Chapter 42 : THE CON MAN'S AURA
Alan Connor's shoes cost more than my monthly rent.
Italian leather, polished to a mirror shine, clicking against the marble floor of the law firm's lobby with the confidence of someone who'd never been told no. He moved through the crowd of suited lawyers like he belonged there, which he did, and like he was better than them, which he believed.
I stood near the hors d'oeuvres table and watched him work the room.
"You're staring," Jeff said, appearing beside me with two glasses of champagne. He handed me one. "At Alan. Who I told you was my best friend from the firm."
"You said colleague."
"Same thing."
It wasn't, and we both knew it.
Jeff had dragged me to this event under the pretense of "networking for your future career," which was transparently false but harder to argue against than his actual motivation: he wanted someone from his current life present while he tried to reconnect with his old one.
The firm's anniversary party was everything Greendale wasn't. Crystal chandeliers. Open bar. People who'd gone to real schools discussing cases that paid more than community college tuition. Jeff moved through it like he was coming home, his posture shifting, his vocabulary elevating, his Greendale accent smoothing into something more cosmopolitan.
Alan found us within minutes.
"Jeffrey!" The embrace was theatrical, the back-slapping performative, the smile so wide it showed too many teeth. "Look at you, still alive, still gorgeous. Community college hasn't crushed your spirit entirely."
"The spirit is unkillable," Jeff replied, matching Alan's energy. "The wardrobe has suffered."
"We'll fix that. We're doing a thing next month — fundraiser, very exclusive — and you HAVE to come. Show these people you're still relevant."
They talked about people I didn't know and cases I didn't understand, and I stood there with my champagne, reading Alan Connor's aura with the clearest deception detection I'd ever experienced.
The colors were layered like an onion of emotional fraud.
Surface level: performed friendship, warm yellow that flickered like a bad bulb.
Layer two: ambition in acid green, calculating every interaction for advantage.
Layer three: jealousy in bruised purple, directed at Jeff specifically — at his charm, his ease, his ability to make people like him without trying as hard.
Layer four: contempt, a sickly gray-green that touched everything he looked at, including and especially the person he called his best friend.
Alan Connor was a masterclass in emotional manipulation, and his aura was the most dishonest thing I'd ever read.
The show told me he was bad news. The episode was literally called "Accounting for Lawyers" and the whole point was Alan's betrayal. But seeing it in person, reading it in his aura... this is worse than I expected.
Jeff laughed at something Alan said. His aura glowed with nostalgia — golden and warm, the color of memories that made him feel like himself. Underneath the gold, shame pulsed in threads of gray, shame about Greendale, about his fake degree, about everything he'd become since his old life ended.
He wanted to go back. He wanted this world to be his world again.
And Alan Connor was going to use that want to destroy him.
I found Jeff alone near the bar twenty minutes later.
"We need to talk."
"About what? The canapés? They're adequate."
"About Alan."
Jeff's expression closed like a door slamming. "What about him?"
"He's not your friend."
The words hung in the air between us. Jeff's aura flickered with irritation, then hardened into defensive anger.
"You've known him for an hour."
"I've watched him work the room for an hour. That's different."
"And what did your hour of observation reveal?" Jeff's voice was sharp now, mocking. The Winger deflection mechanism, activated in response to perceived threat.
"He's jealous of you. He's using you for something. And whatever he's planning, it's not going to end well for you."
Jeff laughed, but it wasn't a real laugh. "You don't know anything about him. You don't know anything about my old life, or the people in it, or—"
"I know what I see."
"You see what you want to see. You've always been like that — observing, cataloging, acting like you understand people better than they understand themselves." Jeff stepped closer, his aura spiking with frustration. "Alan is my friend. He believed in me when nobody else did. He's the reason I survived my first year at the firm."
He's also the reason your career ended. The show made that clear, even if you don't know it yet.
But I couldn't say that. I couldn't explain that I'd watched Jeff Winger's life play out on a television screen, that I knew exactly how this episode ended, that Alan's betrayal was as certain as the sunrise.
All I could do was warn him with information that looked like intuition.
"You're not listening," I said.
"Because you're not saying anything worth hearing."
Jeff walked away, champagne in hand, aura still glowing with golden nostalgia and defensive anger. He found Alan across the room and the two of them resumed their performance of friendship, and I stood by the bar knowing exactly what was coming and completely unable to stop it.
Meta-knowledge can predict events. It can't override what someone wants to believe.
The betrayal happened three days later.
I got the details secondhand — Jeff didn't want to talk about it — but the outline was clear enough. Alan had set Jeff up. Something about a case file, something about making Jeff look like the source of a leak, something about Jeff confronting Alan and getting confirmation that the friendship had never been real.
The specifics didn't matter. The result did.
Jeff came to Greendale that night looking like someone had hollowed him out.
I was in Study Room F, alone, catching up on reading I'd fallen behind on during the week. The door opened and Jeff walked in without acknowledging me. He dropped into the chair across the table, loosened his tie, and stared at nothing.
