.

"Seven point seven billion dollars ($7.7 billion) went to four purely speculative, non-productive channels: "First: $2.4 billion in credit lines to commodity brokerage houses—led by Bache Halsey Stuart Shields and Merrill Lynch—financing ten-to-one leveraged margin accumulation of physical silver and gold futures on the COMEX and in London by a handful of Texas and European syndicates, specifically the Hunt brothers, who now hold over fifty million ounces of silver contracts. "Second: $2.8 billion in overnight Eurodollar and London-branch swaps used by New York and Zurich bank trading desks to short the US Dollar against the Deutsche Mark and Swiss Franc on five-percent margin. "Third: $1.6 billion in syndicated bridge loans for hostile, non-productive corporate takeovers and paper stock buybacks. "Fourth: $900 million in speculative commercial-land syndications in Florida and Nevada."

The Boardroom went completely quiet.

Even Henry Wallich looked down at the breakdown sheet with a deeply troubled frown. Eighty-five percent of the entire monetary surge that had terrified the monetarists had nothing to do with wages, factories, or consumers buying groceries—it was Wall Street and Zurich gamblers borrowing cheap bank reserves to corner silver, hoard gold, and short the dollar!

Then Paul Volcker played his final, trump card—the one that ended the debate on the spot.

"And there is one more factor," Volcker said, lowering his voice so that it carried only to the nineteen people inside the sealed marble room, "which I am sharing with you under strict national-security classification on the authority of the President and the Secretary of the Treasury.

"Between October 15th and the end of December, the United States Treasury and the Department of Defense will be executing a major contingency military mobilization in defense of vital strategic interests in this hemisphere and abroad.

"During the next seventy-five days, the Treasury must auction $14.5 billion in short-term mobilization bills, and our primary defense aerospace and ordnance contractors—Boeing, McDonnell Douglas, General Dynamics, Lockheed, FMC—must draw $4 billion in working-capital credit lines to surge military production around the clock.

"Now I ask every member of this Committee," Volcker said, his six-foot-seven frame leaning over the mahogany table as his dark eyes swept from Roos to Wallich to Coldwell: "Who in this room wants to walk into the Oval Office on Monday morning and tell the Commander-in-Chief that on the eve of a major military deployment of the United States Armed Forces, the Federal Reserve just jacked the cost of federal war borrowing and defense-plant credit to twenty percent—just because Nelson Bunker Hunt is buying silver bars in Dallas?!"

Not a single hand went up.

Lawrence Roos stared down at his statistical charts, his mouth shut tight. Philip Coldwell slowly closed his binder. Henry Wallich took off his spectacles and set them on the green blotter.

"Nobody," Volcker said quietly. "I didn't think so."

Volcker pulled a stack of twenty bound, cream-covered policy directives from beneath his blotter and passed them left and right around the oval table.

"We are not going to use a blunt monetarist bludgeon that breaks the bones of American industry to kill a parasite on Wall Street," Volcker declared. "We are going to use a surgical two-tier vise—under Section 19 of the Federal Reserve Act, Regulation D, Regulation T and U, and the Credit Control Act authorization signed by President Carter at eleven o'clock this morning.

"Here are the four operative pillars of the October 6th Monetary & Credit Stabilization Directive:

"Pillar One: The Productive Industrial & Sovereign Corridor (6.75% – 8.50%). "The Federal Reserve will not float or un-cap interest rates for the productive real economy. The Federal Funds target range for commercial banks meeting our productive-lending ratio is maintained at a stable 8.25% to 8.75%, and the Industrial & Defense Rediscount Window at all twelve Federal Reserve Banks is fixed at 7.50% for documented working-capital loans to domestic manufacturing, agriculture, export-import financing, defense production, and municipal infrastructure! Long-term Treasury and municipal bond yields stay anchored below eight percent—preserving 100% of the capital value of our domestic and sovereign international bondholders."

