Chapter 13: Penny's Three Data Points
The groceries were heavier than they should have been — two bags of what had seemed like reasonable purchases at the store but had somehow multiplied into an arm workout by the third floor landing.
Adam was coming down the stairs.
He had clearly been running — athletic clothes, slightly flushed face, the particular looseness in his movements that came from recent exertion. The encounter was unremarkable except for the part where he had clearly been back for at least twenty minutes based on his dry shirt and normal breathing, and yet—
"Morning," he said, stepping aside to let me pass on the narrow landing.
"Hey. Good run?"
"Productive."
I shifted one of the bags to free a hand. "Help me with these?"
"Sure."
He took the heavier bag without comment, and when our hands brushed during the transfer, his palm was warm. Not warm like someone who had just exercised. Warm like someone running a low fever, or like someone whose internal temperature was simply calibrated differently than everyone else's.
This was the third time.
The first had been the handshake on his first evening at the apartment — warm enough that I had noticed and filed it under "good circulation" without thinking more about it. The second had been at the Cheesecake Factory, when I had briefly touched his shoulder passing behind his chair and felt the heat through his shirt.
Third time. Pattern established.
We walked up the remaining stairs together, Adam carrying the bag with the ease of someone who found physical tasks unremarkable. His warmth was not fading the way post-exercise warmth should fade. Twenty minutes after stopping, a normal person's hands would be approaching ambient temperature. His were still radiating like he had been holding a coffee cup.
"Thanks for the help," I said at my door.
"No problem."
He handed me the bag. Our hands touched again — briefly, casually, the normal contact of a grocery transfer. Still warm.
"Your hands are always warm," I said.
The words came out before I had fully decided to say them. An observation, delivered casually, with the specific lightness I used when I wanted to see how someone reacted to direct attention.
"Good circulation," he said.
"No, like — warmer than that."
"California sun."
I looked at him. He looked at me.
There was a moment — brief, barely perceptible — where his expression shifted from casual deflection to something more careful. Not defensive, exactly. More like someone who had been caught in a minor inconsistency and was calculating how much effort to put into explaining it away.
"Okay," I said.
I went back inside.
He continued up the stairs.
I put the groceries away on autopilot, my mind running through the three data points.
Data point one: warm hands, first evening, filed as unremarkable.
Data point two: warm through shirt fabric, Cheesecake Factory, filed as possible coincidence.
Data point three: warm twenty minutes post-exercise, just now, filed as pattern.
I called Bernadette.
"Hey," she said, her voice carrying the particular energy of someone in the middle of a work task. "What's up?"
"Random question. Is there a medical reason someone's hands would be consistently warmer than normal? Like, not fever-warm, but noticeably-above-ambient warm?"
"Several reasons. Hyperthyroidism, certain medications, metabolic conditions, anxiety that presents as elevated body temperature. Why?"
"The new guy. Adam. His hands are always warm."
"The esper researcher?"
"Yeah."
"Have you asked him about it?"
"He said 'good circulation' and then 'California sun.' Neither of which explains it."
There was a pause on the other end of the line. Bernadette's processing silence — the one she used when she was shifting from casual conversation to analytical mode.
"Is there something else about him that's bothering you?"
"Not bothering, exactly." I sat down on my couch, phone pressed to my ear. "He does this thing where he goes somewhere else for a second. Like, in the middle of a conversation, there's this tiny pause where his eyes unfocus and he's just... not there. And then he's back, and he covers it with checking his phone or picking up his coffee or whatever."
"That could be a lot of things. ADHD, anxiety, dissociation—"
"It's not random. It happens when he's watching something. Like he's recording."
Another pause.
"Recording?"
"I don't mean literally. Just — like he's paying very close attention to something and then processing it. The pauses happen after he's been watching someone for a while."
"That's... specific."
"I know."
"Anything else?"
I thought about it. The question pattern at dinners — one question about what someone was working on, one about what was hard about it, one from an unexpected direction. The way the third question always got the longest answer. The way he seemed to listen with his whole body, like he was absorbing information rather than just hearing it.
"He asks questions in a specific pattern," I said. "Three questions. Always three. And the third one is always the interesting one — comes from a direction you don't expect."
"Like an interview technique?"
"Sort of. But not performative. He actually seems curious about the answers."
Bernadette was quiet for a moment.
"Is any of this actually alarming?" she asked.
"No."
"Has he said or done anything inappropriate?"
"Absolutely not."
"Then what are you actually worried about?"
The question sat in the air. I turned it over in my mind, looking for the honest answer.
"Nothing," I said finally. "He's interesting. There's a difference."
"Okay," Bernadette said, with the tone she used when she was recording information for later deployment. "Keep me posted."
"Will do."
I hung up and stared at the ceiling.
Okay but that's not California sun.
I didn't know what it was. But I was starting to have a theory about the shape of it.
He was a very bad liar about specific things. The "California sun" explanation had been delivered with the particular flatness of someone who knew the excuse was insufficient but was offering it anyway. He hadn't tried to sell it. He had just put it out there and waited to see if I would accept it.
But he was a very good liar about general things. His cover as a visiting researcher was seamless — the way he talked about his work, the way he integrated with the group, the way he handled Sheldon's categorization attempts. None of that felt fake. It felt real in a way that made the specific lies stand out more sharply.
He's real in general and fake in specifics.
The observation crystallized something I had been circling around. Adam Carter was not pretending to be interested in physics or the group or Pasadena. He was genuinely interested. The performance was not in what he cared about — it was in what he was hiding beneath the caring.
I added a fourth mental note to my file on him: very bad liar about specific things, very good liar about general things. The warmth is specific. The interest is general.
An hour later, I was heading back out — laundry run, the unglamorous necessity of adult life — when I passed Adam on the stairs again. He was coming down with his mail, the same easy stride, the same unremarkable presence.
"Hey," I said.
"Hey."
We paused on the landing. The moment felt different from the grocery exchange — less casual, more weighted. He was looking at me the way he looked at things he was evaluating, which meant he had noticed my noticing earlier.
"Can I ask you something?" I said.
"Sure."
"The California sun thing. Is that what you actually think is causing the warmth, or is that just what you say when people ask?"
His expression shifted — not dramatically, just a subtle recalibration. The careful look from earlier was back.
"Both," he said.
"That's not really an answer."
"I know."
We looked at each other. The moment stretched.
"Okay," I said.
I continued down the stairs. He continued up.
Neither of us said anything else.
Back in my apartment that evening, I thought about the exchange.
He hadn't denied that the warmth was unusual. He hadn't offered a better explanation. He had just acknowledged that his answer was insufficient and let the conversation end there.
That was interesting too.
Most people, when caught in an inadequate lie, either doubled down or pivoted to a different excuse. Adam had done neither. He had simply acknowledged the inadequacy and moved on, leaving the question open rather than forcing it closed.
He's not trying to convince me. He's just maintaining plausible deniability.
The distinction mattered. Someone trying to convince would keep explaining, keep elaborating, keep filling the silence with words designed to make me believe. Adam had given me a single inadequate answer and then let the inadequacy speak for itself.
Either he didn't think I was a threat worth serious deception, or he was operating under rules that prevented him from lying more effectively.
I didn't know which option was more interesting.
Get Early Access to New Chapters
Thank you for reading. For those who want to skip the wait, my Patreon is currently 21 chapters ahead of the public sites.
Schedule: 7 new chapters released every 10 days.
Benefit: Gain a significant lead of 7 to 21 chapters depending on your tier.
Support the project and start reading the next arc now: Patreon.com/IsekaiStories