CHAPTER 38: CHERYL'S QUESTION
The book was one of Harry's favorites.
He'd found the memory while searching for something to read at bedtime—a fragment of the original Harry Mason's consciousness, preserved alongside the technical knowledge and muscle memory that had helped him survive. Where the Wild Things Are. Harry had read it to Cheryl dozens of times before Silent Hill, before the corruption, before everything.
"And the wild things roared their terrible roars..." He kept his voice low, matching the rhythm that felt both foreign and familiar. "...and gnashed their terrible teeth..."
Cheryl listened from her bed, blankets pulled up to her chin, expression shifting between attention and distraction. She'd been quieter since the fog returned—not sad, exactly, but thoughtful in a way that sometimes felt older than her years.
"...and rolled their terrible eyes and showed their terrible claws..."
"Daddy?"
He paused mid-sentence. "Yes, sweetheart?"
"Why do you look sad when you see me sometimes?"
The question hit like a physical blow. He kept his face carefully neutral, the book's pages suddenly difficult to focus on.
"What do you mean?"
"Sometimes when you look at me, you get this... face." She scrunched up her features in an imitation that was simultaneously accurate and heartbreaking. "Like you're thinking about something that hurts. But then you smile real fast, like you don't want me to see."
She noticed. Of course she noticed. She's been watching me for two weeks, reading my expressions, learning my tells. And I wasn't careful enough.
"It's complicated, sweetheart."
"Grown-up complicated or actually complicated?"
Despite everything, he almost laughed. "Both, I think."
"Try explaining it." She sat up slightly, blankets pooling around her waist. "I'm pretty smart for a kid. The other one says so."
The other one. Alessa, watching through her eyes, hearing through her ears.
"You remember when we were at the lighthouse? When I was trying to help you and... the other one... come together?"
Cheryl nodded slowly. "It's fuzzy. Like a dream I can't quite remember. But I know it was important."
"It was. And during that time, I was very afraid." He set the book aside, giving her his full attention. "I was afraid I might lose you. That something might go wrong, and I wouldn't be able to fix it."
"But you didn't lose me."
"No. But sometimes, when I look at you, I remember how afraid I was. And that fear... it leaves a mark. Even when the danger is over."
Cheryl considered this with the gravity of a child taking adult emotions seriously.
"Like how I'm still scared of the dark sometimes? Even when I know you're right there?"
"Exactly like that." The parallel was surprisingly apt. "Fear doesn't always listen to logic. It just... is."
"But you're not scared of me, right?" Something vulnerable flickered across her face. "Because sometimes the other one comes out, and I can't always control when—"
"I'm not scared of you." He moved from the chair to the bed, pulling her into a hug that she returned fiercely. "I'm not scared of Alessa either. I'm scared for you. Both of you. Because I love you, and love makes people afraid of losing what they care about."
"That's a lot of feelings."
"It really is."
She pulled back slightly, studying his face with that unsettling perception that children sometimes possessed.
"You're still not telling me everything."
No. I'm not. Because the everything includes being a different person wearing your dead father's face, carrying knowledge of futures that may never happen, building a life on a foundation of necessary lies.
"No," he admitted. "I'm not. Some things are too complicated for right now. Maybe when you're older, I can explain better."
"Promise?"
"Promise."
She seemed to accept this—not because she believed it completely, but because the alternative was pushing harder, and some part of her understood that pushing harder might break something they both needed intact.
"Okay." She settled back against her pillow, reaching for the book. "Can you finish the story?"
"Of course, sweetheart."
He picked up Where the Wild Things Are and found his place. But as he read about Max and his terrible crown and his voyage home, he couldn't shake the feeling that something had shifted between them. A question asked and partially answered. A truth approached but not yet reached.
You're the best daddy.
Cheryl's words from days ago echoed in his memory. Joy and agony simultaneously—because he wasn't, not really. He was someone else wearing the shape of the best daddy, trying to fill a role that belonged to a dead man.
But he was trying. And maybe, in the end, that was what mattered most.
Cheryl fell asleep holding his hand.
Her grip loosened as her breathing deepened, small fingers uncurling around his larger ones. He stayed beside her bed, watching her sleep, feeling the weight of a question that had been partially answered and would inevitably be asked again.
How long before she figures it out? How long before the lies I've built this relationship on come crashing down?
Movement in the corner of his vision. He turned his head slowly, not wanting to disturb Cheryl's rest.
The light man stood near the window.
He could barely see it—a shimmer in the air, a suggestion of form rather than actual substance. But his Otherworld Connection confirmed what his eyes couldn't quite process: Alessa's consciousness, manifested in the way Cheryl perceived it, watching her other half sleep.
"She knows something's wrong." The words came out barely above a whisper. "She's too perceptive not to."
The light man flickered. He felt rather than heard the response—a sense of agreement, of shared concern, of something that might have been protectiveness.
"I can't tell her the truth. Not yet. Maybe not ever."
Another flicker. This time, the sense was different—not agreement, but understanding. As if Alessa knew about necessary lies. About truths too heavy for children to carry.
"You're watching over her."
A third flicker, stronger now. Yes. Always.
"Thank you."
The light man faded, its presence retreating to wherever Alessa's consciousness resided when it wasn't actively manifesting. He sat in the quiet darkness of his daughter's room, hand still held loosely in hers, and wondered how long any of this could last.
quick update: unwrittenrealm.com has bonus chapters and the story translated into 14 languages. no paywall for the translations, they stay free once unlocked.