"Pillar Two: The 16% Speculative Marginal Reserve Guillotine. "Effective midnight tonight, under Regulation D and the Credit Control Act, the Board of Governors imposes a mandatory, sixteen percent (16%) non-interest-bearing Marginal Reserve Requirement on all managed liabilities, Eurodollar borrowings from foreign branches, repurchase agreements, and commercial-bank credit lines extended to: "(a) Commodity, bullion, and precious-metals brokerage accounts; "(b) Non-trade foreign-exchange forward and swap transactions; "(c) Unproductive corporate takeover bridge loans and speculative land-holding syndicates. "If Citibank or Chase Manhattan wants to lend a hundred million dollars to Caterpillar to build turbines for Africa or locks for the Panama Canal, their reserve tax is zero, and they can rediscount the paper at 7.50%. If they want to lend a hundred million Eurodollars to a Zurich desk to short the dollar or to Bache Halsey to help the Hunt brothers corner silver, they have to lock sixteen million dollars in a zero-interest vault at the New York Fed, and we impose an eight-percent penalty surcharge on their discount window—making the effective cost of speculative money nineteen percent while productive factory money stays at eight percent!"

"Pillar Three: The 65% COMEX & Bullion Cash Margin Rule. "Pursuant to our emergency authority over securities and commodities credit under Regulations T and U, and in coordination with the CFTC and the COMEX Board in New York, effective at the opening bell on Monday, October 8th, no commercial bank, broker-dealer, or financial institution under US jurisdiction may extend credit on gold, silver, or platinum futures or physical warehouse receipts in excess of thirty-five percent of value. Cash margin requirements on all non-industrial precious-metals positions are raised from ten percent to sixty-five percent (65%), retro-active to all open speculative positions exceeding five hundred contracts!"

"Pillar Four: The $6 Billion New York–Bombay Reciprocal Swap Line. "Finally, under the Foreign Currency Directive on page nine, the Federal Open Market Committee authorizes the Federal Reserve Bank of New York to activate an immediate $6 billion reciprocal currency and bond-stabilization swap arrangement with the Bundesbank in Frankfurt, the Bank of Japan in Tokyo, and the Reserve Bank of India / Asian-African Development Bank clearing facility in Bombay. "At nine o'clock Monday morning in Europe and Asia, the New York Desk, Frankfurt, Tokyo, and Bombay will intervene jointly and without limit to crush any speculative short-selling of the US Dollar."

Around the vast mahogany table, the effect of Volcker's four-pillar architecture was electric.

He had solved the riddle that had baffled central bankers for a decade: how to murder speculative asset-and-commodity inflation in forty-eight hours without raising the cost of capital for a single factory, a single homebuyer, a single city water bond, or a single defense plant!

"Look at what Pillar Two and Pillar Three will do to the gold and silver bubble on Monday morning," Governor Nancy Teeters said, a broad smile breaking across her face as she read the Regulation T margin language. "The Hunt brothers and the Zurich bullion syndicates are leveraged ten-to-one on ten-percent margin! When the cash margin requirement jumps to sixty-five percent at nine o'clock Monday morning and their banks are hit with a sixteen-percent reserve penalty, they will have to dump forty million ounces of silver and two million ounces of gold onto the market before lunch just to meet their margin calls—while a car buyer in Detroit or a steel mill in Cleveland doesn't see his interest rate go up by a single penny!"

"And look at what it does to the international bond market," Charles Partee added approvingly. "By keeping the core Funds rate in the eight-percent corridor while crushing gold and currency speculation, long-term US Treasury, corporate, and municipal bonds will rally on Monday morning instead of crashing!"

Even Henry Wallich and Lawrence Roos looked at the document with grudging respect. With a nineteen-percent effective penalty rate slamming down on Eurodollar and commodity speculation, the money supply growth in the speculative sector would be cut to zero overnight—achieving the monetarists' goal of drying up excess paper liquidity without triggering a general depression.

"I call for the vote on the Domestic Policy Directive, the Regulation D and T Margin Amendments, and the Foreign Currency Swap Authorization," Chairman Volcker said at 1540 hours. "Mr. Bernard, call the roll."

Normand Bernard, Secretary of the FOMC, called the twelve names around the mahogany oval:

"Chairman Volcker?" — *"Aye."*"Vice Chairman Schultz?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Balles?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Black?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Coldwell?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Mayo?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Partee?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Rice?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Roos?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Solomon?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Teeters?" — *"Aye."*"Governor Wallich?" — *"Aye."*

"Twelve ayes, zero nays," Bernard recorded. "The directive is adopted unanimously."

