"He's too strong. Without proof, I can't touch him. If I go with you, I'll die."
"You don't trust me?"
"No. I don't trust anyone."
Throne's gaze settled on Eina, his voice softening.
"I won't put the person I love in danger. I'll investigate this myself. Once I've got the evidence, I'll step forward."
"I am The Dauntless. I don't fear evil. I don't fear strong enemies. I don't fear betrayal. I raised the banner of the Tarnished once. I'll do it again."
Before anyone could react, Vyke slammed his war spear into the ground. The impact echoed like thunder. Dust and debris scattered. When it cleared, a corpse lay in the dirt. Throne had made his declaration and vanished.
He left no memories of Vyke behind—only riddles and speculation.
"Vyke, come back!"
Eina's scream tore through the ruins. The Tarnished snapped out of their shock, murmurs spreading like wildfire.
What kind of enemy could force The Dauntless to abandon everything? Even his words couldn't be used as evidence. Was it betrayal within the Roundtable Hold? The thought was too terrifying to entertain fully. And why had his closest companions kept their distance?
Simple. No one dared touch Eina or the others now. Doing so would only incriminate themselves. Resentment thickened in the air. The warriors didn't glance at the Finger Maiden wailing over the corpse. Betrayal, not strength, was what they despised.
If even The Dauntless had been driven to this, what hope did ordinary Tarnished have?
"Little Vyke, you've handed me a mess," Tragoth muttered. He removed his helmet, his rugged face etched with a bitter smile. This had to be handled carefully, or it would blow up in their faces.
Had the Sir lost his mind? Consorting with the Bloody Fingers? Tragoth already suspected who Vyke had meant. Only a few voices carried weight at the Roundtable Hold. He took a deep breath, steadying himself. This couldn't be ignored or downplayed. As an upright Tarnished, Tragoth had no choice.
He yanked his great hammer from the ground and bellowed, "Arrest everyone from Raje's side! Not a single one escapes!"
The black-robed guards froze, their faces pale. They'd been spectators, but now the spotlight was on them. Before they could react, the Tarnished swarmed, pinning them down.
Some drew their blades, cutting down those who couldn't dodge in time. These were trusted aides—they knew the stakes. Being caught wasn't an option.
"They're resisting! Something's wrong!"
The Tarnished surged forward, blocking every exit.
Realizing escape was impossible, the aides didn't hesitate. They drove their blades into their own chests.
"Damn it! What are you standing there for? Pour the crimson tears!"
Tragoth hadn't expected this level of desperation. Suicide? Without hesitation?
"My lord, they've taken Scarlet Rot toxin. They're beyond saving."
The Tarnished who'd rushed to help now backed away. The corpses were already turning red, like cooked lobsters. Scarlet Rot was contagious—no one wanted to risk it. Tragoth's face shifted from pale to crimson. This wasn't just suicide out of fear. It was proof. Vyke hadn't lied. Every finger pointed to one man.
Looking at the several corpses that were as red as cooked lobsters, the Tarnished who had intended to save them fled. This Scarlet Rot would spread; they couldn't handle that. Tragoth's face went from pale to red. This looked like suicide out of fear, but to him, death was even more troublesome. It meant Vyke wasn't lying, and it pointed all fingers at that one person.
I can't accept it, but I must. Great Horn's gaze drifted sideways. Eina clutched Tina, her shoulders shaking with sobs. Some Tarnished stood stunned, others seethed with righteous fury. No matter the reason, he shouldn't have done it. The act shattered every rule.
Great Horn exhaled heavily. The Roundtable's first law: all Tarnished are equal. Killing one another was forbidden.
Raje had broken that law before, but at least his actions could be chalked up to personal ambition. Now the second rule lay in ruins too. He stared at the wreckage, a wave of helplessness crashing over him. If his plan was to use Vyke's death to unite the Tarnished, it had backfired spectacularly. The rift only widened. This wasn't over.
Either Sir Gideon Ofnir or Vyke had to die, but where would their deaths lead the Tarnished? Tragoth had no answer. He noticed some slipping away quietly. No need to ask—they were heading back to Stormveil to spread the news. A twisted satisfaction coiled in his chest. You're always scheming, aren't you? Did you foresee this?
If you don't step in to calm things within five days, I won't be able to hold it together. Someone will raise the banner of rebellion, and when that happens, there's no turning back. The sequence was clear, logical, inevitable. Yet a flicker of doubt nagged at him. Vyke… seems sharper than before. The plan went too smoothly. Throne hadn't gone far.
He'd pulled a diversion—the war spear kicking up dust—then used Starlight movement to leap a hundred meters away. The illusion mask was discarded. No Dauntless here, just a curious bystander chewing melons. He blended into the crowd, catching snippets of whispered conversation. Feigning ignorance, he asked, "What happened?"
