Chapter 15 : THE MEMORY WARLOCK
Magnus Bane's loft looked different with an audience.
The same silk tapestries. The same antique furniture. The same purple flames dancing in the impossible hearth. But now Clary stood in the center of it, flanked by Jace and Izzy, staring at the High Warlock of Brooklyn like he held all the answers to her broken world.
I stood near the door, positioning myself where I could watch both Magnus and the others.
Our eyes met across the room.
His sparkled with barely contained amusement.
"Shadowhunters," Magnus drawled, sweeping into the space with theatrical grace. "To what do I owe the pleasure of four armed warriors in my living room?"
He was performing. We both were. The second time I'd stood in this room, pretending it was the first, while Magnus played along with a smirk that said he knew exactly how absurd this was.
"We're looking for information about Jocelyn Fairchild." Jace stepped forward, all business and barely concealed impatience. "She's been taken. We believe you might know who would target her."
"Jocelyn." Magnus's expression shifted — something genuine beneath the performance. He'd cared about her. In his own way, for his own reasons, he'd spent years helping her stay hidden. "That's... unfortunate news."
"More than unfortunate." Clary pushed past Jace. "She's my mother. Someone has her. And apparently you're the warlock who helped her hide from... whatever she was hiding from."
Magnus studied her for a long moment. The resemblance was obvious — Jocelyn's fire, Valentine's stubbornness, something uniquely Clary in the way she demanded answers.
"You have your mother's eyes," he said softly. "And her gift for walking into situations she doesn't understand."
"Then help me understand."
"It's not that simple." Magnus crossed to his bar, began pouring drinks with practiced efficiency. "Your memories, Clarissa — the ones that would explain all of this — were suppressed. By me, at your mother's request, when you were two years old."
The room went silent.
Clary's face cycled through confusion, betrayal, and a desperate hope I recognized from watching this scene on a screen months ago.
"You took my memories?"
"I blocked them. Hidden, not destroyed. The distinction matters." Magnus handed her a glass of something amber. "Your mother wanted to give you a normal life. A human life. Free from the Shadow World that had already cost her so much."
"Can you give them back?"
"I can." Magnus's eyes flicked to me — brief, questioning, aware of what I knew and what I wasn't supposed to. "But there's a cost. There's always a cost with this kind of magic."
"What cost?"
"A memory demon." Magnus set his own drink aside, expression going serious. "The being that guards your suppressed memories requires payment. Happy memories, given willingly. Someone in this room will need to sacrifice their happiest moment to unlock what was taken from you."
The weight of that landed differently on each of them. Jace's protective instincts flaring. Izzy's calculating assessment. Clary's desperate determination.
I already knew how this scene ended. In the show, Jace had lost his memory of his father — the man he thought was his father, anyway. The sacrifice had driven plot points for episodes.
I could change it, I thought. Offer my own memories. Let them take something from a life I don't remember anyway.
But that would raise questions I couldn't answer. Why would the hostile brother sacrifice himself for a stranger? What memory could be important enough?
The script had to play out. Some changes were worth the risk. This one wasn't.
"I'll do it," Jace said, exactly as I knew he would. "Whatever it takes to help her."
Magnus's eyebrows rose. "How gallant. Though you might want to consider what you're offering before you commit."
"I know what I'm offering."
The room arranged itself for ritual — candles appearing, symbols drawn, the particular choreography of summoning magic. I positioned myself near the edge, ready to act if something went wrong but unwilling to be part of the central working.
"Alexander." Magnus's voice was pitched to carry only to me. "A word?"
I joined him near the supply cabinet, out of easy earshot.
"Quite the performance," he murmured. "Walking in here like we'd never met. I almost believed your confusion when I opened the door."
"Professional separation of concerns."
"Is that what we're calling it?" His cat eyes glittered. "The others don't know about your previous visit."
"No."
"Interesting." He selected a crystal vial from his collection. "And what else are you keeping from your family, Alexander Lightwood? What other secrets does the competent brother hide beneath that composed exterior?"
I met his gaze directly. "More than you could imagine."
"Oh, I imagine quite a bit." His smile sharpened. "You intrigue me. That hasn't changed since our first meeting. If anything, watching you navigate tonight has made you more interesting."
"Is that a good thing?"
"Ask me after the ritual." He turned back toward the others. "Right now, I have memories to unlock and a demon to summon."
The ceremony that followed was exactly as I remembered it from the show. The memory demon rising from smoke and shadow. Jace offering himself as sacrifice. The moment when everything could have gone wrong but didn't — not quite, not completely.
Clary screamed as her suppressed memories flooded back. Eighteen years of hidden truth, crashing into her consciousness like a wave against cliffs.
And Jace — golden, confident, certain Jace — went pale as his happiest memory was torn away. The father he'd loved. The childhood he'd clung to. Gone in exchange for Clary's past.
The demon dissipated. The candles guttered. And in the aftermath, everyone stood in Magnus's loft, changed in ways they were only beginning to understand.
Magnus caught my eye across the room.
Two people performing roles, his expression said. Both knowing more than they should.
Something was forming between us. Not yet romance — nothing so simple — but recognition. Two creatures wearing human masks, navigating a world that didn't fully understand what they were.
"The ritual is complete," Magnus announced to the room. "Your memories are your own again, Clarissa. I hope they give you the answers you're looking for."
Clary stood with tears streaming down her face, processing a childhood's worth of suppressed truth.
Her mother, a Shadowhunter.
Her father, a monster.
And the Mortal Cup — the artifact Valentine needed to rebuild his army — hidden somewhere only Jocelyn knew.
The search was about to begin in earnest.
And somewhere in the city, Valentine was already moving his pieces.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.