Volcker tapped his cigar ash into the tray and stood up.

"One final instruction before I walk down to the press room at six o'clock," Volcker said, looking around the table. "In our public press release tonight, there will be zero mention of the Pentagon mobilization schedules and zero headline mention of the New Delhi political accords—our foreign swap line with Bombay will be listed simply as a standard technical line alongside Frankfurt and Tokyo in Paragraph Six of the annex. To the public and the press, this is a purely domestic Federal Reserve strike to choke off Wall Street and Zurich commodity speculation and channel American credit into productive American industry. Keep your remarks strictly to that script."

Monday, October 8, 1979 — 0900 Hours EDT (1830 Hours IST)

The COMEX Floor, 4 World Trade Center, New York • The New York Stock Exchange • The Reserve Bank of India, Bombay

When the opening bell clanged across the cavern of the Commodity Exchange (COMEX) on the eighth floor of 4 World Trade Center in lower Manhattan at nine o'clock on the morning of Monday, October 8th, 1979, the slaughter in the gold and silver pits lasted less than thirty-five minutes.

Over the weekend, the stunned commodity brokerage houses of New York, Chicago, and Zurich had digested the iron teeth of Paul Volcker's Saturday night announcement: a 65% hard cash margin requirement on all non-industrial precious-metals positions, coupled with a 16% marginal reserve tax and 8% discount penalty on any commercial bank extending credit for commodity hoarding or currency shorting.

At 08:45 AM, fifteen minutes before the bell, the compliance committee of Bache Halsey Stuart Shields and the credit officers of Citibank had telephoned the 36th-floor suite of the Placid Oil Building in Dallas, Texas, informing Nelson Bunker Hunt and William Herbert Hunt that unless they wired $420 million in unborrowed cash to New York by ten o'clock that morning to meet the new 65% federal margin requirement, their silver and gold futures contracts would be liquidated at the market opening.

They did not have four hundred and twenty million dollars in unborrowed cash. Neither did the Swiss and Saudi bullion syndicates riding on their coattails in Zurich and London.

At 09:01 AM, the sell orders hit the COMEX and London bullion rings like an avalanche.

In London and Zurich, spot gold plunged $68.50 an ounce in ninety minutes—crashing from Friday's fever peak of $415 straight down to $346.50, wiping out every leveraged speculator who had bet on the collapse of the US Dollar.

In the silver pit at 4 ,World Trade Center, the price of silver collapsed from 16.80 anounce straight down through the daily limit to 11.20, breaking the back of the Hunt brothers' corner six months before it could threaten the stability of the American brokerage system.

And three blocks south of the World Trade Center, at the corner of Wall and Broad Streets, the exact opposite was happening on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange and in the government and municipal bond dealer rooms along Pine Street.

Because Paul Volcker had explicitly protected productive industrial credit in the 7.50%–8.50% corridor while killing the commodity casino—and because the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the Reserve Bank of India had stepped into the foreign-exchange markets at three o'clock that morning in Tokyo and Bombay with their $6 billion swap line, sending the US Dollar soaring four percent against the Swiss Franc—capital was pouring out of gold bars and silver futures and flooding straight into American industrial stocks and long-term bonds!

By two o'clock in the afternoon in New York:

The Dow Jones Industrial Average was up 38.40 points (+4.3%) in a single session on record volume of sixty-two million shares—led by General Electric, Boeing, Caterpillar, Ford, US Steel, and Bechtel-linked industrials.The yield on 10-Year US Treasury Bonds and AA-rated Midwest Municipal Bonds actually fell by thirty-five basis points, as pension funds and commercial banks rotated billions of dollars out of penalized Eurodollar speculation into tax-exempt municipal and industrial debentures!

Nine thousand miles away, on the eighteenth floor of the Reserve Bank of India Central Office Building on Mint Road in Bombay, it was seven-thirty on Monday evening.

Outside the tall windows, the lights of the ships anchored in Bombay Harbour glittered across the calm October water.