"Raje's dead. Brutally."
The Tarnished beside him grinned, unable to hide his glee.
"Master Raje? Surrounded by guards? Who could've killed him?"
"Master my ass. Those lackeys couldn't stop The Dauntless. Damn, I've hated him for ages. Good riddance."
Another Tarnished chuckled, turning to Throne.
"Drinks tonight. What's wrong? Aren't you happy?"
"I've dealt with Master Raje before. He didn't seem that bad."
Throne played the clueless newcomer, drawing disdainful looks from the crowd.
"You're fresh, aren't you? Let me explain."
An older Tarnished patted his dusty chainmail.
"We're equals. We all woke to the Greater Will's call, tasked with a great mission. Why should we scavenge ruins, risk our lives for Runes, while Raje grows stronger without lifting a finger?"
"Why?"
"Power. Cursed power. Limgrave's broken. The Roundtable heroes feast and grow fat on Runes, while we bleed for scraps. Want to enter Stormveil? Want a Finger Maiden? Risk your life for those damned contribution points. Fair?"
"Not at all!"
"Right. Even against General Radahn, we're sent to die on the front lines while they pick at the spoils. Disgusting."
Before Throne could speak, a group of Tarnished erupted into shouts, their voices swelling. Another faction glared back. One side hurled accusations of cowardice, the other spat curses of stupidity.
Chaos erupted. Fists flew. Blood spilled. Tragoth, still piecing together clues, scrambled to restore order. The night roared louder than any beast. Combatants tore at each other, blind to the fact that the stranger who'd sparked the conflict had vanished long ago. Fools? No. Everyone here knew exactly what they were doing.
Throne slipped through the fray unnoticed. He stood in the wilderness, looking back at the town. The villa's dying flames cast long shadows, illuminating truths everyone had worked so hard to ignore. The fractures among the Tarnished ran deeper than he'd realized.
This wasn't new. Once they'd escaped death's grip and planted roots in Limgrave, these tensions were inevitable. Someone just needed to rip off the scab. Vyke, darling of the commoners, idol of the downtrodden—even he couldn't resist power's pull. Throne's lips curled. The last illusion shattered.
"Noble blood makes kings? Nobles?"
Throne chuckled dryly.
"The Roundtable Hold sets the rules, hoards resources, and leaves scraps for the rest. Of course they're unhappy."
The firelight danced across his face, twisting his features into something demonic, something cruel.
They propped Vyke up to give hope to the hopeless. And I, in disguise, tore it all down today. Throne's gaze shifted west. He melted into the darkness. Your move, Gideon Ofnir.
West of Limgrave, south of Liurnia—a city loomed where major trade routes converged. Its defenses were formidable, but its true strength lay in location. Redmane Castle and Elphael might be impregnable, but they were tucked away, irrelevant. This city sat at the crossroads of everything.
A year had passed since Godrick's death and the Tarnished's bloodless seizure of Stormveil. The fortress had transformed. Caravans streamed beneath its walls, carrying goods north, south. The city thrived. Tarnished settled, built lives.
Bars and markets sprouted like weeds. Citizens of the golden order mingled freely. Hunting was forbidden in Limgrave—without that, the Tarnished here could never sustain themselves. Benevolent policy fueled prosperity. In a few years, it might rival Caria itself.
"Pity," Gideon Ofnir murmured. His time was up.
From atop the walls, Gideon crumpled the parchment in his hand. A flick of fire reduced it to ash. He surveyed the city he'd built, pride and regret warring in his chest. The old nobility still lingered. Castle Morne remained elusive. The Tarnished had gained land, wealth, comfort—and lost their edge.
No one wants to sleep in the dirt, dodge death daily. But livestock can't survive in The Lands Between. Gideon's prosperity had become a trap. He'd seen it coming, though. Prepared for it.
First, use fifty years to observe whether the offspring of Tarnished and citizens of the golden order can be immune to the madness. If not, encourage reproduction; if so, stall for time. During these fifty years, he must maintain friction with neighboring factions, using constant small-scale battles to keep the Tarnished combat-ready.
Within a century, he could pacify Caelid, then march north to devour Liurnia. With power of that scale, surely they could crown a King. But everything shifted. Caria expanded too fast, allied with General Radahn, seized Mt. Gelmir in a flash. Rumors swirled they'd fought at Elphael too.
The threat loomed too large, leaving the Erdtree no time to wait. Godfrey returned, unraveling Gideon's plans. That King had no patience for slow cultivation. Caria wouldn't idle while the Tarnished grew.
Gideon had no choice but to take a shortcut: war. He'd throw the Tarnished into the crucible, temper their beastly nature, prove their worth in blood. As for himself—
"I cannot disobey his orders."
