Chapter 41 : THE STRANGER'S FACE
Three weeks of relative peace had made me suspicious.
The Institute operated smoothly under my authority. Aldertree's reports to the Clave were predictably hostile but contained nothing actionable. The alliance with Luke's werewolves and Raphael's vampires held strong. Magnus's intelligence network tracked Valentine's remaining forces across Europe, finding nothing but abandoned safe houses and severed communication lines.
Too smooth. Too quiet.
War didn't pause because you needed a break.
"Alec?" Izzy stood in my office doorway. "The new transfer is here. Sebastian Verlac, from London."
The name hit like a blade between the ribs.
Sebastian Verlac. The identity stolen by Jonathan Morgenstern — Valentine's true son, raised in Edom, filled with demon blood that made him stronger and more monstrous than any Shadowhunter had a right to be.
In the show, he'd wormed his way into the Institute through charm and manipulation, targeting Clary because she was his sister, using everyone around him as tools for Valentine's plans.
I'd known he would come eventually. I just hadn't expected it this soon.
"Bring him to the formal receiving room." My voice was steady. "I'll meet him there."
Sebastian Verlac was beautiful.
It was the first thing anyone would notice — the symmetrical features, the dark hair, the smile that invited trust and rewarded attention. He stood in the receiving room with the easy confidence of someone who'd never doubted his welcome anywhere.
"Acting Head Lightwood." His accent was perfectly English, his bow precisely correct. "Thank you for receiving me. I've heard so much about the New York Institute's recent... achievements."
Achievements. A careful word for building a Downworld alliance and defeating Valentine's army.
"Mr. Verlac." I kept my expression professionally neutral. "Your transfer papers mention family connection to the Lightwoods?"
"Distant, through the Branwell line. Third cousins, I believe." That smile again, warm and genuine-seeming. "I've always admired your family's work. The Institute's recent defense against the Circle was remarkable."
"We did what was necessary."
"More than necessary, from what I've heard. An unprecedented alliance with Downworld factions. Coordination that broke Valentine's assault." He leaned forward slightly. "I requested this transfer specifically because I wanted to learn from the Shadowhunter who made that possible."
Every word was calculated. Every gesture designed to disarm.
The demon memories I'd consumed screamed beneath my skin: Danger. Predator. Threat.
"We're always happy to welcome dedicated Shadowhunters," I said. "Isabelle will show you to quarters and explain our operational procedures."
"Of course." Sebastian turned that smile on Izzy, who'd been waiting silently. "I look forward to working with you, Ms. Lightwood."
As they left, Sebastian glanced back at me. Just a moment of eye contact, his expression perfectly friendly.
But something flickered beneath the surface. Recognition, maybe. Or the particular awareness of one hunter acknowledging another.
He knows I'm watching him. He doesn't know why.
I filed his transfer papers with a note for "extended verification" and began counting the days until I could prove what I already knew.
Sebastian integrated with terrifying efficiency.
Within days, he'd charmed half the Institute. He helped young Shadowhunters with training, offered intelligent insights during strategy meetings, and showed particular kindness to those who seemed lost or uncertain.
I watched it all with growing horror.
"He's good with the trainees," Jace observed during one of our patrols. "Patient. Knowledgeable. Some of the kids worship him already."
"That's what worries me."
"You've been tense since he arrived." Jace's voice carried the particular weight of parabatai concern. "What do you know that you're not sharing?"
Everything. I know everything — and I can't prove any of it.
"His records are too perfect," I said instead. "No disciplinary issues, no conflicts, no mistakes. People don't have clean records unless someone's been cleaning them."
"Or unless they're genuinely good at what they do."
"Nobody's that good."
We walked in silence through streets that smelled of rain and car exhaust. Through the parabatai bond, I could feel Jace's skepticism — not disbelief, exactly, but the reasonable doubt of someone who hadn't seen what I'd seen.
"I'll keep an eye on him," Jace said finally. "But Alec... sometimes paranoia is just paranoia."
"And sometimes it's survival."
Clary found Sebastian fascinating.
The observation made me physically ill.
"He knows so much about the London Institute," she gushed during dinner one evening. "The history, the traditions, the way they do things differently there. He's been helping me understand Shadowhunter culture better."
Of course he has. You're his target, even if he doesn't know you're his sister yet.
"That's... helpful," I managed.
"He asked about my rune creation abilities." Clary's eyes sparkled with enthusiasm. "Apparently, there are theories about why some Shadowhunters develop unique gifts. He thinks my blood might be—"
"Clary." I cut her off more sharply than intended. "Be careful about sharing information with new arrivals. Not everyone has good intentions."
Her face fell. "Sebastian isn't—"
"Just be careful. Please."
The hurt in her expression made me want to explain everything — to tell her about the demon-blood brother she didn't know she had, the monster that wore a charming face and asked calculated questions about her abilities.
But I couldn't. Not without revealing knowledge I shouldn't have.
The trap would take time to build.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.