Around the teak conference table in the Governor's suite sat Dr. Manmohan Singh, RBI Governor Dr. I. G. Patel, R. Venkataraman (President of the Asian-African Development Bank), and Aditya Shergill, who had flown in from Lucknow that afternoon to monitor the first week's mark-to-market audit of the Indian institutional bond portfolio in New York.

In the corner of the room, the green CRT terminal of the Bombay–New York Federal Reserve Direct Link flashed with the two o'clock Manhattan bond and equity prices.

Aditya Shergill tore the printed valuation strip off the terminal, scanned the bottom line with a rapid flick of his eyes, and laid it down in front of Dr. Manmohan Singh with a broad, appreciative grin.

"Read that bottom line, Dr. Singh," Aditya said. "On Monday morning last week, LIC, Shergill Capital, and SBI put $1.25 billion into Detroit, Cleveland, and Pittsburgh municipal bonds and Ford and Caterpillar industrial debentures at par.

"After Paul Volcker's selective credit squeeze crushed the gold speculators and drove Wall Street banks back into productive bonds this morning, the market value of our 1.25billionAmericanportfolioissittingat∗∗1.25 billion American portfolio is sitting at 1.25billionAmericanportfolioissittingat∗∗1.298 billion—an unrealized capital gain of forty-eight million dollars ($48 million) in five trading days, on top of the eight-percent tax-exempt coupon yield!"

R. Venkataraman adjusted his spectacles, looking at the currency-swap readout from the Bombay Interbank Payment System (BIPS) downstairs.

"And on the currency desk," Venkataraman noted with quiet satisfaction, "we didn't even have to draw a single dollar or rupee of the 6billionswaplineweannouncedwithVolckeronSaturdaynight.ThemereannouncementthattheFederalReserveBankofNewYorkandtheReserveBankofIndia/AADBwerestandingtogetherwithsixbilliondollarsofinterventionammunitioncausedeverycurrencyspeculatorinZurichandHongKongtocovertheirshortpositionsbeforeteno′clockthismorning.AndCitibankandChaseManhattanjustsubscribedforanother∗∗fourhundredcrorerupees(6 billion swap line we announced with Volcker on Saturday night. The mere announcement that the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the Reserve Bank of India / AADB were standing together with six billion dollars of intervention ammunition caused every currency speculator in Zurich and Hong Kong to cover their short positions before ten o'clock this morning. And Citibank and Chase Manhattan just subscribed for another four hundred crore rupees (6billionswaplineweannouncedwithVolckeronSaturdaynight.ThemereannouncementthattheFederalReserveBankofNewYorkandtheReserveBankofIndia/AADBwerestandingtogetherwithsixbilliondollarsofinterventionammunitioncausedeverycurrencyspeculatorinZurichandHongKongtocovertheirshortpositionsbeforeteno′clockthismorning.AndCitibankandChaseManhattanjustsubscribedforanother∗∗fourhundredcrorerupees(533 million) of our AADB Series-C Infrastructure Bonds to escape Volcker's sixteen-percent Eurodollar reserve tax!"

Dr. Manmohan Singh picked up his porcelain teacup, looking out the window at the lit skyline of Nariman Point.

Three years earlier, when he and Karan had drafted the first pages of the Shergill Doctrine in Lucknow, the world's financial system had been a one-way street running through New York and London, where every crisis in the West meant high interest rates, capital flight, and recession exported onto the backs of developing nations.

Tonight, on the eighth of October, 1979, because India had capped the world's oil at forty dollars in Rupees and wired its own institutional billions into the heart of the American industrial midwest under the New Delhi Concordat, the Chairman of the United States Federal Reserve had been compelled to throw away the monetarist sledgehammer and use a scalpel—saving the American factory floor, enriching the Indian balance sheet, and keeping the industrial engines of both hemispheres running at full throttle on the eve of the Middle Eastern storm.

"In economics, Aditya," Manmohan Singh said softly, setting his teacup down on its saucer, "the ultimate form of power is not when you force another superpower to do what is in your interest against theirs. The ultimate form of power is when you structure the board so thoroughly that the only way they can save themselves is by making you richer."

Manmohan closed the New York valuation folder and glanced at the clock on the wall.

End of Chapter 401

More Chapters