If Godfrey hadn't returned, the Tarnished would have followed him naturally.
But with the first King's return, Sir Gideon Ofnir became nothing more than a mouthpiece. The Erdtree's higher-ups gripped the army, ordered him to test General Radahn. Yet the Tarnished weren't subjects of the golden order. Each wielded their own power, their own will. And then there was The Dauntless, singing a discordant tune.
"Therefore, I must eliminate you," Gideon muttered to himself.
"The Tarnished exist to mend the elden ring. They can never live as normal people. Such luxuries are for after the ring is whole."
He didn't care how many died. This was destiny. Yet even this foolproof plan had gone awry.
Footsteps approached. He didn't turn, his gaze fixed on the distant storm.
"What do you wish to ask?"
His voice remained calm.
Vargram the Raging Wolf and Dolores the Arrow of Deep Sleep stood behind him. Just as the council's five permanent members held hierarchy, so too did the heroes of the Roundtable Hold.
"The news spreads through Limgrave like wildfire."
Vargram's voice was low, thick with understanding.
"Tragoth's demanded an investigation. Caelum's enraged. Everyone wants answers."
"I know. It was inevitable."
Gideon's head tilted slightly.
"I've seen the recorded phantasms. They were well-crafted."
"The enemy's formidable," he continued, his tone laced with mockery. "From The Dauntless' return to kill Raje, to the news' spread—it's all connected. Perfectly tailored to the public's taste."
Heroic resurrections, lone wolf revenge—such dramas never faded. Add the Roundtable Hold's fundamental contradictions, and it was a powder keg. But he had no choice. The Lands Between weren't in decline yet. How else could he spur the Tarnished to act?
"It's suspicious. An invisible hand seems to pull the strings."
Vargram nodded, then slowly shook his head.
"But this doesn't clear you. The ordinary Tarnished can't see the full picture."
Gideon's mouth twitched. Outwardly composed, inwardly he seethed. Who's meddling from the shadows? He racked his brain but found no answer.
The Mohgwyn Dynasty stood as the prime suspect, but a moment's thought revealed the absurdity. Everyone involved was an adult. No past animosity linked them. For the Mohgwyn Dynasty to act against their interests made no sense. 'They're outcasts of the golden order. They'd want chaos.'
'Could they be too stupid to see that I am behind this?'
Impossible. He knew the Lord of Blood too well—a master of schemes, a weaver of shadows. Survival demanded cunning. How could anyone lacking even basic intelligence endure this long?
"Gideon," the woman in hunting attire asked softly, her voice laced with pain, "are those rumors true?"
"Do you think it matters, Dolores?"
Gideon met her gaze, steady, unflinching.
"It does."
"Then you're wrong. Dead wrong. Justice bows to truth, and the truth of the Tarnished is the mending of the Elden Ring."
Gideon turned sharply, his fist clenching.
"Knowledge, power—they exist to serve the mission. Do you think Vyke is justice?"
"No—"
"To strip the Tarnished of their claws, to reduce the savior chosen by the Greater Will to a mere spectator—that's a crime beyond words. If survival were the only goal, why wake at all? Unless we end this, living will be worse than death."
His voice wasn't loud, but it carried a seductive weight. For a moment, it almost made sense.
The Greater Will hadn't awakened the Tarnished to idle or play supporting roles. Madness spread like wildfire. Soon, The Lands Between would be empty. Even if the Tarnished remained untouched, how could a handful of souls face the vastness of this ruined world without breaking? Dolores' lips parted, but no words came.
She knew Gideon had tacitly admitted it. She knew his methods were wrong, but his intent—his intent was pure. Vargram sighed inwardly. He couldn't refute it. As 'Vargram the Raging Wolf,' the sight of a city full of idle hands infuriated him. And yet, he wasn't sure he'd kill Gideon for the sake of justice.
"Tell me," Dolores pressed, "how do we salvage this before the news reaches Leyndell?"
"It wouldn't matter if it did. Godfrey cares only for results. In matters of faith, the dead golden nobles are far more loyal."
Gideon wasn't panicked. He didn't offer an immediate answer. The situation was too bizarre.
Even with his intellect, he couldn't unravel the mastermind's identity. Vyke wasn't someone easily manipulated—unless he was a counterfeit. Impossible. The Bloody Finger was real. The Blood Incantation, performed in full view, couldn't be faked. And why would the Mohgwyn Dynasty oppose him?
This matter involved the Black Blade. Turning against them would be suicide. Gideon couldn't make sense of it. No matter how wild his imagination, he'd never considered the Mohgwyn Dynasty itself might be in trouble. A week ago, intelligence reports still mentioned their slave-catching squads. He stopped trying to piece it together. It was beyond him.
