Chapter 25: THE HATCH — PART 2
"We need to talk," Desmond said again, the rifle lowering slightly. "All of us. But especially you."
His eyes hadn't left mine since he'd emerged from the corridor—that wild, searching gaze of a man who'd been alone too long with too many questions. Three years in this bunker, pushing a button every 108 minutes, waiting for someone to relieve him. And now we'd arrived, and something about me didn't fit the pattern he'd expected.
"What's he talking about?" Jack stepped forward, positioning himself between Desmond and the rest of us. "Do you know each other?"
"We met." Desmond's voice held confusion beneath the tension. "Years ago. Running the stadium, training for a race. But that's not—" He shook his head. "That's not what I'm talking about."
"Then what are you talking about?"
Desmond didn't answer. His attention stayed fixed on me, studying my face like it held secrets he needed to decode.
He recognizes something. Not me specifically—we've never met, not in this timeline or any other. But something about me triggers his instincts.
"Brother." Desmond finally addressed me directly. "Step forward. The rest of you stay where you are."
"I don't think—" Jack started.
"It's fine." I moved past him, keeping my hands visible, non-threatening. "Let's talk."
We stood facing each other in the dim light of the Swan Station—two men with impossible knowledge, circling the truth neither could fully share. Desmond's rifle pointed at the floor now, forgotten in his need to understand.
"I've been down here three years," he said quietly. "Pushing that bloody button every 108 minutes, watching orientation films, reading the same books until the words stopped meaning anything. And in all that time, I never stopped thinking about one thing."
"Penny."
The name slipped out before I could stop it. A single word, carrying the weight of six seasons of television, of a love story that spanned years and continents and the boundary between life and death.
Desmond's face went white.
"What did you say?"
Shit. Shit shit shit.
"Said plenty's waiting." The cover came out smooth, automatic. "Out there. Food, people, rescue. Plenty waiting for all of us."
"No." Desmond stepped closer, his eyes narrowing. "You said Penny. Her name. How do you know that name?"
"I don't know what you're—"
"Don't lie to me." His voice cracked with three years of desperate hope and crushing disappointment. "I've been alone in this bunker since Kelvin died. No one's come. No supply drops. No rescue. Just me and the button and the hope that she's still looking for me." His hand tightened on the rifle, though it stayed pointed down. "So when a stranger walks into my prison and speaks her name—I bloody well want to know how."
The others were watching. Jack with growing suspicion, Locke with that calculating serenity, Kate and Hurley with confusion that would turn to questions soon enough.
"We should continue this conversation in private," I said.
"We continue it now."
"Then everyone hears what I have to say. Everyone asks questions I can't answer." I held his gaze steadily. "Is that what you want? Your story, your hope, your Penny—spread across a camp full of strangers who might use it against you?"
Something shifted in Desmond's expression. The desperate man retreating, the strategist emerging. Three years of isolation had sharpened him into someone who understood leverage and vulnerability.
"Fine." He looked past me to Jack. "You lot—explore the station, figure out the button, do whatever you need. But him—" He pointed at me. "—stays with me. We have things to discuss."
"I don't think that's—" Jack started.
"It's his choice, brother. Not yours."
I nodded. "Give us twenty minutes."
Kate touched my arm as I passed. "Be careful."
"Always am, Freckles."
I followed Desmond deeper into the station, leaving the others behind with their questions and their suspicions.
---
The corridor led to a small room I recognized from the show—Desmond's quarters, cramped and personal, filled with three years of accumulated solitude. Books stacked in precarious towers. Pencil sketches taped to walls. A photograph of a woman with blonde hair and kind eyes, preserved in a frame that had been polished until it gleamed.
Penny.
"Close the door."
I complied. The click of the latch felt like a seal being closed.
"Now." Desmond set the rifle aside, but stayed within reach of it. "Tell me how you know her name."
"I can't."
"Can't or won't?"
"Both. Either." I sat on the edge of his bunk, trying to project calm I didn't feel. "The explanation wouldn't make sense to you. It barely makes sense to me."
"Try."
What do I say? That I watched your love story on television? That I know you'll find her, marry her, have a son named Charlie? That your eight years apart end with a phone call from a freighter that changes everything?
"I know things I shouldn't know," I said carefully. "About this Island. About the people on it. About what's coming and what's already happened. I can't explain the source—it's not psychic exactly, not prophecy, not anything with a name. But it's real."
"And one of the things you know is Penny?"
"Yes."
"What do you know about her?"
Everything. Her father Charles, who'll do anything to keep you apart. Her determination to find you, funding searches for years after everyone else gave up. The way she looked when she finally heard your voice across impossible distance.
"I know she's waiting," I said. "I know she never stopped looking. I know you'll see her again."
Desmond's composure cracked. Just for a moment—a flash of raw hope so painful it hurt to witness. Then the walls came back up.
"How can you know that?"
"I just do."
"That's not an answer."
"It's the only one I have."
The silence stretched. Desmond studied me with the particular focus of a man trying to determine whether to trust an impossibility.
"If you're lying," he said finally, "if this is some kind of con—"
"It's not. Penny Widmore is real. She loves you. And you will find your way back to her."
The use of her full name hit him like a physical blow. He hadn't mentioned Widmore. I shouldn't know it.
"Jesus Christ." He sat down heavily, as if his legs had stopped working. "Who are you?"
"Right now? Just a survivor trying to get off this Island like everyone else."
"But that's not what you really are."
"No," I admitted. "It's not."
"Then what?"
A transmigrator. A man living in someone else's body. A viewer who stepped through the screen and can't find his way back.
"Someone who knows too much," I said. "Someone trying to help without making things worse."
"And have you? Made things worse?"
Shannon's face flashed through my memory—gray with shock, blood pooling beneath her, the butterfly consequence of saving Boone.
"Sometimes. More than I'd like."
Desmond nodded slowly, processing. "Well, brother. That sounds familiar."
"Does it?"
"I've been pushing that button for three years. Every 108 minutes, saving the world—or so they tell me. But I've never seen the world I'm saving. Never known if the button actually does anything. Just faith and routine and the endless hope that it matters."
"It matters," I said. "The button matters."
"You know that for certain?"
"Yes."
"Then tell me what it does. What happens if it's not pushed?"
The electromagnetic buildup releases. The sky turns purple. Desmond gets unstuck in time. The Island becomes visible to the outside world. Everything changes.
"It holds something back. Something dangerous. The details are—complicated. But the button needs to be pushed."
"For how long?"
Until you decide to see what happens. Until you don't push it and the world cracks open.
"I don't know," I lied. "But long enough that we should establish a rotation. Share the burden."
Desmond laughed—a hollow sound, but with genuine humor beneath it. "Share the burden. That's the first sensible thing anyone's said to me in three bloody years."
"So we're okay? You're not going to tell the others about—"
"About Penny?" He shook his head. "No. That stays between us. But in exchange, brother—when you know something that matters to me, something about getting off this Island or finding my way home—"
"You'll be the first to know."
We shook on it. His grip was strong, calloused from years of button-pushing and bunker maintenance.
"One more question," he said.
"What?"
"You said I'll see Penny again. Did you mean here, or somewhere else?"
Somewhere else. A freighter offshore. A phone call that bridges eight years. "I love you, Penny. I've always loved you."
"Somewhere else," I said. "But you'll see her."
Hope flickered in his eyes. Raw, desperate, achingly human hope.
"Good enough," he said. "Good enough."
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.