I didn't speak.
Minutes passed. Five, then eight, then ten. The silence stretched between us, filled with everything Jeff wasn't saying and everything I wasn't going to point out.
I told you so would have been accurate. It also would have been cruel.
Are you okay would have been performative. He clearly wasn't.
What happened would have been invasive. If he wanted to tell me, he would.
So I sat there, reading a textbook I wasn't really absorbing, sharing space with someone who needed to not be alone but also needed to not be talked to.
At minute twelve, Annie walked in.
She took one look at Jeff, one look at me, and understood the situation without explanation. She walked to the coffee maker in the corner — the one Shirley had brought in sophomore year, claiming the cafeteria coffee was "an insult to Jesus" — and started making two cups.
She brought them to the table, set one in front of Jeff and one in front of me, and left without saying a word.
Jeff picked up the coffee. Held it. Didn't drink.
"You were right," he said finally.
"I know."
"I didn't want you to be right."
"I know that too."
More silence. The coffee steamed between us.
"How did you know?" Jeff asked. "About Alan. How could you tell?"
Because I watched your life on television for six seasons. Because I know every major event that happens to you for the next four years. Because meta-knowledge gave me the answer before I ever met him.
"I pay attention," I said instead. "People show you who they are if you're willing to see it."
Jeff laughed, hollow and tired. "Alan showed me who he was for years. I just didn't want to see it."
"That's human."
"Is it?"
"Yeah." I closed my textbook, giving Jeff my full attention. "We believe what we want to believe. We trust the people who make us feel good about ourselves. And when someone uses that against us, it's not our fault for trusting — it's their fault for betraying."
Jeff looked at me for a long moment. His aura was different now — the defensive anger gone, the nostalgic gold faded, replaced by something rawer and more honest. Pain, yes. Humiliation, definitely. But also something I hadn't seen in him before: gratitude.
He's not grateful that I was right. He's grateful that I'm not rubbing it in.
"I'm going to go home," Jeff said. "Drink something stronger than this coffee. Try to figure out how to face everyone tomorrow."
"You'll be fine. The group doesn't care about Alan or the firm or any of that."
"I know." He stood up, leaving the coffee untouched on the table. "That's sort of the problem."
He walked to the door and paused — just for a half-second, just long enough to mean something without having to say it. Then he was gone, and I was alone in Study Room F with two cups of cooling coffee and the knowledge that I'd warned him correctly and it hadn't helped at all.
The next morning, Jeff showed up to study group like nothing had happened.
His performance was good — charming, deflecting, making jokes about anthropology and Pierce's tie and Britta's "activism of the week." Nobody else would have noticed the strain underneath.
But I noticed. And Annie noticed me noticing.
"What happened last night?" she whispered while Jeff argued with Britta about something meaningless.
"Nothing you need to worry about."
"That's not an answer."
"It's the only answer I'm giving."
She studied me for a moment, her expression somewhere between frustrated and curious. Then she nodded, accepting the boundary without pushing further.
She trusts me. I'm not sure I deserve it, but she trusts me.
Jeff's aura had a new color in it today — a thread of something I hadn't seen before. Respect, maybe. Or at least the beginning of respect, directed at the person who'd been right when he wanted them to be wrong.
The study session continued. Abed made a meta-commentary about second seasons typically escalating interpersonal conflict. Troy laughed too loud. Pierce contributed something accidentally offensive that Shirley corrected with patient exasperation.
Normal chaos. Study group dynamics.
But something had shifted between Jeff and me, and we both knew it. The rivalry that had started with suspicion, evolved through grudging acknowledgment, and nearly collapsed under Jeff's defensive anger had reached a new equilibrium.
He'd ignored my warning. The warning had been correct. And I hadn't punished him for being wrong.
That meant something, in Jeff Winger's world.
Not friendship. Not yet. But the foundation of something that could become friendship if we both let it.
After the session ended, I stayed behind to clean up the coffee cups Annie had left. Jeff was the last to leave, and he paused at the door the same way he had the night before.
"Pierce's mother is sick," he said, not looking at me. "He told Shirley this morning. I don't think he knows how sick."
The words hit like cold water.
Oh no. This episode. This one is going to hurt.
"Thanks for telling me," I said.
Jeff nodded once and left.
I stood alone in Study Room F, thinking about Pierce Hawthorne and the mother he never talked about, and started planning the meal I'd need to cook when the phone call came.
Support the Story on Patreon
If you are enjoying the series and would like to read ahead, I offer an early access schedule on Patreon. I upload 7 new chapters every 10 days.
Tiers are available that provide a 7, 14, or 21-chapter head start over the public release. Your support helps me maintain this consistent update pace.
Patreon.com/TransmigratingwithWishes
extra chapters are live on unwrittenrealm.com
also the full story is available in Arabic, Spanish, Hindi, Korean and 10 more. just pick your language.